7 ms·
This has been known for a many years and many people who have been searched figured it out. Dogs are a key element in letting them rob people on the side of the
by rdtsc 11y ago
This has been known for a many years and many people who have been searched figured it out. Dogs are a key element in letting them rob people on the side of the road. We hear those K-9 are treated as officers, someone shoots one, and the sentence for that is usually pretty harsh. It takes years and many tens of thousands of dollars to train them. But they are worth their weight in gold. They are the the magic voodoo doll that hacks the 4th Amendment. You say 'no', but, the puppy says 'yes' and there go your rights. It is pretty magic.
What is interesting here is that person who was searched got to present his story to the news and it was published as is.
---
"NewsChannel 5 Investigates asked Ronnie, "You are convinced that they cued that dog to hit?"
"Yes, 100 percent," he said. "There is no doubt they cued that dog."
---
Usually traditional media takes the side of the cops. At best, they would make the cops' version sound just as plausible as that of victim of the robbery (hrm ... I mean, the person who was detained).
So, of course, what makes this story, is the occupation of one of passengers -- he is both a cop and a veteran. That is front and center in the article. It is emphasized mutiple times, even in the HN title. We don't want the audience to forget that and think he is just a regular janitor or plumber here! I believe that says a lot about the beliefs that go around -- that cops are somehow more honest, and noble (and so are the troops). This aspect, is just as interesting to look at as the story itself. In order to stop this behavior, it is important to change that attitude, first, and then it would be possible to talk about fixing the laws that allow this to happen.
- mason55 11y ago> It is emphasized mutiple times, even in the HN title. We don't want the audience to forget that and think he is just a regular janitor or plumber here! I believe that says a lot about the beliefs that go around -- that cops are somehow more honest, and noble (and so are the troops). Interesting thought. My reaction to the headline was "good, as a cop people will listen to him and he's in a better position to help change this." I'm sure plenty of people out there are more likely to believe him and, while I'm not, he could become a useful spark for change. Even if he's lying there are thousands of other people who experience the situation for real.
- rdtsc 11y ago> good, as a cop people will listen to him and he's in a better position to help change this Yeah I had the same thought. Even if we don't rationally think cops are inherently more noble and honest than the average person, we know that the average person believes it. The news station knows that too.
- c22 11y agoWhen I was a much younger fellow I was involved in an incident that should have netted us a whole bunch of trouble. We were out on the beach at a park breaking about every rule in the book: ad-hoc firepit during a burn ban, setting off fireworks, open alcohol where "No alcohol" was clearly posted, underage drinking, etc. A park ranger happened upon us and was none too pleased with our activities. He had us pack up our stuff and follow him back to our illegally parked cars and I was certain a large fine would be our very best outcome. He started lecturing us as he collected each of our IDs but the moment my friend handed him an active military ID the mood instantly changed. He started talking about how nice the nature was and sent us off with a warning. Blew my mind.
- brbsix 11y agoAs a young fellow, my best friend's father was high ranking law enforcement officer. Anytime we encountered any trouble (similar to the sort you mentioned), he'd simply hand the officer his father's card or phone number and off we'd go. You don't even want to hear about the sorts of things wives of law enforcement get away with...
- whafro 11y agoAgreed. We're always more interested when people speak up against "their own" than when criticism comes from outsiders. Football players speaking up about their head injuries? That's a better story than some tenured professor writing from his lab. Employees blowing the whistle on their employer's bad practices, teachers arguing against tenure policies, police calling out police abuse or racism – these are all compelling narratives. Of course, ideally, we'd look to the quality of the argument and the strength of the evidence, but an insider account gives us the mental shortcut to think "this one knows what they're talking about, and they don't have a clear motivation to disparage their own."
