7 ms·
Never consider a travel planning startup
- corybrown 11y ago"The problem is a better product is not necessarily a good business" Hear, hear. This gets lost oftentimes when you hear the whole "build something people want" mantra.
- michaelbuckbee 11y agoAgreed, along those same lines: A business that requires you to execute at a scale you can't to be successful is a bad business. Which is what I think when I hear $2B in Priceline advertising per year, etc.
- ThrustVectoring 11y agoYup. It'd be trivially easy to make a better dating app than what's available - all the incentive issues for guys to spam girls go away if you have each side rank the other for who they'd like to meet, then pair everyone up with their highest ranked person that can't find a better match. Dating is a classic matching market, and there's excellent mechanism design for making good matching markets. Unfortunately, good mechanism design is one of the least important factors for whether or not a dating app succeeds - what is important is whether or not you can convince people to use it.
- superuser2 11y agoThrustVectoring is referring to the Gale-Shapley algorithm, also used to match medical residents to hospitals and in a few other places. One of the more interesting days of Algorithms class.
- marincounty 11y agoI've played around with dating apps, but never found one that was even close to being useful. Finding someone you want to be around is such a complicated thing. Speaking as a dude, what these dating apps all get wrong is I don't want someone like myself. Yea, I verbalized I want this quality, and this, but in the end; I really don't know what I want. People change. People are not their profile. The long term relationships, I had, were with people who were my exact opposites. People I thought I would have nothing in common with. When I walk into a room, I just know who I'm drawn to. It has nothing to do with looks. It's just feeling I get. I don't think an app will ever replace this evolutionary mechanism. Plus, some people just photograph horridly. I'm a Photographer, and there's people who photograph well, and there's people that don't. If I'm doing a free photo shoot, and the model is only going to pay for sent head shots. I always ask for a candid picture of the future client before I shoot them. Before I waste a day shooting them, I want to see if they have a chance in hell of getting a job in the future. (I make money off the sent head shots. Free studio time, but they don't get the negatives/RAW files.) Some beautiful people in person--just photograph horridly.
- tacon 11y ago>The long term relationships, I had, were with people who were my exact opposites. People I thought I would have nothing in common with. You are an outlier as far as research on attraction. Studies show that people are attracted to very similar people on all dimensions, except for the opposite sex. Maybe there needs to be "The Opposite" dating app: George Costanza Does The Opposite https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cKUvKE3bQlY https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cKUvKE3bQlY
- nathan_f77 11y ago> I don't think an app will ever replace this evolutionary mechanism. I don't know, we could probably get pretty close with machine learning and enough data.
- ThrustVectoring 11y agoThe point isn't to put a huge amount of investment into finding someone - that's dating's job. The point is to quickly and efficiently schedule things that have a better chance of going well. There's an additional knock-on effect from being able to treat the dates lightly: if you're not a good match, you've lost something like ten minutes of scheduling and a half hour of date prep.
- tarci 11y agoI just inherited $10 billion and am now considering a travel planning startup.
- imtringued 11y agoFirst step to a million dollar business: start with a billion dollars.
- ghaff 11y agoThere's a lot of good detail in the article, but I have to believe that the fundamental problem is an implicit one--namely that most people effectively tolerate commission fees baked into booking prices but they're not willing to explicitly pay for travel services. Even back when people still widely used travel agents, personalized advice for complicated trips was effectively subsidized by all the people booking cruises and simple air travel.
- wooyi 11y ago@garrytan said it as well in 2012: Travel planning software: The most common bad startup idea http://blog.garrytan.com/travel-planning-software-the-most-common-bad http://blog.garrytan.com/travel-planning-software-the-most-c...
- rwhitman 11y agoTravel is the white whale of tech startups. It's very alluring to tech entrepreneurs since it's: A) Sexy - the idea of running a travel startup sounds exciting. It feels like an opportunity to periodically escape from the humdrum life of staring at a computer screen in the office all day, while still doing what you're best at. B) A broken business - travel booking, planning etc is very confusing and flawed in many ways C) A "big pie" to take a bite out of - it's a multi billion dollar market, so there must be opportunity in there somewhere. The problem is, every tech entrepreneur has these same thoughts, and everyone has tried to execute on them at one point or another. It's a ridiculously competitive market, and for the most part the big $$$ for revenue are locked up by monolithic travel booking networks, that are only willing to relinquish a teeny tiny piece of the travel $$ pie to newcomers. Then drop in this hard truth - recreational travel isn't actually all that commonplace amongst average people. The average joe goes on one or two major vacations in their entire life. So if you want to make money, you need to cater to either travelers with a lot of disposable income (the wealthy or retired), or business travel. Those niches are already very crowded but dominated by big, established, aggressive players, that you and every other dreamy-eyed tech entrepreneur eventually have to compete with for attention. It's a long, nearly impossible battle to wage for anyone who hasn't spent their life in the industry. Winning in that space is a war of attrition competing with businesses with decades in the travel field, all in hopes of this grand and naive vision of striking it rich while on permanent vacation. Unwinnable. The white whale.
