7 ms·
What’s Apple’s competitive edge going forward?
- leonatan 11y agoThe author mentions one thing which perplexes me. Do Not Disturb turns off automatically every morning, eve if I manually enable it during negotiations the day. His example makes no sense.
- josephpmay 11y agoApple's major competitive edge right now is supply chain and economies of scale. They are able to source materials far better than basically anybody else. This has always been Tim Cook's strong suite. Another competitive edge is chip design. Apple's A9x has a custom PowerVR implementation that blows its competitors out of the water in terms of power and efficiency. They seem to be consistently ahead in this regard. Apple's major R&D investments right now are in Music, VR/AR, and the car project. They're working on some cool things in music that I can't talk about, but IMO music is too small of a market with too small margins, and Apple is putting way too much effort into it. Apple has made some really good VR/AR hires, but Facebook, Microsoft, and Alphabet have better teams. Who knows how the car project will turn out. Apple is currently investing more in R&D than they ever have before. This scares me because their successful projects have almost always been on the thin side investment wise. Apple has traditionally launched products with the bare minimum of features and built up from there. People hate them for it, but it works. I hope they're not moving to a more monolithic model. Lastly, Apple seems to have had a collapse in quality in the past year or so, especially with phones. This is anecdotal as I haven't seen any actual data on it, but I know so many people who have gone through numerous iPhones (for the most part 6s's and 6s Pluses) that have had one problem after another. I've been pretty lucky, but I have a 6, not a 6s. My previous 5s, however, barely lasted a year.
- tonyedgecombe 11y ago"Apple's major competitive edge right now is supply chain and economies of scale." This is interesting because it wasn't why people started switching in droves, it was because customers perceived the product to be much better than the competitions.
- fleitz 11y agoPart of that IS supply chain... You can't make a great phone with shitty components. Many things that Apple does in the supply chain are completely out of reach for it's competitors either because of resources or culture.
- vixen99 11y ago'its competitors'
- jinushaun 11y agoTheir supply chain is why competitor can't make phones that come close in terms of fit, finish and quality. Everyone else is stuck with second rate parts because Apple has the supply chain on lock.
- HappyTypist 11y agoI think that's just a result of technology getting more complex and complicated. A light bulb is pretty reliable for its lifespan, and my Commodore 64 still works fine. The latest iPhones have curved glass displays, even more accurate color reproduction retina displays, much more advanced baseband and OS, multiple microphones, etc, not to mention it's thinner. These advances come with trade-offs - the more parts there are, the more likely it's to break.
- Nr7 11y agoSupply chain was one of Nokia's competitive edges when they were big and it didn't do much good to them in the end.
- sytelus 11y agoApple really really need to focus on starting new product lines. The biggest mistake companies often make at this stage is "it's not for us if it's not going to be billion dollar business" mindset. Apple should just go after every product that it can produce at significant improvement. Everything from kitchen microwave to digital picture frame to 3D printers to quadcopters to children's toys is a fair area to explore. This will require balancing resources between mature products and new products, aggressive talent acquisition and product life cycle management that scales to 100s of products. Companies with cash flow like Apple should be announcing new product every quarter. Instead of trying to optimize for one product and get all possible thud for once-a-year event they should spread out their events over more eggs in the basket. Some of the products will only sell few million and may not move the needle but as long as Apple had good return on their total investment, it should be ok.For example, they can easily spin up team of just 10 people to produce digital photo frames and it's not going to be billion dollar market but if it makes revenue in access of 10 million, it's prett good ROI. Eventually the long tail of small products should be much more anti-fragile and sustainable for large margins. This is exactly opposite to what Jobs wanted (focus on 2 or 3 things). I think Jobs philosophy was necessary as long as there was one super good guy who needed to make all the calls. This is extremely fragile system. A much better system is 100s of product designers working on 100s of internal experiments and 10% of those passes internal scrutiny on quality and advancement of art to finally face the market except that not every product is expected to become billion dollar market. Just 10s of million dollar market supported by small a team should be good enough. Create a long tail instead of keep looking for that lucky unicorn.
