10 ms·
The Promise and Confusion of USB Type-C
- mattikus 11y ago"Just because a device has USB Type-C connectors does not mean it supports power or any other alternate mode, such as support for video standards DisplayPort or MHL (used on some smartphones to drive larger >In fact, technically, it’s even possible to have USB Type-C ports that don’t support USB 3.1, although in reality, that’s highly unlikely to ever occur." This is actually a bigger problem than the author theorizes. Both the Nexus 6p and the Nexus 5x support USB-C on USB 2.0 rather than 3.0 or even 3.1. When USB-C computers become more prevalent, people might be sad to see their fancy device lacking the promised bandwidth they associate with the connector rather than the protocol.
- ossreality 11y agoOr finding out that my Chromebook Pixel 3 has USB Type-C, but not Thunderbolt 3... which means I can't have an eGPU. And with the Razer Blade + Core set to actually make eGPUs a big thing... I'm pretty disappointed. I'll probably end up with a Razer Blade sooner rather than later.
- guan 11y agoI am designing some embedded devices that would only support USB 2.0, and I considered using Type C because it would be more convenient and also more compatible in a future world where most people have type-C cables. So I am wondering why the author thinks type-C ports that don’t support USB 3.1 would be that rare. Edit: The author might have meant the downward facing ports in a computer or hub, and it would be rare to have those type-C ports not support USB 3.1. That would make more sense.
- marshray 11y agoFor the same reason you're using USB 2.0 when you could maybe get by with USB 1.1: in a few years a big majority of the mainstream embedded chips you'll use will support USB 3.1, so you'll effectively get it for free. I say "a few years", but I seem to recall it taking 5 or more for the transition from USB 1.1.
- IshKebab 11y agoEmbedded chips (i.e. microcontrollers) won't support USB 3 for a long time (think 10 years at least). Very very few even support USB 2 High Speed and that was released 15 years ago.
- VLM 11y agoThere's a division forming in embedded where "real embedded" like my dishwasher uses an 8-bit microcontroller to turn pumps and valves on and off in sequence which may never have a USB and for price reasons will never support above USB1. It has very little stored state to talk about, and the more state and sensors the less reliable and productive it'll be, so that's unlikely to change any time soon. The other division of embedded is best described as duct taping a tablet computer permanently to a refrigerator, and those will have USB-C like next year. In the '80s we put TVs and VCRs into the same case and called it innovation... This is the '10s version. One type of embedded is like industrial control, the other type is like product tying. One segment is extremely price conscious because China sells the USA 10 million value engineered dishwashers per year, and using a microcontroller that costs $1 more to do something the market is completely uninterested in is a $10M loss which the market will not tolerate. The other segment is luxury gadgets for rich people where price is no object and sales never exceed the thousands, although the web pages are extremely elaborate and expensively designed.
- bsder 11y agoHigh speed USB 2.0 support is quite rare on cheap chips. Most are still at USB 1.1 speeds. USB 3 connectors? WAY COOL. I'm running USB 1.1 on the inner pairs and Ethernet on the USB 3 pairs for several projects. USB 3 standard? Oh, hell, no. The signal integrity requirements are outrageous. And most embedded chips can't even transmit at the 400+Mbps necessary to saturate even USB 2.0.
- moreati 11y ago> I'm running USB 1.1 on the inner pairs and Ethernet on the USB 3 pairs for several projects That sounds like a nice trick. Could you elaborate, or is there any public information you could link to?
- recursive 11y agoI care more about symmetrical plugs than I do about bandwidth. Hallelujah! My prayers have been answered!
- mattmaroon 11y agoIt's my favorite thing about the nexus 5x. The 3a charger ain't bad either.
- ytdht 11y agoImagine if the connector was round...
- mchahn 11y agoThe new Google Pixel has a type-C on both sides. It is heaven. I can pick the pixel up with my eyes closed and always get it in (please, no jokes). And on my lap the cord can drape out either side. These features may seem like small ones but they make a big difference in everyday convenience.
