9 ms·
Back in 2009 when I was getting into bitcoin, it was widely described as a "stateless currency" and not just an alternative to Visa or credit cards. Having a ba
by AndrewKemendo 11y ago
Back in 2009 when I was getting into bitcoin, it was widely described as a "stateless currency" and not just an alternative to Visa or credit cards. Having a background in economics, bitcoin looked to me like a truly revolutionary technology and if it was adopted en masse would change politics forever.
The problem however is that a nation's currency is arguably the primary source of it's sovereignty. Whomever controls the currency primarily used in a nation, controls the nation. So it's safe to say that no nation is going to let bitcoin or any other currency take hold for widespread commercial use in lieu of it's sovereign currency - that's a hallmark of a failed state.
In fact that's why when regulators declared bitcoin as a commodity it was such a big deal. The US doesn't really care because we haven't had commodity money since the 1970s, but the idea that if enough people decided that they wanted commodity money, they would arguably have a medium with which to do it with that wasn't tied to any state.
So as with every product, unless a massive number of people decide to stop using their home currency and start using bitcoin, then bitcoin will "fail."
Whether it pivots to some kind of credit system or not is largely immaterial because of the potential it had.
It's like if we created Artificial General Intelligence and it decided to just write movie reviews forever.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- valarauca1 11y agoThe problem however is that a nation's currency is arguably the primary source of it's sovereignty. Whomever controls the currency primarily used in a nation, controls the nation How does Canadian Tire Money work then? :^)
- steve19 11y ago> nation's currency is arguably the primary source of it's sovereignty Not really. Many countries do not mint their own currency, and other mint currency but peg its value to another. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Currency_substitution https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Currency_substitution What constitutes sovereignty is complex. It mostly comes down either legal recognition of sovereignty (de jure) or physical/guns on the ground control (de facto). https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sovereignty https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sovereignty
- stcredzero 11y agoIt mostly comes down either legal recognition of sovereignty (de jure) or physical/guns on the ground control (de facto). It usually comes down to the latter. De jure sovereignty without physical control gets overrun by de facto. I wonder if either Japan or China would grant de jure sovereignty to a seasteading platform anchored to that sinking island both of them want so badly? Then the new nation could grant their supporter some economic rights in exchange for military support.
- AndrewKemendo 11y agoThere is a massive difference between a currency peg and citizens using another nation's currency for transactions. In the former case the state still controls the currency and it's distribution, the latter they are completely divorced. and yes sovereignty is of course complex, but if you can't control how your economy runs then you can't control your nation. Forcefully seizing notes or issuing new currencies is hallmark of a power transfer.
- the_mitsuhiko 11y agoA peg can be changed with a moment's notice. You can't do that with a currency you do not issue. This is the dofference between what happened in Switzerland and Greece last year.
- stcredzero 11y agoWhy not let it write movie reviews forever? Perhaps they're really good reviews. I'd say Roger Ebert had a life well lived. Making such a decision is probably a sign that we really had achieved AGI. Likewise, if people can use Bitcoin or some other digital currency to achieve some measure of independence from existing states, it will have achieved something important. Perhaps something important of the scale you mention will come about, but it will take more time.
- slg 11y agoAs someone with an economics background, I'm surprised you think the biggest problem is the statelessness of Bitcoin. The biggest economic problem to me has always been an unintelligent control of the money supply. You can criticize some of the actions that many central banks do to manipulate the economy, but I have a hard time buying the answer to bad management is no management.
- supster 11y agoThe money supply is fixed to 21 million. Fortunately, the coins are basically infinitely divisible, so as the coins become more valuable (assuming over the long run that coins are used for larger and larger amounts of commerce rather than speculation), small transactions simply happen at smaller units. In other words the system is steadily deflationary instead of the highly volatile inflationary system we currently have with fiat currencies.
- Hupriene 11y agoThe theoretical maximum money supply is 21 million. The actual amount of money in circulation can still vary wildly as keys to wallets containing bitcoins are lost (resulting in a permanent reduction of the maximum money supply) and as speculators cash out (resulting in a temporary increase in the effective money supply).
- dragontamer 11y agoMore importantly however, is the rent-seeking by BTC enthusiasts. BTC hoarders don't "deserve" any more wealth than later adopters, and yet wish to create wealth from nothingness and basically a giant Ponzi scheme. At least with stocks and companies, the stock actually means something: typically a vote for the board, or access to a dividend.
- Freak_NL 11y agoIt seems strange to consider a currency as a viable alternative for other currencies, when a sizeable chunk of the total available sum of it is owned by a single person or group simply because they came up with the system, and another large part is in the hands of speculators. There is nothing fair about a currency that is so volatile in value by design and is essentially speculative in nature. It is sad to see that this side of Bitcoin is not stressed more often.
- snowwrestler 11y ago> The problem however is that a nation's currency is arguably the primary source of it's sovereignty. The reverse is also true--any significant currency creates sovereignty by elevating the power of those with the greatest influence over that currency. In the case of Bitcoin, the "core" developers, in addition to the highest-volume miners, have been elevated to the sovereign position. Rather than a distributed stateless currency (which I would argue is impossible), what Bitcoin has become is a currency whose sovereigns are accidentally selected, poorly organized, and not responsible to its currency users in any direct way. There is a famous concept called the "tyranny of structurelessness," which says that there are always political structures when groups of humans interact, the question is just whether they are defined or hidden. A "structureless" organization, rather than egalitarian, is governed by a small secret clique that assembles for unknown or possibly trivial reasons. There are no clearly defined procedures for removing or adding sovereigns, or for adjudicating disagreements. Does this sound like Bitcoin? Based on the articles I've read this week, it does to me. Edit: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Tyranny_of_Structurelessness https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Tyranny_of_Structurelessne...