- gareim 11y agoThe day I notice them doing this is the day I sell any shares I own in Apple. Maybe it works in the short term, but going into "100s of products" dilutes not just the brand, but the attention to detail as well. When I walk into an Apple store, I see the three main product lines and I see a few others scattered. I see a great staff (35 floor employees on a Thursday afternoon!) helping people with new purchases, teaching people how to use their Macs, and occasionally a tutorial on a specific subject. In your vision, I would be walking into a Walmart.
- jevgeni 11y agoLet me rephrase the title: "What Might Apple's Competitive Edge Be In The Future?" Abstract: A guy fuels the brand war using a "harvard.edu" domain, some hand wavy anecdotes, and ugly English.
- fleitz 11y agoEleventy billion in cash.
- adventured 11y ago*two-eleventy billion dollars in cash All joking aside, they have a net of something like $165 billion in cash. That's a very large competitive advantage indeed, even if they had to take a large tax hit on it in the process of repatriating. Basically every other phone maker except Samsung has to be careful not to make a big mistake from one generation to the next, or it might be their last.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- MaysonL 11y agoCulture, retail, people, and organization.
- dijit 11y agoreading the topic and not the article, my gut feeling is high quality products, whether it be phones or laptops. But, -especially- laptops. I've been looking for a replacement for my x201 thinkpad for about two years, for me, it's the last high quality laptop that exists with linux support. Taking OSX is fine because it's widely used and has a POSIX backend/bash/etc So, if you want high quality hardware and a POSIX OS then OSX/Apple is definitely where you go. and it runs linux better than most laptops /anyway/.
- mironathetin 11y agoThis is a funny reply, if you remember yesterdays discussion about Apples missing computer innovation: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10980023 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10980023 enjoy
- dijit 11y agoInteresting; and I agree with their point. For me a well crafted tool is more important than a highly performant one in terms of GPU/CPU throughput. Build quality and driver support mean a lot to me, which is why I'm still using a 5-6 year old Thinkpad X201
- mironathetin 11y agoYes, I agree with that too. I prefer a well done computer, that is stable and low maintenance compare to a super high end one. But I wouldn't mind, if Apple could offer both: close to cutting edge hardware plus a stable OS. I also used Thinkpads as long as I was on linux. But I dropped linux because it took so much more time to administrate compared to OS X.
- dagw 11y agoA related aspect of this is that Apple focuses on just a handful of models while companies like HP and Dell seem to have hundreds, making it even harder to choose. Let's say I read that the HP Xbook 2788Q is the greatest laptop ever and has perfect Linux support, and want to buy one. First of all since HP has so many different laptops, finding a store that actually carries a particular HP laptop is very tricky so it's basically impossible to get a hands on look at the laptop before buying. Then it turns out that HP doesn't sell the Xbook 2788Q in my country, they sell the (visually similar) 2789P instead. Are there any major differences? Is the reviews for the 2788P relevant? There's no easy way to tell, making it very difficult to compare and buy laptops. Apple makes it easy, a MacBook is a MacBook all around the world so I know exactly what I'm getting.
