19 ms·
Chicago Police Hid Mics, Destroyed Dashcams to Block Audio, Records Show
- Shivetya 11y agoI do not understand how these cannot be made idiot proof and cop proof. You can buy the simplest dash cams from China that record HD video and sound that take mere minutes to set up for under a hundred bucks. The first step needs to mandate a tamper proof system and disabling of any police car from leaving they yard unless the device passes on all tests. Then it should be required to report periodically to a central location if it is working and if not the officer can be directed to obtain a new car. Any device found damaged or tampered with should be a federal offense and investigated by the FBI. As in, those given the ultimate responsibility should be held the most strict standard. Don't like it, get out.
- vijayr 11y agoThese steps may be necessary, but how much of their behavior will change? And at what cost? Maybe it is time to evaluate training methods, hire people who have more empathy for powerful positions like police?
- kasey_junk 11y agoThink of how easy it is to spin that politically. "Why did crime rates go up? Because 20% of our patrol officers were stuck in a garage waiting for camera techs at any given time." Also remember that many American cities finances are in a shambles (and Chicago is a prime example). Hiring enough techs or more officers to make up the difference your rules will require is simply not an option. I don't disagree with the sentiment, and I hope federal law starts to treat police camera tampering as a major offense, but there is not an easy technical fix to the problem.
- rm_-rf_slash 11y agoThe spin on the other side would be just as intuitive: "Our police officers are more concerned with getting away with abuse of power than following the law they're supposed to enforce, and as a result, tens (to hundreds) of millions in taxpayer money is being spent on lawsuit payouts, essentially a bailout for bad behavior." While I agree that cameras should be required and intentional tampering a crime, I think behaviors would change much more quickly if laws were put in place to dock pensions and pay across the board to compensate for lawsuits of wrongful death and the like. Suddenly the "blue wall of silence" would become a very vocal supporter of police reform to identify and get rid of bad apples that threaten everybody's pension. Incentives are very powerful tools for changing behavior, much more powerful than blanket force by bodycam laws.
- ptaipale 11y ago> "blue wall of silence" would become a very vocal supporter of police reform to identify and get rid of bad apples that threaten everybody's pension This sounds like collective punishment - don't know about America, but over here, it would be not possible due to human rights treaties and legislation. The trade union or police would challenge this in a court and government would back down from such threats immediately. (Hey, even cops are human. Especially they are human. So even they have human rights.)
- rm_-rf_slash 11y agoIt depends on how you define the law. It could simply be a state or federal resolution that cuts funding to a municipality, regardless of where the money goes. So if money for roads and hospitals goes to pay for the misdeeds of bad cops and the administration takes no action, how will voters respond in the next election cycle?
- ams6110 11y agoI'm sorry but this is hoplessly naive. It's Chicago. One of the most historically corrupt machine governments in the USA. Nothing gets done without dozens of people getting paid off if not in cash than in favors or quid pro quo. It's not even something that people on the inside find unusual. It's just how it is, and always has been. It's a much bigger problem than just mandating tamper-proof cameras.
- Shivetya 11y agoThis is why I state, these items must be tamper proof and back by regulations and laws. Likely all this must be at the federal level and it become a crime on the federal level to tamper with them. So you make it nearly impossible to break/tamper without trying and its a federal offense to do so. Simple.
- ams6110 11y agoWho is buying the cameras? Who is installing the cameras? Who is determining if they are tampered with? Who is making the laws concerning the cameras? Chicago city politicians or employees. All of whom are being paid and influenced to do do their jobs in a way that favors the right people. You seem to be suggesting a federal takeover of the Chicago police department -- a city whose mayor is the former chief of staff of the president, who himself is a Chicagoan. Good luck with that.
- grb423 11y agoI've been on a ride-along with my suburban, middle-America department. The guy had to put clip the wireless mic to his shirt, make sure the antenna was oriented and power it on at go time to save battery. I don't know if there's newer tech that had more of a promise of being able to be made fool-proof from human error much less willful defeat.
- Cthulhu_ 11y agoYeah, smartphone technology; they run on 3/4G networks and have long battery life if just recording / transmitting audio.
- Cthulhu_ 11y agoYeah, just install smartphone technology behind the windscreen; always on, always connected, and can be monitored remotely. Software on there can deal with spotty connection, too - keep recording if connectivity is lost. And of course make any intentional damage to the things come out of the police officer's own pockets.