- NateDad 11y agoI can't remember the last time I plugged my phone into my laptop. Bandwidth for USB-C is way low on my list of reasons to like it on my 6P. #1 for me, personally, is that it's more durable.. my micro USB ports on my phone always started to loosen up, and the cables would stop staying plugged in (yes, even after cleaning out pocket fuzz). My 6P's connection, so far, seems much more robust. But also, more power, 3 amps is pretty sweet, and the reversible connection is very nice to have, if not really a huge deal.
- onion2k 11y agoUSB is still the primary method of backing up your phone for most people, although, admittedly, a lot of people don't bother doing that.
- guelo 11y agoThat's because Google has been actively discouraging the use of the cable for data transfer in order to encourage cloud use. Your phone won't transfer to Mac or Linux at all except via ugly buggy apps you learn about after digging through online forums.
- Animats 11y agoOh? An Android phone plugged into a Ubuntu 14.04 LTS system appears as a USB drive. Android brings up a popup asking if you want to enable USB access (a basic security measure against hostile charging ports) and, if allowed, the phone's storage appears as a folder.
- LeonidasXIV 11y agoAn Android 2.x phone. Android 4.x+ replaced the MSD protocol they spoke with MTP which nobody seems to get right so you have FUSE filesystems like jmtpfs, mtpfs-simple etc to deal with your particular brand of breakage.
- cesarb 11y ago
- jcassell 11y agoThe progression of USB Type-C is simply going to continue to split the web of port connectors as we enter into a season where Thunderbolt 3.0 is already confusing everyday users vs Thunderbolt v.1&2. What we need is a single identifier for a wireless standard, not the continued progression in port and the problem with icon design. USB was supposed to the universal port, but even what the author suggests will be the dawn of a new era of connectivity, what we really should be relishing are new steps in wireless methodology.
- NateDad 11y agoWireless is a pipe dream. You can't power something wirelessly over any reasonable distance with any reasonable power draw... furthermore, the bandwidth capacity needed just keeps increasing such that even wired standards have a hard time keeping up. Ever tried running a 4k monitor over HDMI? Older versions couldn't even do it. So, you need a cable for power, and you need that cable for video, you might as well make it bring over all your data, too.
- yincrash 11y agoIn addition to the sibling, there is only so much wireless bandwidth, and crowding it with several point to point mini wireless networks is a surefire way to get poor user experiences due to interference. Wires can use all the bandwidth with very little interference to other wires.
- w1ntermute 11y ago> The crux of the problem is that not all USB Type-C connectors support all of these different capabilities and, with one important exception, it’s almost impossible for an average person to figure out what a given USB Type-C equipped device supports without doing a good deal of research. A Google engineer has been reviewing USB Type-C cables on Amazon, in order to resolve some of the confusion[0]. His reviews have since been collected in a spreadsheet[1]. 0: http://arstechnica.com/gadgets/2015/11/google-engineer-leaves-scathing-reviews-of-dodgy-usb-type-c-cables-on-amazon/ http://arstechnica.com/gadgets/2015/11/google-engineer-leave... 1: https://www.reddit.com/r/Nexus6P/comments/3robzo/google_spreadsheet_for_usbc_cables_with_benson/ https://www.reddit.com/r/Nexus6P/comments/3robzo/google_spre...
- j_s 11y agoAs seen on Hacker News! https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10508494 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10508494
- jsheard 11y agoBensons reviews aren't really about capabilities. He's warning people against poorly designed A-to-C cables which identify as high-power sources, permitting the USB-C device to draw up to 3A from a USB-A port which is only required to handle 0.5A. It's a sad state of affairs that so many cable manufacturers can't get a simple ID resistor right.
- ethbro 11y agoCan't the owner of the USB copyright mark revoke and sue them for using it in a non-standard implementation? If you don't follow the spec, and nobody punishes you, don't be surprised if more people follow suit...
- mkj 11y agoIt's a trademark too, so if they don't enforce it then they'll lose it? Perhaps enforceability is already lost...
