4 ms·
You're Not Allowed to Criticize Startups, You Stupid Hater
- rm_-rf_slash 11y agoI'm not entirely convinced by the argument that criticizing startups is a social faux pas. My friends and I talk about startups like sports teams and there's no small share of schadenfreude when our predictions of failure came true.
- salmonet 11y agoDefinitely not the case outside SV. It's easier to make fun of the overly optimistic than the overly pessimistic, so it's safer to criticize. I'm glad there is a place like SV where over optimism could even be a problem.
- potatolicious 11y agoIt depends on what circles you're in. I'm in your boat - most of my friends talk about startups and tech and are routinely skeptical, if not brutal, in our assessments. But I also know a few people who are much closer to the money side of the business who don't ever shit-talk startups, no matter how crazy and dumb they are, or no matter how scummy their behavior. I would say that the social acceptability of criticizing startups is proportional to your professional distance from a VC. Accordingly, the social acceptability of criticizing the meta-aspects of startups (fundraising, investing, etc) is the square of your professional distance from a VC ;) There's definitely a "cone of silence" effect around VCs/incubators. Everyone walks on eggshells around them and criticism is extremely muted. Forget optimism/pessimism, even criticism of downright unethical/illegal actions is largely nonexistent.
- rm_-rf_slash 11y ago>Forget optimism/pessimism, even criticism of downright unethical/illegal actions is largely nonexistent. This is something that scares me about Silicon Valley. That kind of attitude opens a market for respectability, and once that becomes accepted, the tech bro douchebaggery is going to get shunned, hard. The services they made so cheap will make it even easier for someone else to eat their lunch, and even pointedly NOT being a part of the Valley could be a point in a company's favor (privacy-centric consumers who see SV companies willingly send personal data to NSA dragnets). Then it becomes a matter of fashion. ("You're still using snapchat after X came out? What are you, 12? The government is reading all of your snaps by the way.") But leave it to a society of nerds to forget the vital necessity of being cool.
- mesozoic 11y agoI think maybe it's only in the Silicon Valley echo chamber that not criticizing ludicrous startups is a thing. Everywhere else it seems to be good fun to watch an idiotic idea die.
- volaski 11y agoIt's not cool to criticize startups in silicon valley because that's what the place stands for. There's already enough people in the world who will say it's a stupid app (probably 99.9%), I don't see anything wrong with some encouragement from a small community. And like you observed, an app won't get traction no matter how famous the founder is if it's not good enough, so life is not exactly "unfair".
- jff 11y ago> It's not cool to criticize startups in silicon valley because that's what the place stands for. Fucking what? Would you say nobody in Hollywood should ever judge a movie script because the place is about making movies? "Well, whoever wrote this script obviously put a lot of effort into it, so here $50 million"
- volaski 11y agoNo investor says "Well, whoever wrote this script obviously put a lot of effort into it, so here $50 million". But I'm sure hollywood community also encourages each other for their creativity no matter how crazy something sounds. Encouragement and actually putting in $50million are very different things. Everyone outside of silicon valley will react the same way you do, and that's why silicon valley is necessary because it's one of the few places on earth where you can talk about ridiculous stuff and not worry about being judged, which encourages creativity. (For example, most people will think "AirBnB for pets" is an idiotic idea and it probably is, but the fact that people can talk about these things freely is a good thing)
- BinaryIdiot 11y ago> It's not cool to criticize startups in silicon valley because that's what the place stands for. While I'm not "in" SV I do interact with many who do. I think SV it's more "cool" to give honest and direct feedback above anything else. Though my observations are purely anecdotal as are yours (I'm assuming). But I don't think it's healthy to encourage if you think the app is stupid. Feel free to refrain from commenting at all but let the people who really like / use the app be the cheerleaders.