- sbkjabklvlag 11y agoThat police have the emotional and intellectual maturity of children wouldn't be so bad if they didn't also wantonly kill innocent people largely without consequence. Just another fine example of the American police state, but I'm sure some fascist can explain away.
- mapt 11y agoMaturity? You see this as a prank? I think you're on the wrong foot here. The premise of the cameras was not that they were there for decorative effect as some sort of symbol to be vandalized. I see it as a majority of the Chicago police force destroying evidence and equipment necessary to investigate their actions. This is open rebellion with the intent to escape justice - though for what crime specifically we may never know. Any proveably "deliberate" tampering should end in a firing, revocation of pension, and then court case brought against them. Any deliberate tampering during which the officer sustains a complaint against them? Enter this into presumptive evidence against the officer and recommend prosecution. We started monitoring the officer because it turns out they can't be trusted as much as we thought - slipping our monitoring and destroying our property is an overtly hostile act, the same as openly slitting the tires of an Internal Affairs agent in the process of investigating the officer. To deter it in the future: ramp up the random checks (you did have random checks... right? I should be able to pick a random time and download footage) and enter in punitive fines for poorly maintained or operated cameras; Raise salary slightly to make it budget-neutral, but pay for prompt repair first.
- MCRed 11y agoA big part of the problem is our system is set up to favor the governent-- when there's a trial, the judge, the prosecutor, the cops (who handle and control all the evidence) the lab (many scandals in the past 40 years about fraudulent lab work) all work for the government. Even your lawyer is compromised by not being allowed to make certain arguments and the risk of offending the judge (Who there will be future cases before.) The jury are given blatantly tampering instructions from the judge, eliminating much of the value of an independent jury system. So, who is going to try cops when they are corrupt? By what mechanism can we the people enforce the law on our own government? It seems silly to go before our own government and beg for them to obey their own laws. Sometimes we get lucky- like gay marriage- but how many decades did that take? It was 1980s when the supreme court ruled that sodomy could be criminalized on the basis of "a thousand years of christian tradition" (namely NOT on the basis of the constitution.) So of course, we will continue to see more and more corruption until like AIDS is now, and the wars overseas -- the news simply stops reporting about it, because it has become the background noise of the society we live in. That's going the wrong direction. I'm far more afraid of being killed by a random cop than I am by Walmart or anything in walmart. They all have an incentive to keep me safe so I'll keep buying. They would face consequences (not even criminal, just market consequences) if they were killing people. Cops on the other hand, they get away with it. And blatantly do day in and day out.
- pjc50 11y agoUntil police are jailed for this, nothing will improve. What's the US equivalent of the Independent Police Complaints Commission?
- bdisraeli 11y agoThere is no national body that oversees police, but Chicago has the Independent Police Review Authority. However IPRA rarely upholds complaints against police (it's staffed by ex-cops and other people connected to the police), and recently an investigator was fired after finding a shooting unjustified[1]. [1] http://www.wbez.org/news/city-fires-investigator-who-found-cops-fault-shootings-112423 http://www.wbez.org/news/city-fires-investigator-who-found-c...
- elthran 11y agoHas this been proposed at all? Is there anything weird about american policing/law that would mean a national, federal agency wouldn't be able to take on this role?
- ceejayoz 11y agoThe US Department of Justice does some of this. They sue for civil rights violations, often resulting in a "consent decree" where they either take over the police department or place them under a variety of restrictions. Ferguson just agreed to one: http://www.npr.org/sections/thetwo-way/2016/01/27/464610005/ferguson-justice-unveil-draft-of-negotiated-consent-decree http://www.npr.org/sections/thetwo-way/2016/01/27/464610005/...
- doobiedowner 11y ago"The reality is that we do not wash our own laundry - it just gets dirtier. " - Serpico
- pc86 11y agoThis would be much easier to implement at the state level. Aside from a few specific instances with the DOJ such as the consent decree mentioned elsewhere, the federal government does not have any authority over local police departments such that it can do much of anything.
- moomin 11y agoJust to be clear: what we are looking at is a concerted and coordinated criminal conspiracy to cover up a range of activities including murder.
- late2part 11y agoThis can't be upvoted enough. You're right. The police are protected by their dependent partners, the prosecutors. Anyone who does this should at the very least be prosecuted for one of the following: 1. Interfering with a police officer 2. Obstruction of justice 3. Destruction of property Ask yourself why they aren't? Is it the police union? Is it a true explicit conspiracy? What world we we live in that people get 3 days suspension for breaking a recording device their management put in? Can you do this to the cameras at your work location?