- 11y ago
- jjoonathan 11y agoFirst we had mSATA and M.2 types A, B, C, D, E, F, G, H, I, J, K, L, and M with profiles S1, S2, S3, D1, D2, D3, D4, and D5. Now we have USB Type-C which may-or-may-not support a handful of other standards, speeds, and wattages. What happened? Did the hw/cable vendors take over the standards bodies and "growth hack" in some defensive differentiation?
- manaskarekar 11y agoI haven't gone searching for answers, but purely from speculation, the sturdiness of the USB Type-C ports seems like a regression with comparison to USB 1/2/3 ports. I love how rugged USB ports have felt in the past (that is, before type-C).
- rl3 11y agoI find the opposite. USB Type-C ports seem more sturdy to me than prior USB standards. It's possible that's because my Type-C hardware is newer, and the other hardware I'm comparing it to has years of use. I find that with regular use, connectors and ports naturally loosen up over time. One other possibility might be spec compliance. A lot of the third-party Type-C hardware out there right now isn't fully compliant. If you're shopping for Type-C adapters or cords, definitely only buy stuff that's 100% compliant.
- stordoff 11y agoI can't really comment of the ports, but the connector at least seems like a step up from microUSB connectors for phones etc.. Those have always seem flimsy to me, and I've damaged a couple trying to plug them in backwards. I don't foresee having the issues with Type-C (especially as it is reversible as well).
- notatoad 11y agoHave you used a USB type-c device? They look small, but they have a really strong hold and feel much stronger than any other connector type I've used.
- mrsteveman1 11y agoHow would you compare them to Apple's Lightning connectors in that regard?
- chipsy 11y agoI find the sturdy feeling is mostly derived from the specific devices in question. My "main" laptop has looser ports than my old netbook; when I connect some brands of flash drive, they tilt a little bit out of the port. But with other brands the fit is solid. In all cases we're talking about USB2 devices.
- notthetup 11y agoHow I wish there were some nice diagrams in this article explaining which standards are superset of which and how the different connectors look like.
- crudbug 11y ago+1 for "Virtualization" for physical port insight. What we need now is a logo for each supported protocol on the back of every device or on top of the port (if available) - power / displayport / usb / thunderbolt.
- marshray 11y agoDon't worry, they'll all be there on the back of your game console in raised black on black plastic. If it's not on the back, it will be printed in special low contrast gray paint.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- p1mrx 11y agoEven the standard C-C cables aren't all the same: some are wired for USB 2.0 (with 6 wires) and others for USB 3.1 (with 17 wires). As one might expect, the 3.1 cables are thicker, more expensive, and pretty much impossible to find in lengths greater than 1 meter.
- legulere 11y agoIt's even more confusing: There are 5 different profiles for USB power delivery [1] so you have effectively 10 different types of cables with no marking whatsoever. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/USB#PD https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/USB#PD
- X-Istence 11y agoUSB 3.1 has a huge issue that it pollutes all over the 2.4 Ghz/5Ghz space thereby reducing Wifi/Bluetooth to almost useless. Longer cables exacerbate the issue and make it worse because it now is a nice long antenna.
- CamperBob2 11y agoNot really. Once it's longer than 1/4 wavelength at the frequency in question (about an inch at WiFi frequencies) it doesn't matter how long it is.
- ankurdhama 11y agoIt's not the cable that matters rather what kind of "controllers" on each end of the cable are connected and that causes a lot of confusion as people think of all those features as being "cable" based rather than controllers.
- ksec 11y agoI may get downvoted into oblivion for this, but i do much prefer to pay and use Apple's Lighting Cable with MFi for charging. The amount of absolutely terrible USB cables alongside with disastrous Charger are simply insane. I hope there is a USB-C Certification, or Heck rename it as USB-D or something, that provide guarantees to speed ( USB3.1 ) and Power Delivery etc. Personally I dont see much confusion with the USB -C cable, as long as you use it to plug into the same Logo Shown on both side it should be ok. The Logo being a display of Whether it is using HDMI / Thunderbolt etc.