- mikestew 11y agoDogs are a key element in letting them rob people on the side of the road. Ya know, after I had written my parallel comment and gave it some thought later, I concluded that it's all just bullshit. The dog didn't alert by sitting, and the officer didn't cue him. They were going to search the car regardless. You say 'no', but, the puppy says 'yes' and there go your rights. It is pretty magic. Here's where I disagree with you (but only in the details). The dog didn't say anything. I mean, I've seen dogs sniff for drugs (and find them). I've watched amateur Noseworks competitors (slightly related to the training sniffing dogs). No dog "alerts" by sitting, at least none I've ever seen. Dogs sit all the time, it would be a stupid cue. That dog could have just stood there and ripped the meanest fart you ever smelled, and the thieves (pardon: cops) would have said that the dog "alerted". "Yup, smells like he found something!" As you point out, the dog is a prop, a talisman. That car was getting searched, full stop. They just needed a "get out of the 4th amendment free" card in the shape of a German Shepherd. They might as well train gerbils for that. They fit in your pocket, cost less to feed, and with a little propaganda we can all be led to believe they work just as well as dogs (and they probably will if you're just looking for false positives). (And to be clear, I'm not saying you can't train a dog to sniff for drugs or bombs. Obviously they can be trained for this, and to a high degree of reliability. They can, however, also be trained to bark, dig, or whine on command, whether they smell drugs or not.)
- rdtsc 11y ago> As you point out, the dog is a prop, a talisman. > Here's where I disagree with you (but only in the details). Oh I agree, the dog saying 'yes' was meant to be the officer using the dog to note on paper that 'dog said yes'. As you said, in case of this group, they didn't have to pretend much at all. I imagine others would actually have a functional, probably somewhat non-obvious alerting signal. But this groups was getting good results without trying much. I think they probably learned their lesson from this -- spend more time training the dog to actually alert and figure out how to make it do it reliably and out of the sight of the camera.
- mark-r 11y agoHow do you reach the conclusion that they've learned any lesson from this? Have the officers been reprimanded in any way? If this couple had any amount of cash on them, it would have been confiscated as "drug money". Good luck getting it back, even in the absence of any evidence. That's why these tactics are tolerated, it's a source of income for the department. Who cares if a few innocent out-of-staters are taken advantage of? The whole situation just makes me sick, and I'm continually surprised that it hasn't been ruled unconstitutional.
- Dr_tldr 11y agoIt is definitely a worrying state of affairs when the only person allowed to dispute police engaging in illegal or unethical behavior is another policeman. The police are the mafia, and the only time they'll be disciplined without overwhelming evidence is when they mistakenly try to shake down another made man. It's not like K-9s are uniquely to blame: the next generation of 4th-amendment violating technologies are already here, just waiting in the wings for judicial approval, or in some cases, to overturn previous rulings. And once they get even the most limited permission, these things (like infrared) will be used by the police as dousing rods to take them wherever they want to go.
- mgleason_3 11y agoHonestly, these laws need to be repealed or found unconstitutional. This is out of control.
- ghayes 11y agoThe latter might take awhile. See Florida v Harris (2013) [0] > Harris ... challenge[d] the dog's reliability, backed by data that asserts that on average, up to 80% of a dog's alerts are wrong. > The Court unanimously held that if a bona fide organization has certified a dog after testing his reliability in a controlled setting, or if the dog has recently and successfully completed a training program that evaluated his proficiency, a court can presume (subject to any conflicting evidence offered) that the dog's alert provides probable cause to search, using a "totality-of-the-circumstances" approach. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Florida_v._Harris https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Florida_v._Harris
- GrinningFool 11y ago> I believe that says a lot about the beliefs that go around -- that cops are somehow more honest, and noble (and so are the troops) I think it implies a certain level of assumed corruption instead. It's unusual (as far as the public is concerned) for enforcement agency A to give any trouble to agency B - 'you scratch my back...' kind of thing.
- rebootthesystem 11y agoI have trained German Shepherd Dogs for Schutzhund competition for years. I have three right now. I can make them do just about anything I want on command. And that does not mean verbal commands. A look, a flick of a finger, gesture, even moving my foot. I am not saying this is what happened here, but I'd be careful to trust a dog unless the training was absolutely 100% verified not to have trained anything that could allow the handler to command the dog to "hit".
- omginternets 11y ago>You say 'no', but, the puppy says 'yes' and there go your rights. It is pretty magic. On a related note, I submit that this is what NSA surveillance is really all about. "The suspect showed a pattern of activity consistent with [terrorism | child pornography | fraud | narco-trafficking]" All the sudden, poof, probable cause. I'll know I'm right the minute I see data from these programs admitted as evidence in court.
- rbanffy 11y ago> activity consistent with [terrorism | child pornography | fraud | narco-trafficking]" Which is probably nothing more than a VPN connection...
- forgotpwtomain 11y agoBecause you wouldn't be using a VPN if you had nothing to hide!
