4 ms·
This is an older article from the beginning the the month as China was really struggling with its stock market. As others have pointed out, debt, in itself, isn
by ChuckMcM 11y ago
This is an older article from the beginning the the month as China was really struggling with its stock market. As others have pointed out, debt, in itself, isn't really an "issue" so much as it is money from the future being brought into the present. And when the future has a lot more money than the present does, sending that money into the past isn't a drag on the economy. But when the economy is about the same size in the future as it is now, then that future economy is going to have to figure out how to operate without all that moeny it sent to the past.
For the government debt it isn't a huge issue because the Government can essentially decide not to pay itself back. But for public debt it means that the economy is held back. Imagine if the trillions of dollars corporations in the US are currently holding in "cash" was all going to paying off previous bond holders. That money would not be available for acquisitions or new investment. So those companies would grow slowly or not at all.
- static_noise 11y agoCan you explain the "money from the future" thing? The only money that I know is a) a metal coin and b) a contract. Now, the contract naturally deals with future expectations as does the stock market. The stock market, however, does not create money. It distributes money. One problem that arises in this regard is making contracts about money (which is other contracts). When the expectations fail, the contracts fail and if the contract was used to create money, you now have a problem. The money supply ultimately shrinks and the contracts about money start to fail. This is usually the point where the government announces big spending programs to lessen the pain. You may ask where does the government get that money? There are two fundamentally different methods. 1) from people who accumulated money. They give it to the government and the government spends it. In turn the government needs more money to pay those people back. Does the money supply increase this way? Kind of, but not really. It just helps to bring existing money back into circulation but does not create new money. It is therefore only a temporary fix. One day the government will stop paying those people back. 2) The government just creates new money. They can do this if they control the currency (sorry, Greece). The dangerous part about this is that it is so easy to create new money once the dam has been broken and this new money isn't backed up with value. When this goes out of hand it leads to hyperinflation (as in Germany 1920s) where the currency is devalued. By having a really strong and reasonable government, you can force 1) at low cost and control 2) without going overboard. China might be in a position where they can do that for a long time.
- ChuckMcM 11y ago"Money from the future" is a way of describing using future GDP to pay for current goods. Its a bet that what ever you are using the money for will result in a way to pay it back in the future while still benefiting from the investment. Simple example: I borrow $50,000 from a bank to open a restaurant. Lets split that into two bets: First, I bet that from my future revenue, I'll be able to pay back the bank and keep operating my restaurant. So in my own time line if you will I am taking money I'll be earning from paying customers in the future and using it in the present to actually build my restaurant. The way I do this is with a bank. Second, the bank kind of believes and kind of doesn't believe that I can pay it back. So it says "we'll take some money we have laying about and give it to you to open a restaurant, but you have to pay it all back to us in 10 years and every year we want an additional 7.2% from you. What that means is that after 10 years you will have paid them back double the amount of money you borrowed. So I've taken $50,000 of my future revenue, and turned it into a monthly obligation to the bank of $834. So if I sell my pies for $8.34, the first 100 pies of every month end up having all that money going to the bank which loaned me the money. So in my "present" money is going to pay off my "past" borrowing. Had I not taken the loan that $834 would go right into my pocket. In a Macro Economic sense, if you take on debt, and invest the capital represented by that debt to grow the economy, then in the future the larger economy, some of the GDP is going to servicing (or paying off) that debt rather than additional growth. If your economy cannot sustain that drag (debt service) then it tends to contract, which makes it even less able to support that drag. If you read George Soros he will tell you that any day now the entire world is going to implode in just that fashion :-). The careful thing you have to watch out for is talking about "money" which everyone thinks of as bills and coins or balances in a bank account, and "GDP" which is essentially the "value" created by all of the economic activity in an economy. Governments try to manage their economy to grow its GDP, and because transactions in the economy are often (but not always!) transacted using the national currency, economic figures are often reported in terms of dollars or yuan or yen or what have you. But you have to remember that you can have an economy that doubles in size, the the size of the monetary denominational transactions might be the same, more (inflation), or less (deflation). China is in the situation of trying to show the world a growing GDP (their economy). They have a spotty track record when it comes to how accurately they compute that :-) but fundamentally if they cannot actually grow it, then the debt they hold which they created in order to grow, will not be serviceable without shrinking the size of their economy. The traditional "fix" for that is that the exchange rate between economic value and currency changes so that the numbers match. China allows the Yuan to "inflate" to 10x its current value, and then services the debt with this inflated value. But what that really means is you aren't selling enough pizzas so you start charging $834 per pizza and just by selling one a month you can meet your monthly debt payment. And the citizen says "Gee, remember when you could get a nice pizza for less than $10? I miss those days."
- thwarted 11y agoFor the government debt it isn't a huge issue because the Government can essentially decide not to pay itself back. But for public debt it means that the economy is held back. "Public debt" is another name for "Government debt"[0]. From the rest of your description, you means "debt owed by the non-government public", private debt, or "household debt" (which doesn't strictly include corporate debt like your example outlines). [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Government_debt https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Government_debt
- ChuckMcM 11y agoAbsolutely, I'd edit the post but rather that acknowledge the gaff here. Debt the government owes to itself it has a number of ways to manage, debt between private entities is a much harder thing to fix without tanking the economy. The canonical example these days is the subprime mortgage crisis.
- hackaflocka 11y agoWhat does "Chinese debt" refer to? - Debt owed by Chinese citizens? - Debt owed by companies headquartered in China? - Debt owed by the Chinese Govt? What about a Chinese multinational that has offices all over the world, and has incurred debt all over the world? Is all their debt considered as Chinese debt?
- ChuckMcM 11y agoDebt instruments denominated in Yuan (renminbi) [1] [1] http://www.economist.com/news/business-and-finance/21679341-its-new-status-might-make-weaker-yuan-chinese-renminbi-joins-imfs http://www.economist.com/news/business-and-finance/21679341-...
- hackaflocka 11y agoThanks. But that's a very fuzzy concept innit? After all, currencies are convertible and fungible. All that it really implies is that the high debt levels will likely keep the value of the Yuan low.
- hackaflocka 11y agoOn a separate note, can some foreign company or government issue debt instruments denominated in Yuan? Why not? It's a convertible currency after all...
- seanmcdirmid 11y agoThe RMB is not a fully convertible currency, so no.
- cylinder 11y agoDebt is always mistakenly discussed when it is more appropriate to discuss debt burden.