16 ms·
Coming from Denmark where life is max 16 years and where people rarely go to jail just because society does not know what else to do with you and then moving to
by ThomPete 11y ago
Coming from Denmark where life is max 16 years and where people rarely go to jail just because society does not know what else to do with you and then moving to the US, the justice system when it comes to petty crimes, always seemed very draconian and counter productive.
For most people — just the mere notion of being in conflict with the law — is enough to send chills down their back. How sad that something that could have been used to actually function as a mild punishment ends up completely destroying a life and the potential of being part of society.
In a hundred years from now people are going to look back at things like the war on drugs as one of the most barbaric, absurd and useless pieces of legislation ever to have been implemented. A war which ended up destroying more lifes than it saved.
I for one applaud Obama for finally taking a stanse against this unnecessarily strict legislation and hoping that normal otherwise law abiding citizens wont get their lifes completely destroyed for things anyone could have done. I love the US but the legislation I could certainly do without.
- CamperBob2 11y agoIn a hundred years from now people are going to look back at things like the war on drugs as one of the most barbaric, absurd and useless pieces of legislation ever to have been implemented. A war which ended up destroying more lifes than it saved. Here in the US, most of us think of Prohibition in exactly those terms.... but that didn't stop us from doing the exact same thing all over again and calling it good.
- Consultant32452 11y agoI hope history doesn't look at the war on drugs as having anything at all to do with drugs. It was all about having a way to lock up blacks and hippies for reasons that seemed legit on paper. Drugs were ancillary. Then of course it morphed into a for-profit industry and is the clusterfuck we have today.
- shams93 11y agoYup it started out as Richard Nixon's war on the counterculture, imagine if Steve Jobs had been taken out in the war on drugs we'd all be stuck using windows 10 at work instead of having nice macbook pros lol.
- rayiner 11y agoMost people don't think Prohibition was bad because it's a bad idea to outlaw a substance. They think it was bad because they don't think alcohol should be illegal. Similarly, while a majority of people now support legalization of marijuana, an overwhelming majority of people still support keeping cocaine and heroin illegal.
- CamperBob2 11y agoTrue. Most people aren't very good at abstract thinking.
- antillean 11y agoThat's not being bad at abstract thinking. That's thinking abstractly (and well), but just differently from you.
- existencebox 11y agoIs it really? The vast majority of Prohibition era issues were relatively substance independent, and given that we've seen the EXACT same public response, political/buzzword currents surrounding the pro-prohibition movements, and emergent criminal enterprise, I think it's fair to say that "prohibition of *" is a reasonable class to abstract by. (Watching Ken Burns "Prohibition" is something I'd strongly recommend to just about anyone, not only is it a fantastic documentary as par for the course for Burns, but it was a steady stream of "HISTORY REPEATS ITSELF" in such stark terms as you rarely see.)
- CamperBob2 11y agoYes, it's being bad at abstract thinking. There's not much that cocaine, heroin, or even meth can do to you that alcohol can't. It's indisputable that we've made poor decisions regarding what drugs to ban -- marijuana as a Schedule I drug? Really? -- and IMHO the reason for that goes back to the fact that we didn't have an appropriate basis for banning any of them in a supposedly-free society. As other posters have suggested (and been duly modded down for it), prohibition isn't really about the drugs.