- tluyben2 11y agoTL;DR laptops have been hit/miss for me but phones/tablets are miles ahead. I am no Apple fan per se; I loved their laptops but I got burnt; I forgot the English/American term for it; monday laptop or something I think it is? The best laptops I had before Apple were Fujitsu... And the warranty. US/EU companies should be so ashamed. For not paying more they would get the laptop from my home and give me a new one mostly, no questions asked. Dropped, water damage, whatever. They still do that for company laptops but they are not so interesting anymore. They were then (8 years ago?) for me, especially the P1510/20 series. Panasonic took that over but they are a lot more expensive. My last P1510 works fine still. Brilliant stuff. Anyway. After that; My first 2 Macbooks were magic. I dropped an entire pot of tea on my 2nd one; it was before the moist sensors and it was under warranty so they replaced it. Very nice. While it was in 'repair' I needed to work; I bought a Macbook Pro and it was horrible. I got the old Macbook back and the Pro which should be faster was slower. Brought both to Apple (in Amsterdam) and they said it had something to do with my software. Yeah. VIM. It's super heavy. Very nasty experience. Battery life on the Pro was not there either but they couldn't find anything so I had to suck it up. I bought an Air 11 inch. What a GREAT machine. Excellent battery life (I USE VIM 90% OF THE DAY FFS), light, looks good. A friend told me the Macbook pro is excellent. So I gave the Air away to a friend and bought a kitted out Pro. The misery. No battery life and it was slow with max mem and cpu. Slower than the Air on everything. Again; Apple says it isn't. I won't mention Vim again. Having said all that; smartphones. I want to use Android. I want to believe in Android and Android phones. I have tried all top phones for Android. But no, it doesn't work; iPhone really feels so much better. And tablets there is no comparison; iPad wins hands down. The MS stuff starts to get somewhere but i'm not using tablets for productivity as it still feels annoying and without productivity iPad really feels so nice. Maybe it happens (I'm trying) one day. When I leave home on long trips I bring an iPhone, iPad and Lenovo X220 (18 hours battery). There is currently nothing that works better for me. Edit: X220 is with Ubuntu; I cannot get into Windows for the past 33 years; I went from Basic -> CP/M -> MS DOS (very shortly) -> Unix (forgot the flavor) -> SunOS/Solaris -> Linux; Windows feels distinctly alien. It is not hatred or anything else than that I really cannot into it or see how I could work efficiently with it.
- pjmlp 11y agoThat is one of the reasons I never jumped the boat to Apple, even though I like the NeXT origins of Mac OS X. For the type of stuff I do at home, games and graphics, CPU and discrete GPU matter a lot. So given the price difference from a Macbook Pro to similar specked Windows laptops, I could never justify the 1000 € price difference specially when the hardware has issues unjustifiable for a 2 500 € laptop (2.5x the average engineer salary on my home country).
- melted 11y ago>> My iPhone 6 Plus became unstable in its 6th month of life Take it to the store, you dummy. People are so used to the complete lack of customer service from everybody else that this doesn't occur to them. The whole point of paying more for Apple stuff is that they make and sell high quality gear. On the rare occasion when there's a quality issue, you just take it to the store and they fix it right there and then, or if it can't be fixed there, in 2-3 days. As to what the advantage is, they're the only ones that know how to make easy to use, high quality computing devices. They could easily go for the marketshare, but that's not the game they choose to play. They choose to own the profits, not market share. Perhaps an old fashioned way of doing things, but I like it. It's great to be the only one who knows how to do stuff properly. Netflix is the only company that knows how to properly run a streaming video business. Amazon is the only one that knows how to properly sell stuff on the internet. FB is the only one that knows how to do social networking. Google is the only one that knows how to do search. Tesla is the only one that knows how to properly make a luxury electric car. And so on and so forth. When you're the only one that knows how to do stuff, your lead is nearly insurmountable, since the competitor has to not merely be as good to win, it has to be twice or three times as good, which is impossible to do in some markets.
- MaysonL 11y agoThrow out the iPhone business. Value it at $0. What is the P.E. ratio of the whole company, taking only the non-iphone profit into account? ABOUT 30!
- tim333 11y agoApple's competitive edge going forward is probably much the same as it's been in the recent past - well designed products, strong brand, high profits through premium sales and economies of scale keeping costs down. I'm not sure that much has changed. Their sales may have levelled but they are pretty profitable. News from summer 15: >Apple Inc. recorded 92% of the total operating income from the world’s eight top smartphone makers in the first quarter, up from 65% a year earlier With Samsung being the other profitable company. Since then: >Tim Cook, Apple’s CEO said in a statement. "Our revenue grew 30 percent over last year to $74.6 billion and: >Samsung Electronics warned that its profits could fall again this year, as it announced a 19 per cent fall in net profit for 2015. The drop was largely driven by a 31 per cent operating profit decline for its IT & Mobile division – dominated by the mobile phone business, which has continued to lose market share to Chinese rivals Which suggests Apple may be making over 100% of phone industry profits. Not a bad competitive position.