9 ms·
The complications of nutrition science
- themagician 11y agoI just wish people would stop acting like food was "designed" for us.
- stephengillie 11y agoWe designed a lot of food for ourselves, from grapefruit to cabbage to bananas.
- danieltillett 11y agoActually it is more the other way around. The last 6-8000 years or so we have been genetically adapting to our historically poor diet. The average peasant has been eating nothing much more than a very limited range of grains and most of us have become pretty well adapted to this diet. This is one of the ironies of the palo diet craze.
- Almaviva 11y ago8000 years is basically an eye blink, for evolution and natural selection to select a whole population (through death and differences in reproduction) with those who are thoroughly well adapted. Yes, humans might be better off for it than we were 8000 years ago, but that's necessarily not saying much.
- danieltillett 11y ago3000 years is more than enough in humans. The lactase persistence mutation in Europeans basically went from 0% of the population to near 100% in Northern Europeans in 3000 years. This was totally due to a change in diet when adults started drinking animal milk. Evolution speed is proportional to the population size as the rate of new genes appearing is directly proportional to the number of individuals while the speed a gene spreads through the population is proportional to the log10 of the population size. If you increase the population 1000 fold then you get 1000 times the rate of evolution. Because the human population has grown so much since the invention of agriculture the rate of human evolution over the last 10,000 years is more than than the preceding million years.
- Almaviva 11y agoThere's a difference between some evolution and being totally ideally adapted. Even lactase persistence hasn't spread though the whole human population. Heck, we haven't even totally adapted to walking on two legs yet. (Side note, you don't need to say log10, all logs are proportional to each other by definition.)
- danieltillett 11y agoThe lactase gene has not spread through the human population as only a small percentage of the human population drinks milk as an adult. The human population is full of genes that have only partly spread through the population - it is actually a huge problem when studying human genetics since as a species we violate most of the assumptions of population genetics. Humans are actually very well adapted to walking on two legs, what we are not well adapted to is the birthing problems caused by the massive increase in brain size and the rotation of the pelvis required to accomodate walking upright. Yes I know all logs are proportional, but I thought I should be precise or else someone would ask which log ;)
- qwtel 11y agoVia negativa: Avoid what is most likely bad (food processed by industry, sodas, excess sugar, excess salt, trans fat and food blogs). Beyond that there isn't too much you can do.
- noondip 11y agoSo avoid all animal products, then? Trans fat are found in all of them.
- lnufnu 11y agoNaturally occurring trans fats (vaccenic acid and conjugated linoleic acid) occur in trace amounts in animal products. They also have been shown to possibly be beneficial for LDL and triglycerides, while hydrogenated oil is harmful.
- noondip 11y agoSource for that? The top result for me was the following review. > Published data suggest that all fatty acids with a double bond in the trans configuration [produced either by industrial hydrogenation or by biohydrogenation in the rumens of cows and sheep] raise the ratio of plasma LDL to HDL cholesterol. https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/20209147 https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/20209147
- DrScump 11y agoSource for that? Um, here's one that you already knew about from the referenced prior thread: Effects of Ruminant trans Fatty Acids on Cardiovascular Disease and Cancer: A Comprehensive Review of Epidemiological, Clinical, and Mechanistic Studies (Adv Nutr July 2011 Adv Nutr vol. 2: 332-354, 2011
- noondip 11y agoHave you got any studies not funded by the dairy industry to share?
- shockzzz 11y agoInteresting choice of slugname: nutrition-science-complicated
- dang 11y agoWe used that (more or less) for the title above, since the article title is linkbaity.
- throwaway999888 11y ago> Why (almost) everything you know about food is wrong They tell me every other year.
- sinamdar 11y agoPG referenced/tweeted a quote by someone "Eat food, not too much, mostly plants". That sums things up pretty well.
- sandmansandine 11y agoThat would be Michael Pollan[0] [0] http://www.amazon.com/In-Defense-Food-Eaters-Manifesto/dp/0143114964 http://www.amazon.com/In-Defense-Food-Eaters-Manifesto/dp/01...
