4 ms·
Dear Hedge Funds: Index Funds Didn’t Eat Your Returns
- randomfool 11y agoMaybe Bill Ackman should not have invested such a high percent of his hedge fund into a un-ethical price-gouging pharmaceutical company (Valeant).
- tristanj 11y agoThat's not a fair criticism. At the time they invested, Valeant posted impressive financials with strong growth potential. Investors had no clue about the fraud occurring within the company. It was very rational to invest at that time. I don't think it's fair to say it's his fault for believing someone else's fraud.
- randomname2 11y agoHe doubled down on Valeant when the fraud came to light.
- hkmurakami 11y agoReminds me of AIG. Looked great on paper until the stuff off the books came to light.
- momavujisic 11y agoYet Ackman argues that index funds are destroying his and hedge fund's abilities to better govern a company. I guess the fraud was the fault of those darn index funds!
- randomfool 11y agoNot all thought so- http://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2015-11-01/munger-isn-t-done-bashing-valeant-after-months-of-holding-nose http://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2015-11-01/munger-isn... The fraud is not so much my concern- it's the unethical business plan. Valeant is just a watered down Turing Pharma. All the while Ackman continued to grow his position.
- mseebach 11y agoOne of the things hedge funds do to justify their high management fees, is to research the companies they invest in very deeply, definitely deeper than looking at financials, often meeting with management.
- dsr_ 11y agoA dozen or so years ago I got a call from what turned out to be Michael Dell's wealth managers. They wanted to interview me about my recent ex-employer. Clearly their research goes much deeper than reading over the 10Q forms and annual reports.
- entee 11y agoIndex funds are by all evidence the better choice for the average individual, but they present something of a chicken and egg problem. To set the price of the index, you need people buying and selling individual stocks. If everyone owned index funds, there would be no index. What is the percentage of the market owned/run by index funds where the premise of following an index starts to break down? The article says we haven't reached it, and that at that point active management approaches will regain an upper hand. Still, I wonder if it's true and the broader question remains.
- HappyTypist 11y agoAs the article days, as index investing becomes more prevalent then the potential profits from price discovery also increases. This should lead to more active investing, correcting the imbalance. Ultimately, index investing returns (before fees) should equal or nearly equal aggregate active investing returns (before fees). This makes index investing /always/ being a better option.
- meric 11y agoThe additional profit from active investing and price discovery will come from timing a market where momentum from index funds has clearly overshot fair value to risk. I think we're over that point, or perhaps I'm rationalising my own active investment.
- randomname2 11y agoOn why index funds are not such a safe bet necessarily: http://charleshughsmith.blogspot.com/2016/01/the-illusion-of-safety-index-funds-are.html http://charleshughsmith.blogspot.com/2016/01/the-illusion-of...
- yason 11y agoTo quote: "What is left unsaid is that if the broad market declines 50%, index funds also plummet 50%." The article is just stupid. If someone doesn't realize that the index funds will go up and down based on the very market they're indexing, and that all markets go up and down all the time, maybe that someone should just consume their money so that people with more wits can take better care of them. Who would be such an idiot to claim they're "safe" in the first place? Any investing is never "safe": you can always risk losing part of your money, even if you invest in a house. Not investing your money isn't safe either. Indexes can certainly dip for years: that's why you manage your risk and only invest money you don't need that much so that you don't have to cash in your investment during bad times. As long as the economy grows the growth will eventually be reflected in the indexes. Even a single 10-year period with a common stock index lower in the end rather than in the beginning would be, in practice, a rare occasion. Most depressions are over in a few years. Some continents can tank longer but you will want to buy indexes from different areas of the world anyway. Or you can only buy your local indexes, making sure you will yourself go up and down with the indexes you buy. An index will grow a few percent annually in the average, compounded. This is over decades which imply bad years and very good years. To buy the most passive index funds that have the smallest operating costs and letting your money sit in there is more and more likely to beat active funds and individual stock picking simply by waiting for the years to go by. Any costs saved by skipping active management fees or stock transaction fees will accumulate into your earnings instead.
- randomname2 11y agoHedge fund Nevsky Capital called it quits about a month ago (and this is a fund with historically stellar performance). Their "goodbye letter" [1] does an excellent job at spelling out some of the reasons hedge funds are a less attractive proposition lately. [1] https://www.scribd.com/mobile/doc/294654490/Nevsky-Newsletter-151231 https://www.scribd.com/mobile/doc/294654490/Nevsky-Newslette...
