5 ms·
Calories definitely aren't accurate but they're "accurate enough." Just as different foods likely result in more human fat development per calorie than others (
by Someone1234 11y ago
Calories definitely aren't accurate but they're "accurate enough." Just as different foods likely result in more human fat development per calorie than others (see bleeding edge research), but ultimately none of that is hugely important because by cutting all calories you're likely cutting the "bad" kind too (namely sugars and complex carbohydrates). Counting sugars and those foods that easily metabolise into sugars is just as effective as actual calorie counting for weight loss.
One key thing to remember is: You cannot outrun a bad diet.
Meaning it isn't realistic to achieve substantial weight loss through exercise. Thirty minutes of jogging could be undone by one extra chocolate bar, a Big Mac, or a soda. If you already have control over your diet exercise can HELP with weight loss goals (e.g. extra pound of body weight a week) but a lot of people assume they can run off 20-30-40 pounds of excess body weight which is just totally unrealistic.
Base metabolic rate is the primary means of weight loss. As simplistic as this sounds, the goal remains to consume less than you burn through BMR, and the latest research on calorie's inherent inadequacies haven't yet changed that.
- finkin1 11y agoYou expressed the sentiment I came here to share beautifully - thank you. I think a lot of people fail to understand that exercise isn't that important when trying to lose weight. Another issue I think is extremely pervasive is moral licensing: apparently, doing something that helps to strengthen our positive self-image also makes us less worried about the consequences of bad behavior, and therefore more likely to make bad choices. This can translate to internal conversations like, "I did good by exercising today, I guess I'll order dessert." I think this error in thinking causes serious problems for a lot of people. There are no "good" or "bad" actions - only actions that add or detract from whatever the goal is.
- QSIITurbo 11y agoThis is the correct answer. The example person is about 177cm and 110kg, i.e., a clearly fat person, trouble moving and likely some problems with breathing already. If he doesn't have a metabolical disorder, with that amount of body mass, it should be _really_ easy for him to drop weight by reducing calorie intake -- just by not constantly eating or drinking. But since he's used to eating like a pig, it's not so easy. And I'm not saying this to mock him, it's a fact of how his body has adapted to eating lots of calories. A single Mars bar can contain the calorie count of half of a meal, which is why these people are not losing weight. After all, it's just a Mars bar!
- humanrebar 11y ago> But since he's used to eating like a pig, it's not so easy. And I'm not saying this to mock him, it's a fact of how his body has adapted to eating lots of calories. If you don't want to mock people, consider not comparing them to barnyard animals.
- QSIITurbo 11y agoI still think it's a good metaphor: they eat constantly while still eating regular meals that must be huge. Like probably a lunch and a pizza or two burgers plus lost of soda or alcohol per day. I'd say 3000 kcal easily per day assuming they do at least _something_ (and that's not much) to add to their basal metabolic rate. They are completely in a feeding mode that is required just to upkeep the amount of fat tissue in their bodies. If that doesn't remind you of a barnyard animal, I don't know what does.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- tallanvor 11y ago>One key thing to remember is: You cannot outrun a bad diet. That's not really true. When I ran 150km/week, I didn't have to worry much about what I ate. A couple of years after having some surgery, I'm only managing about 50km/week, and I have to be much more careful.
- drcross 11y agoYou're using a veiled humblebrag to disprove a generally correct statement. 150 kilometers per weeks puts you directly into the top 1% of the population, meaning you are a complete outlier, as if you didnt know this.
- _Wintermute 11y agoThe point is you can outrun a bad diet. Anyone who puts serious miles/time into an endurance sport knows this. Though as a weight loss strategy it's definitely not ideal.
- elbigbad 11y agoWell, the comment "you cannot outrun a bad diet" is clearly referencing the bottom 95% of the population in this case, especially when followed by referencing "thirty minutes of jogging." Clearly exercise burns calories so it follows that there is some amount of exercise that will allow a person to "outrun a bad diet," so pointing out some edge case isn't helpful or instructive.
- mikeash 11y agoAnd then we wonder why even the simplest statements in advertising need a paragraph of fine print asterisked onto them....
- Lawtonfogle 11y agoSo the statement should be 'it is easier to not eat a bad diet than to out run one for most people, including those who over eat for more complicated reason than hunger'. But you lose the sound bite quality. It is like pointing out the grammatical mistake in a punchline.
