6 ms·
All these "evolutionary arguments" -- this isn't real science. It's just a bunch of "just so" stories that are tested in some of the flimsiest ways (one phenome
by EGreg 11y ago
All these "evolutionary arguments" -- this isn't real science. It's just a bunch of "just so" stories that are tested in some of the flimsiest ways (one phenomenon demonstrated to a statistically significant degree -- therefore that must have been "the reason for the evolutionary change").
Listen, tons of features that an animal has are not correlated so highly to survival as to make enough selective pressure to make that feature come to completely dominate a population. I am very skeptical of the widely "held" assumption otherwise.
For example, lets say the human anorectal angle was specifically "evolved" for pooping while squatting. Is it a "just so" story or did the exact anorectal angle contribute SO MUCH to survival or reprosuction that it became the standard for bipedal humans?
Consider just how much relative advantage with survival and replication any given feature must have in order to come to dominate ALL the other features that are competing in the population. And this is in just one area. During a single reproduction, there are tons of genetic and epigenetic variables that could be selected for, which determine different things. Why would a specific feature in a specific part of the body, that provides merely a minor improvement at any given time, come to completely replace all other genotype expressions? I have never seen a good analysis of this, just hopeful handwaving, especially in popular books like The Selfish Gene.
- facepalm 11y agoJust because many people make up evolutionary just so stories doesn't mean that there can not also be valid evolutionary explanations. If you just say "anorectal angle evolved so that people poop squatting" it is a just so story. To make it solid you have to show the context, history and so on. For example, why is it an advantage to be able to hold your poop in? A lot of things evolved out of serendipity and are not perfect, like those arteries going up and down the whole long neck of giraffes to bridge a short distance. But there are evolutionary explanations for it. As for features related to survival: I think phases with more and less pressure alternate. If you made a breakthrough, say you discovered skeletons, or invented the iPhone, for a while you may have such a big advantage that you can play around with lots of fancy variants. Eventually the rest of the world catches up, pressure gets higher and the less efficient variants get weeded out.
- elcapitan 11y agoIsn't most of 'anthropology' just invention of plausible sounding stories with no way to verify or falsify ever as well?
- chipsy 11y agoIf you mean to say that society is a construct, well, yes. You learn that in the 101 course. That does not lead to a "this is bullshit" conclusion, unfortunately, because we act on the stories we tell ourselves.
- elcapitan 11y agoThere are different levels of "construct" though. There are historical documents from the middle ages, from Rome, from ancient Egypt, etc. that can be checked to a certain degree. And there are stories that are just made out of thin air about how humans supposedly lived 50k years ago. This is not all the same.
- EGreg 11y agoJust having plausible-sounding evolutionary explanations isn't enough, though. You also need a way to falsify the theory. There is a good essay about this called Science as Falsification, by Karl Popper: http://www.stephenjaygould.org/ctrl/popper_falsification.html http://www.stephenjaygould.org/ctrl/popper_falsification.htm... Otherwise how is it different from Marxism or Freud's theories? I can always concoct an explanation in the context of my theory. That isn't science by itself. It's demagoguery.
- facepalm 11y agoYou make a model, then you make predictions. If they fail, your model was wrong. You can do that in evolution theory, even though you are mostly looking at history. Maybe you predict that all birds should have tails at least 30'' long, then you look around and see that they don't. You can also look at the way genes spread - I suppose you can compare the observed spread of a gene to the spread that would be expected if it were random. Nevertheless, once you see something unexplained (like zebra stripe), I suppose you start with creating theories, then you try to verify them. Isn't the article here doing exactly that?
- tim333 11y agoEvolution works on very long time scales. Say a few people have a gene that gives a 0.01% increase in survival so the next generation there are 1.0001 times as many copies statistically expected. Over 100,000 generations the gene would statistically expand something like 22,000 fold. And over 1m generations 1.0001^(1e6) = 2e43 meaning most of the population would have it. I think most popular books skip math lessons - they are not so popular.
- dogma1138 11y agoWhat we found is actually the opposites evolution can and does work on very short time scales exceptionally well favorable genetic traits can propagate throughout the entire population in only a handful of generation (in the best case even under 1 generation). Also you should really not underestimate epigenetics (which we only now beginning to understand) which play even a more vital role than random mutation as epigenetics can selectively play with gene expressions in every offspring (as well as any thing which has already been born) based on both environmental factors, the "genetic" memory of the parents, and the current experience of the mother as far as mammals go. It seems that every part of the tree of life, from bacteria to complex life forms (what's more interesting is that mammals/marsupials, fish, birds, etc. each have their own epigentic mechanisms) have it's own internal genetic restructuring mechanism which is really not dependent on random mutations being pitted against natural selection.
- Udik 11y ago> During a single reproduction, there are tons of genetic and epigenetic variables that could be selected for, which determine different things. Why would a specific feature in a specific part of the body, that provides merely a minor improvement at any given time, come to completely replace all other genotype expressions? As far as I understand it, sexual reproduction with its gene shuffling allows all features to evolve simultaneously. So the genes for the anorectal angle are constantly selected across the whole population in parallel with every other gene.
