3 ms·
Years ago, I used to work as a labourer on building sites, before getting a 'proper' job as a programmer. When I physically worked hard all day, I ate a ton of
by marcus_holmes 11y ago
Years ago, I used to work as a labourer on building sites, before getting a 'proper' job as a programmer.
When I physically worked hard all day, I ate a ton of crap. Burger King for lunch, a loaf of bread a day, hardly any veggies but massive amounts of cheap carbs and meat. I was technically overweight, because I put on so much muscle and I'm not a tall guy. Obviously I did no gym-type exercise. No-one, looking at my diet, body-mass, or lifestyle data would think I was fit, but I was all muscle and in the best shape I've ever been.
The older guys I worked with could lift more than me, for longer, with less visible effort. You'd never look at them and think they were fit, and they ate like pigs too. Again, if you looked at their data they'd be a huge diabetes risk. But they were fitter in their 40's than I was in my 20's, and I was pretty fit back then.
Now, 20 years later, after spending most of those 20 years sitting on my arse pushing little buttons, I'm going to the gym and eating well (diabetes is an effective motivator!). Look at my data now and I'm a bit overweight, but with a good diet and exercise regime.
But compare me with my good diet and exercise regime to those older guys who spent their working lives doing physical labour and eating like crap, and I'm a weak, blubbery mess.
Either the "fitness" they're measuring isn't what we understand to mean by the word "fitness", or they're not measuring actual fitness.
- weeksie 11y agoKeep in mind that a lifetime of manual labor often leads to chronic injuries and pain. How many of those old timers had back problems? I grew up working on fishing boats in Alaska, I know the drill pretty well. I don't have a vise-like grip anymore, but I also don't have tendonitis. Not to say that manual labor won't get you fit, just that if you have the opportunity to sit at a desk and go to the gym and eat a proper diet, it's not really comparable to that kind of fitness (and it's generally far healthier for you).
- jqm 11y ago"but I also don't have tendonitis" How about carpal tunnels? :)
- weeksie 11y agoGood point! Though I am quite good at resting my hands and haven't developed RSI over the last fifteen years or so. I would still place a heavy bet that workplace injuries are more common amongst labor-heavy jobs ;)
- nostrebored 11y agoThe conflation of fitness and strength is common and completely useless. Like the other commenter mentioned, how many have permanent injuries? How many have guts as their activity stalls? Also I think most people looking at your lifestyle data would assume you were reasonably muscular and thin. You work out for nearly a third of every day. I do agree that how they've quantified fitness is absurd. Having lived in Atlanta, it's a horribly unfit city riddled with obesity. Having a park near your house doesn't mean anything if you don't use it, and buying vegetables means nothing if you're using half a bottle of dressing to eat them.
- marcus_holmes 11y agoyeah, but how many fitness freaks have shin splints or herniated disks, or whatever that horrifying thing that happens occasionally to Crossfit junkies is called... It wasn't just strength; these guys could work hard all day, every day, with less visible effort. If that's not what people mean when they say fitness then (to quote) "I don't think that that word means what you think it means" - there's definitely a confusion happening here. I don't know how you would quantify fitness on this kind of scale with this kind of data. It's an interesting problem. But I guess my point is that I would certainly factor for people who do hard physical graft all day, and if they eat tons of cheap carbs and have a high bmi doesn't mean they're fat or unfit.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]