- greggman 11y agoI gained a different perspective from watching the Ken Burns Prohibition documentary http://www.pbs.org/kenburns/prohibition/ http://www.pbs.org/kenburns/prohibition/ Before I watched it I thought "how could people be so stupid as to think they would ever ban alcohol". After I watched it I was like "oh wow, people drank on average 1.5 bottles of hard alcohol a week? Drunks were everywhere? Opening a bar was super cheap because the alcohol companies subsidised them. Ok, maybe I get why people would vote for prohibition". I'm not saying it was a good idea. It was clearly stupid idea which the rest of the doco made clear and is directly analogous to the war on drugs. Another POV that gave me a new perspective was the idea that legal drugs (alcohol) kill way more people than the war on drugs kills. 3+ million a year die from alcohol. (http://www.who.int/substance_abuse/facts/alcohol/en/ http://www.who.int/substance_abuse/facts/alcohol/en/). Legalizing a bunch more drugs may have the unintended consequences of killing an order of magnitude more people than the war on drugs. I'm not saying I'm for the war on drugs. All the unintended consequences of that are horrible as well. The USA's police state, seizure laws, militarization, etc. But, the idea that we'll end up possibly causing 10x more death from legalization makes me wonder if there's some middle position
- mercer 11y agoI do think it's important to consider what you mean when you say 'drugs'. Alcohol is not the same thing as weed, which is not the same thing as heroin. Putting all 'drugs' together in one category muddles up the conversation, and this is worsened by separating them into legal and illegal in ways that don't really make sense. While I'm not necessarily all in favor of weed, for example, I'm convinced that legalizing it, simply because of its properties, will not lead to even a fraction of the deaths that legalized alcohol use does. It's difficult to discuss any kind of position when we use a term as vague as 'drugs'.
- forgetsusername 11y agoIt's about Liberty. Trying to foresee all future consequences is pointless when you have no control over them anyway. Besides, how many lives have been destroyed by the War on Drugs? That requires second and third order reasoning, not simply a body count.
- 11y ago
- wobbleblob 11y agoI'm not from Denmark, but not very far from it. Don't you get civil disorder every time a high profile, widely hated criminal gets off with a sentence that's much lighter than people get in the movies? Where I live, every time that happens, populist and right wing parties rise in the polls. At this time, they're maybe one incident involving a Syrian refugee away from winning the elections. It's inevitable, with so many thousands of them, there's bound to be one who crosses the line at some point. The US has a different kind of democratic tradition. Some will say they're more democratic, but I think it has a lot to do with the "winner takes all" principle vs. "proportional representation". Deep down inside, it's what a significant chunk of the population wants: "as long as there are still people whom I can't identify with out there breaking the rules, we're still not tough enough on crime". The largest group is the one that gets represented, and doesn't have to share power.
- reycharles 11y ago> Don't you get civil disorder every time a high profile, widely hated criminal gets off with a sentence that's much lighter than people get in the movies? I don't remember any such incident in Denmark.
- VLM 11y agoIt might be a cultural thing to average levels of criminality from the top and bottom. Much like Americans believe some things to be binary or some things to be a spectrum, perhaps in Denmark criminality is binary, either you are and they throw the average sized book at all of them, or you aren't. As an anecdote this is the same Denmark that went insane over a retailer selling Marmite, costing many thousands of euro in fines and punishments. That would fit the pattern of once the binary switch flips from non-criminal to criminal, a medium sized book is thrown at all miscreants. Another possible anecdote is I know their neighbors, and probably the Danes also, punish drunken driving similar to how attempted murder is treated in the US. That would also fit the theory.
- ThomPete 11y agoWhat do you mean by similar to how attempted murder is treated in the US and what US state are you talking about? Drunk driving means first getting your drivers card taken if you have too much alcohol in your blod but it requires a lot. And I am not sure what you mean punishment wise. Care to elaborate?
- lfjmfkekdk 11y ago"In a hundred years from now people are going to look back at things like the war on drugs as one of the most barbaric, absurd and useless pieces of legislation ever to have been implemented." How do you explain the rampant crack cocaine drug wars in New York and Miami in the 1980s that killed far more Americans than they do today? You're probably too young to realize how bad New York and Miami were before the war on drugs. How do you explain how Asia has even more "draconian" drug laws than the USA and yet crime is a fraction of ours?
- LordKano 11y agoHow do you explain the rampant cocaine drug wars in New York and Miami in the 1980s that killed far more Americans than they do today? Easy, the War on Drugs began in the early 70s. The murders and general lawlessness that you reference from the 80s are a direct result of the War on Drugs.