- JumpCrisscross 11y ago> Ask yourself why they aren't? The prosecutors and the officers they're charging may be drinking buddies, or at least have collaborated professionally before. Prosecutors may also fear other officers being unhelpful in the future to the person who charged the latters' buddy. The prosecutor may also fear having to open every case that officer was involved in to retrial. The prosecutor, themselves, may have logged those cases as wins. In the end, the system will never work unless an independent prosecutor, with the power to investigate and bring charges, exists for police crimes.
- Ntrails 11y ago> In the end, the system will never work unless an independent prosecutor, with the power to investigate and bring charges, exists for police crimes. Surely that's a trivial and obvious step? That's why an independent branch of cops was instituted to investigate other cops etc. Like I don't mean to denigrate your point - I just mean "How hasn't this already been done?"
- ihsw 11y agoThis right here is it -- the DA's and state's attorney's career advancement is tied to winning cases, and there is no better way to win a case than having the PD on your side. PDs that curry favor from their judicial counterparts get freedom from oversight. Both feed off of each-other, especially when confessions and plea bargains are the norm -- PDs coerce confessions and prosecutors coerce plea bargains, and justice remains un-served.
- moron4hire 11y agoHow long before people start defending them, "It's just a few bad apples"? And I won't hold my breath waiting for them to remember the full phase is "a few bad apples spoils the barrel."
- gopowerranger 11y agoThere are thousands and thousands of cops and you want to hold up one example as being representative? And before you scour the web looking for a second example, remember that there are thousands and thousands of police activities every day.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- ceejayoz 11y agoThe "it's just a few bad apples" excuse is especially egregious, as bad apples need to be disposed with rapidly before they rot the rest of the batch. Farmers who encounter a bad apple don't shrug and say "eh, there'll always be bad apples, nothing we can do". It's really weird how what should be a saying supporting police reform got twisted into something promoting indifference to abuse.
- mineshaftgap 11y agoThis is what happens when Republicans control a city.
- CPLX 11y agoThough I agree that this behavior is reprehensible and probably criminal, the comments here seem to miss at least some of the human dynamic here. I can't hardly imagine that most people posting here would ever consider a job where literally every word or sound that came out of their mouth during their entire working life was recorded, and likely subject to public disclosure. Saying that this is what cops signed up for is not a compelling counter argument either, as this is new and most of the cops in question didn't sign up to work in an environment like that at all. It seems odd to be even somewhat defending Chicago cops but someone should point out that there are two sides to this.
- s_q_b 11y agoIf you're not intelligent enough to know that law enforcement interactions with the public are recorded on dashcams, maybe you shouldn't go into police work...
- CPLX 11y agoBut that's part of my point. When most cops became cops that wasn't the case at all.
- moron4hire 11y agoWhen did most cops become cops? Shortly after discharging from the military. Amped up on PTSD and adrenaline addiction. Yeah, I want a camera on them every second of the day, whether they are on duty or off duty. The mentally ill should not have guns. We've had a steady drum beat that "common sense gun control" should include a psychological test. I don't think most cops coming into the job straight out of the military would be able to pass the same test proposed for civilians.
- pc86 11y agoThe majority of police forces have psychological testing for applicants and routinely dismiss otherwise fit, healthy and intelligent individuals because the psych came back inconclusive.
- mtgx 11y agoJust a few bad apples...that have long spoiled the whole barrel.
- nxzero 11y agoChicago has a long history of wide spread willingness within its government to act criminally in return for personal gain. Until Chicago itself is feed up with it, nothing will change.
- mtgx 11y agoThis is what some of us feared with the push for police bodycams, that they will eventually use the evidence only when it suits the police, but not anyone else, which could generally be even worse than not having the video at all. The footage should be required to be uploaded to a federal agency's cloud every 24h. And now some states are even giving the police permission to do that: http://www.wthr.com/story/31063724/bill-allowing-police-to-withhold-body-camera-video-passes-indiana-house http://www.wthr.com/story/31063724/bill-allowing-police-to-w... This is why Larry Lessig has been so right about the need to fix democracy first. As long as that isn't fixed first, the corrupt systems will always infect even the best ideas and policies that manage to pass at the federal or state level. You need proper democracy so people can easily throw out leaders who side with those with power and protect them.
- rubberstamp 11y agoWhen they can always get away with slap on the wrist, why not destroy camera or turn it off before shooting someone. Some other cop is going to back any and all claims in court. There is no evidence anyway. They make sure of that. I'm still waiting to see what happened with Ian's case. At least some are indicted because of cams now a days. Turning of cam should have some mark on service records and effect their pay/promotions etc. Whats the need of cop is not to obey and enforce law?
