4 ms·
It's a little unclear how this letter changes any of that. You seem to be jumping on the "attack bandwagon" without actually examining the details of the lette
by melling 11y ago
It's a little unclear how this letter changes any of that. You seem to be jumping on the "attack bandwagon" without actually examining the details of the letter. "Must mean the company is a fraud."
- dekhn 11y agoI examined the letter; here's what it says: Theranos's lab isn't CLIA-compliant in a way that potentinally puts patients at serious risk. DHHS is giving them 10 days to remedy some serious noncompliance issues (without reading the CMS-2567 form, I can't see for certain what magnitude they are), but this is very serious. If Theranos doesn't reply satisfactorily, DHHS will fine them daily and possibly revoke their CLIA certs as well as their ability to take Medicare money. I think most people had already concluded that the company, if not outright fraudulent, was being very careful to hide a number of negative facts about their product's deficiencies. At this point nearly every scientist I know thinks their tech doesn't really work as well as they claimed, so it seems unlikely the company should have the valuation it does.
- aminorex 11y agoSections 1215 and 1250 say that they don't follow manual procedure requirements. Not surprising, given that the focus of the enterprise is automating laboratory procedures. The remaining sections cited are requirements on the staff operating the lab. The letter infers that the staff do not conform to regulatory requirements. Again, this is not surprising given that the function of the enterprise is to remove humans from the process. I find the outrage a bit outrageous.
- dekhn 11y agoNote that any automated lab today still requires many manual procedures, and the staff have to conform. It's totally inexcusable, within the current legal environment, to not satisfy those conditions. Their lab isn't some gleaming, hermetically sealed iLab with only mechanics and computers inside. I will note that I placed a caveat that I didn't know the magnitude of the violations, but be aware, this is an extremely serious problem for Theranos, they have no excuses, they would have known what to do ahead of time, and they certainly wouldn't use the reasoning that their lab is partially automated so they don't need to comply with manual procedure requirements.
- epistasis 11y agoThat is a very odd whitewashing. Even if its all automated, you still need a lab director with qualifications to run the lab. And somebody has to fill reagent bottles. People are involved. That they fail when so few people are involved is a lot worse.
- aminorex 11y agoI doubt there is any meat here. The real complaint should be their failure to anticipate and accomodate the perverse but very real requirements of regulatory compliance in the near term. In the long run, the regulations will have to change in light of technological reality, but investors don't usually care about the long run.
- LevyJenningsSD2 11y agoThere IS meat here, but it isn't the hematology problem. It's that their medical director is unqualified to direct this lab. CLIA is very stringent about what qualifications are needed for a lab doing high-complexity testing. This is such a huge mistake by Theranos that I have to truly believe they do not know what they are doing, or perhaps felt they were above these laws. CLIA is indeed the law, passed by Congress many years ago. Even Kissinger can't throw his weight around and bypass it. Duh
- aczerepinski 11y agoTo clarify, it's 10 days to submit a plan of correction. Problems often take longer than that to correct.
- dekhn 11y agoAre you sure? Here's the sentences I read: "when ... pose immediate jeopardy, CMS requires the laboratory to take immediate action to remove the jeopardy" ... "10 days to with a credible allegation of compliance and acceptable evidence of correction". I see the part below that makes it sound like just a plan has to be filed, but I interpreted the text above as meaning they needed to comply within 10 days to even file the form. My interpretation may be wrong.
- aczerepinski 11y agoLess than 100% sure, but 10 days to file a POC was always my experience. Most issues can't be provably corrected in that timeframe.
- dekhn 11y agoAll the news articles I'm reading say that they actually have to remedy the problems within 10 days, not just file a form with their plan. But those articles also say that the investigation was limited to a secondary facility, so the impact may be smaller than I predicted.