- JoeAltmaier 11y agoTravel, and dating sites. Everybody, just stop already.
- ewams 11y agoYou can share your photos from your travel with your new date on our new app. We are changing the world!
- strictnein 11y agoTripr: Swipe right if you want to go on a trip with this person. Do I get showered with VC money now, or is there something else I need to do?
- notahacker 11y agoWant to build a profitable travel planning startup? Hire a competent (and preferably multilingual) salesperson to approach regional tourist boards. After securing your first contract, develop your travel planning app as white label product and sell to other regional tourist boards. There are plenty of them, and they spend a lot of marketing dollars, usually subsidised by the regional government. You won't be a "unicorn", but you also won't be battling deep-pocketed giants over paid search or juggling hundreds of distribution relationships. (Your clients will, but it's their raison d'etre and they're not expected to turn a profit)
- zippergz 11y agoAs someone who travels for leisure quite a bit, I never fully trust commission-driven booking sites to show me the full selection, the real quality ranking, etc. I can't really imagine ever using a single site and trusting that I'm getting the best options (as one well-known example, Southwest flights not showing up in searches on third-party booking sites). When I am spending thousands of dollars on a trip, I need to know that I'm seeing the full picture before I make my decisions. I invariably end up searching for options across several sites, manually checking directly with specific airlines and hotel groups I know, reading reviews from across the web, etc. Once I've done all of that legwork to find the absolute best flights and hotels for my needs, why would I go back to some aggregator site to book? I'll just book directly. This of course takes me a LOT of time, and if there were a way to reduce the time consumed, I'd do it. But only if it got me the exact same result, and I can't see how a commission-based travel planning site could effectively replicate that process.
- wbeckler 11y agoI felt the same way as you and I built a site that aggregates accommodations, including absolutely everything, not just companies paying commmissions. We have couchsurfing, Airbnb, all the main hotel sites, Groupon, Hotwire, and most other sites you might ever bother checking. It's called http://AllTheRooms.com http://AllTheRooms.com.
- williamstein 11y agoNice!
- geverett 11y ago+1 for alltherooms.com being a good service, it's my go-to for accommodation booking. Seriously, being able compare even couchsurfing options is a godsend.
- joslin01 11y agoAlternatively, wait for Airbnb API to open up[1] and then make a travel planning website that rides the back of Airbnb. In general, you shouldn't create start-ups in markets with high barriers of entry. However, the fun part of start-ups is learning how to cleverly bypass barriers while building up your own. If one website was the website to plan an Airbnb vacation, it would have its own barrier that would grow with Airbnb. This would leverage a popular strategy of growing out of a larger, more successful host. [1] - http://all-about-airbnb.com/post/127856658166/airbnb-public-api-coming-soon http://all-about-airbnb.com/post/127856658166/airbnb-public-...
- Marazan 11y agoAnd when AirBnB close their Api that is your business sunk. Basing your business off of one other person's Api is a hugely risky gamble.
- tim333 11y agoI guess the lesson is don't try to do something where loads of people are doing the same stuff if you're not differentiated. That said a year or so I ran into some guys doing a travel planning startup and they seem to be doing ok - Triphobo. Raised $3m. They are a little different I think. Not that I've surveyed the space. http://yourstory.com/2015/03/triphobo-raises-3-million-funding/ http://yourstory.com/2015/03/triphobo-raises-3-million-fundi...
- tim333 11y ago"user generated travel itineraries" I think they are the only (or leading) startup doing that.
- AndrewKemendo 11y agoAnd no, free user acquisition schemes like SEO do not work in 2015 at scale in established markets. This is the big takeaway from this article for me. In fact I think this whole article is great if you are trying to build a new way to do something in an established market. We aren't in the travel space, but we are in the retail home goods space, which is arguably even more established. It follows the same pattern: 1-2 times a year someone needs something and it's a fairly large purchase. We learned early on that the most important thing is getting in with manufacturers and having them promote us. A white-label/tech-vendor strategy works if your product is indeed relevant within the incumbents’ offering, hard-to-build, reasonably easy to integrate and doesn’t step on too many toes. Man that hits home
- tomcam 11y agoAlso, I have found that destinations punish you for not booking on their site. Want to cancel that hotel reservation less than 24 hours before you were supposed to check in? Sorry, we "don't have enough information" because you booked with an aggregator site. Free checked in luggage? That's only if you book with us.
- zippergz 11y agoIn the relatively early days of Expedia, I had a major travel headache because the airline and Expedia were pointing fingers at each other, each saying I needed to deal with the other one to fix the problem (which was not of my doing in the first place - the airline changed the schedule, making my connection impossible). In addition to the reasons I described in my first comment (not trusting that I am seeing all of the options), this is the other thing that puts me off of booking through third-parties. The benefits of booking through someone other than the direct provider need to be huge before I will consider it, and they never are with these travel planning sites.
