8 ms·
New book argues we can’t expect new tech to rekindle rapid economic growth
- _fizz_buzz_ 11y agoI am not too convinced. In my opinion the most impressive growth of any industry happened right after Gordon's "special century": the semiconductor industry.
- lkrubner 11y agoRemember that a country can have an incredibly dynamic and innovative industry that is growing at a fast pace, yet that country can still be in economic decline. See here for details: http://www.smashcompany.com/business/if-the-usa-is-the-most-innovative-nation-on-earth-then-how-can-it-have-a-period-of-economic-decline http://www.smashcompany.com/business/if-the-usa-is-the-most-...
- Apocryphon 11y agoJust look at Japan.
- x5n1 11y agoDid they actually think that growth would happen forever, that it was infinite. Time to switch to non-growth economic models and assume that the markets have reached equilibrium.
- jerf 11y agoIf there are limits to growth, we aren't necessarily near them. Growth isn't all about mining more atoms out of the Earth, it's also about information and more sophisticated arrangements of those same atoms. If it were just atoms, "growth" would have slowed down a while ago. I see no evidence that markets have attained equilibrium. At the very least, the entire planet would need to be raised to a middle-class lifestyle first.
- noir_lord 11y ago> At the very least, the entire planet would need to be raised to a middle-class lifestyle first. Solar system I think, lifting 10 billion people (UN Estimate for 2050) to a middle class lifestyle will probably require more resources than we can find on Earth alone. Energy, metals even hydrocarbons (though we probably need to burn less of those but most fertalisers/plastics require them) are all out there for the taking.
- jerf 11y agoYeah, I was tempted to put that disclaimer of sorts in... people tend to assume "middle-class lifestyle" must be a linear projection of the American middle-class lifestyle. But, virtually by definition, the first "middle-class lifestyle" is the most primitive one. It doesn't mean everyone on the planet needs a hydrocarbon-based car that spews leaded fumes into the air, a 3000-square foot bespoke-constructed house on .5 acres in the suburbs, etc. etc. It just means everyone is going to want a middle-class lifestyle; if that means a bit more density, renting self-driving electric cars instead of owning (since we're still talking decades here), living in more pre-fabbed houses (or other structures) made out of more sustainable materials hooked to Nest-like climate control for efficiency, etc. etc., that's fine. A lot of things have been shrinking and getting more efficient lately. The world of 2050 will want 2050 middle-class lifestyles, not 1960s middle-class lifestyles.
- danharaj 11y agoA suburban lawn is such an egregious use of land. The middle class of the 1950s was grotesque and arrogant.
- smithkl42 11y agoThis is a pretty egregious example of what has been called "chronological snobbery". I won't deny that the 1950's had their problems. But to assume that they were distinctively more "grotesque and arrogant" than today is kinda silly. You want grotesque? Look at the modern hookup scene enabled by Tinder and its ilk. You want arrogant? Look at the comment above.
- marincounty 11y agoI'm with you. I don't see much growth. It's time to batten the hatches. I'm not a Rebublican, but we have too many laws, and regulations. It's stifling in business, and on a personal level. Every day, I think, "What law, or potential fine will I possibly get today. Ever business decision is made with the legality of the move front and center. I don't like living like this. It's like they castrated me. I never thought America would turn into this.
- cmurf 11y agoThe Death of Common Sense, Philip K Howard (1994). So not exactly the newest idea, by HN standards anyway.
- branchless 11y agoWe badly need to define growth. In the UK and the US growth is defined as an increase in GDP which itself is linked to increasing the money supply. Most new money is issued via mortgage lending and yet house prices are not accounted for fully in inflation. Therefore the GDP deflator is too small. And voila - house prices up, not a damn thing built or done and you have growth. Growth should reflect increasing living standards, not growth in economic rent extraction.
