23 ms·
“No Cost” License Plate Readers Are Turning Texas Police into Debt Collectors
- jimrandomh 11y ago> As police cars patrol the city, they ping on license plates associated with the fees. The officer then pulls the driver over and offers them a devil’s bargain: go to jail, or pay the original fine with an extra 25% processing fee tacked on, all of which goes to Vigilant. So, they're planning to turn the Texas prison system into de facto debtors' prisons, and the Texas police system into de facto highwaymen. One more factor to add to the giant pile of reasons for ill-will that the US state and Federal governments have been collecting. That pile can't get much taller without toppling, and while I do greatly hope the blowback happens through the democratic process, that process is pretty severely damaged and this looks less and less likely every year.
- mindslight 11y agoI'd really like to see some state attempt step up and tackle totalitarianism organically. In this case, imagine a registrar of convenience (as I believe South Dakota is often used for Ruins Views), that issues eink-based license plates that generate a new identifier every few miles. Only the registrar could decode those nonces into the long-term vehicle record, with an accompanying legal process and technical audit trail. (Of course such technical workarounds do nothing to fix the ultimate problem of corruption, it only releases the pressure a bit. Unfortunately the logical foundation of this country is based on outrunning tyranny, and in the age of abundance complexity knows no bounds. So to avoid collapse we really need every approach we can fathom)
- X-Istence 11y agoIf there is some algorithm to define what the next number is going to be, the state can share that with the company in order to provide "services"...
- mindslight 11y agoThe core of the idea relies on developing one sane state. But it could be rural (leaders not so corrupted by economic power) and low-population (easier to effect change). If we want to prevent the collapse of our broken society, we must create institutions that usurp the existing broken ones. License plate tracking cannot be solved by private organization (/local "exit") alone, as the problem stems from the government mandated tracking placards.
- jdmichal 11y agoMore likely the state would simply share the already-disambiguated data.
- bmelton 11y ago> I'd really like to see some state attempt step up and tackle totalitarianism organically. The state closest to what you're looking for, I suspect, is New Hampshire. I don't know how much of it is due to their Free Stater influence or what, but among other things, they have relatively low burdens for living a legal life. There are some stupid laws (namely, not being able to pull backward into certain types of parking spots), but for the most part, they take their "Live Free or Die" motto pretty seriously. If they could only fix the weather...
- mindslight 11y agoI'm personally lukewarm on NH. My general take is that their foundation of freedom heavily skews towards dismantling local organization while tacitly approving larger power concentrations. I'd obviously welcome any pushback against USG or private surveillance, it just feels more likely they'll destroy more municipal services. While everyone having a generator is self-reliant and robust, it's also indicative of infrastructure collapse.
- bmelton 11y agoI've found the contrary to be more true. They do have, perhaps, a different view of what the local legislature ought to look like than most, in that the legislators are only paid $200 per two year term (to keep it from being a career position), but they also have the best representation in the nation, as each legislator only has ~3200 constituents. Compared to California's ~450,000 constituents per legislator, it's much, much easier to imagine getting a lunch date with your lawmakers so that your ideas are heard. Meanwhile, on infrastructure, New Hampshire has a better rating than the national average. On top of that, there's no sales tax, no income tax (though a higher than average property tax probably makes up some of the difference), has the highest overall quality of living, is the second healthiest state in the union, the most livable, the safest, and has the lowest poverty rate in America. Certainly, everywhere has its perks and pitfalls, but if totalitarianism is what you're looking to escape, New Hampshire considers mandatory seat belt laws too authoritarian to pass.
- 11y ago
- mjevans 11y agoHow about just making it so that the plates have to be on the vehicle and readable when it is stopped for inspection. This would allow most of the good uses, while preventing drive-by surveillance.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- mindslight 11y agoHit-and-run. And even if it isn't statistically important, that will be the argument. The entropy required by nonce plates might also be prohibitive (a witness will have a hard time memorizing 20 digits), but a clever encoding should make the start or end of the number be significant enough when combined with the date.
- maxerickson 11y agoAt a minimum, the state would use insurance requirements to foil this (by requiring declared residents to buy insurance for the state of residence and not allowing that insurance to be tied to an out of state vehicle).
- mindslight 11y agoPeople seem to "get away" with it for ruins views, and rental companies generally have convenient ownership of their vehicles (eg a surplus of rental cars from Arizona, Penske trucks from Indiana). The only place I've heard of people actually having issues with longer-term out-of-state registration is Mordor^wDC.