- Gibbon1 11y agoThe tl'dr: Eat actual food.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- stevebmark 11y agoThis was fully covered in "In Defense of Food" - good intro read for nutrition. Read that, not Vox, which is rife with strange opinions, like "overeating" being the cause of modern disease? You damn nutritional science then come up with your own solution to everyone's problem, not based in evidence? Neat. It's oversimplifying to say the only studies nutritional science can use are observational ones. There are plenty of high quality, controlled studies on specific aspects of nutrition. We learn from those. That's also not to say that observational studies are all bad. They can be useful for determining when things don't work and aligning controlled evidence. The fact that nutrition is a hard problem doesn't mean it's not a real science. TL;DR Learn who you can trust on nutrition (Vox is not a good start)
- jjoonathan 11y agoIsn't "In Defense of Food" the one that tries to alter the definition of "food" until it no longer encompasses many of the unhealthy things we eat? (EDIT: yes, yes it is.) I originally dismissed it without a second thought because I associate that sort of puerile silliness with... well, things other than science. But now you're saying it gives a solid overview of nutrition science and I can't help but wonder. > Vox is not a good start Yeah, but why is "In Defense of Food" a good start? The author is a professor of journalism and the wiki page links to an opinion piece by a professor of nutrition titled "'In Defense of Food' is short on science," which is precisely what I'd expect from a professor of journalism and from someone who tries to redefine what food means. Which puts me back in square 1 of not knowing where to start.
- stevebmark 11y agoIt's a good start because it's an unbiased, well researched book that's not alarmist / linkbait like "Why (almost) everything you know about food is wrong."
- joe_the_user 11y agoWhy is it strange to think that over-eating is could be considered problem? One might better phrase it as "today, many humans have the ability to consume as much as they wish of many kinds of foods, a situation somewhat unique to evolutionary history and many problems seem to stem from this". I think a fair portion of nutrition experts think this. I don't know if it's a majority but as the article mentions, consensus is hard to find and just about any opinion is hard to support. And you seem to recommend something closer to the cranky fringe as an alternative to a decent article whose main message seems to be "very little is uncontroversial"
- deegles 11y agoThere is a really low bar for human nutrition in the short term. Depending on body fat, a person can go many weeks without eating anything, so a juice "cleanse" will seem to work, low-carb will seem to work, high-carb low-fat will seem to work too, vegan, paleo, etc. Nutritional deficiencies might not develop for years!
- MCRed 11y agoLow carb for 8 months, so I think I'm beyond the short term measure. My bloodwork is better now than before. I can't imagine what nutrition I'm being deficient in, and the things that are potential issues I already take supplements (and since there's not a lot of risk in vitamins I take more than I probably need and for more types of vitamins than I need.) Of course this is anecdote and it gets to the key problem the article is addressing-- there's no controlled group of statistically significant size who are all eating the same diet for decades. When I hit my target weight I'll go into a maintenance mode anyway hat will include more carbs. I've done this twice- once when I was moving and once over christmas where I didn't want to be on the diet and increased carbs. I was able to keep my weight relatively flat. But there are studies where people do this diet-- not just the scores of anecdotes on reddit/r/keto- but actual studies. And of course self reporting is not ideal, but I saw a meta study of a variety of diets that seemed to indicate the more low carb/high fat you went the more effective you were (there is a spectrum- keto, zero-carb, atkins, protien power, pescatarian diets, etc.) The practical thing is, this diet not only caused me to lose weight ,but totally changed my relationship with food-- I'm not longer hungry. I eat as much as I want so long as I keep carbs under 20 a day (and really I usually hit less than 10 known carbs, often zero known carbs, but carbs slip in to all kinds of things, like cheese which should be no carbs has some, etc.) Sometimes I forget to eat meals. When I go off the diet and eat carbs, I find myself hungry soon after eating. This change in my relationship with food and no longer being hungry indicates to me that part of the cause of my previous over eating is the carbs causing hunger. This points to it not being me starving myself, but an orientation towards food, or types of food. Which I think is hormonal. Since many people report similar effects, and it is reproducible, there's room for real science there.
