36 ms·
Personal Space Is a Fear Response
- lr4444lr 11y agoWhy the assumption that it's always fear-based? Personal space boundaries are also cues to kinship ties, and sexual willingness. To my understanding, this is observed even in much of the animal kingdom.
- DominikR 11y agoExactly, I'm not afraid of something when I feel that some woman enters my personal space against my will. I'm just not interested. I'm also not afraid of the colleague entering my personal space, I'm just not interested in friendship with that particular person.
- Jtsummers 11y agoI find language interesting. The word "afraid" suggests some conscious level understanding of the fear you're feeling. A fear response doesn't require you to be conscious of it. When someone stands too close behind me, particularly if it's unexpected or a stranger, while I'm not afraid (I am not concerned about being assaulted in any form), my body still tenses up. That's a fear response. Something comes quickly at you, seen in your peripheral vision, you react by flinching, perhaps some adrenaline. A fear response, it may cause an emotional response of fear, or it may not. But it creates the physiological response to it.
- DominikR 11y agoI'm not a native english speaker so my use of the language is more basic than yours. But yes I agree, if a stranger is for some reason standing very close behind me in an unexpected situation (in public transportation it would be okay) then of course there would be a fear response directly leading to either moving away from that person or showing aggression. (fight or flight) But I don't believe that this fear is wrong on my part and that I should do something about it. It is unexpected and unwanted behaviour in our Western societies and this person should be aware of this and behave appropriately. If the person does not then he/she either doesn't know what our social rules are (can be dangerous) or something is wrong with that person (also dangerous) For example: I am at a party and go home at night through some lonely street, in front of me (10 meters or so) there is some unknown women going the same way. The appropriate thing to do is to keep more distance so she is not afraid, even though I don't have any intentions of harming anyone. (but she cannot know this, I'm a stranger) What do you propose how she should feel if for some reason a person would not keep a safe distance? Is she wrong if she is afraid in such a situation? I don't think so.
- Jtsummers 11y ago> But I don't believe that this fear is wrong on my part and that I should do something about it. I agree. And I think the article is saying the same. Fear (the emotion) is an appropriate response to numerous things, including someone entering your personal space. My response, poorly worded, sorry, was intended to say that a fear response is different from fear (the emotion). Even a non-stranger could elicit a fear response from you, even a trusted person or lover, by entering your personal space. But it may not trigger the emotion of fear. That is, if I know you and trust you, you could be in my face during a conversation. I wouldn't fear you or the situation. But I may still experience the heightened senses, the increased heart rate, due to your proximity because of a physiological response (fear response).
- miguelrochefort 11y agoThis has been said over and over and over again. Privacy is irrational, a response to fear. Why model a future after a fear?
- DominikR 11y agoThen you are probably one of the very few persons that considers it normal to copulate regularly in the public.
- miguelrochefort 11y agoAll animals, except humans, do.
- thaumasiotes 11y agoThis isn't even slightly true. Some animals will have sex in public; some won't as long as they feel they're being observed. Humans, obviously, fall into the second category, but we're quite far from being alone there.
- Tharkun 11y agoWhat do you base this assumption on? Not only do, literally, thousands of people enjoy sex in public, but it was impossible to have sex in private before people got big houses with separate bedrooms.
- Jtsummers 11y agoHouses and bedrooms are hardly necessary for private sex. You don't even need buildings. Just space or cover and careful (or not so careful) timing.
- adventured 11y agoThat's of course incorrect. Many species mate in private for security purposes, including building up elaborate territorial systems to enhance that security. Many species of cats and birds do so for example. I also don't think you understand at all why humans have sex in private. Hint: it's primarily for security purposes. In the animal kingdom, in the more frequently compared species to humans - chimps, gorillas, etc - weaker males are often murdered or otherwise prevented from mating, mating is by force and not consensual, it's ruled by the most dominate males. The dominant males breed at a drastically higher rate than the weak males. Is that how you want to compete as a human, by your capability to deliver violence? How do you think that will work out in practice for most men and most women today? Have you ever seen what happens to women in a violent or agitated crowd in some more dangerous parts of the world - and how do you think sex in that same crowd, or any crowd, would turn out? Turns out security is an excellent reason for having sex in private. http://cogsci.stackexchange.com/questions/1567/why-do-humans-have-sex-in-private http://cogsci.stackexchange.com/questions/1567/why-do-humans...