- jasode 11y agoIt seems most people criticize software not because of hate but because of confusion. Digital products like software don't have a physical "shape" that makes it obvious what they improve on. (E.g. the initial confusion about the intended usages of Adobe Lightroom vs Adobe Photoshop.) Imagine if blind person was told about a bicycle and how it can transport a person from point A to point B. Then someone else presents him with a description of a car and how it has 4 wheels. The blind person might say, "but what the hell would I want 4 wheels instead of 2?!? That's twice the maintenance and replacement parts!" But then you explain that the 4-wheel can self-balance without a kickstand and can transport 5 people instead of just 2. Those kinds of conversations never happen because people can see the obvious differences between a bicycle and a car. Unfortunately, the "shape" of software is amorphous. We can all be "blind" to the value proposition of unknown software. Software is described with "words". (Sometimes with screenshots too but then again, the screenshots themselves often have more "words" surrounded by GUI boxes or colors.) This is why so many "Show HN" threads have the question, "what exactly does this do?" or "how is this any different from X?" As for your theme... I don't know about Techcrunch comments but on HN, there's a propensity to be skeptical & criticise rather than fawn & praise. (https://venngage.com/blog/why-you-need-to-stop-obsessing-over-comments-on-hacker-news/ https://venngage.com/blog/why-you-need-to-stop-obsessing-ove...) To me, "hater" is somewhat clickbaity but I think it originates from the "haters gonna hate" meme so if you want to riff on that, I get it.
- minimaxir 11y ago> To me, "hater" is somewhat clickbaity but I think it originates from the "haters gonna hate" meme so if you want to riff on that, I get it. Yes, it's a riff of that, and a term I've seen expressed by the startup crowd frequently. (That, and "anyone who criticizes my startup is just trolling," which is a related but different problem.)
- aerovistae 11y agoI think that's the point of the Valley, isn't it? That you can try to do something stupid and people will give you the benefit of the doubt? Idk about you but I made $6k off AirBnB last quarter, which was nice, so I'm not complaining. That's a big obvious one, but I could probably list 20 others from the area that have affected me in a positive way. (My point being that sometimes something great comes out of what seems dumb, as is well known.) I don't disagree at all that serious looks at what went wrong are very, very useful to everyone else, but I personally like that Silicon Valley is a sort of safe space for experimenting with dumb ideas where people won't make a big deal out of it if one or more of your ideas don't work out.
- tahoeskibum 11y agoNicely put. I like Valley for the same reason, it is a safe space to try out stuff and see what sticks. Uber saved my ass in London when I got stuck as the public transportation doessn't accept cash or credit (only the special Oyster Card). The hype needs to be taken with a grain of salt but there are some really valuable and useful startups out there. P.S. I too made ~ $6K last quarter on AirBnB.
- bboreham 11y agoThere are machines at every station that will accept your cash or credit card and give you a paper ticket in return. Or give you an Oyster Card, for that matter.
- tahoeskibum 11y agoI was trying to take a bus from a regular bus stop around 7 pm. Nearby shops where I could've bought a card were closed by then (in that part of London).
- nickpsecurity 11y agoYou didn't counter his assertions at all. The first thing is anecdotal and meaningless: give me a person who benefits from most I can give you someone who doesn't. Overall data is more important. This is about startup companies, though, not individuals. Back on startups. Sure, it's great that you can experiment. We can still experiment while calling bullshit when we see it. There's a huge gap between "They're trying something we think might be cool or make it but ton of risk here as prior examples illustrate" and "World-changing app here whose initial uptake indicates billions in making and any problems are just a hiccup! Get it today!" A bit more of the former will at least let people spot problem areas and maybe avoid them more often.
- mattmanser 11y agoTop and 3rd comments on the HN thread are both criticism, and if you actually read the follow up article on tech crunch: Some say it’s dumb, some say it’s great, and a lot say something in between What do I feel about it? It feels fresh Mind you, it’s on a massive hype-train right now so take it all with a grain of salt That doesn't sound like you're not allowed to criticize a startup.
- coldtea 11y agoTo me those statements feel like they're covering their ass for being positive on the rest of the article about an app that's ho-hum at best. Fresh? What exactly is fresh about it?
- digbyloftus 11y agoWhat? That's the least critical hedging comment they could have possibly made. "some say it's dumb" is their extreme negative? Really?
- taytus 11y agoThis is the guy who became "famous" for commenting ALL the time on TechCrunch. Sorry, I can't take you seriously.
- minimaxir 11y agoIncidentally, one of the reasons I started commenting on TechCrunch was because the authors were being too soft on startup shennanigans.
- lanewinfield 11y agoHey man, I didn't realize until the end of your (well written) article with your photo that it was you, the celebrity TechCrunch commenter. I'm a fan. Keep at it!
