5 ms·
>>> “The alien-megastructure idea runs wrong with my new observations,” he says, as he thinks even advanced aliens wouldn’t be able to build something capable o
by sandworm101 11y ago
>>> “The alien-megastructure idea runs wrong with my new observations,” he says, as he thinks even advanced aliens wouldn’t be able to build something capable of covering a fifth of a star in just a century. What’s more, such an object should radiate light absorbed from the star as heat, but the infrared signal from Tabby’s star appears normal, he says.
That seems a rather unambitious approach to possible alien tech. We today clearly could not build, or think of how to build, such structures. That isn't to say that the technology isn't possible, just that we do not understand it. If aliens were able to create and fly structures of such size I think it safe to say they would also be in possession of tech we cannot contemplate.
- ealexhudson 11y agoIn general I agree, but the lack of radiation is a real problem - we would need to have some fundamental error in our understanding of thermodynamics for their tech to be capable of that. That, or the structure itself isn't collecting the energy but only [somehow] redirecting visible wavelength light.
- sandworm101 11y agoLike a mirror? Or a mirror that selectively reflects certain wavelengths but not others?
- perseusprime11 11y agoGuys these are just solar panels. Their race is better at alternative forms of energy than us.
- idlewords 11y agoSolar panels heat up. It's the law!
- sawwit 11y agoPerhaps they use the heat very efficiently?
- sethrin 11y agoNo dice. Conservation of energy and other thermodynamic laws say that [a] there are limits to efficiency, and [b] if you absorb energy you must re-radiate it. Among other things. There's no point in speculating about the blatantly unphysical. @Sharlin is right, it's just "Goddidit" dressed up.
- stevejones 11y agoDo any of them say it must be re-radiated omni-directionally as infra-red light?
- marcosdumay 11y agoPretty much. You can make it cooler than infra-red light (like microwaves), and you can irradiate for half a sphere, or even a bit less. But that's all.
- sandworm101 11y agoDon't forget entropy. Matter can absorb energy without necessarily radiating it immediately. Two objects can be the same temperature but of totally different energy. The easiest to understand is probably phase changes. Ice can melt into water, absorbing energy, without changing its temperature. Even stranger, ice can sometimes melt, still absorbing and retaining energy from its surroundings, while the temperature of the system actually drops (ie if you pour salt on ice).
- tetraodonpuffer 11y agowhat if they were getting the energy from this star system and "beaming" it somehow somewhere else? you would not get any IR from that because it would not be used in this system at all
- ealexhudson 11y agoThe report seems to be saying that the IR is unchanged - i.e. there is IR, it's just what is expected from the star. As the other commenter suggested, it would need to be some reflector which was IR-transparent, which would be a pretty strange setup.
- danek 11y agoCould this be explained by a black hole, slowly slowly siphoning matter from the star? Maybe it's behind the star and we're less likely to observe the radiation from it..
- XorNot 11y agoYou shouldn't be getting downvoted for this, but also no. A black hole would have an accretion disk in this case and be a very bright object. It would also be in orbit so we would've spotted the traversal of it given the timespan or the matter siphon if it was in a large orbit.
- Sharlin 11y agoIf there's no plausible model that involves aliens and explains the observations, it's not science. "Advanced aliens did it in a way we don't understand" is basically a "Goddidit" argument.
- puredemo 11y agoAliens of the gaps? https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/God_of_the_gaps https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/God_of_the_gaps
- sandworm101 11y agoThere is a difference between claiming that aliens have done something, and being critical of those too dismissive of the possibility. This isn't goddidit. That argument is used to end a debate, to say that the how is unknowable. A claim that aliens are doing something is the opposite, a call for more careful and complete scientific scrutiny.
- Sharlin 11y agoThe time to investigate outlandish hypotheses is after the space of more plausible ones is exhausted.
- CamperBob2 11y agoSo let's hear some more plausible ones. If you assert that no intelligent extraterrestrial entities are capable of harnessing, redirecting, or otherwise manipulating the light from a star, then you have a burden of proof of your own to meet.
- titzer 11y agoI think the burden of proof is heavy and squarely on those who propose so lightly that "advanced aliens" do such things.
- 11y ago
- klenwell 11y agoHere's where the casual Bayesian reasoning that Daniel Kahnemann champions in Thinking Fast and Slow can come in handy. What's the base rate probability for believing that unimaginable alien supertech exists? Is it even 1% at the moment? Now tweak that base rate based on this new ambiguous evidence -- evidence which experts seem to think has a natural explanation. It doesn't rule out magic alien tech. But it doesn't make it all that much more probable either. If you want to be more rigorous about it, what's your confidence that we will discover compelling, if not irrefutable, evidence that alien supertech exists in the next 5 years? Wager on your favorite online prediction market accordingly.
- sandworm101 11y agoThere is no percentage upon which to calculate. The reality that is this star is unknown to us. So there is a broad range of possibilities. Aliens is somewhere in that broad range, but as points within a range of knowns, the likelihood is incalculable. It's a few fixes points against an infinity. Bayesian is inappropriate in such circumstances.
- LASR 11y agoYou cannot argue in probabilities when you have zero prior events to go on.
- brudgers 11y agoThe belief that large scale structures are dynamic is the basis of contemporary geology. Another is uniformatarianism [1]. That suggests that on the basis of observing short term changes in a star's brightness, our postulate ought to be that star's tend to vary in brightness. Our observations of other stellar phenomena such as nova's and black holes are consistent with this...as are quasars with the generalized case that the radiation from stars can fluctuate in short cycles even relative to human time. This isn't to say that their may not be creatures [for some definition of "creature"] somewhere capable of constructing dyson spheres, but Occam's razor suggests that we focus on what is more likely. And the argument for the existence of alien technology that we cannot imagine is less well supported {because we have never encountered such a thing} than the argument for a natural process that we cannot imagine {because that is the history of scientific discovery}. Postulating advanced technology developed by aliens based upon variation in a star's brightness is certainly no less scientific than postulating divine purpose upon finding seashell on a mountain top. It is certainly no more so either. My money is geology over biology. [1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Uniformitarianism https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Uniformitarianism
- FajitaNachos 11y agoThat is a very well articulated reply.
- darkmighty 11y agoThe amount of data is so tiny and unreliable on top of that. We can't even be sure to be seeing a seashell. It's important not to ostracize who did this claim, but I too believe it will shortly turn into another example of jumping to conclusions violating Occam's Razor because the explanation excites us.
- kordless 11y ago> My money is geology over biology. Says the biology.