12 ms·
I want privacy because I break the law
- btilly 17y agoEither this is a work of fiction or else the author doesn't actually want his privacy very much.
- philk 17y agoYou're missing the point. It doesn't matter whether the stories are real or not. They're just there to illustrate his point that all of us commit minor infractions of the law from time to time and avoid the repercussions thanks to the level of privacy we're afforded by society. If our privacy is stripped away we get in a situation where we could be prosecuted for giving our mothers a couple of pain killers after her back surgery. Also, he's disclaimed up the top that To the police and future employers: 1. I don’t really do illegal things. I’m actually a pretty top notch guy. 2. Some of the stories in the article may be embellished/fabricated. I do have to say that, right?*
- nostrademons 17y agoIs it really because of privacy though, or is it because of reciprocity? Do people not get prosecuted for trivial law-breaking because the relevant authorities don't know about it, or is it because they're afraid that if they set the precedent that these laws will be enforced, they wouldn't want to live in the world that results? It's always been fairly easy to dig up dirt - even felonies - in peoples' pasts. All you need to do is find one of their childhood friends, act all buddy-buddy, and buy him a few beers. Then as in now, these usually only get prosecuted if somebody has a vendetta against you. Think of the times that people commit crimes right in front of a police officer and walk away. Haven't you ever driven a few mph over the speed limit when a cop pulls up behind you, think "Oh shit, there goes my insurance premium" as you pull over - and then watch him speed past you, because he's got something more important to do than write you a ticket? When I was in college, the campus police would regularly turn a blind eye to underage drinking right in front of them, as long as no property was being destroyed and nobody had alcohol poisoning. When teachers show a movie to their class, does anybody actually believe that they've acquired public-performance rights to the movie? In polygraph tests, questions on these sorts of crimes are asked as a control, on the assumption that everybody lies about them. The theory is that a normal person will be more nervous about the little crimes that they're sure they must've committed at some point in the past (even if they can't remember exactly when), but will know they didn't commit the particular crime they're being accused of. A real criminal will be more nervous about the big crime they just committed, and all the petty misdemeanors pale in comparison to that. Makes me wonder if polygraphs give false results for those saints who don't actually do anything wrong. It's not lack of information that stops most people from being prosecuted for giving our mothers a couple of pain killers, it's that most of the people doing the prosecution figure that they would do the same thing.
- philk 17y agoThe problem is that with the internet evidence of your minor crimes is available to a far wider audience than usual. To expand on your underage drinking analogy, it's the difference between being seen by a member of campus police and being seen by all members of campus police, including the really uptight one and a range of other people (potential employers, etc.), continuing for years after the actual night of drinking.
- nostrademons 17y agoPossibly. One would hope though that there're checks on that one really uptight cop so that he can't single-handedly ruin your life. After all, the situation beforehand was arguably worse, where it was just random chance whether or not it was the asshole cop who happened to see you when you were drinking. The employer issue is already like that, at least for software engineers. I don't care if a potential employer wants to turn me down for something they saw in a FaceBook photo, because there're plenty of other employers who don't give a damn.
- Confusion 17y agoThe article pretty much repeats the main points Bruce Schneier, and other privacy advocates, keep making: the fact that some individual or the government doesn't consider your behavior offensive now, doesn't mean they don't will in the future. A message I think cannot be repeated often enough in the current climate. Once, stealing an apple from an orchard was kiddie mischief, punished by a spanking from the owner. Now it's a criminal activity, which gets you taken away from your parents if you run into the wrong police, or 'children safety' officer. Writing about stealing an apple when you were eight won't cause employers to blink currently (at least, I think). Who knows how moral values will have evolved ten years from now?
- greendestiny 17y agoIt's a slightly different point, and it might be more important. Most of us break the law, right now, and not even including examples of ridiculous laws. A lack of privacy on the data we generate could incriminate us in ways that we didn't set up our justice system to handle.
- potatolicious 17y agoDevil's advocate: if lack of privacy was a level playing field (i.e., nobody has privacy from anyone else) maybe we will finally start looking at all of the illegal activities in the lawbooks and start narrowing them down to actual activities we'd like to make illegal.
- olliesaunders 17y agoI completely agree, but sadly, I don't think this will happen before countless people are thrown in jail for breaking them.
- eru 17y agoAnd you won't get complete lack of privacy anytime soon. Selective privacy is what we face.
- joeyh 17y agoThe real power of masses of laws that are regularly broken is selective enforcement. When you add lack of privacy to the picture, it can look downright dystopian.
- ntoshev 17y agoWe should try to minimize the number of laws that are selectively applied though, because the more there are, the more powerful random officials get.
