8 ms·
I was just complaining to my wife about this earlier this morning (we are in the US). I made a credit card payment last Thursday (1/14) in the mid morning, may
by pc86 11y ago
I was just complaining to my wife about this earlier this morning (we are in the US).
I made a credit card payment last Thursday (1/14) in the mid morning, maybe 9:45 AM. Ideally this should happen pretty quickly, but I know in the US the infrastructure just doesn't match my current expectations. Seemingly there was zero movement until my credit account was credited the payment Friday afternoon, but the money was still in my checking account (no holds or pending transactions).
The weekend goes by, no movement. Monday (a bank holiday) comes and goes, as does Tuesday. I get a text message early this morning (~6:45 AM) that there was a large withdrawal from my checking account - the payment showed up! Nearly three full business days before the money was actually moved, and as of right now it's still a pending transaction.
The cynic in my wants to think that it's so people who don't pay attention to their finances are more likely to overdraw/double-spend the money, but part of me thinks it's just because the US infrastructure around banking and payments is so old it just isn't capable of anything approaching real time transactions. I would love to see a logistical/technical explanation of why it takes so long for this type of thing in the US.
- jrcii 11y agoI've asked bankers at the branch about this before and received a vague answer about how they need time to verify things, but I strongly suspect they were just non-technical and didn't know.
- pc86 11y agoIs part of the problem inertia? What I mean is if there are multiple pending transactions on an account, is it even possible from a technical perspective to say "Is there $100 available in this account for immediate withdrawal?" I would suspect it is possible, but I also wouldn't expect the majority of US banking infrastructure to run on AS400s.
- icebraining 11y agoIsn't that the available balance? At least here in Portugal, we have three balances: accounting (based on all non-pending transactions), authorized (accounting plus all pending transactions) and available (like authorized, but just with the pending debits). The latter is the amount actually "yours", which you can use without paying interest on.
- pc86 11y agoYes but particularly for restaurants where us Americans will tip 99% of the time, the "pending" amount is often different from the finalized amount. You won't usually see that until the item actually posts, which could be several days.
- ChuckMcM 11y agoI don't know how current it is but back in the 90's when I was dealing with technical issues with payments at UBS (UBS was a big Sun purchaser) one of their bankers described bank transfers as a giant exercise in "liability hot potato". Which is to say that at each step of the way the person receiving the funds was trying to avoid becoming liable for them until they were really certain they had them in an account somewhere, and people sending funds wanted to be absolutely sure the destination had accepted liability for the funds before they were willing to release them. Because when it went wrong, they ended up liable for funds they no longer had. And he suggested that there were people that tried to make that true (basically stealing from the system) and that it happened enough to be priced into the transaction fees. The amount of money that was flowing on a daily business through the bank was staggering.
- jrcii 11y agoGiven the crowd on HN I'm surprised there isn't at least one person chiming in that works on these backend bank systems.
- tolle 11y agoA wild guess would be that roughly 90% of all systems handling this are written in COBOL running on z/OS or IBM i. And that most of the developers are currently close to 60, spending their free time with their grandchildren and not on Hacker News. I'm not much help either since I work with mortgages, and having it all explained during a lunch break might be a bit much. There are also, depending on company and country, rules and laws about what you can talk about.
- zhte415 11y agoThere are still a lot of developers for these systems. Updates happen constantly and developers are constantly in need and training-up. For example, credit card legal and security compliance updates happen a lot with really strict deadlines that have to be adhered to, or else the credit card issuer gets into hot water. Some organisations choose to merge old features that differ by country get merged in a central trunk with flagable switches. The code bases are very active. My company (not going to say the name here) employ 500+ mainframe engineers, some working on new projects and codebases because mainframe is the preferred platform. If you or anyone else would like to get in contact regarding COBOL or Mainframe in general, especially getting work done, especially in finance, please find my email in my profile.