- 11y ago
- MCRed 11y agoThe only proof I have is an anecdote but it is consistent with my research-- and I've lost 100 pounds in 8 months as a result. The biggest problem is we have rejected science from food to begin with. We have government spending billions pushing a diet designed to create obesity (which is very high in carbs, effectively sugar, and low in fat.) Likely there are at least two types of people biochemically- those who are insulin sensitive and those who are insulin resistant. The insulin sensitive tend to not be fat and if they are fat its because they are really over eating. These people are the ones who end up thinking that fat people are lazy, or who think that "You should just eat less sugar" (not realizing that carbs are effectively sugar) or "calories in < calories out". The insulin resistant people tend to be the fat ones. And for them a diet low in carbs is effective. I've seen a lot of studies and this is consistent in all of them. Personally, I finally found out about the effect insulin plays on the creation and storage of energy in fat cells. Government has been pushing a high carb diet for decades and as at the same time we have an obesity epidemic. Instead of recognizing the problem (correlation is not causation but you can't claim they have caused obesity to go down) they are going to war against fats. Transfats being banned is junk science (I eat a lot of them and my blood work is great, and getting better, not worse) and their use in the food system is because of government going to war on "Saturated" fats in the first place. The war on Fat is the cause of obesity, in my opinion, because it is political, and not scientific, and ignores the insulin sensitivity issue. ===================================================== I'm slow banned because this site is not tolerant of diversity, so I can't reply to Max below. (And so I'm off to do something fun. Caio!) Here's the reply I tried to give him: ====================================================== Fish oil is trans fats. I'm taking trans fats supplements! I think the larger issue is that people are looking at things way too simplistically ("trans fats bad because more of them means problem x") and not controlling for other things-- eg: there's a huge difference between eating a pure meat and vegetable diet (And consequently a lot of fat) and eating a lot of fats in the presence of a lot of carbs. Those anti-trans fats studies did not control for carbs (as far as I can tell). This is why the blood work of people on keto disproves the "trans fats bad" hypothesis. And also "trans fats" are a government propaganda boogeyman-- how many people take fish oil supplements and also oppose trans fats, do you think? I can't do two experiments on myself at once. Since things are going in the right direction now, I want to enhance my weight loss.
- jernfrost 11y agoLearning about diets and food is also terribly difficult because the internet and books are so full of people who are so dead certain about their pseudo science. There is so much emotion attached to food that getting an objective rational opinion on anything food related is next to impossible. Personally I like the Soylent creators take on it. He seems extremely focused on figuring out the objective truths and ignore all the wishy washy emotional bullshit. And also with so many eating exclusively the soylent mixture which is easy to control what goes into, they got an excellent opportunity to study many hypothesis about food. E.g. how important is it to eat "live fresh food" vs just getting the micro nutrients in the right mix.
- MCRed 11y agoThere are diet specific versions of soylent, now: https://www.thebairs.net/product-category/ketochow/ https://www.thebairs.net/product-category/ketochow/ here is the recipe: https://diy.soylent.com/recipes/keto-chow-104-master-rich-chocolate https://diy.soylent.com/recipes/keto-chow-104-master-rich-ch... Its true that its hard not to sound like an evangelist when you've lost weight-- but it's not pseudo science when there are studies that support the hypothesis (of course a lot of diets are fad diets and are pseudo science). The thing is its hard to tell the pseudo science from the real science. Personally, in my experiment, I'm going to try adding Keto Chow to my diet over the next couple of months and see how I feel about it.
- axlprose 11y agoYou know the dogma is bad when even an innocent comment like this gets downvoted. While I think the term 'pseudoscience' gets thrown around way too loosely these days, it's no secret that the science surrounding nutrition is a convoluted mess, with various peer reviewed studies showing seemingly conflicting results.
- skybrian 11y agoIt would be pretty interesting to do A/B testing starting out with a group of people who regularly drink a lot of Soylent. I haven't heard of anyone doing that sort of testing, though. The experimentation that the Soylent folks are doing themselves looks like the fairly uncontrolled do-it-yourself kind, not like a real scientific study. It seems like it would be difficult to do properly because the formula of Soylent changes quite often.
- Tycho 11y agoThree thoughts 1. As Taleb has often argued, you dont need to fully understand a problem, all the interaction effects etc., in order to understand that nature has already solved it. Eat what your ancestors ate. 2. Could it be that the people who go into food science are basically rejects from more respected disciplines? 3. People seem to widely hold beliefs about diet which are patently illogical. For instance everyone seems to talk about how people put on weight because their metabolism slows down, or because it was slow to start with. This doesn't make sense. Rate of conversion of food into energy has nothing to do with eating more than your activity level required. Could someone explain this to me?
