5 ms·
Yet poverty as a whole is decreasing according to numerous measures. Plus their report contradicts the world bank observations: http://ourworldindata.org/Visu
by ekianjo 11y ago
Yet poverty as a whole is decreasing according to numerous measures.
Plus their report contradicts the world bank observations:
http://ourworldindata.org/VisualHistoryOf/Poverty.html#/Global-Income-Distribution-2011 http://ourworldindata.org/VisualHistoryOf/Poverty.html#/Glob...
Which is not surprising since Oxfam has a clear political agenda.
EDIT: world bank poverty report, clearly showing the decreasing poverty rates globally: http://www.worldbank.org/content/dam/Worldbank/gmr/gmr2014/GMR_2014_Full_Report.pdf http://www.worldbank.org/content/dam/Worldbank/gmr/gmr2014/G...
- TazeTSchnitzel 11y ago"Absolute" poverty, yes.
- iofj 11y agoWhen it comes to food on the table, or material wealth in general, that's the only kind that matters.
- ximeng 11y agoNot quite sure the point of your comment. This article says nothing about whether poverty as a whole is decreasing? The report you link to agrees with what they say is a problem (e.g. "In high-income countries, the rising concern about shared prosperity is a reaction to income inequality that has reached levels unprecedented in the post-war period.") There is no contradiction between the top 1% getting richer and more global equality within the remaining 99%. Oxfam no doubt have a political agenda, we could probably debate how clear it is and what exactly it is, but their political agenda doesn't particularly influence whether this article is correct, nor do your links seem to contradict it.
- ekianjo 11y ago> This article says nothing about whether poverty as a whole is decreasing? They are saying the inequalities are growing, whereas the world bank report says the inequalities in income are shrinking progressively. That's a very different view.
- ximeng 11y agoI've skimmed the report you linked to, and I really don't see the contradiction. E.g. look at the quote below, taken from several on inequality: "The second WBG goal of boosting shared prosperity is new and opportune. It shifts the focus in evaluating economic development from average income growth to income growth of the bottom 40 percent. Indicators proxying the socioeconomic status of the bottom 40 percent of the population, have shown little improvement, even though the growth of incomes of the bottom 40 percent of the population has not been slower than that of the general population in many countries. This growing inequality in basic living standards is worrisome". I don't see anything that contradicts the Oxfam report, while there are some comments that seem broadly in line with it. Overall, the broad thrust of both seem in roughly the same direction, although they do take different views. Again the inequalities in income shrinking progressively shown in the interactive presentation is between countries. It looks at incomes below 100k USD, which is not particularly relevant to a debate on the top global 1%. I'm sure there's a debate to be had on how much inequality restricts growth. Perhaps it's not correct when Oxfam says that reducing inequality could improve the overall size of the pie. But I see little in your links to contradict that at first glance. Maybe you could point out more specific grounds for your views?
- rorykoehler 11y agoInequalities are shrinking not because everyone is getting richer but because the middle class is being hollowed out. People who used to be middle income earners are now low income earners making them more in line with the working class who were always low income earners. #progress
- adventured 11y agoAt least in the US more people have moved up out of the middle class and into the upper tiers, than have moved down and out of it. That is true over 15, 30, 45 year spans. Progress indeed. The middle class is getting richer more than they're getting poorer. http://i.imgur.com/APbN9Th.png http://i.imgur.com/APbN9Th.png
- gozur88 11y ago>Yet poverty as a whole is decreasing according to numerous measures. Yep. You lift people out of poverty through growth, something capitalists are very good at.
- rorykoehler 11y agoThe world is about to enter a deflationary period. Perhaps capitalists are not the geniuses you make them out to be and just got lucky. Correlation != causation etc etc
- sbardle 11y agoContrary to popular belief, there can be economic growth during periods of deflation, as demonstrated by the economist Gary Shilling. Paul Buchheit gave a presentation in London which understood capitalism as a technology. I think that is the right way to regard it. Unfortunately, over the last 30 years Western society has turned capitalism into an ideology, something to be worshipped and bowed down to.
- gozur88 11y agoHow do you know the world is about to enter a deflationary period? With that kind of inside knowledge you can get quite rich.
- rorykoehler 11y agoThe central banks are turning off the money taps, growth is pretty stagnant across all major economies (bar the US and UK). Wealth inequality is rising while automation is arriving with a bang putting people out of their jobs and at an increasing rate and also putting downward pressure on prices as manufacturing costs fall, meaning the masses won't be spending much. China was a major driver of global economic growth but is undergoing a huge correction, Brazil has been in a recession since last year, Russia is suffering under sanctions, the Eurozone is becoming Japan mark 2, the price of oil is dropping like never before affecting the Middle East's ability to grow (notwithstanding the war currently ravaging the area). This all points to a period deflation. Only people with money can make money with economic foresights.
- msellout 11y agoThe World Bank also has a political agenda. Are you not worried about the accuracy of their reports, too?