- nickbauman 11y agoExactly this. Humans have complex social structures. Notice, too, how the sorts of animals humans domesticate are animals with a strong social hierarchy. This is key: to control the lot, you must subjugate the leader. Famously, Zebras were never domesticated because they lack this hierarchy.
- nickbauman 11y agoThe US never really had commodity money. The Bretton Woods system had a merely theoretical commodity status. Nobody in the 1960's believed for a moment that the convertibility to gold was a real thing unless unwinding the entire monetary system was on the table.
- atmosx 11y ago> Back in 2009 when I was getting into bitcoin, it was widely described as a "stateless currency" and not just an alternative to Visa or credit cards. Having a background in economics, bitcoin looked to me like a truly revolutionary technology and if it was adopted en masse would change politics forever. No state or political entity will EVER support en masse a currency that it does not control and/or is NOT backed by another state with larger economy! In Sept 16 1992 the BoE withdraw the Pound from the ERM as a precaution after the most fierce attack the BGP ever received. The cost was ~ 3-5 Billion pounds. The GBP came out wounded, but it came out in one piece because the government had a say. Millions of people in the UK lost money indirectly, but the government was able to minimize the losses. Now imagine if the UK that day had the bitcoin, what would you have them do, block ISP traffic? How would you explain what happened to the population?! Using BTC as a state currency is not just anti-democratic, it is pure insanity.
- AndrewKemendo 11y agoWell this is the point. If private citizens adopted BTC over their nation's currency it would completely upend the political power structures - which arguably is the most democratic thing possible. No nation state would ever encourage it, but in theory it would flatten the world to the greatest extent ever - moreso than any transportation technology (shipping, airfreight etc...) ever.
- atmosx 11y agoYou might be confusing democracy with anarchy: in democracy everybody has a say in anarchy no one does, bitcoin is a lot like the later and none at all like the former.
- Frondo 11y agoIt wouldn't. If anything, it would vastly concentrate power further in the hands of a few--except this time, those few would be the miners and core developers. Say "the people" wanted to vote to increase the pool to 25 million coins, instead of 21. That is a pretty basic form of political power to exercise, saying "we want to change this structure that affects our lives, let's vote on it". How would "the people" hold that vote? The answers I've gotten in the past, when I ask this question, have been one of: * Just patch the software, and if 51% of the miners accept it, that's it! Or... * Currency shouldn't be under democratic control. Neither of those statements is anything like democracy. And those attitudes seem to be pretty prevalent in the bitcoin world. It's for that that I could never, ever endorse Bitcoin in any way. My interest is in pushing for a greater distribution of power--less concentration in the hands of a few--and doing so that actually engages with everyone, whoever they are, open source dev or not.
- nostrademons 11y agoI think many people overestimate the importance of currency because of the visibility it has. Because it represents the stored wealth that people have, people confuse it with wealth itself. The actual game of business is played out in the provision of goods & services that people want. Currency is the score. You need a means of keeping score in order to play the game, and when one doesn't exist, it will be created. And it helps if more people agree on the means of keeping score; it makes it easier for them to play together. But it doesn't really matter whether that's dollars or euros or pounds or drachmas or cigarettes. People use the currency that the people they want to play with use; the dollar is popular because many people want to play with the U.S. They don't adopt a new currency unless there is no alternative way of keeping score. The problem with Bitcoin is that most mainstream goods & services providers didn't really want to play with the people who used it. When they did, they went through intermediaries like Coinbase who immediately exchanged it for dollars. Bitcoin caught on because there was a vacuum in the currency space for people that wanted to trade illegal drugs or move money out of China. It fails because this vacuum doesn't extend to the majority of the population. It's worth remembering this when evaluating other emerging technologies. Look for what people want, places where there's a current lack of available solutions, and ignore the ones that theoretically could change everything if only large groups of people did things that aren't really in their personal interest.
- darkmighty 11y agoCurrency is not just the score, it allows for trades and a certain consensus to be achieved (absolute valuation of goods and services, i.e. total order of preference) that can't be achieved through simple peer to peer trading based on personal preference. Not to mention the inconvenience/logistical inefficiency of having to have a good that interests the seller of your desire, or finding a trading chain. I guess you could create a virtual trading chain that automatically resolves those conflicts (if I recall correctly that's more or less the idea of Ripple), but if the chain fails in the middle the transaction is compromised, and you now depend on a high level of network activity for a viable chain to allow you to trade.
- nostrademons 11y ago
- DickingAround 11y agoCurrencies don't need universal adoption to avoid 'failure'. If a group of people us it as a currency and it has exchange value to other currencies, then it's working as a currency.
- vacri 11y ago> It's like if we created Artificial General Intelligence and it decided to just write movie reviews forever. Bitcoin never had that potential. Regardless of it's theoretical capabilities, the general public would not have been able to use it effectively. It requires a computer, knowledge of digital security, the idea of 'backing up' your money and keeping that safe, and all-in-all, a new approach to handling money altogether (which also requires electronics on the user's part). The average member of the public could handle all this, sure, but half of people are below average. Bitcoin is also more difficult to understand than cash; there's a lot more mental overhead. Alternatively you can let a financial institution handle your bitcoin for you, but then there's no real difference between btc and dollars - at this point, they're just numbers on a ledger.
- makemonies 11y agoIt's 'Whoever', not 'Whomever'
- Udik 11y agoAnd "source of its sovereignty", not "it's". It might be silly, but I really can't stand that mistake.
- tim333 11y ago>a nation's currency is arguably the primary source of it's sovereignty Austria, Belgium, Cyprus, Estonia, Finland, France, Germany, Greece, Ireland, Italy, Latvia, Lithuania, Luxembourg, Malta, the Netherlands, Portugal, Slovakia, Slovenia, and Spain might disagree.