20 ms·
Why Understanding Space Is So Hard
- hownottowrite 11y agoDo not skip the comments on this post. Priceless.
- amelius 11y agoI'm still wondering why space is 3-dimensional.
- gobbo 11y agoDoesn't need to be, but observations constrain extra spacial dimensions to be compact and under ~1mm in size.
- donutz 11y agoDoes anyone have a good way of explaining to a layman how a dimension can be small?
- sdenton4 11y agoImagine a cylinder. It has one flat direction, which goes on forever, and a curved direction which can have a very short circumference.
- aardvark179 11y agoConsider the outside of a straw. The surface is a curved two-dimensional space which is bounded in one direction only by the length of the straw, but is quite small in the other (the circumference of the straw). If the straw is very long and very thin then it may appear to be essentially 1-dimensional, but the surface is still two dimensional.
- DubiousPusher 11y agoNice example. Wouldn't there be easily measurable evidence of this? Imagine a flattened caterpillar like creature living on such a straw. Unwittingly, one day it might wrap itself round the straw many times. Looking back, seeing itself turned round the straw in this way, wouldn't it see slices of itself rather than a whole?
- evanpw 11y agoIn the caterpillar's universe, light rays wrap around the surface of the straw too, so they won't see anything "missing".
- DubiousPusher 11y agoAwww, of course.
- donum 11y agoFunnily enough, the same question is currently at the top of /r/AskScience: http://www.reddit.com/r/askscience/comments/42u57e/how_can_a_dimension_be_small/ http://www.reddit.com/r/askscience/comments/42u57e/how_can_a...
- xyzzy4 11y agoHow can a dimension be under a size? The four regular dimensions (3d and time) can go infinitely in any direction.
- fennecfoxen 11y agoWell, how can you go on forever without falling off the edge of the Earth? The surface of the Earth two-dimensional, and approximately flat... but there's small positive curvature, so you're continuously wrapping around to a different part of the space. The surface of the Earth can be meaningfully understood as a two-dimensional surface that possesses finite dimension. A three-dimensional space can be close to flat but have positive curvature as well (or negative curvature, for that matter). Some proposals give our universe positive curvature, rendering its space finite, though still stupidly-big. (I'm not aware of there being a final word on the subject, though). And if different dimensions can have different curvatures, some of them could be much smaller than others.
- gizmo686 11y agoMy understanding is that we have conducted experiments to measure the curvature of the universe, and come up with answers that are withing the experimental error of being flat. Without any theoretical reason why the universe should be flat, it is still possible that the universe is curved, but to slightly for us to detect, however, but the simplest interpretation is to say that the universe is flat. Of course, if we a assume a multiverse with universes having regularly distributed, positive curvatures, then, the size of the universe would grow asymptotically as the curvature approached flat, so, statistically, life is more more likely to arise on the flatter universes.
- vectorjohn 11y agoIs it possible, or in any way related, that a small but non-zero curvature could be responsible for the accelerated expansion of the universe? I don't know, it's hard to picture. But I'm thinking the idea that you can look at a sphere as a 2 dimensional space that curves and eventually wraps around such that things going opposite directions on its surface eventually can run into each other again. That would probably be more easily measured though. I don't know.
- delinka 11y agoBecause it's not 2-dimensional? /s ;-)
- T-A 11y agoHere is a fun attempt to answer that: http://arxiv.org/abs/gr-qc/9702052 http://arxiv.org/abs/gr-qc/9702052
- aardvark179 11y agoAnthropic arguments such as this are good for examining reasons why spacetime with a different number of dimensions might not support interesting universes, but they fail to ask answer the question why we have a spacetime with 3 dimensions. Some non-string theory attempts at formulating quantum gravity have started without an assumption of space-time and attempted to make it an emergent property, and given 3-dimensional space's quite unique properties that feels like it might ultimately be a better course of reasoning.
- spacehome 11y agoCouple that with Max Tegmark's ideas about multiverses. The idea is that all possible combinations of dimensions exist as a universe. We see 3+1 dimensions because this is the one combination that's most likely to develop life. http://arxiv.org/abs/0704.0646 http://arxiv.org/abs/0704.0646
- rayuela 11y agoYou got any recommended readings on these non-string theory emergent space-time theories?
- jpindar 11y agoBecause a model that supposes 3 dimensions works really, really well at providing a useful and intuitive explanation for everyday human experiences?