- joesmo 11y agoThe pile will topple, you're right. It's just a matter of how. Even people I respect a lot like Radley Balko are not on the right page about fixing the current problems with police. He talks a lot about community policing, literal foot patrols (vs. cars), etc. And that'd be all great, except our society is way beyond that. Maybe such tactics would have worked in the '60's, before the relationship between citizens and police became one of either hate or ignorance. At this point, without dismantling a huge part of the police and corrections system (because calling it "criminal justice" is just plain absurd) nothing will change. But that can still happen through the democratic process. I hope ...
- jdmichal 11y agoI'd like to point out that the Texas law cited allows on-the-spot collection of fines to extinguish existent warrants [0]. That is, without this law, the options would formally be "be detained" and "be detained" [1]. This is strictly providing additional options. [0] The name used by the EFF is accurate but somewhat incomplete; these would be capias pro fine, which is a specific subset related to failing to comply with judgements. [1] I won't indulge the EFF's language of Monopoly-style "go to jail" here, as that's a pretty loose interpretation. You will be detained to appear before a judge in order to plead your case.
- FireBeyond 11y agore [1]: technically yes, practically no. You're going to be detained to appear in front of a judge who is going to say 'you have outstanding unpaid court fines - you can pay them now or be subject to imprisonment'. All that is happening in that case is changing the location of the credit card swipe.
- Someone1234 11y ago> All that is happening in that case is changing the location of the credit card swipe. And the amount. +25% to pay it by the side of the road.
- seanp2k2 11y agoWonder what court fees would be for this. There's also sometimes the threat of impound which isn't cheap.
- brandonmenc 11y agoTrue. When I was very young and stupid, I had a car impounded for unpaid parking tickets after being pulled over for a burnt out tail light. I would have gladly accepted a 25% fee for the option to pay right then and there to avoid the impound procedure. It would've cost less than what the court and impound yard charged me for letting it escalate that far. And not being able to pay the 25% fee, what would have normally happened, would have happened.
- drzaiusapelord 11y ago>giant pile of reasons for ill-will that the US state and Federal governments have been collecting. Lets please not attack the other states because of Texan shenanigans. The fifty states are each semi-autonomous and as such can implement programs like this. This is an exception, not the norm. >blowback happens through the democratic process Why should it? Maybe Texans who work hard and pay their fines want the scofflaws to be caught like this? Democracy doesn't mean "things I like." It often means "things the average voter likes." Maybe this is "ill will" to you, but to a red state with a strong law and order culture to it, it may not be very controversial at all. You can't clamor for states rights in Texas, but also expect liberal soft-on-crime values. All politics is local. Also, these people have capias warrants out for them at the time of this collection. Deadbeats who don't pay child support, ignore a civil judgements, ignore fines, etc get these. I don't really see a problem with this. If there's abuse here, it lies with how capias warrants are given out, not the technology used to enforce them. Why aren't we addressing the root issue here? Is there really an issue here other than SJW wankering?
- JadeNB 11y ago> Democracy doesn't mean "things I like." It often means "things the average voter likes." That seems like a misrepresentation of the post. jrandomh didn't say "this is undemocratic", but rather (paraphrasing) "this generates ill will". Hoping that mass ill will will (not a typo …) lead to change is not anti-democratic; it is exactly the idea of democracy.
- mywittyname 11y ago> Why aren't we addressing the root issue here? You and I disagree on the root of the issue. The ease of enforcement is going to encourage the already despicable behavior of imposing fines that people aren't able to pay. This technology isn't going to effect middle class people that get the occasional speeding ticket. This is going to ensure that people who couldn't afford the fine are caught and fined again, then thrown in jail. What should happen is that suspects should not be forced to pay the court costs associated with trying them. This eliminates the perverse incentives associated with this technology.
- sithadmin 11y ago> they're planning to turn the Texas prison system into de facto debtors' prisons Whoa there, hold on a second. That's not what's going on at all. The plates are being run to detect if the car's owner has outstanding court fines, which are not akin to a simple debt. These are (probably) justified, punitive fees imposed on an individual for some kind of offense against the law (and by extension, the public). It's not the case that the police are extorting people that are behind on their rent/credit card payments or something. That said, this behavior is still troubling insofar as it is likely to disproportionately result in the targeting and punishment of the poor, which is in itself a rather problematic issue. And it's certainly troubling that the additional fee being imposed to process payment for the fines collected is far above what seems to be (at a glance, anyway) a reasonable margin for operating costs.
