4 ms·
>>> Allen’s communication team shows the billionaire is not taking responsibility and implicated the Port Authority, saying the crew followed officials’ instru
by sandworm101 11y ago
>>> Allen’s communication team shows the billionaire is not taking responsibility and implicated the Port Authority, saying the crew followed officials’ instructions on where to place the vessel.
Don't care. Captains are always 100% responsible for the movement of their ship. Though rare in practice, captains are expected to override anyone, including pilots, to ensure safe and lawful operation of their vessels. The captain works for the owner. The owner is financially responsible for mistakes of his employee. Allen should pay up.
- briantakita 11y agothis is a symptom of hoarding capital. paul allen did "earn" all of his wealth, right? good thing he a "responsible" citizen of the world, wielding his abstractions
- zo1 11y agoIt's quite disturbing to see people latch on to this individual's wealth as some sort of automatic "reason" or "explanation" for the incident. You know, it's entirely plausible that this was a genuine accident that couldn't have been foreseen. It's not like rich people go around wanting to damage and destroy the world on purpose.
- briantakita 11y agoall good points that i understand & have once held > it's entirely plausible that this was a genuine accident 100% agree > that couldn't have been foreseen the amount of traffic & large watercraft in close proximity to the reefs are bound to cause issues > It's not like rich people go around wanting to damage and destroy the world on purpose. the issue with wealth in today's global economy is the hoarders of wealth don't feel the consequence of their actions if their wealth contributes to the destruction of the environment, human rights abuses, or the plethora of the consequences of their influence; then it does not matter whether they damage and destroy the world on purpose
- adventured 11y agoYes, to answer your question, Paul Allen did earn his wealth. No different than if a middle class investor bought Las Vegas Sands at $1 in the great recession and rode it to $85, with that investor having fully earned their return too. Except Allen arguably deserves his return even more than said average investor because he was personally, hugely responsible for the formation and success of Microsoft. Your premise is obviously that if you aren't shoveling snow for each dollar earned, then you didn't properly earn it. An arbitrary, agenda oriented, anti-wealth stance: there's no scenario under which any person can ever actually earn their wealth or income in your premise. Any amount of income or wealth can come under attack as having not been fully earned - and that's of course the whole idea.
- sandworm101 11y agoHe earned some wealth, but nobody earns billions. To get to that level of wealth one must leverage things far beyond the control of one person. For someone like Allen, that's probably IP law and the opportunity of being in the right place at the right time to dominate a specific market. It isn't like, had Allen not been around, that we wouldn’t have computers or that the market wouldn't be dominated by a particular OS. Those same billions would have gone to someone else. His niche would have been filled by any number of other people. Other people, equally talented and equally hard working, are paid far far less. To say that Allen "earned" every dollar is to suggest that they have not, that luck is not a factor.
- kika 11y agoLuck is not a zero sum game. Yes, he was partially lucky and yes, he earned every dollar. There're so many lucky people in the world and so few Allens. I also have experience anchoring in the Caribbean, among reefs as well (abeit in a much smaller yacht, like, kind of order of magnitude smaller :-)). And no, you can't predict where your anchor chain will go, especially if your common sense contradicts what "local authority" says. Sometimes they're right (most of the time, they were born there and spent the whole life) but sometimes they are just plain drunk and do not care. Island time.
- forrestthewoods 11y agoHow does one ensure lawful operation if parking where the lawman tells you to park is unlawful. That's quite the conundrum!
- sandworm101 11y agoYou don't park. You go elsewhere. You recognize that lawman is telling you to do something dangerous and ignore him, as you would ignore a cop directing traffic if obeying him will obviously cause a crash.
- ghshephard 11y agoAlways? Even when under controlled areas of water like a Canal? Also, the issue was not the safety and lawful operation of the vessel - the ship was safe, and the captain was following the law by anchoring in the designated area.
- sandworm101 11y agoYes. Where a pilot has directed a ship into danger or illegality, it is the captain's responsibility to disobey. It's professional judgement. Obeying law A (mouring) doesn't grant any immunity from law B (not ripping up a reef). Responsibility comes in layers.
- valdiorn 11y agoWhat was the captain supposed to do; be so skeptical that he sent divers to the bottom of the ocean to check for possible coral reefs? you are unfairly pacing the burden and blame on the captain here.
- sandworm101 11y agoBlame on captain, burden is on the ship owner.
- pvaldes 11y agoThat coral reef was exactly in the same point since the last 800 years. It is supossed that a such expensive yacht would exit the factory including a decent updated map at least. Or maybe with several complex electronic devices able to scan the sea bottom that are common in this century and can be found even in much smaller boats. If not, maybe a quick look at google maps at least could have helped. Divers are optional.
- pm24601 11y agoThe buck stops with the captain. Fairness has nothing to do with it. It is the captain's job to train his crew and keep his ship safe -- no matter what.
- kriro 11y agoThe official who gave these instructions should also be fired. I find it interesting that the discussion centers around Allen. I'd argue that the official who supposedly gave the instructions is the person most responsible and yet I see less pitchforks for him/her than for Allen. Doesn't mean Allen/the captain is innocent but it's odd how the focus of the debate is centered around them. Guess the "evil rich dude" narrative is more fun than the "incompetent official" one. I guess the headline "Incompetent official instructs ship to destroy reef." gets less clicks.
- sandworm101 11y agoBecause Allen, not the captain, is the on refusing responsibility for the damage done by his boat.
- dzhiurgis 11y agoPaul is a ship owner not a captain.
- valdiorn 11y agoDo you think every captain has an onboard and up to date map of all the coral reefs in the area? cause I don't think they have those. In fact, I think what a responsible captain should do is to ask the harbor master where the safest place to park their boat is, because he should know, it's his harbor.
- pm24601 11y agoIt doesn't matter. It is the captain's job to not sink his ship. It is the captain's job to not damage the pier, the reefs, etc. The same rules apply when flying a plane. It is the pilot's responsibility to not be in a collision -- no matter what else is happening, or what someone else is doing.