- CydeWeys 11y agoAnother thing I'd like to point out is that, as long as your overall diet is off by a constant factor, all you have to do to lose weight is calibrating your diet. Think of a feedback loop between how many calories you're eating and what your weight is. If you're not losing weight, then cut the number of calories you're eating more! It doesn't matter what the actual numbers are of how many you think you're burning versus how many you're losing; all that matters is results. If you're not getting those results, reduce intake further. Think of it as solving for an unknown constant factor on calorie account through experimentation with measurement.
- adajos 11y agoExcellent point. And this calibrating is a key point as you lose weight--once you drop a significant amount you've got to revise your calorie intake down a commensurate amount. Estimation is good enough as long as you monitor your progress and tweak it if it's not getting you results.
- philh 11y agoMy understanding is that for some people, I'm not sure what fraction, "just eat less" basically means "just be perpetually hungry". I'd rather be overweight than perpetually hungry.
- tdkl 11y agoWhat's hungry ? After being on intermittent fasting 16/8 for half a year the notion of being "hungry" amuses me. Now being hungry means not eating for 24h or more. Sadly some think that if their stomach is a bit empthy, they have to eat. Or they need to eat because the device on the wall/hand/in the pocket displays a certain number which indicates food time, then wonder why they're fat.
- Someone1234 11y agoJust curious, what does 16/8 intermittent fasting mean? Doesn't everyone do intermittent fasting through sleep for 8 or more hours of a day?
- adajos 11y agoExactly right. It's all about the BMR and while calorie-counting alone won't get you ideal nutrition it is absolutely enough to control weight. I counted my calories with MyFitnessPal last spring and dropped 25 pounds. Consistent, long-term caloric deficit is the answer, except no substitutes.
- roel_v 11y ago*accept
- tdkl 11y ago> One key thing to remember is: You cannot outrun a bad diet. I'll also add that you can't undo a bad diet over x years in much less time. Obese people are shocked that changing the course and loosing fat takes time. Of course, they didn't also get obese in a year. When you're getting fatter and fatter you don't even register couple extra kilograms, compared to if you have a healthy habit of measuring weight/lean body mass/body fat weekly (this is crucial, because measuring JUST weight is just half-assing yourself) and staying in shape. One who's doing that will notice the weight change even without measuring, your more attune to your body and you "know". It's ironic that more better you're in shape, easier it is to stay in good shape, but hey that's how law of fittest works.
- mistermann 11y ago> I'll also add that you can't undo a bad diet over x years in much less time. You can certainly lose massive amounts of weight in a relatively (compared to how long it took to put on) short period of time. https://www.reddit.com/r/progresspics/top/ https://www.reddit.com/r/progresspics/top/
- dspillett 11y ago> different foods likely result in more human fat development per calorie than others (see bleeding edge research) It isn't just varying the food that makes the difference: there is variation by individual as to how certain foods affect the body. There is evidence that it can vary somewhat not just by age and gender, but the results are noisy enough within tightly controlled test groups that it varies per individual. Where there isn't an obvious cause for this such as diabetes, differences in gut microbiome are suspected to be key. Everything you said is still correct of course. This variation just adds wrinkle to it, but a small enough one that "calories in" against "calories out" is accurate enough for the vast majority of the population (i.e. those without significant medical issues). If you are aware of this there is nothing wrong with exercising more so you can eat more, just be careful not to bias your diet by making the extra all "bad food" or you risk being the right weight but unhealthy in a number of other ways. These days I run for three reasons (roughly in order): * Cardiovascular fitness. It is nice to feel healthier than old me ever did. * Stress. A 30 minutes jogging with good music or a podcast and/or around some nice scenery is a great way to break away from hassle long enough to relax so you can deal with it better when you get back (burning 250 calories while you are doing it is almost a "freebie"). Don't speed run while stressed though, you'll not concentrate and damage yourself via putting your feet in the wrong places, bad posture, or literally running into things. * Helping to get rid of the extra I've put on if I had a bit of a food bender last week (over the festive week for example) a little faster then I otherwise would.
- philh 11y agoSomething which is probably not true, but is probably not 100% false, and is in line with what you're saying: "These 5 Genes Predict What Kind of Diet and Exercise is Best For Your Body". http://rockstarresearch.com/these-5-genes-predict-what-kind-of-diet-and-exercise-is-best-for-your-body-2/ http://rockstarresearch.com/these-5-genes-predict-what-kind-... Supposedly, some people lose weight on low-fat diets, and some on low-carb diets. A few can lose weight on either. And most people need high-intensity exercise to lose weight, while a few only need low-intensity. (I have both forms of genetic privilege, and have never had to worry about my weight.) I'm also bullish on microbiome transplant for weight loss.
- basch 11y agothat doesnt really refute anything from the article, except maybe the title