- Cthulhu_ 11y agoIn this case, charge the police officer with murder and obstruction of justice; the camera footage would exonerate them if they killed legitimately, after all. Disabling a camera means they've got something to hide.
- rubberstamp 11y ago[1] http://arstechnica.com/tech-policy/2016/01/body-cam-captures-mans-final-words-begging-the-cops-to-get-off-of-him/ http://arstechnica.com/tech-policy/2016/01/body-cam-captures... [2] http://arstechnica.com/tech-policy/2016/01/man-arrested-jailed-for-filming-cop-settles-lawsuit-and-gets-72500/ http://arstechnica.com/tech-policy/2016/01/man-arrested-jail... In case of [1], that man(and many others) will still be alive if cops behaved professionally rather than behaving like a bunch of _____ In case of [2], why weren't the cops charged with obstruction of justice There is no one overseeing police behavior, they can get away unless someone with enough time and money takes them to the courts and even then they get too little punishment.
- bbarn 11y agoLet's see.. in the 20 odd years here in Chicago, the sum of my police interactions are: Hit by a white shirt (supervisor) who came out of an alley on clark st while in a bike lane - somehow my fault, detained. Hit on foot, by a car with no lights on in a residential neighborhood while crossing at a crosswalk - somehow my fault for being outside while there was "a suspect being hunted" Watching officers on foot in 7-11's, local shops, etc, just walk in, take what the want, and leave. Helping a friend move to another city because he ended a relationship with a cop who made his life a living hell after they broke up. Being accused of trying to "make the neighborhood look bad" when I called the fire department because my neighbor had smoke coming out of the door in his apartment (turns out he was just passed out drunk and left a pizza in the oven, but what else do you do when you bang on a door pouring smoke and no one answers?) So yeah, once my S/O finishes what she needs to to change jobs, we're out of here I think. The police force here is really the icing on the cake of so much else that's overpriced, corrupt, or just plain sucks about Chicago. All the good things it's supposed to have just seem completely irrelevant to me anymore.
- rickdale 11y agoHelping a friend move to another city because he ended a relationship with a cop who made his life a living hell after they broke up. I was dating this girl a couple of years ago and we were pretty early on, but she wanted to spend the night. And we were cool so it wasn't an awkward thing, but what I figured out as that she didn't necessarily want to stay the night as much as she was afraid to go home at night. Her reasoning, "My mom just broke up with a police officer and they harass us now." Shes from a super small town with a police force with a reputation for having nothing to do, but staying busy. But even when she said it I thought she might be being dramatic. Now I get it. This type of behavior is ridiculously childish and it might not be the norm, but it seems like something someone could stop.
- jcromartie 11y agoPolice officers abuse their romantic partners at about twice the average rate. Domestic violence occurs in about 40% of households with police officers.
- GordonS 11y agoIs anyone really surprised with this? These things have to be made tamper-evident, otherwise this is going to happen.
- jordanlev 11y agoIt seems that this is a cultural problem and not a technological one. If the entire police force is against the idea of recording, how will tamper-proofing make a difference (if the people reviewing the videos are also complicit?)
- hwstar 11y agoTamper proofing is required in addition to making the necessary cultural changes. It keeps them honest.
- hwstar 11y agoThere needs to be seals on the cameras, and a connection to the police radio in the car which reports tampering back to the dispatch room. Any deliberate destruction should lead to disciplinary action up to and including termination.
- ihsw 11y agoGood luck proving deliberate destruction -- "accidents happen" and noisy hand-waving will result in nothing beyond three-day suspensions and desk jockeying.
- hwstar 11y agoIf there's a pattern, then a second hidden camera can be installed watching the first camera. You are correct when it comes to discipline, the police union will stand up to bad actor's behalf. That cultural issue will be a tough nut to crack.
- agumonkey 11y agoSeems like separation of power needs to reach further.
- digitalneal 11y agoGoogle Jon Burge if you think this isn't embedded into the culture of Chicago.
- tedks 11y agoThis has been the rebuttal every time the argument "we just need bodycams on police" comes up in the latest thread about police indiscriminately raping or abusing women/shooting black men in the street like hunters shooting deer/pepper spraying protesters at point blank range for having the audacity to stage a sit-in. Body cams won't magically make police accountable or less corrupt. Power corrupts. The only solution is to take power away from police.
