6 ms·
Yoda Is Dead but Star Wars’ Dubious Lessons Live On
- enlightenedfool 11y agoI think what I didn't like is that while it required lot of training to be Jedi in the past, Rey seemed to have miraculously acquired congenitally. Or did I not notice/heard how she got trained?
- danmaz74 11y agoThat's exactly what put me off the most in this latest movie. They completely trivialized the Force.
- littlegreenb18 11y agoIf you look at the prequels vs a new hope, the same could be said about Luke. I think the answer there is that Luke is more force sensitive than any Jedi of the past, making his training to get to the same level minimal. And maybe we're seeing the same thing with Rey.
- danmaz74 11y agoWell, just for the sake of fun, I could argue that Luke only confronts one trained Jedi - his father - and that his father never wanted to kill him. Emperor Palpatine, instead, was having an easy time killing him, and was only stopped by Anakin.
- sotojuan 11y agoThey trivialized them in Episode I when they came up with midichlorians.
- Numberwang 11y agoShe sucked it all out of that rod she found in that basement.
- piptastic 11y agoThe current thought is that she had training from Luke as a kid in the school they mention. But then when the school was disbanded they suppressed her memories and left her on that planet. Then when Kylo used the force on her mind, he broke loose the training.
- msabalau 11y agoI'm not certain we have evidence that training is necessary to use the Force, it may be mostly intended to prevent misuse. The eight year old rugrat in the first prequel was quite remarkable without any training. We have new evil force users, despite the requisite "always being two, a master and an apprentice" both dying at Endor. Luke spent a trivial amount of time training with Yoda and Kenobi, most of which was spent convincing the farmboy that it was a simple matter of "just doing" the impossible. As far as we know, the rigors of Jedi training in the Old Republic were intended to prevent people from misusing "what comes naturally" and falling to the dark side. That Luke, who didn't benefit from that training, had students who fell to become "Knights of Ren" reinforces that line of thinking. If we don't know what the training is for, we can't judge if/how Rey is remarkable compared to other Force users. Regardless, given how the movie ends, it seems likely that we'll have illumination on these questions.
- InclinedPlane 11y agoYeah, when she single handedly destroyed starkiller base after very limited training that was just unbelievable. Wait, I must be thinking of a different film, nevermind.
- blazespin 11y agoThe big thing about Force Awakens I missed was the advances in technological film making. That was always George Lucas most important contribution to film. He always raised the bar.
- TazeTSchnitzel 11y agoAt least TFA tried to go practical effects again instead of all-CGI.
- vlunkr 11y agoThe overuse of CGI in the prequels have made them age badly. All the environments are starting to look like video games.
- TazeTSchnitzel 11y agoYeah, but I'm not sure they looked good at the time either. Sure, they might have been impressive for CGI, but they don't look real to me, and I don't know if people thought they looked real at the time. I think that's probably because they used so much CG they weren't able to put the required work into each environment to achieve photorealism.
- ashark 11y agoThe touched-up "THX Enhanced" versions of the original three movies, where they digitally removed some of the matting artifacts and such, had more convincing and better-looking SFX than the prequels, for the most part. Movies like Jurassic Park and Independence Day that came out before the prequels (well before, in the case of JP) that used a blend of models/animatronics and CGI looked way better. The visuals in Ep. 1 were an obvious step backward the day it was released, no hindsight required.
- rquantz 11y agoI thought the effects looked amazing. Since the turn of the millennium we've had movies switch over almost entirely to digital effects, but pure cgi still just doesn't look really real. It's missing some ineffable emotional weight that makes its fruit not quite believable. TFA, in trying to recreate some of the look of the original films using practical effects, also had the effect of saying, look what we can do when we combine real things that are actually in front of the camera with state of the art digital effects. I don't think I've seen a big special effects movie that looked so actually real since the golden age of practical effects in the 90s – movies like Jurassic Park come to mind.
- bshimmin 11y agoI get the feeling this guy takes Star Wars (and probably himself) just a little worryingly seriously. I can't really understand what he's saying - that George Lucas is evil? That the Star Wars films are promoting Lucas' evil agenda? That no one has actually noticed any of this and that's bad? The cynic in me wonders if perhaps David Brin has a new novel coming out soon...
- leephillips 11y ago"I get the feeling this guy takes Star Wars (and probably himself) just a little worryingly seriously." I was thinking the same thing, but he restores some perspective when he says, "Does entertainment have to have an outcome? We were doing it for fun." But it also seems that, for Brin, Democracy is an unassailable good, and pointing out its shortcomings might be a little bit evil.
- rquantz 11y agoOr perhaps he sees democracy as imperiled and in need of defending. In that view, efforts to undermine the public's confidence in democracy could be seen as evil.
- danharaj 11y agoThat point of view is very helpful to every violent hierarchy that hides behind the language of democracy and liberty.