- vezzy-fnord 11y agoNot at all a new observation. The Cambridge Keynesians of the post-WWII era deliberated various models of growth, income distribution and business cycles that had the curious property of assuming that the rate of growth is actually countervailed by the expansion of the capital stock. They assumed that modern capital goods were more fixed than variable, durable but also factor-specific and mostly inconvertible, hence a growing capital stock would actually lock you into path dependence and a higher rate of depreciation. The more you grow, the more you regress. The Kaldor-Kalecki nonlinear dynamic business cycle model, the Kaleckian profit equation and Robinson's growth model are probably the most interesting results out of that era that still retain an influence on heterodox thinkers. That said, one should be very wary of all such simplifying models since they all carry contestable assumptions. Nonetheless, they do pose intellectual curiosities. I don't know if Robert J. Gordon explores this. The Post's review mostly rehashes the more naive dystopian arguments, so I'll have to check.
- jmsdnns 11y agoI wish more folks would read Carlota Perez. We've had 5 tech revolutions since, and including, the Industrial Revolution. It'll probably be another 10-15 before something as significant as a computer kicks off the next one. Until then, there isn't reason to think a tectonic shift will easily happen. Steamships and canals were a powerful revolution, opening up huge parts of the country to international trade, captured well by how the Erie Canal opened the midwest up to the Atlantic. Rail was another powerful revolution, allowing people to be in New York City and Chicago on the same day. Upon being in both cities on the same day, people observed that the cities didn't have their clocks set the same way, as that was never possible before. Instead of a new human transportation revolution, the information age gave us a way for ideas to travel rapidly. At the speed of light in some cases. This is certainly profound, but consider how HUGE an idea this is. If we look at the start of the information age as 1971 when Intel opened its doors, then we're already 45 years into this one. A lot has been done. There's still more left, but it's probably about upgrading the rest of the planet instead of finding whatever US industries are left to be upgraded. If I were to speculate, I might say the next revolution that could change society in a comparably profound way would be self-driving cars and other forms of automation. Perhaps around 2025-2030 society will be cool with cars driving themselves and many, many businesses will be started to explore the automation space. To compare, there were over 1800 car companies in the US between 1896 and 1930, but today there are 2 US car companies. Another comparison, there were once 500 US steel companies, but today there's basically 2. So perhaps 2030 starts with self-driving cars moving the same speed as human-driven cars and maybe by 2080 they go 300mph instead, which would upgrade humanity's transportation capabilities in a similar manner to when rail upgraded steamships or when cars upgraded rail. This would open up huge amounts of land that is otherwise inconvenient and could give rise to new housing technologies, as new houses would surely be built on this newly accessible land. We are 45 years into the information age. It's completely reasonable that it's not blowing our mind asunder the way it did 10, 20, 30 years ago. I am VERY excited for whatever comes next.
- jmsdnns 11y agoThis is the Perez book I mentioned: http://www.amazon.com/Technological-Revolutions-Financial-Capital-Dynamics/dp/1843763311 http://www.amazon.com/Technological-Revolutions-Financial-Ca... If you follow Marc Andreeson, Chris Dixon, Fred Wilson, etc, you'll see they are all very fond of her work too.
- npalli 11y agoThe book author, Robert Gordon has been on this "economic growth is over" Jihad since forever. I found a 1988(!!) paper where he is complaining that productivity has been slowing down for 20 years (in 1988), that despite the vast investments in computer technologies nothing is showing up in productivity statistics etc. etc. For an advanced economy like the US, economic growth boils down to productivity growth. Well, how did he fare since then. Pretty sure no one is going to say we stagnated between 1988 and 2015. It is clear that there was a huge burst of productivity in the period 1995-2005 when people figured out how to use computers to improve productivity. Curiously, Bob Gordon became silent in this period. But then it slowed down after 2005 and now Bob Gordon is back with his theories about "productivity is over" and growth is finished etc. The new twist is that he claims today's technologies are not as important to productivity as the early 20th century were. Well, the 1988 paper has comments by William Nordhus who shows that in the period from 1900 to 1917 productivity growth was zero and it was very low between 1924 to 1937. For the whole period the productivity growth came in a burst from 1917-1924 and then 1937 to about 1948. The reason is productivity is based on combining technologies in novel ways and it doesn't proceed in a regular 3% manner like population growth or investment. It is likely "bursty" and non-uniform. I fully expect to see another explosion of productivity (and thus economic growth) as mobile/cloud/AI/ML start infiltrating the general economic system. [1] http://www.brookings.edu/~/media/Projects/BPEA/1988-2/1988b_bpea_baily_gordon_nordhaus_romer.PDF http://www.brookings.edu/~/media/Projects/BPEA/1988-2/1988b_...