- eru 17y agoIndeed. I had a taste of it in the -- rather benign -- boarding school I went to years ago.
- goodness 17y agoSchools can be really bad on this. One college I went to charged people with "condoning" if they were aware that someone else was breaking the rules and didn't report it. I think this is actually pretty common among private colleges in the US. Imagine how badly that would be abused if it were a law.
- angelbob 17y agoWell, some things can be "abetted", which is similar.
- goodness 17y agoTrue, it is slightly similar in that you didn't directly commit the crime. Though you do have to have an active role, for example, storing the money after a bank robbery. Another one like this is "accessory after the fact." However, there again, you actually have to take an active role in helping someone you know committed a crime. The difference with something like the "condoning" rules is that they essentially take away the right to remain silent from the 5th amendment. Of course, they can get away with it because they are just rules at a school.
- scotty79 17y agoI don't think that privacy in this case is all that good. If there is a law that you could break without knowledge and without harming anybody then this law is against common sense and should be abolished. Upholding privacy as a way to get around stupid laws is like suppressing exceptions in computer programs so that errors would not manifest themselves. Because no one is bothered there is no incentive to fix it. When it comes to laws we don't need privacy as much as we need common sense and latitude.
- ytinas 17y agoGiven the track record which is more likely to be effective? Continuing to wish for common sense and latitude in our public officials or protecting yourself from their normal behavior?
- nostrademons 17y agoHonestly, in my experience - wishing for common sense and latitude in public officials. I know its fun to rag on public officials on Internet forums. But most of the ones I know have been fairly decent people who are just doing their jobs. There're a few bad apples, but there're a few bad apples in any population. Even the TSA officials (which gets my vote for "worst government bureaucracy") were very apologetic when they confiscated my toothpaste. I think that you're more likely to get absurd institutional behavior - like confiscating toothpaste - when you deny latitude in employee judgment. The TSA screeners have this massive rulebook that they have to follow, and they risk losing their job when they deviate from it, even if they personally believe the rules are stupid. Same with the private sector. Companies that have the best reputations tend to be those that empower their employees to solve the customer's problem, like Virgin or Nordstroms. Companies with the worst reputations tend to be those where the employees can't do anything but follow the playbook, like most telecoms.
- scotty79 17y agoThat's exactly what I'm talking about. Silly laws exist because they may not be obeyed. Citizens get around them, enforcers get around them and the message never bites the policy makers in the ass - the people that are responsible for this mess are often not even aware that they made a mistake. So I am claiming that loss of privacy that I perceive inevitable in face of modern and upcoming technology is not necessary bad thing because it may create the demand for fixing some stupid rules that may cause some of us harm.
- ErrantX 17y agoWhile he makes a valid point I am worried about a few things he says: Say there is only a 0.1% chance that in the next year Google’s servers have a search history leak Sounds like meaningless speculation; and what does "leak" entail. Even if 0.1% of the data is leaked there is a pretty low chance that his data will be included - or if it is, obvious. between all their sharing of data back and forth with the US government Im not sure what this refers to; all data given under a subpoena should be a matter of public record at some point (at least it is here) and I was not aware Google handed out any other data to the government - if he has evidence of that it would be good to see it. A Google search you made tipped off your local American authorities that you are breaking 16 USC 3370. Do Not Pass Go, Do Not Collect $200. Instead go to prison for 1 to 5 years after laying out up to $250k on a fine, unless you get an understanding judge. Is this a scenario that exists? Answer is no. Of course I support the argument that this set up should never exist in the future - but I've not seen a suggestion Google would roll over to this lightly anyway. Unfortunately this guy takes a good point to a somewhat surreal extreme - while that is often useful for pointing out flaws in things, his fruit example points out flaws in the law (which you could fall foul of in any number of ways beyond google searching) rather than making any specific point about privacy. EDIT: any specific rebuttals? Did I get any facts wrong?
- sailormoon 17y agoall data given under a subpoena should be a matter of public record at some point (at least it is here) and I was not aware Google handed out any other data to the government - if he has evidence of that it would be good to see it. Are you kidding? It would, of course, be covered by a National Security Letter (or whatever they're calling them these days), and illegal to even talk about. I have zero doubt whatsoever that the FBI, CIA, NSA and anyone else who wants it has full access to everything Google stores.
- ErrantX 17y agoIt would, of course, be covered by a National Security Letter, and illegal to even talk about. I can only speak for here; but a subphoena through the normal courts probably wouldnt - I cant see it being any different over there. As to the CIA/NSA etc. having allowed access lets see your evidence - otherwise your just propagating paranoia... and anyone else who wants it has full access to everything Google stores. Whom else are you referring to? Dont you think such a massive conspiracy would be fairly quick to come to light if it was that accessible ;) conspiracy theories are usually the root of their own downfall - case in point.