- taneq 11y agoThe fact that fear is the response to a perceived invasion of personal space doesn't mean that your perception of personal space is a fear response. You can't just lump things into two categories: https://youtu.be/bXKvRNnXF3A https://youtu.be/bXKvRNnXF3A
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- je-so 11y agoPersonal space is a natural right! Even animals has this right except farm animals.
- arpa 11y agoWait, how exactly perception of "personal space" is a response; secondly, please drop the pretense that "fear is bad, mkay". It is perfectly fine to feel fear when a red hot poker enters your personal space (i.e. it can harm you). There's nothing to be fixed here, system self-preservation subroutines work just fine, thank you. Oh, and, edit, just because amygdala is partial to fear responses, it doesn't make all the actions that it takes part in "fear". It controls a lot of other functions, such as pleasure, sexual behavior, aggression, memory consolidation; not to mention that a lot of information passes through it both into the brain and out of it. Please, age of phrenology is over. It's not coming back. Human brain and human behavior is not "black and white" anymore, it's never going to be. It's a complex system of neuron junctions and pathways some of which are more specialized than others, sure, but, to reiterate, the incredible malleability and the sheer number of connections in human brain make neuroscientists even doubt the necessity of well established "centers" such as Broca's area. God. Damn. It.
- 0xcde4c3db 11y ago> Oh, and, edit, just because amygdala is partial to fear responses, it doesn't make all the actions that it takes part in "fear". Yeah; this article (or at least the headline) seems to be engaging in the reverse inference fallacy [1]. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Functional_magnetic_resonance_imaging#Reverse_inference https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Functional_magnetic_resonance_...
- hodwik 11y agoSomeone took the article personally.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- arpa 11y agoI like my personal space, and, well, since the article violated my perceived personal belief space, of course, flight-or-fight response was triggered; you can see the outcome pretty clear I suppose. It was not "fear".
- Eric_WVGG 11y agoWhy are so many of the commenters on this page acting as if they were personally attacked? Nowhere in the article are "fear responses" described as bad or unusual. The knee-jerk hostility and lack of any sense of irony is quite telling.
- arpa 11y agoPlease point me to the articles' irony. It's easy to miss in that mess.
- splawn 11y agoI think they are referring to irony found in some of the reactions to the article not the article content. I have never really thought about personal space being a fear response before. I always just thought I hated other people breathing on me.
- mcguire 11y agoTo me, it's more of a safety issue. I move erratically.
- Eric_WVGG 11y agoHistrionic knee-jerks reactions are a common response to fear. Numerous people here are simultaneously announcing that they are protective of their personal space, and lashing out at the article -- one person even admitted that it triggered his "flight or fight" response. All of this is anecdotal proof of the thesis. (Just as an additional anecdote of the flip side of this, I have no personal space issues -- I like crowds and subways -- and have somewhat reckless tendencies)
- arpa 11y agoHistrionic statements receive histrionic reactions; I fail to see connection with fear, fright or threat. I mean, we're all just flinging poo here and that's about it. What got to me is not the title, but the way how an fascinating topic was dragged down to the gutter and then just choked to death. I mean personal space is just another boundary, which one has to cross to "get up close and personal". It is an act of aggression. Now who displays that aggression, is what determines what kind of response you'll get. If it's your sweetheart in a sexy mood, the response will be sexual. If it's a skinhead with a knife, it will be a fear response. The action is the same: violation of personal space; the circumstances are not. You could write a dissertation on that alone. And well here we have a person obviously not in the field, writing a biology column on neuroscience using one quote of neuroscientist and a case study of a brain-damaged patient to drive her point that "personal space is a fear response" and not even doing that well. Sorry. The article is just bad.
- laotzu 11y agoMarshall McLuhan has an alternate but related theory for the difference between "close talkers" and those who like to be able to see the whole person when talking. In The Gutenberg Galaxy, McLuhan infers that "close talkers" are often tribal cultures who rely primarily on the spoken word for means of communication whereas highly literate cultures like to be able to see the whole person because of the stress the print medium has on the eye.