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- chatmasta 11y agoWhy not, because he attaches his real name to his internet commenting history? Max seems like a smart guy to me (and apparently also to Apple, where he's worked for multiple years). I find his comments to be amusing, and writing them is clearly just a fun activity for him, just like posting on hacker news is for us. I'm not sure why the fact he comments all the time on TechCrunch causes you to stick your fingers in your ears and shout "lalala I can't hear you."
- pfarnsworth 11y agoTo be fair, there is a lot of hate on tech forums, because that is generally the attitude of most techies. "Oh, that's stupid because of X. I've seen that back when it was Y." Most people in tech appear to believe that if you think of reasons why an idea will fail, that somehow makes you smart. I've learned the opposite, that figuring out how to make idea work is what makes you smart. That said, HN is the Mecca of all startup-wannabes. You're going to get a disproportionate amount of lashback here either for or against all-things-startup. Like anything, if you're going to post a comment, or a product, expect a lot of dumb negative feedback and ignore the haters. Take the good negative feedback and internalize that, though.
- BinaryIdiot 11y agoI think this depends on the demographic and context more than anything. Sometimes a start-up will be posted to HN and it feels like everyone in the comments section has "drank the kool-aid" and othertimes it seems the exact opposite possibly being too critical (though I feel like a healthy mix is the usual around here). As far as HN is concerned I don't think there is a general "you can't hate on start-ups" mentality but there are times when things can be click-y on any conversational site. Now news sources like TechCrunch? Good luck. If a start-up is on the rise they'll publish whatever gives them more clicks. When a start-up is on the decline they'll still publish whatever gives them more clicks. If that means "not admitting they're wrong" then that's just how it'll be. As for Peach I downloaded it to try it. I didn't "get it". Thought it was terrible because I couldn't share or do anything without finding people first. So I uninstalled. I don't have time to cultivate friends on yet another social network; it needs to essentially be done for me. Which yeah sounds super lazy but I don't think it's off the mark either.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- milesf 11y agoWell played. You took a dying app, and managed to bring it back onto the radar by spinning a story that has nothing to do with the app itself. There must be some sort of pro version of the Hype Cycle circulating in the Valley (http://www.gartner.com/technology/research/methodologies/hype-cycle.jsp http://www.gartner.com/technology/research/methodologies/hyp...). "Okay marketeers, we need to begin the 'underdog' portion of our marketing campaign. If that doesn't work, then we may need to engineer a scandal to boost traffic".
- minimaxir 11y agoI have zero affiliation with Peach, if that is what you are implying. "Any publicity is good publicity" is another fallacy I'd like to take a closer look at.
- milesf 11y agoNaw, I just meant it in the same vein of your article :) Being critical of people being critical by being critical.
- coldtea 11y ago>Well played. You took a dying app, and managed to bring it back onto the radar by spinning a story that has nothing to do with the app itself. It's a story about the launch of the app, the reactions to it and its course in the app charts. It doesn't get any much more about "the app itself" -- except if by that you mean he should only be allowed to review the app and/or write about its feature specs, menus and gradients used in the UI... >There must be some sort of pro version of the Hype Cycle circulating in the Valley. "Okay marketeers, we need to begin the 'underdog' portion of our marketing campaign. If that doesn't work, then we may need to engineer a scandal to boost traffic". I don't see any iota of proof (or even a hint) that he wrote the story to build hype about the app. This accusation borders on tin foil conspiracy theories...
- luckydata 11y agoI wish I could down vote this comment.
- nathanm412 11y agoI would imagine that many in Silicon Valley has pushed the issue of hyper valuation into a deep dark pit inside of themselves. They don't want to consider what would happen to them if this turns out to be a bubble that may one day pop. You'll make these people insecure if you start questioning the way the system currently operates.
- pekk 11y agoToo much of what gets called "criticism" comes from people who aren't really qualified to make that criticism, and is expressed in a way that is not civil or objective or relevant, let alone constructive. Some critics are just sniping at their competition. Many critics are just trying to show off and look smart. Many critics have the crab bucket mentality. A few critics are the kind of people who entertain themselves by pulling the legs off of animals. That is why we have the word "haters" to describe those kinds of critics. It's a useful word.
- te_chris 11y agoOh please, so critics have to be credentialed now? We're not THAT precious around here now are we?