- Retric 11y agoAt human scales Matter and energy behave as if space was 3-dimensional. That does not mean space is 3-dimensional. This may seem pedantic, but a lot of assumptions brake down when you look at tiny or high energy things. So, it's really important to mark down all your assumptions.
- logfromblammo 11y agoYour perception of space is 3-dimensional. The mathematics that model space fit conveniently in 3 dimensions without becoming unmanageably complex. However, by employing additional dimensions, particularly dimensions in which the basis vector multiplied by itself is a product other than itself, you can sometimes simplify the math that describes portions of the universe to a shocking extent. For instance, using geometric algebra with one dimension that squares to positive one and three that square to negative one, Maxwell's Equations reduce to "nabla field_bivector = free_space_permeability * speed_of_light * current_vector". Sometimes, introducing special-purpose dimensions with interesting geometries and constraints upon the multidimensional representation makes certain types of math easier. For instance, conformal representation employs two dimensions that square to zero to represent the origin and infinity, and regular space is represented as a curved subset of the hyperdimensional space. Otherwise complicated operations become simpler, as a translation and rotation through dimensions that do not exist that almost coincidentally lands the result right back on the constrained hypersurface that represents 3-dimensional space. When we invent these extra dimensions for the purposes of doing the math, we have no good way of knowing whether they are entirely imaginary or just undetectable and inaccessible to us at our current level of technology. If the universe had a round dimension with a diameter of less than the Planck distance, we would not be able to detect it, because we can't measure a distance that small. But maybe certain properties in the particle zoo can be more easily explained using an angular phase value on a tiny round dimension perpendicular to everything else.
- abecedarius 11y agoJulian Barbour's The Discovery of Dynamics goes into great detail on absolute vs. relative pre-Einstein. His The End of Time reviews the ideas at a more popular level and continues the story into the 20th C.
- ashark 11y agoDo you have the paperback? If so, is it well-constructed? I'm interested, but with so many pages I'm wary of the format. I'd usually buy something like this in hardcover but the paperback's not cheap and the hardcover's far more expensive, and seemingly out of print.
- abecedarius 11y agoI'm afraid I don't know -- I read a pdf, and a library hardback for the latter book. That one shouldn't be hard to find from a U.S. library, and would tell you whether you want to delve into the former. (Which I found really interesting, though it's maybe too ready to valorize Ptolemy just because we know so little about his predecessors.)
- kazinator 11y agoThe question "would space still exist if matter disappeared" is posed with an ontological bias which influences the answer. A better question is: does a universe in which there is nothing (and never has been) still contain space? (Though a better question, I wrecked it by introducing "never", which presupposes that the universe has time---even though it contains nothing, and therefore no events take place.) The question creates a bias because when we imagine matter being removed from the universe, we firstly imagine the removal as an event unfolding in time. Secondly, we continue to imagine the locations where pieces of matter used to be, and those locations continue to be separated by the abstract space which we continue to imagine.
- jerf 11y agoPhysicists have been thinking about this for a long time, and I seem to recall having seen it pointed out before that the question of a space-time that never had matter in it could be different than one that had it but somehow had it removed. Which then implies the possibility that the space-time has a state in it, in which case, where did it come from and where is it being stored? Given our current state of understanding, there really isn't a need to insist that one question is wrong and some other question is better, seeing as we are currently equally incapable of answering any of them.
- pdonis 11y ago> does a universe in which there is nothing (and never has been) still contain space? Within the framework of our best current theories, the answer is yes, in the sense that flat Minkowski spacetime, containing no matter or energy anywhere, is a valid solution of the Einstein Field Equation of general relativity.
- ratsmack 11y agoTime is simply a measure of change, so if there is nothing to change how can there be time?
- klank 11y agoThis isn't entirely accurate. Think of the exact same system performing the same intra-system permutations (changes) but in two different reference frames (one relativistic and the other not). The changes are identical but the time required by each will be different due to their different reference frames. If time was simply a measure of change than you would expect the time taken by these two systems to be identical. Time then takes on a quality (or rather perhaps has a dependency) that exists beyond simply a "measure of change".
