8 ms·
Headphone and Amp Impedance (2011)
- steejk 11y agoI could have done with reading this article a week earlier. I just built a converter to allow earphones to be used in aircraft audio panel outputs which are typically 150-350 Ohms. Another bizarre thing I learnt is that 1/2" and 1/4" stereo jacks are wired opposite ways.
- cnvogel 11y agoHow did you learn that 1/2" or 1/4" head phones would be wired "opposite ways"? I would doubt that this is the case.
- MrBuddyCasino 11y agoNot sure if we are talking about the same thing, but on a flight with a Boing 777, I found the throw-away headphones that they hand out upon boarding with the very strange connector (dual mono jacks) to be so bad as to be nearly useless. I tried to cut the cable, remove the isolation and connect my Apple earbuds, which worked somehow but not very well because the (very thin) wires were individually isolated. Did you come up with a solution?
- legulere 11y agoThere are adapters you can buy for like 3$.
- amelius 11y agoCircuit theory becomes much more elegant if you start to use complex numbers (conceptually, the Laplace transform [1]). But for an introductory lesson, this page seems nice, though perhaps a bit long. [1] https://en.wikibooks.org/wiki/Circuit_Theory/Laplace_Transform https://en.wikibooks.org/wiki/Circuit_Theory/Laplace_Transfo... (If you grasp this reference, then you understand, I'd say, about 25% of what electrical engineering is about)
- sprash 11y agoBut only if you use linear components (meaning L,C,R). Introduce just one diode and the system of diff equations needs to be solved numerically. In which case you have switch to simulations like spice anyways. Therefore there is no reason to even bother with Laplace transforms nowadays. For hobbyists (and the vast majority of professionals) I would consider it completely useless knowledge.
- raverbashing 11y ago> Introduce just one diode and the system of diff equations needs to be solved numerically Not really. Maybe that's why nobody invented anything with a diode in the signal path before computers were commonplace right? Like radio and guitar distortion pedals > Therefore there is no reason to even bother with Laplace transforms nowadays Sure, let's forget the math and make engineers totally dependent on numerical simulation without knowing the basics, I'm sure that'll work just fine > For hobbyists (and the vast majority of professionals) I would consider it completely useless knowledge. LOL Sure, in the same way that sorting algorithms don't are useless for computer science students, right? Just call .sort() and you're done! Also don't forget Digital Signal Processing, that also relies on that "useless knowledge"
- sprash 11y ago> Not really. Maybe that's why nobody invented anything with a diode in the signal path before computers were commonplace right? Like radio and guitar distortion pedals No, those problems were solved via ultra simplified models. E.g. The current through a diode is described as I = I_0 \Theta(U - 0.7 V). And the rest was done via try and error. > Sure, let's forget the math and make engineers totally dependent on numerical simulation without knowing the basics, I'm sure that'll work just fine How about, lets learn how to solve every differential equation you will ever come across in electronics using e.g. Runge-Kutta. > Just call .sort() and you're done! If you want to get shit done you do exactly that. This is a great problem of many fresh CS graduates. Instead of doing the actual work they would rather first implement their own sort function. In 99.9% of the cases it is a complete waste of time. > Also don't forget Digital Signal Processing, that also relies on that "useless knowledge" In Digital Signal Processing you mainly need to Fourier transform and know the properties of the sin(x)/x function, Nyquist, Shannon etc... Learning how to solve a very special case of systems of differential equations using the Laplace transform won't help you there at all.
- gchokov 11y agoNice, good and cheap amp ($19) mentioned at the bottom of the article, in case you need immediate boost over stock audio from your phone - http://nwavguy.blogspot.bg/2011/03/fiio-e5-headphone-amp.html http://nwavguy.blogspot.bg/2011/03/fiio-e5-headphone-amp.htm...
- ju-st 11y agoOr when you are annoyed by a shitty soundcard in your business notebook, get a Behringer external DAC/soundcard for $29 ( http://nwavguy.blogspot.de/2011/02/behringer-uca202-review.html http://nwavguy.blogspot.de/2011/02/behringer-uca202-review.h... )
- stordoff 11y agoI have a UCA202 (and a UFO202 - AFAIK it is identical but with a phono stage on the line ins) to use with my Surface (the build-in card is very noisy) and it is a noticeable improvement over the built-in card. Definitely recommended if you need a USB DAC without spending a fortune.
- te 11y agoI use an Acer C720 Chromebook running Linux to drive my virtual piano software. I had no complaints with it's on-board audio performance, but after reading multiple exhortations on the internet about how much better external soundcards are, I bought a $5 USB soundcard widely available from multiple vendors on ebay. OK, I can just barely hear an improvement over the on-board. It's better in the sense of "significant" (ie definitely there), but it just isn't a material difference to me. If I'm that deaf to the differences between these two sources, I'm curious if people think the UCA202 will change my life?
