7 ms·
Never short a country with $2 trillion in reserves?
- jhancock 17y agoThis is the most level-headed view I've read on this subject. A worthwhile read.
- siculars 17y agoWow, Michael Pettis melts one particular face in specific and lays out a historical precedent analogous to China's current horde of foreign reserves. Without cribbing his article too much, my main takeaway is the underlying economic imbalances at play in China that have resulted in their accumulation of foreign reserves, particularly 2 trillion US dollars.
- discolemonade 17y agoI remember reading the Friedman piece several weeks ago and thinking to myself, "This guy drank the China kool-aid too." It's part of the whole American declinism notion that pops up every ten years or so and I've never believed it. We were there with Japan in the 80s, The Soviet Union, the EU, and now China (and India too). It's easy to believe China is going to be the next superpower if you look at its growth relative to the U.S over the last decade. But the thing that's always made me skeptical about any country replacing the U.S as the world's lone superpower any time soon isn't our resources. It's our sense of mission and purpose in the world. It's something that nobody else has. Only we have it because it's in our cultural fabric. It's not something you create on purpose. It grows organically out of a hapenstance of historical events. It informs everything else about us. You see it when you travel to other countries and come back. Americaness is optimism and hope. It's a source of our soft power, which is extremely attractive to the rest of the world. It's why everyone wants to be American but nobody secretly wishes they were Chinese or Nigerian or Brazilian. China or Russia or the EU or India don't have that sense of mission and purpose in their psyche. No amount of military hardware or GDP growth can compensate for that.Superpowerdom is unsustainable without it. So China could be a paper tiger.
- alextp 17y agoFriedman is one of the worst sources of opinion I've ever read. The World Is Flat (which is, admitedly, his only substantial work I've read cover to cover) is filled with unwarranted conclusions and groundless generalizations and altogether horrible metaphors. I've learned to just tune out when he's mentioned.
- spot 17y agoyea really. the original story cites him as a middle east expert... who cheered and approved of the invasion of iraq. now that's a record to be proud of. EDIT: i do agree with him though that the US should invest in sustainable energy.
- nitrogen 17y agoI found The World is Flat to be a useful insight into conservative economic thinking. I also interpreted it as an attempt to persuade the conservative political and economic base to take a more global look at their activities using their own language, rather than as an accurate treatise on globalization. In that context, I was able to get past his obeisance to the corporate superpowers of America and his other inaccuracies, and see points that may be valuable. Even though I frequently disagree with their opinions, Friedman and another conservative, George Will, are two of my favorite editorialists. Maybe the fact that I'm neither liberal nor conservative contributes to my enjoyment of their writing.
- deleted 17y ago[deleted]
- enjo 17y agoExcept for China. They actually have a very similar concept of destiny and mission. I think the issues with China are going to be much more practical. They remind me a lot of the Soviet Union. A closed society that is very effective at giving the appearance of prosperity, while under the covers things are very different. They'll be able to keep it up for a decade or two, but over time the whole thing crumbles as the base was never truly well built. Our biggest advantage lies in the risk taking aspects of our culture. We're a people that celebrates the type of risk that leads to true innovation. The cool thing: It's not just the U.S. anymore. Europe has caught on as well. I do think the United States is going to weaken (relatively) in the coming decade. We'll still be a world power, but I think we'll be sharing that with a re-awakened Europe.
- johngalt 17y agoA good counterpoint to the title quote would also be "Never expect a good thing to last forever". At some point growing investments gain a momentum all their own. I.E. everyone invests in China because of their double digit growth; and China has double digit growth because everyone invests in them. The problem with a compounding growth curve is that it gets so steep that it shoots past the place where it should have found equilibrium.