- nickpsecurity 11y agoGood write-up. What we're seeing is something similar to the Gold Rush and Dotcom Boom of the past. There's a bit more reason involved thankfully. Everyone has their eye on the prize and golden ticket to it (tech startups) that they're ignoring every detail that distracts from it. They continue to do this even when the details show they're stepping away from the prize or probably won't achieve it. A chance to pivot or cut losses in favor of different product/service is lost due to how this perspective blinds onlookers. To be honest, it's a lot like a religion. Creating, pouring energy into, praising, and not blaspheming startups is the religion of Silicon Valley. They need more reason and less religion.
- pj_mukh 11y agoMeh. The valley needs its naysayers, but it mostly works because a select few can ignore naysayers completely. Unless, I see a reason why this is dangerous to anybody other than private consented money, this is a molehill not a mountain.
- zpallin 11y agoYea. We're only really looking at the criticism of one startup. If we looked at the whole, we'd probably find that a vast amount of startups are simply not even "starting up" because of criticism, which is good. Perhaps the point here, which we could explore more, is that startups backed by tons of money typically push relatively unoriginal ideas to the forefront that are simply "marketed better" because of $.
- pj_mukh 11y agoSV famously values "execution". A combination of finding the right market (slightly more complicated than just pumping money into marketing) and staying doggedly focussed. Sometimes if you focus on the wrong thing, you die (and get made fun of). The press coverage the author seems to have such an issue with is famously fickle. Make an electric car that looks like a toaster and a fish and market it to the general consumer. You die. Make an electric car that looks like a luxury sedan and market it to the top end of the market. You become Tesla. Obviously, in the latter case he backed up that market selection with world class engineering. The two then get inextricably linked. You have to look past the predilections of the establishment to get there though.
- calcsam 11y agoThe existing puff piece aura of most startup articles has a more simple explanation: selection bias. Many people have an incentive to write "Startup X launched!" If Startup X never raised significant funding, no one has an incentive to write "Startup X died."
- desireco42 11y agoHa, nice writeup. It looks like it was well organized campaign to launch app, they did everything right, yet even with all this 'cheating' involved, it is genuinely hard to make a successful app. Plus this is area that is crowded with apps and probably not the best place to focus your efforts.
- potatolicious 11y agoMessaging is hard, speaking from experience having been part of an attempt that failed. IMO it seems like Peach did everything they possibly could and the execution was in broad strokes excellent, but a messaging app in 2016 is the Hail Mary of Hail Maries. Firstly, there are no "new users" to messaging. Literally everyone is already using something for messaging - Hangouts, Messenger, Line, WhatsApp, etc etc. Unlike other areas of tech, social messaging is a zero-sum game where every user you gain means someone else loses a user. This is hard environment for any new product with no existing traction. Messaging is also one of those things that is used so much that it's driven heavily by habitual behavior. Which also means you have to break a user's muscle memory/habits before you can have a shot at keeping them in the long term. The default for a competent messaging app is that people try your app out, think you're cool, and then promptly go back to whatever they were using before, because you haven't broken their old habit and/or haven't formed a new one. 14-day cohort retention is going to be nearly zero in the default case. Habit-formation within users is really, really, really f'ing hard.
- dang 11y agoPeople criticize startups on HN just fine. What you're not allowed to do here is post linkbait titles.
- 6stringmerc 11y agoIt's one thing to needlessly criticize a new business (start up), or an espoused goal (hyperloop) but a completely different situation when bringing in some run-of-the-mill skepticism. I think skepticism is healthy - it's one of those interesting emotional/intellectual mechanisms. In the most effective circumstances, skepticism seems to blend past experience + current facts + future hypothesis, all of which fit into the context of the referenced article. Generally I don't bring much of any philosophy into the skepticism approach. Every once and a while though, it does play a role. I'm not really proud of it, but I'll publicly admit that I was so utterly repulsed by the Aurous concept that I did a little happy dance when market forces (i.e. the RIAA) took on Aurous, shut it down fast, and moved on from the dead carcass. Am I happier for its demise? Yep.
- rburhum 11y agoThis is HNs, plenty of people think they know everything about startups because they can deploy a React app on Digital Ocean. Running a startup is difficult as hell, so IMHO, if an app manages to have a successful launch, then more power to them. At the end of the day, it boils down to capturing value to be able to make it. For some businesses Techcrunch/Buzzfeed/etc press may be a key factor in this process, for others, it is just vanity. Why do we even care?