- ossreality 11y agolol, I don't know how you could have broadcast "I don't know what I'm talking about" more than you just did.
- oxplot 11y ago"Okay, I’ll admit it — it’s not exactly the sexiest topic in tech." I actually find USB-C one of the most "sexiest". As the author himself puts it, it's a "Virtualization" of connectivity ports. But I think it virtualizes "power" delivery too. With a high powered adapter (e.g. 80 watts) and USB PD (Power Delivery) support on both ends, I can use a single adapter with many devices. Wait a while and you'll see adapters with multiple USB-C ports on them each supplying difference voltages to connected devices. The possibilities are mouth watering. I'm currently researching to build a DC-DC converter and I'm thinking of providing a USB-C output with PD support.
- VLM 11y ago"I can" More like "you could". The point of an insanely complex protocol with zillions of shipped variants is to benefit top to bottom silo manufacturers (apple, etc) while destroying the market for non silo manufacturers. USB 1 really could charge off almost any port and almost any port could access almost any flash drive. That is being eliminated other than in silo'd ecosystems. My favorite part of type C is the high voltages, its going to be fun watching Chinese grade cables short and utterly fry and ignite USB connected devices. Much like the fire department inspector gets out of whack about seeing extension cords plugged into extension cords, the inspector of the future is going to condemn office buildings where USB cables are present, of any sort, due to USB-C contamination.
- oxplot 11y agox86 and Unix are insanely complex too and a big part of that complexity has to do with backward compatibility. I've scanned through the specs and I haven't seen any complexity just for the sake of it. Care to point out any specifics? Also note that some of the added complexity is to support new features, such as power provider/consumer switching and power safety. As for the substandard Chinese grade products, they've always done that and will continue to do it. Bulk of existing USB chargers you find have horrible ripples and have power factors that seem to have been engineered to be embarrassingly low.
- philfreo 11y agoWith the new MacBook it seems like Apple is moving towards USB C as the does-everything connector, including for charging. However on the iPhone and other recent mobile devices they seem to really be behind Lightning. Is there some reason why the iPhone and MacBook couldn't or shouldn't use the same?
- kondro 11y agoUltimately Apple controls the Ligtning spec and they can add capabilities to it as they see fit without having to wait on an external body to ratify. This is super-important for them as the iPhone is the core of their business and they need to be able to iterate as they see fit. One of the biggest death-knells for Type-C coming to the iPhone is the connector is bigger than Lightning. Apple continues to move towards thinner, lighter with less ports. There's no way they're going to move to a connector that is bigger than their current one.
- tomp 11y agoUSB-C is too thick to fit in the (thin) iPhone, so Apple must use something else.
- legulere 11y agoThat's a myth. With lightning you additionally need space for pins in the device. With usb type c the pins lie in the inside of the port.
- darkmighty 11y ago"Eventually, most of these connections will likely become wireless." I have my doubts. It takes a lot of effort to enable 10GB/s wireless transmission. The spectrum is physically constrained by bandwidth, noise and interference, and it becomes evident in wireless. While a fairly cheap piece of ethernet cable and router will enable several Gbit/s (up to 400 Gbit/s soon, that's simple impossible in the 2.4Ghz band due to spectrum and current interference situation. So you need to use a less overcrowded, shorter range band with multiple physical antennas of large size, and you get beautiful monstrosities such as this: http://www.amazon.com/dp/B016EWKQAQ http://www.amazon.com/dp/B016EWKQAQ And the only way up from there (about 10Gbit/s) imo, is to move to other frequencies entirely, and lose many aspects that make wireless convenient, like wall penetration and long range. So I think wireless isn't a very elegant solution for high bandwidth. What would be ideal I think is that every outlet would have a Type-C port that you could plug your device and get both power and high speed internet. Keep WiFi and other wireless technologies low power and low bandwidth (actually improving the interference situation), like browsing, reading remote sensors and controlling appliances -- for things/situations that are meant to be remote, wireless. Note: this was already addressed in some comments here... I'll leave this for my own reference :)
- PhasmaFelis 11y ago> http://www.amazon.com/dp/B016EWKQAQ http://www.amazon.com/dp/B016EWKQAQ Hell with wifi, I just want one of those to hang on my wall as a sci-fi art piece.