- vonklaus 11y agoInteresting. Markets are totally broken but I hadn't seen any legitimate players acknowledge that yet, good find. While the main argument in favor of HFT is providing liquidity, there really isn't a situation where a 'real' investor needs liquidity at the microsecond level. Solid private companies refuse to go public not on boarding the typical mix of innovators/new companies on an exchange. Companies have much shorter lifespans. and a massive amount of other factors, I can't do justice to on a 48hr sleep deficit. My personal thesis, we are in a huge bubble. Tech, while certainly overvalued, is possibly the least out of whack with a true underlying value (to the degree that even exists). Signs of this are everywhere. It isn't a terrible thing I don't think, but an average investor might not make much money in the market if they started putting money in now.
- kasey_junk 11y ago> Markets are totally broken but I hadn't seen any legitimate players acknowledge that yet That is one way to read the letter. Another way to see it is that technical innovation has provided much cheaper ways to capture the value the hedge fund previously provided. Between index funds that are a cheap way to capture macro gains and and algo funds as a cheap way to capture micro gains there just isn't a reason to pay a hedge fund manager his 2 & 20. I for one am glad about this, because that hedge fund managers profit came largely out of my (or some aggregate person much like me) pocket. > HFT is providing liquidity, there really isn't a situation where a 'real' investor needs liquidity at the microsecond level This is a common misstatement of the liquidity argument for HFT market makers. The correct way to frame it is that HFT market makers can provide liquidity cheaper for a variety of factors: 1) cheaper infrastructure as it is much cheaper to get a machine at an exchange than a person in a pit. 2) more efficient quoting as a computer can quote thousands of markets while a person can quote a half dozen. 3) less risk which is the crux of the argument for speed. To a market maker (HFT or otherwise) the risk they are trying mitigate is the risk presented by hedge funds and other large block orderers. Those large blocks will move the price of the market (that is in fact how the large block orderer captures profit, the information imbalance they have at the beginning of the order compared to the end). Historically some of that profit came out of the market makers pocket, so they had to price every trade higher to account for it. It has always been a cat and mouse game between market makers and hedge funds. Now HFT is better at recognizing and reacting to these large block orders meaning the market maker can price less risk into all of their quotes. > an average investor might not make much money in the market if they started putting money in now. One of the very nice things about our markets is that they will actually reward you handsomely if you take that opinion and turn it into action.
- kgwgk 11y agoMatt Levine's take on Bill Ackman vs index funds: http://www.bloombergview.com/articles/2016-01-27/bill-ackman-runs-an-anti-index-fund http://www.bloombergview.com/articles/2016-01-27/bill-ackman...
- paulpauper 11y agoThe rise of indexing parallels the cutthroat, winner-take -all nature of the post-2008 stock market and economy where winners like Google, Amazon, Visa, and Facebook, for example, are bid higher and higher to no end and companies that show slightest weakness are culled quickly. Even blue chips are not immune to this. Walmart stock crashed 30% in 2015 in an otherwise flat market due to some minor weakness in store sales. In the 80's and the 90's, large funds were more willing to put money in sub-par stocks & sectors, investing indiscriminately, but post-2008 capitalism has gotten much smarter and discriminating. That means lots of losing stocks and few winners, leaving investors with one of three choices: be lucky or skilled enough choose the handful of winning stocks, choose index funds, or choose active management, the latter which tries to beat the first two but almost always fails and has really high fees. The second choice is the most viable.
- cm2187 11y agoThe solution would be larger indices referenced by ETF, so that passive investors would buy pretty much "the whole market" and not just a subset of stocks that would end up being overpurchased. But a smaller index has one important benefit, which as an ETF investor is key to me. I do not believe in the ability of a randomly picked asset manager to outperform the market (and I have no way to pick one any other way). An index selects stocks by just one criteria: the market capitalisation. So it will be selling stocks that are on the way down and buying stocks on the way up (as they become big/small enough to enter/exit the index). Very simple investment rule and good enough in my opinion. This strategy comes with a "tax": hedge funds are watching stocks about to get in or out of an index and front-run the expected flow of ETF buyers and sellers, which means I leave some money on the table. That's the tax I pay for being a lazy investor.