- ohitsdom 11y agoWe do need bodycams on police, but the program needs to be properly administered. Documentation when things break, enough spares so malfunctions are quickly and easily replaced. The Chicago PD is clearly rife with corruption, so you can't just point to this program and say it won't work. There are lessons to be learned here, and they can be avoided with actual (and immediate) accountability.
- tedks 11y agoI think it's naive to assume that prosecutors will ever prosecute cops without massive public outcry, that police departments are at all capable of policing themselves (including documenting broken bodycams), or even that politicians are going to have enough teeth to stand up to the police unions. It's so naive it borders on stupidity. Do you really think "documentation" would change anything? It'd just lead to "Oops, didn't know that was broken sarge, I'll get a spare." "Oops, looks like all the spares are gone. Sarge, can you order some more?" "Oops, forgot to order some spares. Maybe I'll get to it tomorrow." Chicago is especially corrupt (as far as I know it's the only metropolitan police force with its own CIA-esque black site), but it's absolutely naive to think this can work anywhere. This is just the tip of the spear.
- DannyBee 11y ago" “How they determine that it’s purposely caused damages, I’d like to know,” Angelo said last month. “How they can figure out what is mechanical or what is human error, I’d like to know.”" Yeah, i mean how could you possibly tell whether it was human error for things like "wires cut with diagonal cutters". If the officers are so worried, they could do something fairly simple. They could take a cell phone video of what's going on when they try to turn on the audio! Crazy, i know
- alistairSH 11y agoTo be fair, Angelo's job (head of the local union) is to protect and advocate for the officers. Yes, he sounds completely ridiculous, but he can't come out and say "yup, they broke the dashcams." (In no way do I mean to imply he is correct, or that the system isn't completely broken.)
- DannyBee 11y agoFun fact: it's not effecitve advocacy if nobody believes you :)
- alistairSH 11y agoFair enough. :)
- mirascarvalone 11y agocomment
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- ej3 11y agoWhy is this the top post on hacker news? What does this have to do with anything other than anecdotal, hysterical media BS?
- entropicmind 11y agoI'm just speculating but I'd say that with the recent death of Ian Murdock and how that situation played out, tensions are high between the HN community and the police in America.
- trophycase 11y agoYeah, great. A bunch of tech nerds and programmers commenting on a job where your safety is constantly on the line and you have to make split second decisions and you're under enormous stress and there is no black and white. This board is so anti-police it's just disgusting.
- Aloha 11y agoI work in an industry that supports public safety. Yes, being a police officer is dangerous, but their safety is not /constantly/ on the line - yeah, maybe once a day, maybe a couple times a day, an officer is going to have to make a choice that could endanger them - its not every second of every day. The cameras in the end are supposed to protect the officer as much as the citizens, it makes the officers accountable, as well as provides backup for their version of events. Now I get the desire to not be recorded all the time, no one wants a surveillance state - but when the methods of redress for a corrupt officer are so few, body cameras are a reasonable precaution in the eyes of the public. HN is generally anti-authority, and right now, I can of very little visible authority wise than the police, so right now the police are there as a focus point.
- awqrre 11y agomaybe all police officers should have to record audio and video and do a live broadcast while on duty (someone has to make sure their equipment is working properly)...
- thorntonbf 11y agoThis is a problem at the top and the bottom of the department, and it won't get fixed until both sides are held appropriately accountable. The beat officers don't care because their management stack doesn't care. This should be pursued criminally, and would be were it anyone else messing with municipal equipment. This is a departmental corruption issue first and foremost - and it's the senior management that should be held to account. Unfortunately, the problem won't be fixed until some of them go to jail and/or are made to make compensation for the damages and time spent repairing the system. Only then will the policies change to where the guys on the street quit damaging equipment.
- ihsw 11y agoIt extends out of the department as well -- look no further than the DA and the stable of state prosecutors for another cesspool of laziness and neglect.
- thorntonbf 11y agoAgreed. And, that's actually pretty scary. When it comes to Ferguson-type departmental corruption, it shows just how institutionalized the racism is - and how far it extends outside of the departments. We should likely spend more time on this, as in this light, it doesn't matter what changes are made at a departmental level - there's no path to success on their own. Change is going to have to be at the elected official level - but those systems are so gerrymandered, and so corrupt that it presents a really difficult problem.