- zkhalique 11y agoHave you ever seen the mathematics on this? When so much is being selected "at the same time" it seems like most of the time it would never get selected in the wash. After all, selection works on an individual organism, and it's binary: either the organism survives, reproduces and passes on its genes, or not (we are not talking about DNA swapping between microorganisms here). This binary signal is supposed to be the "vote" for whether a particular combination of genes is more fit or not. But you can't just say "it's all possible given a really long time", you'd have to actually quantify what the chances are of say, the mechanism a single vote selecting simultaneously 1000 different traits, would increase the prevalence of all the "beneficial" traits. Do you have enough resolution to decide e.g. whether the bone density, color of skin or the length of legs was the factor that led to survival? I am especially not sure why it would select the traits -- like a colorectal angle -- that would make an individual simply more comfortable rather than make a tangible difference to survival. If we took the predictions of evolutionary theory seriously, then their contrapositive seriously too. In particular why would gay people exist if genetically homosexuality confers a much lower genetic fitness? Why do we say homosexuality is primarily genetic if evolution is true?
- joaorj 11y ago> Why do we say homosexuality is primarily genetic if evolution is true? In my opinion it must be to help the fitness of the community they live in. The communities with low likelihood to spawn a gay person are (were?) much more likely to go extinct. It can also be a basic property (side effect?) of the sexual appeal arms race. There is also the case of suicides, when they happen to young people that hasn't reproduced yet. It can also be argued its for the benefit of the community. So the thesis is that the primary force in evolution is not individual's fitness but it is the community's fitness.
- jules 11y agoThat is true but not for species that reproduce sexually. This is precisely why sexual reproduction is so successful.
- dTal 11y agoI agree that a lot of "evolutionary arguments" that make their way as far as popular culture are indeed post-hoc "just-so stories". However... >Consider just how much relative advantage with survival and replication any given feature must have in order to come to dominate ALL the other features that are competing in the population Answer: very little! This is the advantage of sexual reproduction (or at least gene transfer) - it allows us to do our evolving "in parallel". A single "feature" might only convey a tiny advantage, and you'd think it'd be swamped by all the thousands of other features - but the "experiment" is repeated zillions of times, enough to bring it out of the statistical noise. It doesn't have to "make the difference" between reproductive success and failure in any particular instance. It also bears repeating that most "features" don't spring out fully formed - most "features" only convey a tiny advantage! Sorry if this isn't a very good explanation. You've hit upon a key aspect of evolution, and I think you're right that there isn't a good, popular layperson's explanation of the mechanism that actually tackles the statistical aspect instead of glossing over it.
- EGreg 11y agoSorry if this isn't a very good explanation. You've hit upon a key aspect of evolution, and I think you're right that there isn't a good, popular layperson's explanation of the mechanism that actually tackles the statistical aspect instead of glossing over it. I want to reply in a very strongly worded way to this point. There is a huge disconnect between the assertions made by proponents (like Dawkins) of evolutionary explanations, that "evolution has been proven LIKE GRAVITY at this point" and the lack of widely accessible explanation of how the most obvious statistical questions are settled in favor of the theory actually working. I don't even mean comfortably working, like "it should have taken 3 trillion years but we got lucky". I mean like, how does a binary decision select for things that are not even correlated to survival or reproduction but merely comfort? And even more astonishingly, how is it able to take such long (1000s of generations) speculative paths, without any apparent benefit until the basic version of the thing is fully formed? Combine that with the contradictory empirical evidence of punctuated equilibria broken by genetic explosions and I'm not so sure the theory is correct. Mutation and natural selection seem insufficient to explain the features we see. But the disconnect between the dearth of actual answers (as available to someone with a mathematics background like me) with the insistence that evolution "is as sure as gravity" makes me skeptical. I find the situation very close to bullshit that is politically motivated and propagated through systematic bullying. I should point out that this is not for religious reasons but merely because the theory seems like one of those early simple theories (like the humors or luminiferous ether) that always felt off and were too simple. PS: just to be clear, I am not challenging the theory of common descent, but rather the proposed explanation for evolution as being completely a product of random mutation and natural selection -- evolution is a vague term which adds to the equivocation problem and is further evidence that there is strong political pressure in the scientific establishment to prop up the theory.
- dragonwriter 11y ago> All these "evolutionary arguments" -- this isn't real science. It's just a bunch of "just so" stories that are tested in some of the flimsiest ways That's pretty much the process of generating a scientific hypothesis, so that description itself isn't the not-science part. The not-science part is presenting such stories as conclusions and leaving them set.
- nitrogen 11y agoThere's a concept in electrical engineering and signal processing called superposition. It basically means that a linear circuit will process the sum of a bunch of signals the same way it would process them one at a time (in very rough terms, to the best of my recollection, etc.). Maybe something similar applies to selective pressures; at a statistical, population-wide scale, the result of optimizing thousands of traits at the same time is mathematically equivalent to optimizing one at a time?