- Vraxx 11y agoI think the common complaint here is that there are plenty of "crimes" that are committed on a daily basis like minor speeding (going 1-5 mph over the speed limit), jaywalking, etc, that are nearly impossible to entirely enforce. This gives police the ability to selectively enforce said laws simply because they can't totally enforce it. As you noted this can be used to punish the poor far more than others. The combination of all of these factors and the ability to track these "offenders" down more easily, it isn't a far shot from what the parent poster was saying by comparing it to a debtors' prison.
- Karunamon 11y agoWorth asking: Why do they punish the poor more so than others? I really doubt it's because those in poverty give fewer fucks about following traffic law. I doubt it's a matter of education since you're supposed to demonstrate that minimum competence before you get a license anyways, and if you're not, we've found the problem. What's left?
- masterzora 11y agoI believe you're looking at the wrong part of the equation. It's not about the relative rates of traffic violations among the poor vs everyone else; it's about the relative impact the same fine has. If you have comfortable amounts of wealth and/or income and get hit with a $500 fine you might be annoyed but you can pay it and go on your way. But for the poor it's not so simple. First, that $500 represents a much larger burden. Even if they do scrape together the money to actually pay the fine, it might mean other bills would have to go unpaid, for example. And if they don't or can't get the money to pay the fine, those outstanding fines can get additional fees tacked on like Vigilant's 25%. So it's not about seeking out the poor disproportionately more than the rich; it's about how the same punishment is actually more punishing.
- finid 11y agoIf you're expecting that pile to topple any time soon or if ever, I think you're going to be very disappointed. You see, the modern police state has learned from the mistakes of Stazi, and technology has made the police-state surveillance very seamless. Most citizens don't even realize what's going on, and when told, they have too much to worry about. That their's no external force working against the interests of our system makes it all the more hopeless. Seat back, folks, and enjoy whatever freedom you have now.
- dh997 11y agoWaiting for the cost to reduce, performance and battery tech of semiautonomous drones to improve to the point where crowdfunded watchdog groups could begin to afford to follow every police officer with a camera, live streaming and recording them almost all the time while on duty. It could be possible, at least start off with problem cops while they're patrolling on foot. I think that's one of the most effective ways to hold them accountable and provide a direct, counterveiling force against pervasive, unbridled hubris that most resembles a mafia. Not like confrontational YouTubers, but change the thinking to "we're watching you."
- mindslight 11y agoThe majority is fine with surveillance, because the majority believes it will decide the usage of the surveillance. And to a first approximation, it's correct. The collapse occurs because of the resulting top-down groupthink. There are plenty of external forces working against our system, just on the time scale of several generations.
- finid 11y ago> The majority is fine with surveillance, because the majority believes it will decide the usage of the surveillance. And to a first approximation, it's correct. Wishful thinking. Just keep dreaming. If by "first approximation" you're referring to voting, then, yes, majority gets to vote their favored lawmaker into office. However, because of political lobbying, the laws that are passed will not necessarily be in the interest of the majority.
- jt2190 11y agoForgive me my ignorance... What am I supposed to do with this information other than get angry? (Double that for non-Texas residents.) What is the point of this if there's no call to action? I'm a rage-aholic! I'm addicted to rage-ahol!!!" -- Homer Simpson
- thieving_magpie 11y agoAwareness of governmental overreach and tax funding for police helps us make informed votes. For instance, if (when) your local representative pushes a bill like this you now have some information to fight it.
- GigabyteCoin 11y agoThe EFF isn't a problem solver, they're a watch-dog. Do what you will with the information they give you.
- colinbartlett 11y agoI think the point of these releases by the EFF is to call attention to an issue. It's not supposed to present both sides of an issue or offer an objective, reasoned, solution or response. (Other EFF releases have been scorned here on HN for being too hyperbolic.) The EFF is an advocacy organization with a distinct viewpoint and they produce these releases to bring about attention, discussion, and hopefully news media coverage, to an injustice. If I might suggest, channel your anger toward a letter to your representatives or perhaps a letter to the editor of your local news publication. Frequently the EFF will call out specific politicians who support troubling legislation so you can express displeasure to them directly.