- nitrogen 11y agoThe noise floor is the main issue with most cheap sound hardware. It's often loud, and not spectrally flat. You'll be able to hear more of your music at lower volumes if you get a high quality DAC with a low noise floor. The other big issue is distortion/nonlinearity. This is much less of an issue than the noise floor, but can still be noticeable on cheap DACs. It's likely that you can do a lot better than a $5 DAC on both of these factors.
- thucydides 11y agoThis guy also built and open-sourced a universally admired headphone amplifier and DAC. His O2 amp: http://nwavguy.blogspot.bg/2011/07/o2-headphone-amp.html http://nwavguy.blogspot.bg/2011/07/o2-headphone-amp.html His O2 DAC: http://nwavguy.blogspot.bg/2012/04/odac-released.html http://nwavguy.blogspot.bg/2012/04/odac-released.html JDS Labs and others sell them commercially for those who don't feel like building them by hand.
- yoodenvranx 11y agoThere is an interesting article about him, his amp and the resulting problems due to his disappearance: http://spectrum.ieee.org/geek-life/profiles/nwavguy-the-audio-genius-who-vanished http://spectrum.ieee.org/geek-life/profiles/nwavguy-the-audi...
- jzelinskie 11y agoHe/She has also inspired some other manufacturers to rethink their products. IIRC Schiit was formed when some engineers thought they could improve the O2/ODAC design on their own[0]. I own an original Schiit Stack (Magnus & Modi) and would definitely recommend them. [0]: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8834176 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8834176
- qb45 11y agoNot exactly, you may want to actually read the source you linked :) The company existed before O2 and M/M were independent designs.
- jzelinskie 11y agoThanks. I had read that someplace else and went digging for the link and simply assumed that was it.
- teraflop 11y agoOn a tangentially related topic: When I used to listen to music on my previous phone (a Nexus 4) I would have to constantly adjust the phone's volume: all the way to maximum when using an aux cord in my car, and way back down when using headphones. Recently I upgraded to a Nexus 5X, and noticed a surprising new feature. Somehow, the phone detects which device it's plugged into, and remembers a separate, previously-set volume level for each device. Does anyone know how this works? It's really convenient, which makes it surprising that I can't find it documented or even mentioned anywhere online. I'm assuming the audio hardware is somehow sensing the impedance of whatever it's connected to, but is that really a reliable indicator of headphones vs. line-level inputs?
- ferongr 11y agoLine-level inputs will be in excess of 1 KOhm (10KOhm if properly designed) Headphones will be up to 600 Ohm (I guess some boutique brands could have examples higher but I digress, the grand majority is between 16 and 250 Ohm).
- sdk77 11y agoIn my opinion as an EE there would be some reasonably reliable ways to detect either a line or headphone connection. Headphone impedances are typically between 16 and 600 Ohms, and line impedance is typically in the 10's of kOhm range. That's one way to differentiate. There has to be an output signal (presumably audio) first, however. Another way is to apply a very small DC current (that would certainly not damage headphones, so I would guess in the micro-ampere range) and check if there is continuity or measure the DC resistance of the load outright. For line inputs, as they're usually AC-coupled, DC resistance would be infinite, and for (DC coupled) headphones it is very low. It's an interesting subject and I wouldn't be surprised if there are some patents involved.
- jeff_marshall 11y agoDetecting AC vs. DC coupling would be obvious to a practicing EE, if presented with the problem, yes? I'm just a software guy with an electronics hobby and I think I could have figured that one out. That said, DC vs. AC coupling detection could probably be granted a patent if nobody had "disclosed" the idea prior to filing of such a patent, based on my experience with software patents. Sorry to vent, but patents on this sort of thing drive me crazy. I don't have any gripe with you or your post.
- ericzawo 11y agoI currently use a Schitt (http://schiit.com/ http://schiit.com/) Modi and Magni stack with my Beyerdynamic DT880 600 ohm headphones. When I tell you that music is a completely different experience at home with these cans, believe it. I'm a DJ and honestly prefer staying in and listening to mixes than going to my mate's parties to hear what they're spinning because they absolutely obliterate any live system (and I've been to some of the best venues in North America.) I know it's a poor comparison of course, but I'm never going back to monitor speakers for personal use again. If you're looking for a decent AMP/DAC combo, I highly recommend Schiit.
- chroma 11y agoNwAvGuy has some not-very-nice things to say about Schiit. Basically, that they don't know how to design audio gear. He discovered that one of their amps could damage your headphones. For this warning, he was banned from the Head-Fi forums: http://nwavguy.blogspot.com/2011/07/banned-at-head-fi.html http://nwavguy.blogspot.com/2011/07/banned-at-head-fi.html
- ericzawo 11y agoWhoa, never spotted this. Thanks for the relay
- sanoli 11y agoNot only banned him, but tried to deny his findings at first.