- tajen 11y agoAnd that's right. What US needs here is not only softer laws, it's a whole mindset of flexibility with the law, like we have in more latin or corrupt countries: Tolerance with driving rules, tolerance with income tax workarounds, tolerance with violence on the street. I had a friend in France drop a complaint for fondling of his daughter by a teenager, the cop said the agressor was going to be merely told off in a meeting at the station, nothing more. I'm not saying this is the right middle-ground, but it implies a forgiving law framework.
- mattlutze 11y agoI do hope you're not being serious, here -- your humor is a bit dry. Strong rule of law is one of the defining hallmarks of a just and fair legal system. If a law is causing injustice, you repeal or rewrite it. You don't simply ignore or downplay it when it "feels" right.
- prawn 11y ago"Usually traditional media takes the side of the cops." They did, Ronnie. The other two are pirates.
- mc32 11y agoTraditional media take the side that fits their story. NPR takes the side of the unempowered, even when they might be on the wrong side, other outlets have their own agendas and follow through with that. Usually it's to make their audience feel good or bad about themselves. Confirming biases, etc. If the police are out to get traffickers and the outlet thinks traffickers are bad, guess whose side they'll take. If they side with the victims of floods, famine etc., guess whose side they'll lean towards. You play your audience or risk losing it. It's not like there is only one official news website and you have no choice. You're not Xinhua or Pravda.
- mtbcoder 11y ago> Traditional media take the side that fits their story. NPR takes the side of the unempowered, even when they might be on the wrong side, other outlets have their own agendas and follow through with that. This isn't true and I think you have traditional news media confused with the "info-tainment" world. I can assure you NPR doesn't have a unified agenda that is required to be met or is run by some "cabal" locked away in a secret lair picking sides and passing down marching orders. News media is produced by a wide variety of outlets and sources. Organizations leverage both in-house staff/resources as well as thousands of external sources (AP, Reuters, ITN, et al) for producing content. Not to mention all of the smaller, independent public media stations producing content that NPR picks up. Phrases such as "it's to make their audience feel good or bad about themselves" or "You play your audience or risk losing it" are simply lazy arguments without merit.
- mc32 11y agoAP, Reuters, etc, are news gatherings orgs and are different from the NPRs huffpos, WSJs, etc. NPR, huffpo, WSJ all have their biases and a narrative they want to present for their core audience, otherwise, why would they diverge on how they present the same topic and why do the topics they cover differ? NPR is always the underdog. They also make good use of techniques to put things in whatever perspective they want. Softball questions to sympathizers, leading questions, etc. If you study propaganda, they use pretty much all the techniques. Obviously this is why they and Glenn beck and co sound the same. You don't need a cabal, you need a head of news, producers and journalists who share the same interests. Just make it all line up organizationally.
- gspetr 11y agoAn american friend of mine once told me that when his brother graduated from a police academy they told him: "Now you're in a gang that wins".
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- V-2 11y agoI'm not an American, so it could be that my perception is just different, but for what it's worth, I didn't read it that way - to me it's about the irony of the fact that cops themselves fall victim to this sort of abuse, too.
- Paradigma11 11y agoI think the cop aspect is interesting because: He is a professional commenting on his own profession. If the topic would be sanitation, Joe Plumbers opinion would hold more weight. He is speaking against his own colleagues, which might have negative consequences down the line, and has no apparent personal gain in doing so. So he is more likely to be honest than disgruntled joe plumber.
- bcg1 11y agoHere is a clear example of how it works: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=w-WMn_zHCVo https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=w-WMn_zHCVo
- nickpsecurity 11y agoThere's a lot of speculation in articles and comments despite video evidence available for this sort of thing. Here's a step-by-step video of what they do for anyone interested that also shows them cue the dog: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=w-WMn_zHCVo https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=w-WMn_zHCVo
- Infernal 11y agoI believe that says a lot about the beliefs that go around -- that cops are somehow more honest, and noble (and so are the troops). I can't help but think that the root of this phenomenon is the adversarial nature of policing in the U.S. It's assumed that the police are on one side and the people are on the other, and that the two sides are going to be at odds. And like most adversarial relationships, you assume that most critiques of "the other side" are noise. There's probably some element of "police are honorable", but I think the adversarial setup has more to do with it.