- joesmo 11y agoBetween this and cops simply stealing money, also known euphemistically as asset forfeiture, it's a huge risk to drive anywhere these days. How can ordinary, law-abiding citizens have respect for the law when the law is written to specifically hurt them? I suppose on our way to fascism, privacy is only a small bump in the road, barely even worth this comment.
- Alupis 11y ago> How can ordinary, law-abiding citizens have respect for the law when the law is written to specifically hurt them You do realize for the scenario to play out as-in the article, one must have already broken the law and is therefore not a "law-abiding citizen".
- joesmo 11y agoSo they will only collect my information if I have broken the law? You're wrong.
- Alupis 11y agoYou also need to realize police already drive around and randomly type into their computer license plate numbers to see what comes up. This system just makes it faster and red flags those who are really breaking the law.
- FireBeyond 11y agoYeah. They do. That's not GPS stamped. It's not loaded into a commercial database for a company to sell to other companies for gain. And to add insult to injury, who pays for it?
- rhino369 11y agoLicense plate readers only collect a government issued ID that exists to publicly ID you. The info on the servers the cop looks is about you but it's not your information.
- s0uthPaw88 11y agoTo me the most disturbing part is that Vigilant can keep the data for as long as they want: > According the company's usage and privacy policy, Vigilant “retains LPR data as long as it has commercial value.” Vigilant can sell or license that information to other law enforcement bodies, and potentially private companies such as insurance firms and repossession agencies.
- DanielBMarkham 11y agoJust when you think it can't get worse. It gets worse. I guess in a crazy kind of way it makes sense. Government has been mooching off commercial data collection for some time. It's about time the commercial sector got to use government agents as sort of a contracted private intelligence agency. <sarcastically>And hell, you could bump this up a notch. Just start paying for body cams on all federal agents. If the agent needs the data in court you save it, otherwise it can magically disappear (without any kind of judicial overview). Better yet, lying to a federal agent is a felony! So just text the guy and give him some sample questions he might want to ask. It'd be like a magic button to privately deposition anybody you'd like.</sarcastically> I apologize for the hair-on-fire reaction. Good grief, it's blatantly obvious that the players here, both commercial and governmental, are going to push this thing as hard as they possibly can until somebody stops them. I'm still trying to figure out who somebody is going to be. ADD: A plug: I rant about this often on my FB page. God knows I try to keep it off HN but it's a long-lasting news story that's intricately related to the things we do. (FB page is https://www.facebook.com/Freedom-or-Safety-405551942874575 https://www.facebook.com/Freedom-or-Safety-405551942874575)
- Kluny 11y agoWell, the historical response to being robbed by armed thugs is to get bigger weapons and your own thugs. And in Texas, it's easier to get guns that it is to get water (as far as I can tell, observing from Canada). The only thing I don't understand is why an open shooting war between the police and the citizens hasn't broken out already.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- abawany 11y agoAFAICT, the citizenry that votes loves law enforcement and "tough" regulations; the people most comfortable with guns are also in love with this government. Further, voter turnout in the last major election was ~28% (or 34%, depending on whom you ask) so the ability to work the democracy angle is quite limited. The government keeps the populace happy by making noises related to "lowered taxes", which is accompanied by the reality shown by this extortion gambit, skyrocketing fines in general, and generally regressive taxation policies. It is a sad state of affairs, no pun intended. http://www.dallasobserver.com/news/texas-had-the-worst-voter-turnout-in-the-country-and-the-rain-in-dallas-didnt-help-7117659 http://www.dallasobserver.com/news/texas-had-the-worst-voter...
- hardwaresofton 11y agoI can't say I'm surprised that this is happening. As technology progresses, it only makes sense that government becomes more efficient at doing things that we like and don't like. As soon as red-light cameras became OK, or any license plate reading systems, this eventuality was on the table. I'm only saddened by the fact that they've been essentially duped by some private sector company into selling private citizens' data (and allowing them to retain it even after expiration of the contract) instead of trying to develop this technology themselves, and actually innovating. This move reduces citizen privacy, and costs citizens privacy all at the same time. The next thing I look to see happen is automated speeding tickets. There's no reason radars shouldn't be set up in conjuction with license plate readers, or actually just pulling speed data from cars with in-car transmission ability and tickets being auto-generated to constituents. Imagine trying to argue against why your car shouldn't be monitored for speeding infringements -- surely you're either a speeder trying to kill kids and families, or you're a getaway driver trying to commit crimes. Then the law goes into place (of course, save the kids), then people realize some car companies transmit location info by accident/on purpose, and people can now pretty much watch you drive places.