- bilbo0s 17y agoSo Chanos may turn out to be wrong, but not for the reasons Friedman thinks he is. This is probably a reasonable view. Professor Pettis is also correct in asserting that the role of central bank reserves is one of the most misunderstood concepts in economics. In fact, nowadays, almost any economic concept as it relates to governments or sovereign states are routinely misunderstood. Probably because that is precisely the part of the economy that the average person feels they understand so well. For instance, many people worry, rightly by the way, about our USD1.4 Trillion deficit. They feel qualified to comment on its implications authoritatively since we can SORT OF understand the concept. Yet you see no publicly expressed concern at all over the USD500 Trillion house of cards that is the derivatives market. Very few people understand derivatives markets well enough to know the implications of this situation. I think this causes us not to think about it and to hope that someone else will deal with it before the bottom falls out. Now understand that these guys are not average at all. I have attended Pettis' talks and he is definitely not average. But I think the same sort of intellectual dynamic goes on even in their circle.
- mediaman 17y agoOffice vacancy rates in Pudong are over 50%. Many of the signs of excess capacity are readily apparent in China: it is only the massive currency injections, in keeping the currency pegged to the dollar, that have allowed such expansion unjustified by demand. One way or another, China has borrowed from the future and will have to pay for this excess expansion. It could be a crash, or it could be years of stagnation as the nation attempts to use up the excess capacity it has built. This is a good piece written by someone who understands the underlying economics. Chanos has been criticized as just recently beginning to study the Chinese economy, but sometimes being fresh to a subject helps distance an analyst from recent past--which can be a good thing.
- maxklein 17y agoChina is taking all the massive cash it is making now because there is no other really big and cheap factory, and sticking it into infrastructure. Buildings, roads, subways, minority villages - all of that is being built up. Even if you have a crash, a built road is still there and a built office still exists. Pudong is empty because the offices are expensive and it's not really in town - if a crash happens that forces the government to reconsider whom they want to target pudong at, then there will be enough people moving in there when the prices are right. China is not developed, it's developing. It's not borrowing from the future - the U.S is borrowing from the future and giving it to china. China is taking the money and building infrastructure. Property is not expensive in china. There is no excessive inflation or speculation. China has the typical bubble of any rapidly growing economy, but the huge internal market, massive infrastructure development, and large population of highly educated people, and the introduction of chinese businessmen to secondary markets in Africa and South America mean that the fundamentals of the chinese economy are fine. If there is any bubble, it will blow over and growth will continue.
- ohashi 17y agoInfrastructure for infrastructure's sake? If it crashes and forces the government to re-think things, you think this happens instantly? That crash is figuring things out and filling up the excess capacity.
- lucifer 17y agoA country that can draw from a larger pool of "geniuses" can afford channeling that resource into a larger set of activities. Dividing China into 4 will result in a set of nations with a reduced set of talent to distribute in key national industrial and scientific efforts.
- hga 17y agoYes, but how will that help the broad economy? For example, it could help you to increase your level of military technology, but it doesn't provide markets for all those factories who's export markets are drying up. Haven't we learned that central planning doesn't work (for long) for this sort of thing? See Japan, Inc.
- lucifer 17y agoYou've misunderstood [my] post. The article is arguing that China's massive population (and consequently the size of a cream of the crop brainiacs slice) is irrelevant, which made little sense. [edit]
- nazgulnarsil 17y agoThis is because it is about central bank reserves, a topic that to my dismay probably generates more confused and mistaken thinking than any other topic in economics. not understanding the basics of sovereign accounting is understandable. could you make heads or tails of a companies finance if they did all their accounting in their own stock?
- va_coder 17y agoIf one factor - large reserves - leads to economic problems than this guy is dead on. But it doesn't. Economic success or failure is due to many factors. He should have chose to argue with Jim Rogers, who has much more credibility, than Friedman.
- mediaman 17y agoHis argument is that large reserves do not protect from economic problems. This is in response to Friedman's assertion that the Chanos analysis is wrong because despite excess capacity, China can use its currency reserves to stave off recession, which isn't true. In the article he states explicitly that large reserves do not necessarily cause economic problems.
- deleted 17y ago[deleted]
- deleted 17y ago[deleted]
- known 17y agoI hope China will invest more on its Infrastructure & Irrigation projects.