- PeterisP 11y agoThe "need to verify" is not a technical need and can't be solved with technical means - it's all about counterparty risk, it is a business need to verify so that you're not vulnerable to all kinds of exploits and fluctuations. It is trivial to have the payment messages happen in near-real time. However, to actually make a final credit in the receiving account and allow the end user free access to withdraw that money, you need one of three things: 1) the receiving institution simply trusts that they'll receive the money and releases the money as soon as they can - which is not realistic due to counterparty risk, fraud/revocation risk, etc and can happen only either if the whole payment happens in a single central system/institution (e.g. something like paypal) or the system includes very high fees to cover those risks. 2) each sending institution has a large binding collateral and there are appropriate safeguards that in the case of someone "going bad" the receivers are going to get paid anyway - which requires a strong central system to manage it, and the institutions deffering a lot of power and money to it (in this context, a million doesn't come close to a lot of money). This is the system described in the original article - the payment gets credited/finished first, and covered/settled between the banks afterwards. 3) in the absence of strong guarantees or blind trust, everyone in a payment chain pays the money forward only after they have been actually paid to cover the payment, adding days and days to the processing time. This is the current US system and also how general arbitrary international payments can be settled - particularly in international payments, you can get the full payment data nearly immediately, but you generally wouldn't receive the funds until every institution involved has covered their risks.
- pbhjpbhj 11y ago>It is trivial to have the payment messages happen in near-real time. [...] receiving institution simply trusts that they'll receive the money and releases the money as soon as they can // Surely the message is "the money", it's not like a truck pulls up at the bank each night with the transaction balance for the day? I don't see how there's a risk if there's a transactional process: for example Bank A sends request for money from B (eg to fulfill a payment by debit card); B reserves the money and sends a verified payment (crypto signed and what-have-you); A processes the payment and increments the relevant account with reserved funds and sends a receipt to B; B processes the receipt completes the decrease on the relevant account using the previously reserved fund and acknowledges the receipt; A receives the acknowledgement and verifies the funds as available in the account. So, if B doesn't have funds to reserve then the payment can't be processed and A won't acknowledge any receipts claiming the transfer of monies. "A" thus won't increase a balance for any accounts. Where's the risk?
- apaprocki 11y agoIn the US, ACH is moving towards same-day clearing in two batch windows. This is supposedly rolling out starting in Sep 2016. https://www.nacha.org/rules/same-day-ach-moving-payments-faster https://www.nacha.org/rules/same-day-ach-moving-payments-fas...
- pjg 11y agoYes, but in 2016 it'll be same-day ACH Credit only. That doesn't solve the problem. The ACH delay is on the Debit side (2 working days ) which will not be same-day until 2017 and the banks are not mandated to update balances same day until 2018. So same day ACH will not be effective till mid 2018
- prplhaz4 11y agoPer the linked article, effective Sept 23, 2016: >> Virtually all types of ACH payments, including both credits and debits, will be eligible for same-day processing. Only international transactions (IATs) and high-value transactions above $25,000 will not be eligible. Eligible transactions account for approximately 99 percent of current ACH Network volume. Also of note, same-day is not real-time...it is disappointing that we are not pursuing real-time transactions.
- BallinBige 11y agoa large problem and reason why ACH's are so slow, revolve around the lack of real time fund validation. it doesnt exist. Returns (NSF's) create a huge issue and lag in the entire process
- patio11 11y agoWhich credit card company? The fastest possible resolution for your fact pattern would have been "money withdrawn on Friday" unless one or both of your banks decided to covertly extend you credit. This is because ACH pulls are an overnight batch process in the US. Given that it took a few days, it's possible that your credit card company is using an intermediary to process ACH payments (there could be a variety of reasons for this) and, as a cost-savings measure, either the CC told the intermediary "We'll take your cheaper 3 business days option in preference to next day" or the intermediary told your bank "We'll take your cheaper 3 business days option in preference to next day." The cynic in you should probably not worry overmuch about why a bank is willing to grant you free float. It's pretty pedestrian: back office optimizations, yay.
- pc86 11y agoChase card, M&T Bank. I did know that ACH stuff is a daily batch, but I hadn't thought about an intermediary between the card and bank, that's a good point. And even without it, I would imagine that even an entity the size of Chase probably gets a discount on 3-day v. next-day.
- Spooky23 11y agoI think Chase has problems in this area. AMEX seems to clear payments overnight for me. Chase will take days.