- SwellJoe 11y agoSomething about travel is deadly alluring to some category of entrepreneur. I once went to a party in Silicon Valley, where I met multiple people working on "it's sort of like WikiPedia for travel" (this was a few years ago, when "wiki for X" seemed like a reasonable business idea and occasionally even got funding and actually launched something). And, I said, "Oh, I think I just met your co-founder a few minutes ago." and, they replied, "No, my co-founder isn't here", or "no, I don't have any co-founders". Multiple people, multiple conversations. None of them knew the others or had any awareness that they were competing with, seemingly, thousands of people who had the same brilliant idea. By my calculations, something like 10% of all the people at that party were working on a fucking travel wiki. That's kind of a microcosm of Silicon Valley, in general, but yeah...travel seems like a weird black hole for entrepreneurs.
- exelius 11y ago> travel seems like a weird black hole for entrepreneurs. Not that weird at all actually -- it's an easy to understand business with an overly-complex buy flow they think they can fix. It's the kind of problem that many entrepreneurs are likely to have run into themselves and said "Well I can do this better".
- tim333 11y agoThere are lots of successful companies in the space too. Must be >20 large ones. Skyscanner just became I think the first Scottish unicorn a week ago and I'm sure there will be more. Just a lot of competition.
- bigchewy 11y agoone of my favorite Warren Buffet quotes: "When a management with a reputation for brilliance tackles a business with a reputation for bad economics, it is the reputation of the business that remains intact."
- maxlamb 11y agoLove this quote, it pretty much predicted the on-going situation with Marissa Mayer and Yahoo.
- nathan_f77 11y agoNo but for real, where is the travel planning service that actually does all of these things laid out in the article? I've been wanting this for years, and all I'm reading is about how I should never build it. And there seems to be quite a few stories where some startup tried to build a trip planning site, and they pretty much succeeded, but they got acquired and shut down! That's so frustrating. > The Priceline Group spends over $2 billion per year on Google Ads alone. WOW, that's unbelievable. > even when one of them sends a link to some vacation rental he’s found on Airbnb that’s not available on your app. I thought this hypothetical app was supposed to be amazing in every way, and it doesn't even support AirBnb
- Marazan 11y agoThere is zero brand loyalty to the middle men in the travel industry. Only the providers get brand loyalty.
- TillE 11y agoI've seen no middlemen that deserve brand loyalty, just a bunch of half-decent search sites with crappy service. Beyond basic price comparison of flights and hotels, I don't see anybody providing value.
- busterarm 11y agoHow is CruiseSheet doing?
- morgante 11y agoFortunately for entrepreneurs, this idea seems to be catching on. Unfortunately for consumers, it seems that the user experience is stuck in 2007. I still can't find a good app which allows me to plan a full trip at once, especially when I haven't entirely decided where I want to go yet. As someone who travels about once a month, I'd love to see something better than Kayak.
- geverett 11y agoIf you haven't decided exactly where and when you want to travel, Hitlist (hitlistapp.com) makes it easier to compare options across variable dates/destinations.
- rajacombinator 11y agoSilly article. Life is hard - why try anything? Just because this guy's idea didn't work doesn't mean there isn't a killer app for this.
- J-dawg 11y agoPaul Graham's essay on plausible, but ultimately bad startup ideas comes to mind [1]. "The danger of an idea like this is that when you run it by your friends with pets, they don't say "I would never use this." They say "Yeah, maybe I could see using something like that." Even when the startup launches, it will sound plausible to a lot of people. They don't want to use it themselves, at least not right now, but they could imagine other people wanting it. Sum that reaction across the entire population, and you have zero users." [1]http://paulgraham.com/startupideas.html http://paulgraham.com/startupideas.html
- hackuser 11y agoI don't know that it would scale up well, but I wouldn't mind travel booking as a personal service: * Planning the trip: Someone who has expertise in all the sites, options, services, loyalty programs, hidden-city fares, likely delays, smaller nearby airports, fare-tracking, best seats on the plane, best hotels, etc.; who learns my preferences; and who then books everything for me, with absolutely minimal time and effort on my part. I don't want to look through all the sites and gather the options; it seems like a waste that so many people spend so much time gaining a little expertise in the nightmare of travel booking. * During the trip: Monitor their customer's trips for delays, cancellations, etc., find out before everyone else (i.e., while seats on the next plane still are available) and respond appropriately (find alternative flights, rebook, reschedule ground transportation, obtain refunds, etc., or simply update me). I just want a text message telling me the new plan, or if absolutely necessary, a couple of options. * At the destination, some concierge service: I need dinner delivered, food waiting in my hotel fridge, a tennis game Wednesday morning, a doctor, another shirt, a bar showing the game back home, etc. It's time consuming to do all that in an unknown town and time is more constrained due to the usually crowded schedule of a traveller. Every time I have to deal with this stuff, I think about how someone who developed expertise in it would be much more efficient. Just getting to know the resources well would be a big advantage. As for tech: An app that displays and syncs your current itinerary (including delays, etc.) with the vendor, and with a prominent 'Talk to me!' button that opens an immediate video chat: A friendly, helpful face in a crowded, strange airport, amid cranky flight attendants, during a frustrating trip would make customers very happy. They might pay for that alone.