3 ms·
Trump is in no way representative of the country as a whole. He exists as a phenomenon because a relatively small minority really likes him, and because the Rep
by mikeash 11y ago
Trump is in no way representative of the country as a whole. He exists as a phenomenon because a relatively small minority really likes him, and because the Republicans have not managed to find any candidate even slightly worthwhile.
When you see that Trump is polling at 31% or whatever, keep in mind that 31% of early Republican primary voters is a pretty small number of people. With a more normal candidate you might take that as being in some way representative of the wider population, but Trump is probably not going to gain much more support than he already has, since he's so extremely polarizing.
- api 11y agoIf by "small minority" you mean "blue collar working class" then yes. These are the losers of globalization and they are seething with rage and would vote for Hitler if it would bring back jobs.
- hysterix 11y agoBlue collar workers would vote for Hitler. Ahh yes, glad to see there is still civil discussion on ycombinator.
- api 11y agoI was being a bit hyperbolic but I think the level of anger is nearly there, yes. For all but the highest skill brackets of the workforce, real wages have fallen since around 1970 while everything else (food, energy, real estate, tuition, health care) has gone up. You can't do that to people and expect anything good to come of it. I think Trump (and to a lesser extent Sanders) is only a preview. We'll see a full-blown fascist or hard-line socialist candidate eventually if this doesn't reverse. I also wasn't meaning to badmouth blue collar folks. On the contrary, I was trying to communicate just how much anger there is out there outside of BubbleLand. Sometimes you have to be hyperbolic to get your point across and get people to wake up and see what's happening. The middle of America has been in a depression since 2000... that's going on 15 years.
- pc86 11y agoIt's been said a couple of times by people smarter than myself in this area - Trump has a high floor [of votes], but a very low ceiling.
- mikeash 11y agoYep, that's exactly what I'm trying to say with a larger quantity of less intelligible words.
- mineshaftgap 11y agoTrump only exists as a candidate because of politically correct bullshit which is about to go the way of the dodo. Only in Europe can it be seen as viable that the majority of people can be on the government dole.
- dragonwriter 11y ago> but Trump is probably not going to gain much more support than he already has, since he's so extremely polarizing. I doubt that's true; that 31% is with the conservative establishment pouring an order of magnitude more money into the campaign of establishment candidates (particular Jeb Bush) that are getting no traction despite the vast spending; there's already signs that significant parts of the establishment are coming around to Trump of the least-bad viable candidate (and others parts of the conservative establishment going to Cruz, who is similarly situated with regard to the establishment, and likewise seeing success despite the vastly greater spending and conservative establishment support for other candidates that are not gaining traction). When the flood of conservative establishment resources that has been deployed against Trump/Cruz begins being split by Trump and Cruz -- and most of it finally lines up behind one of them if, as seems likely, they secure the party nomination -- they'll do much better than they do with those resources opposing them.