3 ms·
Donating to MADD doesn't get one out of obeying traffic laws. If anything, this shows that Allen was well aware of how sensitive reefs are and so should have m
by sandworm101 11y ago
Donating to MADD doesn't get one out of obeying traffic laws. If anything, this shows that Allen was well aware of how sensitive reefs are and so should have made sure his boat wasn't part of the problem.
- ghshephard 11y agothe crew followed officials’ instructions on where to place the vessel. Shifting winds reportedly changed the position, pushing the ship toward the reserve but it was relocated to avoid damage.
- sandworm101 11y agoFollow all the instructions you want, captains are still responsible for the physical movement of their vessels. The captain probably should have recognized that safe mourning was impossible and moved the ship elsewhere. Captains, like doctors and lawyers, are not hired to simply follow orders.
- ghshephard 11y agoThe ship was safe. The water was deep enough. The anchorage presented no threats to the ship. I think you are over-representing the responsibility of the captain of a ship. It's entirely reasonable to say that they did the job the best they could, but that circumstances were such that the ship still caused damage to the coral, through no fault of the ship's captain. Lots of things that a captain can't take responsibility for - particularly when it doesn't involve the safety of the ship and it's passengers.
- dogma1138 11y agoYou do understand that while this is a nice head line it's not his "fault" in any other means than owning a yacht. The yacht has a captain and a crew they are responsible for managing the ship and unless Paul Allen was yelling at them threatening to fire them if they do not plow into the coral reef it's just an unfortunate event that the media likes to blow up because hey it's another rich guy with a yacht.
- sandworm101 11y agoFault no, responsibility yes. Owners of vessels like these are responsible for the damage they do, just like any other employer.
- tw04 11y agoMost of these yachts are rented out by their owners. I don't see anything in the article stating he was even on the ship. I'm not sure how you can hold him responsible if he wasn't even on the ship at the time this occurred.
- sandworm101 11y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Respondeat_superior https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Respondeat_superior >> ... a legal doctrine which states that, in many circumstances, an employer is responsible for the actions of employees performed within the course of their employment.
- dogma1138 11y ago"When applied to physical torts, an employer-employee relationship must be established (meaning that no vicarious liability is established for work performed as an independent contractor) and the act must be committed within the scope of employment (i.e., substantially within time and geographical limits, job description and at least with partial intent to further employer's business)." Don't think that it really falls under this legal doctrine. I'm pretty sure he'll feel responsible non the less but doesn't it mean he's liable and it sure doesn't mean that it needs to be overblown in this manner. Cargo ships do much more damage to the environment on a daily basis. That said he most definitely owns the Yacht he owns several his biggest Yacht is often loaned to researchers. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Octopus_(yacht) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Octopus_(yacht) The cause for the incident is probably more interesting as if the damage was done while mooring it begs a question why is there a mooring spot so close to a coral reserve in the first place.