- p4wnc6 11y ago> The fastest possible resolution for your fact pattern would have been "money withdrawn on Friday" unless one or both of your banks decided to covertly extend you credit. This is because ACH pulls are an overnight batch process in the US. I don't think this is true. There is the NACHA same-day ACH initiative [0] which is opt-in and at least some institutions have already opted-in. I've experienced frequent same-day resolution of ACH transactions when using bank services from two very large US banks (one based on the west coast, one based in the east coast) and also a small employer credit union. It's true that my experience is not common and it often does take longer than a day. Many banks still do use overnight ACH. But I don't agree with the statement that overnight is "the fastest possible resolution" -- some banks have opted-in to doing faster and have already begun doing so. [0] https://www.nacha.org/content/same-day-ach https://www.nacha.org/content/same-day-ach
- pbreit 11y agoMost likely your "available balance" was reduced and everything worked fine.
- arca_vorago 11y ago"The cynic in my wants to think that it's so people who don't pay attention to their finances are more likely to overdraw/double-spend the money" The cynic in you is right. There have been numerous lawsuits that have won against banks for structuring the movement of money so that it is the most likely to incur overdraft fees, which are a $1 billion money maker just for the top three... Bankers are more the enemy of the people than terrorists.
- onetwotree 11y agoIt's possible to "game" this a bit to squeeze an extra $50 or so out of an empty account. Of course, it's a losing proposition given the overdraft fees, but I managed to get a few desperately needed bottles of booze this way back when I was struggling with alcoholism.
- arafa 11y agoIn addition to the time needed for ACH, some or most of the lag may be due to fraud/money laundering concerns, even if it's low-risk. If that's true then it's a regulatory issue.
- amenghra 11y agoFlavors of fast (https://www.fisglobal.com/-/media/FISGlobal/Files/Report/Flavours_Of_Fast.pdf https://www.fisglobal.com/-/media/FISGlobal/Files/Report/Fla...) is a fun read.
- ytdht 11y agoI was thinking that they added this delay so that they could profit from everyones money for a few days, continuously.
- jslampe 11y agoThis used to be a big thing, but since Check 21 and truncation that amount of money banks made has been severely marginalized. The big reason stems for risk. The 2-3 allows the receiving FI to mitigate, IIRC, around 70% of the risk associated with the most popular types of rejects. (e.g. insufficient funds)
- otakucode 11y agoI worked at a data center for a bank from 1997-2001. Processing ACH transactions for our data center involved a 1970s-era NCR mainframe, a decade-old MS-DOS PC (they tried to upgrade it once, but the expansion card that handled the encryption wouldn't work with a faster system and a new card cost upwards of $10k), 9-track vacuum-fed tape drives, manually dialing a phone and then switching it over to a 9600 baud modem, and running batch-processing jobs which took greatly varying amounts of time to run. I did not handle the sending of ACH data back to the ACH system, only receiving it and processing it. I worked from 4PM "until it was done". Most nights this meant around 9:30PM. However, in situations like you described, where there is a bank holiday on a Monday, things would always take longer (higher volume of transactions, nothing was done on weekends so everything just accumulated). In situations where it was the end of a month AND a bank holiday on a Monday? Holy crap. I wouldn't get out of there until 4AM usually in those situations. There was a great deal of hand-holding and operator intervention during the processing. The systems used were older than many of the people working on them. When software updates needed to be made, companies had to locate retired software engineers that originally made the systems and pay them astronomical amounts to either perform the modifications or consult on such modifications. When hardware broke down, like our high-speed dot matrix printer that printed on that green-bar paper with holes on each side, they had to pay specialized repair techs $400+/hr (starting from when they got in their car in a city 1.5hr away) to come out to troubleshoot. Then they had to track down replacement parts. When you work with a bank, if something still functions, or the cost of repairing or updating it costs less than purchasing and transitioning to a new system, it does not get replaced. Systems ossify and live pretty much forever. The mainframe we used was literally the only one of its kind still in operation in the entire country (we found this out when the other people who used one, a restaurant, decommissioned theirs and gave it to us for free if we would hail it away... we finally got a disaster recovery solution that way).
- mavhc 11y agoI get why they don't want to migrate, but wouldn't it be sensible to create a new bank, with new systems, and gradually move people over? All new accounts go to the new system, and over 20 years or more it's migrated.