- songshu 11y agoWe need badge-equivalent cameras. What I mean is that we need to make cameras work the same way as badges and uniforms, in the sense that you just can't do police work if you don't have a working camera. A working camera has a red light on it which means that it is currently streaming (possibly buffering if temporarily out of wireless range). The police don't have to record anything, they just need to stream somewhere with associated meta data. NGOs will come forward to read the streams and save them. I understand it will be hard to get unions to agree to this and I don't have a solution, but I'm minded of the reforms made to policing in Northern Ireland as a success story.
- brandonbloom 11y agoyou just can't do police work if you don't have a working camera This is already becoming the policy in many forward thinking agencies. they just need to stream somewhere with associated meta data There are real challenges, both technical and practical. Technically, you've got to worry about connectivity and battery life. Practically, somebody has to pay for it all! There's also many genuine use cases for turning off cameras during a shift, not the least of which is that officers have to use the bathroom just like the rest of us, but others like when talking to confidential informants or at the request of domestic abuse victims. None of these problems are insurmountable, but it's going to take time, energy, and money. I understand it will be hard to get unions to agree to this That was true a few years ago, but now it's becoming very clear that the majority of decent officers want body cameras. They protect them individually and taxpayers against an endless stream of lawsuits. Google around: studies show that they work, very well, for reducing complaints and use-of-force incidents. Disclaimer: I work on Axon body cameras in Seattle. If you (or anybody else!) are interested in writing code that will help put a camera and less-leathal weapon on every police officer, please email me: brandon@evidence.com
- songshu 11y agoThanks, that actually made me feel more optimistic about it, although I hadn't thought of the issues you raise. Keeping a camera charged and working shouldn't be harder than other maintenance already needed such as keeping a firearm clean or keeping a car on the road. If we refine the condition to "you can't appear in public or interact with the public without your camera" then the bathroom problem goes away. Connectivity and confidentiality are harder problems. Confidentiality in particular if it's the case that that's also where a lot of the corruption is.
- Zigurd 11y agoThere is a near-total failure of the press to dig in to police corruption. When a case like this happens, the victim's name is splashed in the papers, and the press camps out on the victim's family's lawn. That's backward, and it does nothing but create some sensation. The cop involved in the shooting, his personal life, his family, his buddies in the PD, the cops who witnessed the event, their supervisors, etc. should be the ones under the TV lights. That's where you will find the perjurers and the corrupt.
- FourSigma 11y agoThese guys seem to make a decent living. https://data.cityofchicago.org/Administration-Finance/Current-Employee-Names-Salaries-and-Position-Title/xzkq-xp2w https://data.cityofchicago.org/Administration-Finance/Curren...
- chowes 11y agoThis seems like a good use case for https://petitions.whitehouse.gov https://petitions.whitehouse.gov, no? I have to imagine such a blatent abuse of the system would have to warrant more than a cookie-cutter answer from the administration.
- pg_is_a_butt 11y agowhy doesn't a citizen sacrifice their life for the greater good and show corruption how it can be effectively dealt with? you're all cowards.
- malloreon 11y agoif you destroy evidence, you should be found guilty of the crime itself as if you'd conspired in committing it, and get the maximum sentence.
- TheMagicHorsey 11y agoHow is disabling cameras and audio recorders only a slap on the wrist? Something is deeply wrong with policing in this country.
- c3534l 11y agoSo in even the most extreme, overly generous estimation of plausible "errors" a person could make, we're talking about a police force that is around 40% corrupt?
- mgleason_3 11y agoLook at the comments from the union rep. at the end of the story. Why is there no call from the public to: Outlaw public employee unions?
- thatswrong0 11y agoYou're getting downvoted, but I think this is a legitimate question to ask, at least about police unions. There are many serious problems with public sector unions. I'd like to point to the financial situations (unfunded pension liability related) of California and Illinois as prime examples of such problems.
- mgleason_3 11y agoI look at the comment from the Police Union and cant help wondering why there is no public outcry to: Outlaw public employee Unions?
- oliv__ 11y agoI just watched L.A Confidential a couple of days ago. All of this sounds awfully too similar.
- th0waway 11y agoMaybe it's time to disband police, in general? Just put up a few more cameras (total public coverage), make the footage available to anyone for up to a year, and allow persons to press charges for crimes committed (with hefty penalties for demonstrable false statements with mal intent). There would need to be some kind of force in place to investigate crimes committed in private areas, but we wouldn't need nearly as much shoe leather on the street. Yeah, there would be minuses too.