- nakedrobot2 11y agoLi-Fi can be extremely high bandwidth. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Li-Fi https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Li-Fi "It is so far measured to be about 100 times faster than some Wi-Fi implementations, reaching speeds of 224 gigabits per second." I know that in practice, my colleague has tried it, and yes, in practice, it can work.
- orik 11y agoOnly works with line of sight though, not useful or practical when in most line sight situations you could just run a cable anyways, and not have to worry about potential interference.
- marcosscriven 11y agoI recall being utterly astonished to read[0] that the USB C cable that comes with the latest MacBook only supports USB 2 speeds! "You can also use the USB-C Charge Cable to transfer data at USB 2.0 speeds between your MacBook and another USB-C device." [0] https://support.apple.com/en-gb/HT204360 https://support.apple.com/en-gb/HT204360
- legulere 11y ago> Also, full-bandwidth Thunderbolt 3 cables can be expensive, because they require active electronics inside them. So far all thunderbolt cables needed active electronics. Now you can use cheap full-featured usb-c cables for thunderbolt (at reduced speed). > it’s even possible to have USB Type-C ports that don’t support USB 3.1, although in reality, that’s highly unlikely to ever occur. The cited macbook doesn't support 10Gbit/s
- TazeTSchnitzel 11y agoSpeed is an issue too. The 2015 MacBook has USB-C with 3.0 speeds (which is considered USB 3.1 gen 1 or something, it's not the new high speed mode 3.1 adds, see: http://arstechnica.com/gadgets/2015/08/what-the-usb-if-is-doing-to-clear-up-confusion-about-all-these-usb-specs/ http://arstechnica.com/gadgets/2015/08/what-the-usb-if-is-do...)
- mrkoot 11y agoIn March 2015, Karsten Nohl is quoted wrt type C in the context of BadUSB: '"The additional openness and flexibility of USB Type-C comes with more attack surface," says Karsten Nohl, one of the researchers who first discovered BadUSB. "No solution for BadUSB is in sight even with this new standard."' (source: http://www.theverge.com/2015/3/16/8226193/new-apple-macbook-usb-type-c-security-risk-badusb http://www.theverge.com/2015/3/16/8226193/new-apple-macbook-... ) Any new developments or new information available on that, other than, say, iOS prompting the user on 'Trust This Computer'?
- throwaway7767 11y agoI'm certainly not excited about the idea of all the random USB devices I plug into my machine having a PCIe lane with DMA capabilities available to it. Random vendor-provided USB mass storage sticks being able to read all the system memory? What could possibly go wrong? In theory, IOMMU can mitigate these risks. In practice, barely any OS actually enables those protections, and AFAIK the CPU manufacturers (at least Intel) are still using availability of IOMMU as a differentiating factor for high-end CPUs.
- paulmd 11y agoOK, so if I have this straight: * USB Type-C is the physical connector, and in practice usually implies USB 3.1 gen-2 support * USB 3.1 gen-2 is a signalling specification which depending on the device will support some combination of USB 3.0 data transfer, advanced power/charging capability, video signals, and PCIe lanes * USB 3.1 gen 1 is just USB 3.0 * However, Type-C devices can fall back to USB 2.0/1.1 speeds if they don't support super-/hi-speed transfer, or if the cable is not wired with the extra pins for 3.0. Allowing Type-C cables to be sold with only the 6 wires for 2.0 instead of the 17 wires for 3.1, in particular, is a real head-scratcher. Also, renaming 3.0 to 3.1 Gen 1 is a bonehead move since they're totally different. One is a data transfer standard while the other is a Thunderbolt-style multi-stream connector. In practice that makes the "USB 3.1" designation entirely meaningless.