- wnevets 11y agoComments like this are why I come to hacker news. The "journalist" at Washington post made no effort to bring this up in his piece for Gordon's new book.
- dtornabene 11y agoVery much so. Had a similar reaction to the "Aliens!!!1!!" megastructure articles of the last few days, "need to duck over to hn and see what someone not selling ad space has to say about that"
- brianclements 11y ago
- fsloth 11y agoI have this itch that the true productivity maximization by smartphones will be in the future if/when more companies start operating in a more decentralized manner. -Most tools we still have for enabling productivity are such crap - trying to emulate paper document based workflow, instead of offering a task oriented one. - AI:s can probably observe employee patterns and raise red flags if someone seems to be goofing off. Less need to spend time in reporting, more time for value creation.
- eli_gottlieb 11y ago>- AI:s can probably observe employee patterns and raise red flags if someone seems to be goofing off. Less need to spend time in reporting, more time for value creation. So, hold on, let me get this straight. As artificial intelligence advances, the really productive application for it is going to be haranguing people into working harder? What in the world!?
- hueving 11y agoThat's a depressing thought. The AI revolution replaces management instead of the workers. :(
- ashark 11y agoLow-paid shift workers are already living in that hell. Life-hostile "optimized" software-based shift scheduling, transaction timers, and so on. AI techniques will only make this worse and probably expand the pool of people subjected to it.
- jernfrost 11y agoFor a lot of the big things we don't have a lot of progress today. Diggers, cars, railroad etc can't improve substantially. I think in the short term we won't get a lot of economic growth. But I think these things happen in phases. We are waiting for the next big breakthroughs. I think Artificial Intelligence, 3D printers, robotics and cheap sustainable power will be the key things to create a new potential for high growth. E.g. if we perfect the technology to 3D print large structures that should bring down costs for house construction a lot. Companies are starting to do this now. But we are in very early stages. AI and more advance robotics will allow us to automate so many tasks we are stuck with using humans now which really limits productivity growth. It is very hard to increase output from a doctor, teacher, lawyer, cab driver, cooks etc at the same rate as say a car factory. This sort of development doesn't go in a gradual phase. As we develop AI we are not gradually making medical diagnosis cheaper or driving cheaper. The huge cost reductions will come when these technologies are completed and can start replacing people at massive scale. Once cars, trucks etc can be driven by and AI, transportation costs will get huge cost reductions. Likewise with medical science. If an AI can diagnose you, one can save enormous amounts of money.
- marshray 11y ago> The book author, Robert Gordon has been on this "economic growth is over" Jihad since forever. Let's not start saying everyone who maintains a position you don't like over a long term is "on a Jihad". > I found a 1988(!!) paper where he is complaining that productivity has been slowing down for 20 years (in 1988) Which is consistent with the claim that 1870-1970 was a special century for technology-driven productivity gains.
- AnimalMuppet 11y agoAnd the growth stopped in 1970? The PC revolution didn't cause growth? Yeah, I'm not buying it. Take Google, for instance. I can now get at the world's information, for free. This only shows up as Google's ad revenues in the GDP statistics, but it's worth far more than that in terms of utility to everyone else. The real value doesn't show up in the statistics because Google is capturing so little of the actual value that they create.
- marshray 11y agoNote that I didn't say growth stopped in 1970, only that the author's position was consistent. While I personally work in a field (cloud services) that is totally driven by PC and internet productivity, I would probably look at the world a lot differently had I grown up with family and a career in the manufacturing sector post WWII.
- dozzie 11y agoConsistent despite the circumstances proving him wrong again and again. Holding up to one's position is only a virtue up to a point, after which it becomes stupidity.
- banku_brougham 11y ago" The competition for scarce funds will intensify..." That's a bold misreading of the macro environment. Competition for funds expresses itself in higher rates, not lower. If the author's "competition for funds" intensifies further I think we may be in danger of being crushed under piles of money.