- robk 11y agoCamera speeding tickets are totally common across Europe already
- JupiterMoon 11y ago> The next thing I look to see happen is automated speeding tickets. There's no reason radars shouldn't be set up in conjuction with license plate readers, or actually just pulling speed data from cars with in-car transmission ability and tickets being auto-generated to constituents. I'm fairly certain that this happens already in the UK.
- brewdad 11y agoThe system I witnessed set up in the UK seems reasonable, if you allow that such a system can ever be reasonable. The cameras capture plates entering and exiting a multiple mile stretch of highway and if your average speed exceeds the threshold, you get cited. No worries about momentary speeding and no need to immediately slam on the brakes as happens with single location cameras in the US.
- carc 11y ago"We’re unlikely to get answers from the government agencies who signed these contracts. To access Vigilant’s powerful online data systems, agencies agree not to disparage the company or even to talk to the press without the company’s permission" How is it possibly legal for a government, which is supposed to be transparent, to contract with a private company and accept a term saying they cannot talk about the private company without company approval?
- pm90 11y agoHoly crap this is alarming! I'm so glad that there are institutions like the eff that can catch these kinds of practices and predict how they can be mismanaged to serve rather ulterior motives. As a side note, I have a sick feeling that this technology will be used to exclusively target the most vulnerable of society. In fact, it provides an incentive for police to patrol those neighborhoods, since they are (AFAIK) more likely to have outstanding debts or unlikely to have the means to pay them promptly.
- jkot 11y agoI live in Europe, we have similar problems but not at this level. I will just add one quote from Greece: > New bill lowered fine from 400 euros to 50 euros, as long as offender presents vehicle at KTEO for inspection within 10 days of violation. Traffic wardens were hesitant to issue fines with debt crisis. http://livingingreece.gr/2007/04/20/fines-parking-tickets-moving-violations-greece/ http://livingingreece.gr/2007/04/20/fines-parking-tickets-mo...
- analyst74 11y agoI have a mixed feeling about this. On one hand, having law enforcements make money for private organizations sound really terrible; on the other hand, letting people get away with breaking rules will create a terrible culture that I experienced first hand. A bit on the later, if the rules are too strict, or punishment(fines) too high, then rules should be challenged/modified. Whereas if you create very strict rules, but only enforce it selectively, either due to officer's personal judgement or lack of policing resources, it creates incentive for police officers to become corrupt, less deterrent for people breaking rules and making bad rules more tolerable (because most people do not get personally affected).
- ck2 11y ago25% tacked on ??? That's government enforced shakedowns.
- overcast 11y agoYou could argue the "privacy" factor and I get it, but I don't really see a problem with this. You're already registered with the state, and the license plate identifies you. You chose to break, evade the law, and not pay your fines. Everyone else obeys the law. So you get pulled over, pay the fine, and be done with it. I'd consider taking it a step further in the efficiency department. If someone doesn't follow up with a ticket after ninety days or whatever, auto debit their account. Thoughts?
- jimbobimbo 11y agoThat "efficiency department" wants 25% over the debt amount AND unlimited usage of the collected data until it's "commercially viable". The latter part is especially outrageous.
- overcast 11y agoAny idea how much simple tickets cost after compounding for months/years? They'll end up costing multiples of the original. This sounds like a win for both sides.
- jimbobimbo 11y agoTickets should not be used for profit generation. It's a form of punishment and determent. Plus, for how long +25%? For the time it paid off the system or perpetually? Is there a price on other "commercial" usage of collected data?
- Eldarrion 11y agoNobody said it's a 'lease to own' situation with the system. Never mind that it includes computing time and server-side calculations and database access so chances are it is a system that is simply being 'leased' to the police at the cost of 25% added value to all transactions made possible through it.
- Eldarrion 11y ago
- samstave 11y agoThis should also highlight Jobs' non-plated vehicle loophole that he used. Eveyone should be using that loophole... oh wait you have to be the $1% in order to afford such an exploit. I recall getting a C&D order for making a comment on HN here a while back warning of a particular company who was installing LPR devices at their HQ. LPR is an insidious technology.
