3 ms·
I'm a (or at least was) a huge Michael Lewis fan. Until he wrote a book about the industry I was in (HFT). Regardless of where you stand on HFT, Flashboys does
by kasey_junk 11y ago
I'm a (or at least was) a huge Michael Lewis fan. Until he wrote a book about the industry I was in (HFT). Regardless of where you stand on HFT, Flashboys does a very bad job explaining the technical aspects that are occurring. Further it presents a completely 1 sided look at the industry, without ever quoting someone knowledgeable about the technical aspects.
I don't dislike Flashboys because of its conclusions, I dislike it because of its inaccuracy. It called inot question every other book of his. Which was really disappointing as I had enjoyed them all so much.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- sharkweek 11y agoThis is super interesting to me - got any resources of people counter-pointing Lewis's writing? Would love to dive in a little deeper.
- kasey_junk 11y agohttp://kc.my-junk.info/hft-books/ http://kc.my-junk.info/hft-books/ ^^ a blog post where I collect this stuff as I answer this question so often.
- toddmatthews 11y agobut you don't really give any specific counter points. if Flash Boys is dreadful, i would think you would have specific points to counter it
- tptacek 11y agoIf there was a way you could have worded this comment without implying that Kasey was just making things up, it would have been a better comment. As it stands, I think you can take the time to use the search bar at the bottom of the page to find what he's written about the book on the site before.
- toddmatthews 11y agoin no way was i implying he was "making things up" but he has said that Flash Boys did a "bad job of explaining HFT" and on that website he links to it says its "dreadful". He also says he "answers this question so often" he made that site. but the site just lists books, but doesn't really answer any questions. Just pointing to other peoples books is not really answering a question. and i think if Flash Boys is "dreadful" he could point to a few concrete examples
- Nimitz14 11y agohttps://scottlocklin.wordpress.com/2014/04/04/michael-lewis-shilling-for-the-buyside/ https://scottlocklin.wordpress.com/2014/04/04/michael-lewis-... Quote: > I think this is the crux of this story: according to Michael Lewis and Katsuyama, we’re supposed to trust people like Einhorn who have been convicted of insider trading, people who are suspected of insider trading (buy side is by definition rife with this; particularly firms that do merger arb and special events), J.P. Morgan, Goldman and Morgan Stanley: we’re supposed to trust these guys more than we’re supposed to trust a bunch of tiny little market making firms who had been inconveniencing them by taking away some of their flow. Lewis tries to make this seem like a battle between the underdog “good guys” and the evil establishment. To believe this, you’d have to believe that Goldman Sachs and people like Einhorn are underdogs, rather than the actual establishment. To believe this, you’d have to believe the tiny industry of HFT traders actually rules the world and buys off congressmen and the SEC more than … J.P. Morgan and Goldman. [...] Yeah, I might believe that. I might believe that if I were a dribbling retard.
- toddmatthews 11y agoStill this is all just Ad-Hominem attack on the characters in Flash Boys and seems a bit over the top "Yeah, I might believe that. I might believe that if I were a dribbling retard." doesn't really answer why Flash Boys does such a terrible job of explaining HFT
- tptacek 11y agoYes, it does. You didn't read it carefully enough. The whole premise of the David and Goliath story Lewis wants to tell is that HFT is a device used by the Wall Street establishment to screw over the rest of the market. But in fact it's more the opposite: HFT firms are upstart prop trading and market making shops that are pissing off giant banks like Goldman and JPMC by making it harder for them to skim profits off block trades for pension and hedge funds. Also: the use of rhetoric like "dribbling retard" isn't what makes an argument "ad hominem". An ad hominem argument is one whose logic rests on a claim about its opponent and doesn't account for its opponent's argument. The logic behind the quote you're commenting on doesn't do that.
- kasey_junk 11y agoI think that is a fair criticism. You can read my blog post to be "Flash Boys, Not So Fast is the rebuttal I would have written if I had the time and was a good writer". Maybe I should change the post to be more explicit about that.
- toddmatthews 11y agoFair enough
- airza 11y agoThis is an excellent and fairly short book on the subject: http://www.amazon.com/Flash-Boys-Insiders-Perspective-High-Frequency-ebook/dp/B00P0QI2M2 http://www.amazon.com/Flash-Boys-Insiders-Perspective-High-F...