- cthalupa 11y agoNwAvGuy has his side of the story, Schiit has theirs. http://www.head-fi.org/t/701900/schiit-happened-the-story-of-the-worlds-most-improbable-start-up/765#post_10463052 http://www.head-fi.org/t/701900/schiit-happened-the-story-of... Personally, I'm extremely satisfied with the variety of Schiit gear I own, from my work Modi/Vali setup to my home Ragnarok/Yggdrasil
- chroma 11y ago
- lowmagnet 11y agoI wonder what nwavguy does for a living these days. He disappeared from the Internet in that persona shortly after the release of his designs and dropping some serious allegations at some manufacturers for a transient overvoltage issue. He's a solid engineer and I hope he's just quietly improving the state of audio somewhere.
- tacos 11y agoThis guy is fantastic. Having spent a little time around professional audio, it doesn't surprise me that he did amazing stuff for 18 months (anonymously) then vanished from the web. This piece on his site has lots of interesting insight into the audio industry. It also relates to objective, critical thinking in general. http://nwavguy.blogspot.com/2011/05/subjective-vs-objective-debate.html http://nwavguy.blogspot.com/2011/05/subjective-vs-objective-...
- calinet6 11y agoHe had an interesting mind. Absolutely too objective, in my (subjective) opinion. It was almost as if his entire purpose was to remove the validity of all opinion from the discussion completely, and frankly, it was sad and inhuman—despite his amazing technical contributions.
- chroma 11y agoI think his viewpoint is spot-on. The goal of most audio systems should be to accurately reproduce the original waveform. If you want to add "warmth" or "color" or whatever to the sound, it's better to quantify what that means, then purposefully distort the audio in a dedicated device (or in software). Think about what life would be like if displays were built and reviewed like audio tech. Imagine companies like NuForce and Schiit sold screens that didn't accurately reproduce colors. Owners of these displays would praise them for their "warmth" or talk about how much green colors "pop" or whatever. It would be absurd. We can actually measure contrast ratio, color accuracy, viewing angles, etc. That's how we evaluate displays. People who prefer a different gamma or white point change it in software. They don't buy defective monitors. But switch the topic to audio and people forget all that. It's bizarre.
- ubercow13 11y agoI greatly respect NwAvGuy and agree with almost everything he says, but I think in practical terms that's a slightly over-simplified perspective. Look how inaccurate even these headphones are [1], arguably the best or one of the best ever made. Getting the inaccuracies to be the right inaccuracies is quite subtle and very important in my opinion. See for example this review of his [2] and in particular the paragraph near the end: >AN EQ EXPERIMENT: I tried using highly configurable parametric EQ to tweak my Denon D2000s to be similarly forgiving and I failed. When I filter out equivalent amounts of sibilance and harshness with the Denons, more of the music is gone and the result sounds veiled and artificial. The HD 650, to my ears, somehow works more like polarized sunglasses. They largely remove what I don’t want while revealing more of what’s left. It’s not just a simple frequency response difference. My objective side wants to pin down what’s going on but I don’t have a full explanation besides the HD 650’s lack of distortion. [1] http://www.innerfidelity.com/images/StaxSR009.pdf http://www.innerfidelity.com/images/StaxSR009.pdf [2] http://nwavguy.blogspot.co.uk/2011/06/sennheiser-hd-650.html http://nwavguy.blogspot.co.uk/2011/06/sennheiser-hd-650.html
- jhallenworld 11y agoOn the one hand, any loudspeaker amplifier with feedback is going to have very low output impedance (minimum acceptable damping factor of 20 with an 8 ohm load or .4 ohms max). So for at home, AC powered use just hook your headphones to the speaker outputs. On the other, things do get interesting with low power / battery powered amplifiers, for example where they use a low power OP-amp for headphone drivers. For this case, the article is very relevant. Heh, or get headphones with nearly flat impedance, for example Sony MDR-v600: http://www.cliftonlaboratories.com/headphone_impedance.htm http://www.cliftonlaboratories.com/headphone_impedance.htm
- kazinator 11y agoGood grief, headphones do not need electrical damping. This is relevant to large speakers, and only at around their resonant frequency (as mounted in the cabinet). If you're getting some funny resonance in your headphones, electrical damping isn't going to do anything; it's a mechanical issue.
- basicplus2 11y agoone further point to keep in mind is the rule for the inductive reactance of a device (either an amplifiers output or a speakers input) is stated for 1000Hz which is an old rule for the mid range of audio for the clear hearing of intelligible speech, and of course the most efficient transfer of energy is when the output of an amp matches the input of the device it is driving. To understand a given amp and speaker you also need to know the inductive reactance for the full range of frequencies you want to use.. so amp and speaker maybe matched at the rated impedance is at 1000hz but way off at 15khz