- colordrops 11y agoSpinning motion is an illusion and doesn't exist as a fundamental form of movement, similar to how lack of gravity in orbit is an illusion, in that you are continuously falling downward but missing the earth. Spinning objects are made of particles that are all actually going in straight lines but forces against each other are causing them to change direction, cummulatively appearing to be spinning, like an extremely coherent eddie current or vortex. Their movement is in relation to each other, and there is no need for an objective space in which to spin.
- tarikjn 11y agoSuppose your object is the only thing in space, how do you tell that it is spinning? How do the particles in the object can tell that the object as a whole is spinning? What you describe are particules going in straight lines, but over what space/grid are they going on a straight lines? If they are going over straight lines on something then your description is one of an objective space. If pulling forces are still exerted on its edges in proportion to said "spinning", then there exist a static field in space for which the object is in static alignment when the pulling force are at minima. Interestingly the same observation could be made of two objects in orbit or the electrons orbiting individual atoms in the object, with the static alignment being observed when the acceleration between the objects is at a maxima i.e. they are falling into one another.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- colordrops 11y agoThey are going in straight lines in relation to the other particles in the object. Then the force of one particle exerts on another particle as they get closer or further from each other, causing them to change direction. This happens for innumerable numbers of particles, appearing like a singular object that is spinning, since the forces are too great to pull the object apart. If you spin it fast enough, the particles will overcome the atomic forces holding it together, and the object will break apart, with the individual pieces continuing to move in a straight line.
- hashmymustache 11y agoDo objects have inertia in higher dimensions?
- CPLX 11y agoSpace is big. Really big. You just won't believe how vastly, hugely, mind-bogglingly big it is. I mean, you may think it's a long way down the road to the chemist, but that's just peanuts to space.
- charlieflowers 11y agoYou are here.
- danbruc 11y ago52! is the number of different ways you can arrange a single deck of cards. Let's try to wrap our puny human brains around the magnitude of this number with a fun little theoretical exercise. Start a timer that will count down the number of seconds from 52! to 0. We're going to see how much fun we can have before the timer counts down all the way. Start by picking your favorite spot on the equator. You're going to walk around the world along the equator, but take a very leisurely pace of one step every billion years. Make sure to pack a deck of playing cards, so you can get in a few trillion hands of solitaire between steps. After you complete your round the world trip, remove one drop of water from the Pacific Ocean. Now do the same thing again: walk around the world at one billion years per step, removing one drop of water from the Pacific Ocean each time you circle the globe. Continue until the ocean is empty. When it is, take one sheet of paper and place it flat on the ground. Now, fill the ocean back up and start the entire process all over again, adding a sheet of paper to the stack each time you’ve emptied the ocean. Do this until the stack of paper reaches from the Earth to the Sun. Take a glance at the timer, you will see that the three left-most digits haven’t even changed. You still have 8.063 × 10⁶⁷ more seconds to go. So, take the stack of papers down and do it all over again. One thousand times more. Unfortunately, that still won’t do it. There are still more than 5.385 × 10⁶⁷ seconds remaining. You’re just about a third of the way done. [1] Well, the volume of the visible universe is 3.4 × 10⁸⁰ m³ and therefore another factor of 4.2 trillion larger than 52!. And then the entire universe is estimated to be at least another 150 or 250 times larger than the visible universe. In diameter, not volume. [1] http://czep.net/weblog/52cards.html http://czep.net/weblog/52cards.html
- scoj 11y ago
- jopython 11y agoSpace is infinite. It seems most humans cannot comprehend/accept infinity. Without understanding infinity you will have a hard time understanding space.
- hyperion2010 11y agoI was walking along the other day after a class about mathematical modelling of biomolecules and was suddenly struck by the thought that space doesn't really even exist. This came from the observation that when we calculate van der Waals interactions there are two terms [0] and the term raised to the 12th power is an approximation to account for the fact that down at the quantum level two electrons cannot occupy the same orbital. We can map electron orbitals onto space but then we get something funky like the Pauli exclusion principle and suddenly a force that appears to be 'spatial' in origin is now a consequence of a completely non-spatial phenomenon. We use space as a convenient intermediate in many measurements but it is not clear to me that the fundamental accounting system of the universe actually needs it (though as the article points out, general relativity seems to suggest that space-time does exist or at least provides a pretty reliable coordinate system). 0. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lennard-Jones_potential https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lennard-Jones_potential
- Videweo 11y agoRather illuminating. I like to think that this could open some interesting thought experiment in centrifugal space travel.