4 ms·
Kinda. The Chinese government has been trying to mix sitting on a powder keg and rapid economic growth. They do not want to become a second USSR by opening up a
by 50CNT 11y ago
Kinda. The Chinese government has been trying to mix sitting on a powder keg and rapid economic growth. They do not want to become a second USSR by opening up all the floodgates at once. Also, considering how they got to their position, I don't think that any of them have preconceptions of a gentle fall if things go south.
What seems to be the case is that they're shooting for slow incremental improvement, moving from less touchy areas to more touchy areas. They've gone from not talking about corruption to cracking down on it higher and higher up the ranks. It's a very slow sleigh of hand, with the distraction being economic growth, and various distinctly communist tasting programs (the current one should be 中国梦(Chinese Dream), if I recall correctly).
But their fear doesn't seem unjustified. There are still spontaneous uprisings which are usually nipped in the bud before they can escalate by means of information and communication monitoring. That's what they care about. Expats in China using VPNs? They don't give one.
Whilst I'm all for democracy, introducing it to China right now would work about as well as introducing it to the Middle East. Groups feeling under-represented would fraction off, there would likely be civil war, widespread devastation to one of the most populous countries of the world, and worst of all, whilst Iran getting nuclear weapons seems like a looming threat, China does have them. The sheer pandemonium would make Syria look like a backwater stand-off. I may be exaggerating, but then look at the bloodshed of the cultural revolution.
I grew up in Germany, so it's not like I'm opposed or unfamiliar with the idea of democracy, it's an incredible system. But for China right now? Well meant, but not practical. It'd be a less bloody affair to turn the US into a monarchy (to make a comparison). In 20 years, maybe, though it might take longer.
Thinking China can be fixed with a fair heaping of democracy and human rights ignores a lot of very significant details in a country that works contrary to a lot of accepted wisdom in the west.
/rant
PS: There's lots of interesting things going on here, playing churned lover with western ideals is literally the least interesting thing to talk about. The day before yesterday they announced changes to the Visa regimen, coming into effect in March. 72-hour visa free visit in 4 yangtze river cities, and some streamlining of visa/green card programs for tech people and entrepreneurs working in China. Maybe I should have chosen a less ironic user name, because this is starting to sound like a sales pitch.
- seanmcdirmid 11y agoOh, I thought your user name meant the rapper :) The new visa regimes are interesting, but it hasn't seem to trickle down yet to us tech PhD people's. Really, China doesn't like foreigners, and they merely tolerate us, making us register at police stations after every trip, making us renew our visas yearly, not giving us access to the same services as natives.
- 50CNT 11y agoYes, the registration thing is a nuisance. They do seem to be working on ironing out the bugs in the current visa laws though, and there's reason to believe they'll become a lot more lenient, especially to y'all tech PhD people's. The regulation I'm referring to seems like a pilot program in scope. It allows foreign students to work for and start tech businesses in the Zhongguancun area, as well as allowing people that have worked for 4 years or more for a technology company here to receive a residency permit. That's been exciting me the last 3-4 days since I heard of it, since I've been playing with the thought of doing exactly that. It does feel like people well versed in technology are the bottleneck for startups over here. Investment is plenty, people with ideas are a RMB a dozen, but tech people knowing more than some PHP or how to set up Bootstrap? Not nearly as many, at least where I'm hanging out. It's certainly an interesting couple of years ahead, as long as they keep tolerating us here.
- felipemora 11y agoThank you for your very insightful comment. Reading your comment it reminded me of how you cannot just give regular food to a starving person [1], it would kill them. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Refeeding_syndrome https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Refeeding_syndrome