- lfjmfkekdk 11y agoThe crack epidemic had its origins in the 1970s and became widespread in the 1980s[1]. Crack was finally targeted in 1986 with laws that heavily punished crack dealers. This happened after crack became widespread throughout major American cities.[2] "The murders and general lawlessness that you reference from the 80s are a direct result of the War on Drugs." Where were the "murders and general lawlessness" in other countries that had even more expansive Wars on Drugs, like Singapore or Taiwan? America's War on Drugs is relatively mild compared to these countries that sentence drug traffickers to death. [1] http://www.crack-facts.org/historyofcrack.html http://www.crack-facts.org/historyofcrack.html [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Crack_epidemic#History https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Crack_epidemic#History
- gohrt 11y agoThose countries didn't have their own government propping up the drug trade in order to generate illicit funding for illegal wars and to criminalize and imprison poor black people. USA did. > these countries that sentence drug traffickers to death. USA put small-time addicted drug users, in long jail terms. But only if they use crack, the "poor/black people" variant of cocaine, not the (expensive) white-powder variant of cocaine that rich/white people used.
- toephu2 11y ago"always seemed very draconian and counter productive" How so? U.S. laws are actually quite lax compared to other countries. Lets say your society had a rampant theft problem, and a law was passed saying that anyone caught stealing would have one of their hands chopped. Would this not reduce the amount of theft?
- antillean 11y ago> "Coming from Denmark where life is max 16 years..." What's the rationale for that limit? Is that the maximum time it takes to reform someone? The time after which anyone's being a threat to society expires? The magic number of years for just retribution for all (combinations of) crimes?
- TelmoMenezes 11y ago> What's the rationale for that limit? The rational for such limits in Europe is always the same: the law of diminishing returns. Increasing the max sentence after a certain point no longer has any impact on crime rates, so why do it? It costs money and creates unnecessary human suffering. Notice that Europeans do not place the same importance on retribution as Americans do. You hear less talk of "paying your debt to society" and such things. The modern European justice system is mostly seen as a mechanism of deterrence. I suspect that this is because Europe is more secular.
- cm2187 11y agoThat relies on the fundamental assumption that all criminals will reform their way after a few years in jail and therefore deserve a second chance. Most criminals should but I don't think everyone agree that all criminals should. The alternative to the death penalty for the most dangerous criminals is to be able to lock them up forever or until such age that they cannot cause any more harm. In that respect I see these short sentences for very serious crimes (multiple murders, etc) to be more dangerous than helpful. Obviously it's only a problem in countries where you have significant levels of violent crimes.
- antris 11y agoEven in countries that have maximum prison sentence length, people who are considered dangerous are still not let out into the public. They'll stay until they are considered rehabilitated. For dangerous people that have mental health problems, they don't get a prison sentence at all, but they will be forced to stay in a treatment facility until they are no longer dangerous to others. At least that's how it works in Finland. The whole system is designed to get people to become productive and healthy citizens with minimal suffering, not to provide retribution.
- cm2187 11y agoIn France, where you have a high level of common criminality, and where the justice system is trying to keep criminals out of jail but for the most violent crimes, the results are absolutely disastrous. The police doesn't even bother charging criminals as they systematically walk free. Criminals accumulate dozens of offenses on their criminal records in complete impunity. Denmark, Switzerland, Norway or Sweden can afford to have very lax justice systems because they have a population that commits little crime. But with a different population these systems would just fall apart.
- downandout 11y agoThe flipside of that is having people with lenghty but minor criminal records doing life without the possibility of parole for drastic offenses such as being the middleman for a $10 marijuana transaction, or stealing a $160 jacket [1]. I would gladly accept a rise in petty crime to not live in a country where such barbaric sentences for nonviolent crimes are even possible. [1] https://www.aclu.org/report/living-death-life-without-parole-nonviolent-offenses https://www.aclu.org/report/living-death-life-without-parole...
- cm2187 11y agoIt's not exactly the flipside, rather the other extreme.
- johnyjud 11y agoI can't relate to your way of thinking at all. Don't steal people's jackets and this problem won't affect you. I can't understand someone who would take something that doesn't belong to them and then say 'it's not fair you've locked me up'. Did they think that stealing someone's jacket was fair? If someone can't follow the rules, and is more than once reminded of the rules, and still can't follow the rules, then fucking throw them down an oubliette and let them die of thirst I say.