- dkersten 17y agoThe book "How to be Invisible"[1] makes a few good arguments for privacy too. For example, if you are charged with a serious felony, but later released because you are actually innocent - lack of privacy almost ensures that your life is ruined anyway, even though you are innocent, because the media loves to blow everything out of proportion - but rarely seems to go back and correct their earlier stories when you've been found innocent, or if they do, most people have already read the sensationalized news condemning you and the damage is already done. So, without even breaking any laws or doing anything wrong, without privacy you might find your life ruined anyway. [1] How to be Invisible, by JJ Luna, http://www.amazon.com/How-Be-Invisible-Essential-Protecting/dp/0312319061 http://www.amazon.com/How-Be-Invisible-Essential-Protecting/...
- romland 17y agoAm I the only one that find it a tiny bit ironic that he uses Google Analytics on that page? Probably.
- 3pt14159 17y agoYeah, I do a whole lot of ironic things. Including using Gmail, Google Reader, etc. If only Google didn't make such good products.
- easyfrag 17y agoThere's an interesting book that I've read about, but haven't picked up yet, called "Three Felonies A Day". It discusses the selective enforcement of vague statutes and the incredible number of said statutes. http://www.amazon.com/Three-Felonies-Day-Target-Innocent/dp/1594032556 http://www.amazon.com/Three-Felonies-Day-Target-Innocent/dp/...
- deleted 17y ago[deleted]
- Torn 17y ago'Why should I care about privacy, I have nothing to hide" is one of the most harmful, narrow but yet common arguments put forward for this. I strongly recommend people with viewpoints on either side of the argument to go read D. Solove's essay on the subject over at http://crysp.uwaterloo.ca/courses/pet/F07/cache/solove.pdf http://crysp.uwaterloo.ca/courses/pet/F07/cache/solove.pdf - it's quite short and a great read. His "Understanding Privacy" work is a fantastic book which develops this and his other essays, and provides a great methodology for understanding the scope of - and breaking down the harm inherent in - modern privacy problems. I studied it for my Master's in Cyberlaw, and would highly recommend anyone with an interest in IT / cyberlaw / philosophy to track down a copy and read it. http://www.amazon.com/Understanding-Privacy-Daniel-J-Solove/dp/0674027728 http://www.amazon.com/Understanding-Privacy-Daniel-J-Solove/...
- dpatru 17y agoRelying on privacy to avoid liability for inadvertently breaking laws does not seem to me to be a good solution to the real problem: that laws can be so numerous and obscure that one can inadvertently become a criminal. Privacy does have a role in helping to avoid prosecution: if the government doesn't know about my lawbreaking, it can't prosecute me for it. But privacy should also limit government's power to legislate and prosecute: Government should not make criminal what is not its business. A citizen ordinarily should not have to live in fear that he could be prosecuted if only the government knew what he was doing. In this sense, privacy can harm freedom because it allows government to expand its claims without public resistance. Privacy has enabled the government to make most American teenagers potential felons because they share music. If there were less privacy, if the government knew and prosecuted all the file sharers to the full extent of the law, the resulting public backlash would cause the law to be repealed. The best way to change an unjust law is to enforce it.
- fauigerzigerk 17y agoThere are many more good reasons for privacy. Laws are sometimes inconsistent, and it turns out to be impossible not to break at least one of them in a particular situation. Sometimes you have to break the letter of the law in order to comply with its spirit. Making such breaches visible to everyone would do nothing but open the floodgates to blackmail. Also, there are moral issues. Abortion is legal in many jurisdictions, but many people will still treat it as homicide. Am I really under any obligation to argue about abortion with a potential employer or suffer the consequences of not sharing the employer's opinion? I think not. Keeping professional duties and private opinions separate is my right and it is necessary for any company to remain functional.
- rwmj 17y agoJuries are (hopefully) your defense here. If the govt really did start prosecuting lemon buyers, one would hope that juries would not convict.
- daten 17y agoHopefully you get some jurors who are familiar with Jury Nullification. Otherwise the instructions from the judge and persuasion by the prosecutor might convince them they have no choice but to follow the letter of the law.
- tungstenfurnace 17y agoI want privacy because (1) I break laws I don't know about (2) I do things which might be misinterpreted as breaking the law or as being immoral (3) I do things which are considered immoral by most people, but which are not illegal. For these reasons, I cannot act autonomously or creatively without privacy.
