4 ms·
While it is natural to attribute much of this to individual efforts within the company, and to lack of innovation, the result you see at Microsoft might be more
by wglb 17y ago
While it is natural to attribute much of this to individual efforts within the company, and to lack of innovation, the result you see at Microsoft might be more of a natural consequence of a company of that size and success.
Just a little thought experiment here: in the eyes of shareholders, which is more important at the end of each quarter -- innovation, or profit? So did the profitability of the Office division suffer from not engaging the tablet? (note that some think that the anticipated use of the iPad is more on the consumer end, and less on the creation end).
And another little quiz: where does Simon Peyton Jones work and what does he do and what has he produced?
To me, the underlying takeaway from this story, and I disagree a little with the slant the author of TFA has, is that execution can trump innovation.
There have been articles referenced here on HN that talk about others stealing ideas (my favorite was one told by Steve Blank) but at the end of the day, the winner is the one who executes well.
Isn't this the bottom-line message from the Microsoft story?
- gabrielroth 17y agoJust a little thought experiment here: in the eyes of shareholders, which is more important at the end of each quarter -- innovation, or profit? So did the profitability of the Office division suffer from not engaging the tablet? And yet shareholders are not, in fact, rewarding Microsoft for its consistent profitability: http://www.google.com/finance?chdnp=1&chdet=1265317200000&chddm=492269&cmpto=NASDAQ:AAPL;NASDAQ:MSFT&cmptdms=0;0&q=aapl http://www.google.com/finance?chdnp=1&chdet=126531720000... msft&ntsp=0
- ajross 17y agoThat's a link to Apple's chart, not MSFT. And MSFT has been tracking the overall market pretty closely over the past few years. It hasn't been tanking, nor booming. I'd say that's a validation of wglb's point, no? Investors don't care about anything but revenue, and revenue of a company this size tracks the economy, and thus it behaves pretty much the same as the market does.
- gabrielroth 17y agoLook closer. It's a link to a chart that compares the share prices of Apple and Microsoft over the past five years. Apple, driven by innovation, has increased by 400%. Microsoft, with its consistent profits, has remained almost perfectly flat. This makes the previous poster's claim that investors have responded positively to Microsoft's approach look pretty weak.
- awa 17y agoMSFT has been able to maintain the stock price near $30 levels for sometime while paying dividends consistently
- nradov 17y agoDividends don't actually change the picture much. In the past five years (02/03/2005 through 02/03/2010), total shareholder return (including dividends) for AAPL was 412% whereas MSFT only returned 19%.
- awa 17y agoWell AAPL and MSFT are two different ball games. AAPL hit the jackpot with iPhone, post iPhone Apple has been a second coming of Apple, its no longer the same company for investors. For investors, due to consistent profitability and revenues, MSFT is a safer bet than Apple which reflects in the returns.
- carbon8 17y ago"AAPL hit the jackpot with iPhone, post iPhone Apple has been a second coming of Apple" And before the iPhone, AAPL hit the jackpot with the iPod, post iPod Apple has been a second coming of Apple. And before the iPod, AAPL hit the jackpot with the iMac, post iMac Apple has been a second coming of Apple.
- robryan 17y agoThe apple price would factor in the constant innovation they bring, if this were to stop then I'd imagine they would lose a lot of value.
- eagleal 17y agoFrom Wikipedia: Simon Peyton Jones is a British computer scientist who researches [...]functional programming languages, particularly lazy functional languages. [...] Since 1998 he has worked as a researcher at Microsoft Research in Cambridge [...]. He is a major contributor to the design of the Haskell programming language, and a principal designer of the Glasgow Haskell Compiler (GHC). He is also co-creator of the C-- programming language. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Simon_Peyton_Jones http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Simon_Peyton_Jones EDIT: Perhaps this article applies only to Microsoft Research, not MSFT as a whole.