- thenomad 11y agoHaving a quick look at the crime statistics, France doesn't seem to be a hotbed of crime and violence at the moment. According to what I could dig up from Google, it's had a homicide rate of 1.2 per 100,000 people and a serious assault rate of 299 per 100,000 people over the last couple of years. Those are respectively slightly higher (1.2 vs 1.0) and significantly lower (400 vs 299, although data collection methodologies may be different) than the UK where I live, which is generally considered to be a reasonably safe country crime-wise. (Didn't really have time to dig into other crime categories - would be interested to hear if they buck the trend.) Not claiming your statement isn't true, but unless I'm misreading the statistics the effect doesn't seem to be a massive crime wave.
- nl 11y agoDenmark where life is max 16 years Is that actually the law or some kind of convention? Wikipedia says otherwise: In Denmark, a life sentence (Livsvarigt fængsel in Danish) theoretically means life without parole: that prisoners will spend the rest of their lives in prison. However, prisoners are entitled to a pardoning hearing after 12 years.... Prisoners sentenced to life imprisonment serve an average of 16 years, more for cases considered to be particularly grave. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Life_imprisonment_in_Denmark https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Life_imprisonment_in_Denmark
- mtgx 11y agoI think in many European countries the maximum prison sentence is about 20-25 years, even for the worst crimes and even for multiple crimes combined, because they are usually not combined at all. Only the highest sentence is taken into account. There's no such thing as 200+ year prison sentences in Europe because you combine 15 offenses. I don't even know what's the point of such sentences. Is it for PR purposes? "Look at us, we gave Osama Bin Laden 1,200 years in prison! Aren't we tough?!" Because it makes no sense to me. Just like it makes no sense to get a few years for rape or murder but be even charged with 30+ years for some online crimes.
- wobbleblob 11y agoYou can't lump all of Europe together, they all have their own justice systems, very different from each other. Three terrorists in Spain were sentenced to about 30 to 40 THOUSAND years each.
- nommm-nommm 11y agoEurope has many countries with many different legal systems so you can't make such blanket statements. Especially depending on how you define Europe. >I don't even know what's the point of such sentences. Is it for PR purposes? It is not for PR purposes, usually. It is so that if a person is acquitted of one of the crimes they still stay in jail for the others. If someone gets 50 years for rape and murder and is later acquitted for murder, but not rape, they still serve their rape sentence. The judge can decide if the jail time is served concurrently or consecutively. It seems silly to give someone 3 life sentences, after all, you only have one life. But that means they'd have to be acquitted of 3 different crimes to get out of jail. The other reason is if those life sentences come with the possibility of parole after x years - by stacking those life sentences consecutively it would delay the parole hearings until after the person is dead. Buy sometimes it is used to emphasize the crime's severity. Such is probably the case with the 40,000 year sentence for the Spanish terrorists. Even though they will only serve 40 years - the max allowed by Spanish law.
- drinchev 11y agoThousand times yes for this. There are many science studies that once you become a prisoner, instead of actually improving yourself, you degrade to the point that you become better criminal. The world goes to reducing punishments and this is the way to go. Usually there is a "healthy" amount of criminals in every nation, but you will never solve the problem by increasing the sentences, this actually makes it worse.
- dwc 11y agoThis is also an area that can be studied. In addition to the other points it's worth looking at recidivism rates, which are much lower in places like Norway than in the US. The major reasons for success of Scandinavian countries in crime and punishment are larger than a single metric, IMHO. They have a (more) comprehensive philosophy that touches on many areas, all of which work together. If the US adopted the prison conditions and lighter sentencing of Norway without other measures, it would be a complete disaster. For the US to get similar benefits we would need to (ideally) first shift our attitude toward thinking of criminals as people, and thinking most of what benefits society rather than how to punish for punishment's sake.