- Theodores 11y agoAlthough such behaviour has gone on in one way or another for as long as there have been police/soldiers, this is not part of the Orwell 'Big Brother' script. In most Dystopian futures the apparatus of Police state is paid for with some type of other taxation, not the police officers doing highway robbery.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- apaprocki 11y agoI had a friend in NYC just hit by a case of mistaken identify with ALPRs being used by roving repo men looking to reclaim vehicles. It certainly isn't restricted to the realm of law enforcement...
- dopamean 11y agoThey should be charged with grand larceny if they mistakenly removed his car.
- tonyarkles 11y agoAm Canadian, so my legal understanding may not match American law. My understanding of Canadian law is that that situation would not have had mens rea (a guilty mind); the repo man was repossessing a car which he believed was one that he was entitled to repossess. However, the repo man would like be guilty of civil negligence and the owner court would ensure that the owner was made whole (no towing fees, rental fees covered, maybe a bit of extra cash to cover the hassle/lost work/whatever).
- rasz_pl 11y agoyou need to check vin, otherwise you are straight up stealing a random car
- apaprocki 11y agoBasically the repo guy was negligent. They got a reader hit for a car they were looking for and he just drove to that block and looked for a white make X model Y and went up to the first one he found (my friend's) and tried to tell him he was going to take the car without ever looking at the VIN #. The cops were called and the guy admitted he never checked the VIN, which was obviously not a match for what he was looking for.
- tonyarkles 11y agoFor sure... But was it civil negligence or criminal negligence? Civil negligence is exactly what I'm talking about, with the courts coming up with an adequate remedy to make the car owner whole. In Canada, criminal negligence is defined as: "219 (1) Every one is criminally negligent who (a) in doing anything, or (b) in omitting to do anything that it is his duty to do, shows wanton or reckless disregard for the lives or safety of other persons." It'd be a pretty hard sell here for him to meet that definition, but the common law/civil definition would certainly fit.
- imgabe 11y agoAre your movements in public really private information? "John Smith as seen on the corner of 14th and Main Sts at 12pm today" doesn't really smack of private info that needs to be protected. Yes, someone could analyze all the data and learn about your habits, but to what end? If you've got someone that dedicated to watching where you go, you probably have a larger problem than just the information existing in a database (i.e. a stalker, abusive ex, etc.) and that problem needs to be dealt with. Your location in public has always been publicly available to anyone near you, it just wasn't recorded and stored.
- bweitzman 11y agoKnowing any single piece of information is not a big deal, but stringing them together is basically stalking which is illegal.
- ctrl_freak 11y agoThe information becomes more private the more aggregated it gets. If you have a stalker following you around everywhere, you can get a restraining order against them. If detailed information of your locations were to be available online, you couldn't stop anyone from looking at it.
- imgabe 11y agoLooking at it and then what? If they act on it by actually stalking you, then yes, arrest them. We already have laws against that. What harm comes to you by someone looking at a record of where you've been?
- glitchdout 11y agoHe can know when you leave and get home. Perfect time for a robbery.
- imgabe 11y agoThis is backwards from how robberies work. Burglars go to a neighborhood and look for a house where nobody's home. They don't pick out a house before hand and wait until it's empty. Even if they did, why would they try to crack into a government database instead of just sitting outside until you leave?
- pmorici 11y agoThis is odd when juxtaposed with Texas's debt collection laws which are extremely liberal.
- newman314 11y agoWhat is the accuracy rate on the ALPRs? As anyone that has dealt with data on a large scale attest, data purity is hard to maintain at scale and over time. Vigilant has already had to issue apologies for incorrect warrants being served. The consequences of "oops, my bad" are asymmetrical and not tilted in favor of error. One might argue collateral damage but I do not believe this is acceptable at all.
- joshmn 11y agoBroke? Go to jail, that will sure help. The system is so broken. If they want to pull people over, great, let's set them up for success instead of threatening to take away their liberties.
- marshray 11y agoWhy is it the EFF reporting on this and not the ACLU?
- bloaf 11y ago>Anyone who is not an anarchist agrees with having a policeman at the corner of the street; but the danger at present is that of finding the policeman half-way down the chimney or even under the bed. G. K. Chesterton, What I Saw In America, 1922
- dakotasmith 11y agoHow feasible would it be to build a personal ALPR?