- rquantz 11y agoOnly if by undermining democracy you mean undermining the word itself. Teaching people that the people cannot govern themselves, that democratic institutions cannot be trusted, and that leaders are born, rather than elected, are all helpful to authoritarians and harmful to actual democracy.
- rquantz 11y agoHe says he takes mythology very seriously. Is that really a bad thing? Star Wars is a common dream that a huge percentage of humanity shares. It's the raw material of our imagination at this point. It's as legitimate to take seriously and criticize as the myths of the gods would have been to ancient Romans.
- legulere 11y agoI think the worst about our media, is that most stories are based on dividing people into good and evil. This way of thinking is also very common in our society. Why do criminals and terrorists act like they do? If you ask people they will tell you because they're evil. But actually nobody is evil, everybody wants something positive. The question is just for whom they think it will be positive and why they think it is positive to do. When you think that they're evil on the other hand you don't have to think about anything and just fight them, because good needs to fight evil.
- dawnbreez 11y agoI've been saying this for at least a year. Finally, someone else gets it.
- globba22 11y agoWise thinkers throughout history have been saying it too :)
- mikeash 11y agoSome people really are evil. Some psychopaths, for example, know that what they're doing is negative and do it anyway. (Many more cover it up and try to do the right thing, of course.) But of course this doesn't apply to terrorists or most criminals. The occasional serial killer fits the bill and not much more. What really gets me is that if you start taking about terrorists like this, saying you should understand what makes them tick, that they think they're doing the right thing, etc., people freak out. I just think we should understand them better so we know how to stop them, but any attempt at understanding is taken as justification for what they do.
- arethuza 11y agoLook at what happened in the UK with the IRA - for years we had the approach of refusing to talk to them. Eventually we did, found that they had some legitimate complaints and when those were addressed we eventually got an end to the Troubles. Now we have people like Martin McGuinness, a former IRA leader, as active politicians in Northern Ireland.
- ZanyProgrammer 11y ago" I’ve issued a challenge for anyone out there to come show us even one scene in the latest flick that was not an homage to earlier Star Wars episodes. " I hate it when people give these pseudo-challenges. There were quite a few, and I fear I run the risk of some easily mocked nerd rage if I attempt to list them.
- ZanyProgrammer 11y agoWhen Kylo killed Han, how was that an homage to any earlier scene in a SW movie? No character in any Star Wars move had ever killed their parent-Anakin's mom was killed by the Sand People, and Vader/Anakin succumbed to injuries sustained by Palpatine's force lightning, that shorted out his circuitry.
- probably_wrong 11y agoFirst of all, well, spoilers. I think it's a perfect parallel of the scene when Vader kills Obi-Wan: Evil Jedi-turned-bad kills an important figure of his past, while the untrained future Jedi can't do anything but watch how a father-like figure and source of inspiration dies. The fact that it happens while sabotaging the new new Death Star and it involves the new Vader drive the point even more.
- ZanyProgrammer 11y agoKylo brutally murdered Han in cold blood-Obi Wan let himself be cut down as to become a Force Ghost. That's...I suppose same in some respects?
- tgb 11y agoThat scene was overt homage to the "I am your father" scene in V. With a number of inversions, of course.
- ZanyProgrammer 11y agoExcept Luke didn't murder Vader in cold blood.
- babatong 11y agoHe obviously has the right to his own opinion, but it would help if he actually gave the impression of watching the films thoroughly. To quote: "The force was only a little bit about talent and more about training: Obi-Wan offers to teach it to Han" This simply does not happen anywhere, neither in the films nor in the now de-cannoned EU. He also gets the plotlines of Ep. II and III quite mixed up in a few paragraphs about Yoda, and fails to realise that the Republic is hardly modelled on a modern-day parliamentary democracy but rather the fatally flawed Weimar Republic. While this doesn't necessarily invalidate his trains of thought, it certainly makes their basis scientifically dishonest.
- mratzloff 11y agoSome commenters disputed the Han statement, and some others flew to his defense. His own defense of that statement was rather uncharitable to the objectors and he coyly avoided pointing out where exactly it occurred. I myself reviewed the script several times, and I couldn't find it anywhere. The only time the topic came up with Han and Ben was while Luke was training with the helmet and droid, and Ben definitely does not offer to train him. So I'm confused where he seems to think this occurred.
- rdlecler1 11y agoA bit off topic, but was anyone else disappointed that a sanatation trooper was able to have a decent light saber fight with a Jedi!!?? Unless Finn has special Jedi powers that we don't know about yet. That would be like my Luddite artist friend taking an hour of code and beating out Linus in a hackathon. (Still the movie was very special).
- spchampion2 11y agoI got the impression that Kylo Ren was toying with him. The whole chest thumping bit was Ren saying "I'm kicking your ass without even trying."
- QuercusMax 11y agoHe had just been shot by a bowcaster and was severely wounded. He was hitting his wound to get himself pumped up with rage.