- SwellJoe 11y agoThe police forces in most of America have become a magnet for sociopaths and bullies. There is such a deeply held belief and culture of covering up wrongdoing by fellow officers that it provides a safe space for the absolute worst behavior humanity has to offer. And, because there is still a strongly held belief among most of the nation that, "most cops are good" or even that most cops are downright heroic, that to question or criticize police is to put a target on your back. A number of my friends are anti-police brutality activists (a few relatively well-known nationwide for it, but all are known by name by many in the local and state PD), and they have quite long arrest records; all bullshit charges, none of which stuck, but all part of a campaign by the police to make their lives miserable. One "accidentally" had his head smacked into a marble floor, hard enough to cause a concussion and a pool a blood on the floor and a night at the hospital, while he was passively filming police at an unrelated protest. This is not restricted to Chicago, though Chicago seems to be quite far advanced on the path to being the worst. In short: I don't know what should replace police in the US, but drastic change is needed. Not merely reform; the whole damned system needs to be torn down and rebuilt from scratch. The prison industrial complex, of which police are the front line foot soldiers, is a national disgrace.
- 13thLetter 11y agoDoing a ctrl-F for "emanuel" or "daley" in this comment section produced zero results, which is unfortunately rather telling. Chicago has been run by the same political party since 1931. If the police are this bad and you keep re-electing the people running the city anyway, you are part of the problem. Throw the bastards out, don't just grump on message boards and then keep obediently pulling the same lever in the voting booth where it counts.
- pessimizer 11y agoThere are no good choices. The challengers are generally people who have heard that Chicago/Illinois are great places to feed. In Chicago, there's The Machine: a system for raising large numbers of votes for Duh Mare's candidates from people who don't care who wins, they just want their Alderman to respond to their phone calls. Outsiders like Blagojevich and Rauner at the state level are just as awful. The amount of Republican pond scum that Illinois has had to deal with easily compares to the amount of Democratic pond scum that it has had to deal with, it's just a matter of upstate/downstate/collar counties preference which scumbag you vote for. They're all ultimately friends anyway; I think Emanuel once worked for Rauner.
- fencepost 11y agoDaley in particular was quite a piece of work - particularly in closing out his time in office with the parking meter giveaway. I can't help but wonder what kind of kickback evidence to he and his family we'd find if anyone were actually to do a real investigation of it. The real kicker is that if the city removes parking spaces temporarily or permanently, it must compensate the private vendor for the lost revenue. That makes sense, but when you throw in that it's a 75-year deal it starts to get a little murkier - want a bike lane? Better budget for the next 70 years of paying the vendor for the parking revenue for any removed spaces (and how is that calculated? Does it get recalculated every year? Is it based on nearby comparable areas or on fixed utilization percentages that don't account for changes in driving patterns and neighborhoods over time?) I strongly suspect that given changes in how people drive, etc. that by the end of the 75-year agreement Chicago will have ended up paying more in penalties to the vendor than they got in the first place, even indexed for inflation.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- odk 11y agoFrom the wise words of N.W.A - Fuck da police!!!
- photonwins 11y agoI grew up in an Asian country where I have seen police corruption first hand more than once and I always wished my country had better educated and morally strong individuals who would protect the weaker sections of the society instead of siding with rich/powerful people even if they are criminals. I always wished like in the west police would enforce the law regardless of the status of that individual and that police and other govt officials are better paid and hence there was no need for them to get corrupted for the sake few extra bucks. I am currently working in one of those "developed" countries in the west and observing things around me, reading articles/comments like here. It appears that, it is not really very different here either. I guess human greed is universal.
- AndrewUnmuted 11y agoMany police forces in Europe operate in a totally different manner than what you've described of Asia + America. This is not a "universal" problem. Ultimately, this comes down to the management strategies the police utilize. The British/American paradigm is the tragic, horrible police management strategy that leads to the types of stories we're discussing now. Many Asian countries follow the same such policies. Go look at Norway's police force, and you'll see that things can be very, very different.
- vacri 11y agoPolice in the US are very much not like police in other Anglo countries; they are much more adversarial. Not to say the other police are perfect, but it seems much worse in the US. Example: I'm from Australia, and was recounting a story here on HN about how I don't like that subtle power play when police pull you over and talk down to you in the car. So I get out (I'm very tall) and wait for them in a friendly manner. It changes the tone of the traffic stop. Doesn't change the outcome, but it's hard for them to talk down to someone they have to physically look up to. On relaying this story, multiple HN'ers from the US thought I was genuinely putting my life at risk of being shot by the police, and told me I should never ever do that. This is a genuinely foreign concept to me - that I should be fearful that police might be predisposed to shooting me for getting out of the car. That these folks even have that general fear speaks volumes as to the excessive force the US police use.
