7 ms·
Why your favorite apps are designed to addict you
- lalos 11y agoReminded me of this long but worth it piece: http://www.theverge.com/2015/5/6/8544303/casino-slot-machine-gambling-addiction-psychology-mobile-games http://www.theverge.com/2015/5/6/8544303/casino-slot-machine... "I can’t tell you how often I’ve been approached since the publication of my book by Silicon Valley types who say things like, ‘Wow, the gambling industry really seems to have a handle on this attention retention problem that we’re all facing,'" Schüll told me. "'Will you come tell our designers how to do a better job?’"
- PhasmaFelis 11y agoA friend of mine was doing a business internship; someone mentioned hiring "a Chinese sweatshop" to make their product. He laughed, but they weren't joking. They're jolting, those moments when you realize you've been talking to someone who acts just like a normal human being but is totally disconnected from basic human empathy.
- Dr_tldr 11y agoThey exist, they don't offer good working conditions, but chances are that the majority of the items in your home and almost all the clothes you wear were made under similar conditions. I don't see any empathy being expressed by someone who's complicit in a (mostly) bad thing but then denounces and dehumanizes anyone who openly acknowledges it. I think you're confusing 'empathy' with 'virtue signaling.'
- shostack 11y agoFinally managed to kick my Clash of Clans habit the other day. I realized I had been logging in 1-2x/day for multiple years with maybe a couple weeks of breaks after buying shields around the holidays. My life has become increasingly cluttered with feeds, needing to login to games I like to get bonuses and such, and it has started to pile up so I decided I needed to make some changes, starting with CoC. At first I had a lot of anxiety because the mechanics of the game would penalize me pretty harshly if I was away for a few days/weeks and wanted to come back. The lizard part of my brain started urging me to play it in a way that was so urgent it felt like I could almost reach out and touch it. But I had deleted the app from my device, and I sat myself down and told myself that those urges had no weight because the consequences would never be felt since I wasn't going to play the game again. Now I'm past the hump, and while I still have many more things on my list to extricate from my life in my path towards simplifying things, I definitely feel a bit better. One less responsibility. Don't get me wrong--I'm still a gamer, and likely will always be to some degree. But I'm so jaded by games with super transparent mechanics like this that they are starting to lose their hold over me. Started playing Pillars of Eternity last night and it was refreshing to get into something story-driven that didn't devote a significant chunk of the initial gameplay to introducing me to various IAP mechanics.
- siquick 11y agoAt first I had a lot of anxiety because the mechanics of the game would penalize me pretty harshly if I was away for a few days/weeks and wanted to come back. The lizard part of my brain started urging me to play it in a way that was so urgent it felt like I could almost reach out and touch it. But I had deleted the app from my device, and when I sat myself down and told myself that those urges had no weight because the consequences would never be felt since I wasn't going to play the game again. The second sentence is the most important here - good work on getting rid.
- shostack 11y agoThanks! I consider myself fairly self-aware and the most fascinating aspect of this for me has been observing my thought process as I went through this. The way I laid it out above makes it seem rather simple. Like, I had a five second mental conversation with myself and was like "oh, ok, no consequences so I don't need to care anymore." However the reality was that it was something I needed to continually coach myself on until I internalized it over the course of a day or two. The initial realization of this came pretty quickly, but actually breaking the hold it had on me took real repeated effort. I have newfound respect for those who are able to kick much more harmful addictions where the body's response is "pain and agony" vs. just "an annoying nagging feeling."
- seivan 11y agoI gotta ask you, as a gamer, don't you find Clash of Clans to be... well kinda bad? I mean the tech stack behind it, with replay functionality and async multiplayer is cool together with its "Battle.net like" integration is also working great for mobile. But as a game, it isn't better than any random mod on WC3. It's essentially build, purchase crap, and attack. Sometimes they give you the false notion that anything you do impacts the game itself as you attack. You get "bombs" to drop and etc, but as a game... it's essentially just a shallow graphic layer on top of numbers. I understand you can say the same thing about most games, but somehow my brain just rips apart Clash of Clans or Boom-beach easily, while it won't treat Star Craft same way. Just needed to ask.
- lilcarlyung 11y ago"Hooked: How to Build Habit-Forming Products" by Nir Eyal and Ryan Hoover is a really interesting read on this subject. For me it was eye-opening to think about app development from a behavioral and psychological perspective, albeit manipulative. http://www.amazon.com/Hooked-How-Build-Habit-Forming-Products-ebook/dp/B00HJ4A43S http://www.amazon.com/Hooked-How-Build-Habit-Forming-Product...
- siquick 11y agoGreat book, even if my girlfriend called me a creepy weirdo for reading it.
- ywecur 11y ago>Addiction may not even be the right term, at least psychologically. According to Rosen, the reason we check our phones constantly is not to gain pleasure—the telltale sign of true addictive behavior—but something else potentially even more worrisome for our well-being. I might be completely wrong here, but I read about a study where mice were deprived of dopamine (chemical responsible for motivating behavior). There they shows that the mice would rather starve to death than seek out food and water. However, if food was placed in their mouths they would swallow it and gain pleasure. I believe apps are a perfect example of addiction in this case since they create compulsive behaviors without giving pleasure.