- oilywater 11y agoOur ancestors at one point in time had a diet consisting 60-80% of animal flesh. Do you think that this is what nature solved? I mean, technology has given us a way to rise above the evolution. We do not have claws, or teeth that could pierce an elephant, lion, gazelle. It doesn't seem that nature solved anything. Or us, drinking cows milk? Did nature solve the digestion of human to consume milk of another mammal? Was this a thing in past. I do not think so.
- Tycho 11y agoNature, over time, destroys what is fragile. If your ancestors have been drinking milk for millennia, then it is probably safe for your body. In similar dosages. Eat what has been field tested by nature, not the latest voodoo food.
- danblick 11y agoThis article seems to suggest science is hopeless when we can't conduct randomized controlled trials. I don't think that's fair: the methods used in econometrics for learning from quasi-experiments (e.g. natural experiments, regression discontinuity) seem like they would be perfectly good for studying nutrition too.
- lnufnu 11y agoI really have respect for the work of Weston A. Price. Although his work seems to be discounted and too fringe for a lot of people, I have learned a lot through his Foundation about nutrition as well as practices like culturing foods, soaking grains, making broth. He was a dentist who started looking into the relationship between diet and teeth in the early 1900s. He decided to do a series of ethnographic nutrition studies in villages in Switzerland, Gaelic communities in the Outer Hebrides, Eskimos and Indians of North America, Melanesian and Polynesian South Sea Islanders, African tribes, Australian Aborigines, New Zealand Maori and the Indians of South America during the 1930s and find out what common denominators they had in their diets that contributed to their great teeth and good health. He published these in his book, Nutrition and Physical Degeneration. I'm not exactly sure why his studies are neglected, but I agree that it's possible to learn about nutrition using other methods.
- martinpw 11y agoInteresting that the cure for scurvy is used as the example of the first clinical trial. The story is an instructive one, since the real reason for the cure was not understood, leading to the cure being lost for ~150 years, due to a variety of bad assumptions, eg that it was the acidity of the fruit that was preventing scurvy. This lead to lemons being replaced with limes (that had far less vitamin C but were more acidic) because they could be sourced from within the British Empire rather than outside. Long article here: http://idlewords.com/2010/03/scott_and_scurvy.htm http://idlewords.com/2010/03/scott_and_scurvy.htm and shorter summary of above here: https://lonechemist.wordpress.com/2010/11/01/82/ https://lonechemist.wordpress.com/2010/11/01/82/
- noondip 11y agoI've really enjoyed learning about nutrition science through http://nutritionfacts.org http://nutritionfacts.org, especially in videos about the conflict of interest present in modern research.
- saosebastiao 11y agoConflicts of interest like the one that Michal Greger has himself, as an employee of the Humane Society? He literally gets paid to put an MD stamp of approval on anything vegan and attempting to discredit anything that is not vegan. Have you actually critically read anything from this bullshit factory? https://www.sciencebasedmedicine.org/death-as-a-foodborne-illness-curable-by-veganism/ https://www.sciencebasedmedicine.org/death-as-a-foodborne-il...
- noondip 11y agoHere, take a look at this - http://donmatesz.blogspot.com/2013/02/harriet-halls-critique-of-gregers.html http://donmatesz.blogspot.com/2013/02/harriet-halls-critique... I'm simply satisfied with the format studies are presented in his videos (they are always directly cited). I often read them for myself and usually agree with the conclusion, but not always.
- Outdoorsman 11y agoI think it's helpful to keep in mind, when deciding on our "individual" takeaways from this article, that our DNA requires nothing more of us than that we stay alive long enough to reproduce and pass it along... The earliest humans likely ate whatever was immediately available to stay alive...some survived doing that and they became your ancestors...some died doing that, their DNA with them... If you doubt that just observe babies when they first become ambulatory (start crawling), and come to your own conclusions--babies put a great number of things into their mouths to "try it out"... We think about past humans, and ponder the dietary choices the fossil record indicates they appear to have made... Is a diet that kept them alive long enough to reproduce a diet that has the potential to keep us feeling well into our 30s-50s, or to keep us alive well into our 60s-90s...?
- dschiptsov 11y agoDo they found how to factor out air, water, climate and bacteria or realized that a body continuously adapts to behavioral patterns and environmental conditions? Or that what happens in Vegas stays in Vegas, and naive studies on already overweight US student subjects does not replicate anywhere in less developed world?