- Shivetya 11y agoHe is being a political opportunist coming out with this proposal and others during an election cycle. If he had truly given a damn he had seven years to fix the plight of those imprisoned in this country. He had seven years to fix a lot of things but didn't. Since Republicans are portrayed as tough on crime this is being tossed out to put them in a lose lose situation. Don't even for once take any actions by any political figure in the US as anything less than political opportunism. Seven years, two of which they had near complete control of the government. Yet what did they do to improve the plight of those incarcerated, end the war on drugs, civil forfeiture, or countless other oppression of the people by the law enforcement industry? Hell he has waited till recently to finally close Gitmo. Applaud, more than shame him for wasting seven years
- tptacek 11y agoNo, that's now how the system works in the US. He has nothing left to run for; he's term limited and leaving the highest office in the country. The election cycle does have something to do with it: in the last year of his presidency, he has nothing to lose legislatively by putting all his proposals on the table. In previous years, he had to weigh each of them against the cost of losing whatever he was trying to accomplish with Congress. That's not Obama's fault; it's the nature of the system. The President can't do whatever they want; their hands are tied by the other two branches of government. Blame John Adams.
- qrendel 11y ago> No, that's now how the system works in the US. He has nothing left to run for; he's term limited and leaving the highest office in the country. Outgoing Presidents still work towards the future electability of other members of their party over the alternatives - in Obama's case, Clinton or Sanders over the Republicans. That's part of the opportunism, along with, yes, saving the more controversial unilateral actions for when they no longer need to worry about their own re-election or cooperation from Congress.
- tptacek 11y ago
- kelvin0 11y agoPrivate prisons and the incentive to keep them full does not help. http://www.globalresearch.ca/the-prison-industry-in-the-united-states-big-business-or-a-new-form-of-slavery/8289 http://www.globalresearch.ca/the-prison-industry-in-the-unit... https://www.aclu.org/issues/mass-incarceration/privatization-criminal-justice/private-prisons https://www.aclu.org/issues/mass-incarceration/privatization... http://www.salon.com/2013/09/23/6_shocking_revelations_about_how_private_prisons_make_money_partner/ http://www.salon.com/2013/09/23/6_shocking_revelations_about...
- frostmatthew 11y agoPrivate prisons are more a symptom then a cause of high incarceration rates. States began using them in response to prison over-population - and the percentage of inmates in private prisons is relatively low (single digits IIRC). edit: to be clear I am against privatization of prisons because I think the incentives are woefully misaligned, but wanted to point out it's inaccurate to suggest they're the cause of our high incarceration rate
- vezzy-fnord 11y agoPrivate prisons are largely a red herring. They account for some 8.4% of the prison population. [1] Many of the horror stories coming from them are simply from the fact that state corrections agencies willfully loosen their standards when contracting with private prison operators. [1] http://www.bjs.gov/content/pub/pdf/p14.pdf http://www.bjs.gov/content/pub/pdf/p14.pdf, p. 14
- joshuaheard 11y ago..."go to jail just because society does not know what else to do with you..." The purpose of putting to people in jail stems from the 3 Rs: Retribution, Removal, and Rehabilitation. Retribution: punishment for the crime. Removal: removal from society so no further harm can be committed by the individual. Rehabilitation: make the individual a better person so they don't commit more crimes and become better citizens. Unfortunately, we usually don't accomplish all 3, but 1 of the 3 usually gets done.
- grumio 11y agoAnd one more reason: deterrence. Supposedly, would-be criminals are deterred by seeing others get jail time. Depending on the crime, that purpose is rarely accomplished as well.
- shkkmo 11y agoI think that falls under retribution.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- 13thLetter 11y agoDeterrence exists, but all the research (in the US) suggests it's caused by certainty of punishment, not magnitude of punishment. A two-week stint in jail that's almost guaranteed will do far more to deter criminals than a ten-year stint that almost never happens. Unfortunately, it's much easier to crank up the penalties and posture as "tough on crime" than it is to make sure police are actually closing cases.
- pluma 11y agoSpecifically, the US tends to be obsessed with the first R, not just in jail terms but also how the law is applied. Especially with "values"-based laws.
- mbillie1 11y ago
- kaonashi 11y agoJail is the constitutional exception to slavery, so American law enforcement has had a built-in incentive since reconstruction to incarcerate as many people as possible to make up the work gangs that had previously been filled with slaves.