3 ms·
> However, individuals who buy and hold investments, including those who invest in index funds that trade infrequently Wait, how is that possible? Are the und
by kasey_junk 11y ago
> However, individuals who buy and hold investments, including those who invest in index funds that trade infrequently
Wait, how is that possible? Are the underlying trades that make up the index not taxed? Do the funds receive some sort exemption? If so, how do I become an entity like that?
Seems to me that as an "average" investor I'm going to get taxed 3 times now. The underlying index trades, my own entry and exit from the index and on the gains from the trade (hopefully). Wouldn't it be simpler to just tax the gains as we do now at a higher rate?
[Later] On second thought this is even worse for folks like me (whether I count as "average" or not I don't know). Most of my trading portfolio exists in the form of index funds in tax deferred accounts. My long hold of those index funds now acts as a back door for lots of taxation that is less obvious.
- vostok 11y ago>Seems to me that as an "average" investor I'm going to get taxed 3 times now. The underlying index trades, my own entry and exit from the index and on the gains from the trade (hopefully). I don't have a view on whether this is good or bad, but this is exactly what happens in one of the markets with a relatively high transaction tax.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- tomp 11y agoIf the goal would be to slow down the market, you could simply... slow down the market. Genious, I know! For example, a mandatory delay for all orders. Or auctions every 1/2/5 minutes.
- kasey_junk 11y ago> If the goal is to slow down the market, a transactional tax is needed The idea that a transaction tax will in anyway slow down the market is dubious to me, that said, if our goal is to limit the number of transactions, why don't we just pass a law that does that? Even if we did that, it still doesn't follow that it won't impact people who are invested in index funds...
- vanviegen 11y agoThe difference is that individual investors will often hold on to their shares for months or years, rendering the trading tax insignificant. The tax is targeting (very) short-term professional traders, selling and buying back shares multiple times a day (or per second, in some cases). This type of trading adds little value to the useful allocation of capital, and imposes a 'tax' on other traders. To me, that sounds like as good a thing to tax as any. Besides, I'd guess that implementation of such a tax would be relatively straightforward, as far as taxes go.
- kasey_junk 11y agoExcept if I'm "holding" an index I'm not really holding anything. An index is made up of lots of trades over time. I'm dubious about every part of your argument, but even if I weren't it still doesn't hold that long term index "investors" aren't impacted by this.