- eru 17y agoYou can make your statement stronger by weakening the conditions: "(3) I do things which are considered immoral by _some_ people, but which are not illegal."
- jacquesm 17y agoThe biggest reason why privacy matters is because there are always going to be crimes committed so there will always be people that have nothing to do with the crime caught in the dragnet around the crime scene. Coincidences do happen and if you happen to be around the area of two murders you'll have a very hard time to explain that away, whereas in a society with good privacy you would never even appear on the radar. So even if you haven't broken the law or done something that could be misconstrued as such you are still at risk. All this lack of privacy does is increase the size of the haystack while keeping the number of needles constant. But hay looks a lot like needles and plenty of 'hay' will end up being prosecuted for stuff the needles get away with. Less privacy means more solved crimes, but it also means many more false positives. The 'if you've got nothing to hide why do you want privacy' crowd seems to be completely oblivious to this, until they end up being hauled in to the station for something they had nothing to do with themselves. That's when reality kicks in and suddenly they switch sides (but by then it's obviously too late). We live in a society that is predicated on fear, fear of crime, of terror and so on. And most of us are willing to trade their freedom for security all too easily. If you want absolute security, you should realize that that is only possible in a society that has more in common with a prison than with a park. Robert Heinlein wrote a whole bunch of books around this theme, if you like SF and you haven't read those book yet I suggest you do so, there is some really good stuff in there.
- s_tec 17y ago
- TrevorJ 17y agoPrivacy isn't about having things to hide. Privacy is about who has the right to control the flow of information that is your identity. It is a human right and a basic human need. Any argument based around "having nothing to hide" misses the point entirely.
- rapind 17y agoNot too mention loads of arcane laws that haven't been cleared (probably because of the cost). I.e. "In Toronto, it is illegal to drag a dead horse down Yonge Street on a Sunday." more: http://www.mundayweb.com/weirdlaws.php http://www.mundayweb.com/weirdlaws.php
- orblivion 17y agoPerhaps the unspoken point is, we want to be able to deliberately break the law, should such a need arise. Yes, the citizens are potentially at odds with the government. Privacy from government isn't just finding the most effective and just policy for both parties, it's also a give and take negotiation.
- hhjj 17y agoWe need privacy because we may have to break the law...
- run4yourlives 17y agoI want privacy for the same reason I wear clothes - I don't want you to see certain things. That has been my right since these nations (both Canada and the US) were founded. You'd probably find, if you removed my clothes, nothing remarkable really. That doesn't mean that because of that, I should walk around in the buff.
- bbg 17y agoI recently watched The Judge and the General, a documentary about the bloody rise of the Pinochet regime in Chile (link below), and the recent legal action against it. I recall a particularly chilling moment when Pinochet declared (paraphrased): if you've done nothing wrong, you have nothing to fear. Of course, thousands and thousands of people had everything to fear, and thousands lost their lives for the dubious crime of being left wing supporters of the ousted Allende regime. Some things only become 'crimes' in retrospect. http://www.pbs.org/pov/judgeandthegeneral/ http://www.pbs.org/pov/judgeandthegeneral/
- heresy 17y agoAgree totally. I'd be so screwed if everything I've done came out. Today, I'm a pretty law abiding citizen (if I break it, it is in ways that hurts no-one). I was a rather confused and angry teenager growing up though, and did a lot of things I shouldn't have. I really take offense to the notion that that should have fucked me over for the rest of my life. There is such a thing as wanting to start with a clean slate. Make exception for pedos, etc, if you want, but don't use them as a justification to screw everyone out of privacy. For fucks, sake.
- heyitsnick 17y agoJust want to add what a fantastic thread of comments there is on this page. Thanks for such well thought-out debate and discussion guys.
- teeja 17y agoI want privacy because it's a self-explanatory, daily part of the human condition that every human understands from the time they're small. I don't have to explain it, I refuse to justify my need for it, and I will do whatever I have to do to protect it. Including breaking your $#)($& laws. Consequently, I will never take a job for which a piss-check is a condition of employment. For one thing, that is self-incrimination, from which I'm protected by the 5th amendment. And I'm not signing away my constitutional rights to work for some totalitarian employer.
- kelnos 17y agoI don't disagree with your premise: I'd never work for a company that did drug checking. But: private companies are not bound by the 5th amendment. The Constitution and Bill of Rights covers only what the government may or may not do.
- teeja 17y agoI understand that; I'm saying: for an American company, I won't give up my rights at the door. They can insist, and I'll walk away. Forced self-incrimination is not consonant with reasonable liberty. Should that stop at the door of a business? Consider who got the piss test started: Ed Meese, Attorney General of the U.S. at the time. Purely contradicts the Fifth.