- thomasec 11y agoThe CPD and City of Chicago have long operated under their own terms, and they need to be very careful now that there is a national focus on them. The common perception from outsiders of the city has always been "well....that's just Chicago" - think when characters like Rod Blagojevich make it to the national spotlight. With high profile cases of police corruption at the very highest level, I think the "charm" of corrupt politics and government start to go away. I lived there for 7 years before relocating elsewhere, and at no point did it ever feel like the city was operating on behalf of its residence. There is segregation unlike anything I've seen in any other major city that is entirely ignored, the "startup" culture that they've been trying to cultivate for years is complete BS and at odds with how anti-business the city is, and now people are starting to see what happens when large government organizations go unchecked for decades. I guess the one silver lining about incidents like this is that it should put some national pressure (and hopefully, accountability) on the CPD. I am aware that things like this happen elsewhere, but having lived in about a half dozen cities in the US, I never felt like the problem was as large and systemic as I observed in Chicago.
- shostack 11y agoI'd love to know where Obama is in all of this given his South Side heritage. Also, corrupt cops are a very real thing in Chicago. Dated a girl briefly in Lakeview who warned me that I didn't want to meet her dad as he was a cop and it eventually came out that he was pretty fucking corrupt. The relationship ended for other reasons, but holy crap was I determined to end it amicably. Last thing I wanted was to be on the shitlist of a corrupt Chicago cop/dad.
- tptacek 11y agoA reminder that the primary election for Anita Alvarez, one of the country's worst states attorneys and the person with the most discretion in pursuing cases like this, is this March.
- a3n 11y ago> “How they determine that it’s purposely caused damages, I’d like to know,” Angelo said last month. “How they can figure out what is mechanical or what is human error, I’d like to know.” How video uploads significantly increase after the change in policy, with the same equipment and people, I'd like to know.
- anigbrowl 11y agoChicago PD needs to be disbanded and rebuilt from scratch under federal supervision. I had a lot of police in my family growing up and revered them as public servants, now I cross the street when I see a cop and won't give them the time of day. Yeah, a lot of cops are decent people doing a hard job, but no more respect until they clean up their own act.
- benclarke 11y agoPolice dashcams and bodycams are there to protect officers as much as the public. This being said, I can totally understand why many officers aren't too thrilled about being recorded every second of their shift, and clearly in Chicago several of them have taken action. Police officers are thrown into highly stressful situations every single day, and even "good" cops will make poor decisions from time to time. I think Police dash cams are in the public's best interest, and strongly believe that citizen journalism is helping communities hold authorities accountable, but there needs to be a balance between accountability and unfair scrutiny. Once this balance is found, hopefully incidents such as those described in the article will drop significantly.
- ccvannorman 11y agoCitizens, get some police suppression/accountability laws on the fucking ballot. The only people who will vote against police suppression laws are police. It's time to stop this bullshit.
- cant_kant 11y ago"The head of the police authority review board just resigned. An off-the-books police facility where over 7,000 people were taken and had their rights trampled was uncovered. So many people were tortured by the Chicago Police Department that a reparations fund was created. So many people were wrongfully convicted that the city has now been labeled the "false confession capital of the world."" http://www.nydailynews.com/news/national/king-chicago-police-department-corrupt-country-article-1.2457985 http://www.nydailynews.com/news/national/king-chicago-police...
- infinite8s 11y agoI bet a simple classifier on all these HN anecdotes could pinpoint the race of the posters to within 99% accuracy.
- atomicbeanie 11y agoThis is interesting. Normally police departments claim they have few ways to catch corrupt police. And I think there is more than a little truth to that. However, in this case the article shows that corrupt police are revealing themselves through the practice of destroying equipment. This could be an indicator that acts as a "canary" for police corruption! If police departments appropriately monitored such indicators, they may be on verge of discovering an easy method to spot criminal police officers before they do the damage to society.
- atomicbeanie 11y agoOf course, if the police do stuff like this: http://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2016/feb/07/leaked-police-files-contain-guarantees-disciplinary-records-will-be-kept-secret http://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2016/feb/07/leaked-police... it is unlikely they are willing to take responsibility for enforcement. Rarely does enforcement happen without oversight. By hiding police records they protect themselves, the police department leaders. We should, however, be able to do better. Public records, paid for by the public, are easily considered public property. I think courts could handle this.