- bitwize 11y agoEvery time I try out one of these damned stupid mobile ganes, I reach a point where I'm like "okay, fuck this" and that's the point where it starts getting grindy without spending cash. It's very subtle, like the moment a stripper stops being friendly and starts silently expecting generous tips in order to keep being friendly. But it's there, I hate it, and it makes games profoundly unfun.
- pimlottc 11y agoWhat worries me is that kids growing up today will think that this is normal, just part of "how video games are". I miss the days when you paid once and got full access to the entire game, limited only by your own skill. When the game designer's chief concern was fun and playability, not artificial roadblocks to spur paid "upgrades". It's a sad trend.
- Terr_ 11y agoOn the flip-side, we've moved away from "fixed in the cartridge" games which were Nintendo Hard. [0]: http://tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pmwiki.php/Main/NintendoHard http://tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pmwiki.php/Main/NintendoHard
- CM30 11y agoThose things still exist, they're just reserved for completionists now. The optional content in any current era Mario game is arguably more awkwardly designed than anything from similar games in the NES era, with the assumption being that anyone attempting it is the kind of person who liked the 'Nintendo Hard' titles of the 80s. Presumably, designers now often see the 'main' adventure or campaign as for everyone, the multiplayer mode as a way to keep most people playing instead of fake difficulty and the 100% completion 'optional' content as for the masochists.
- soylentcola 11y agoI look at it as an evolution of arcade games. Granted, arcades were also meeting/hangout places and they often had games that looked and played better than anything you could get at home. Still, from the perspective of the companies that made them, it was similar. Look at the earlier games or even the current gen of pachinko games that are still popular in Japan and you can see the sort of overlap between video games and the exploitation of impulses and reactions typically associated with gambling. I remember not understanding why my folks never wanted to give me money to go screw around in the arcade at the mall but looking at microtransactions and "energy games" on mobile, I completely get it now. Sure, to beat an arcade game or beat a high score can take enormous skill but in order to develop that skill, you need to keep feeding an endless stream of quarters. It's the original gaming microtransaction.
- ccvannorman 11y agoI am more addicted to Hacker News than most apps.
- ywecur 11y agoMe too. I wanted to switch to only reading Hacker Monthly, but sadly it's been discontinued :(
- jonzfisher 11y agoI had this problem as well, so now I just get the weekly newsletter of popular Hacker News posts through usepanda.com. I get the top six posts of HackerNews and DesignerNews.
- ywecur 11y agoMaybe not the perfect solution, but I created a bot that notifies me when "a lot" of activity occurs on my friends Rocket.chat server. Basically when more than 3 people write more than 5 messages each, pretty quickly. I've found that I rarely check it anymore since I'm always notified when something interesting is happening or when people specifically want to reach me; I'm no longer afraid I'll "miss out".
- Animats 11y agoI have Facebook only on the desktop, not on my phone. I don't want it bothering me. There's nothing on Facebook that needs immediate attention, and less and less of it that has anything to do with what my friends are doing. Remember, sharing is spamming.
- wernercd 11y agoI have Facebook on my phone... but I have "App Platform" disabled. I'd like to use it for some minor "log in to this..." functionality, but it's not worth the extra baggage.
- soared 11y agoI just deleted the facebook app off my phone for two reasons. First, I would find myself browsing fb, close the app, then IMMEDIATELY open it back up without thinking about it. Second, I would see the same content 2-3 times a day. Now just on desktop it is so much nicer, but I don't really know what to do on my phone anymore.
- soylentcola 11y agoI've got a third party FB app that is basically a sandboxed wrapper for easier browsing of the mobile website, but yeah, I agree. It's more for the rare occasion I need to check on a conversation with someone who insists on using Facebook. Otherwise, it's just something I look at once or twice a week when I'm bored and want to see what people are up to. I never connect any mobile games or other apps with my FB account and if a program or site requires FB login, I stop using it.
- owlish 11y agoAs developers, many of us work everyday on increasing page hits, creating more engaging user experiences. What are the ethical implications of this? At what point do we become responsible for users' addictive behavior?
- amelius 11y agoAs long as you, the developer, feel that you contribute positively to society, then I would say there is nothing wrong with engaging users.
- excinit 11y agohey all - i wrote this piece and really happy to here its sparking discussion here. Let me know if you have any questions, either here, or twitter.com/excinit
- mikeash 11y agoPut a rat in a box. Connect a lever to a pellet dispenser. When the rat pushes lever, it gets a food pellet. This trains the rat to push the lever. Now modify the lever to only give a food pellet sometimes. Sometimes there's nothing. This turns out to be much more effective at getting the rat to compulsively press the lever. Now look at the internet, and services with frequent updates like Facebook, Twitter, or even HN. Sometimes you push the lever and get a reward, and sometimes you don't, effectively training the user to compulsively check.
- rambos 11y agoFor social its all about validation and self-worth. Like, favorite, share, subscribe, follow, some type of hierarchy system. That's how you get people addicted.