3 ms·
I know opiate addiction and death is a real problem, but do you have a source for the "kills more than saves per year" claim? I've never heard that before.
by MBCook 11y ago
I know opiate addiction and death is a real problem, but do you have a source for the "kills more than saves per year" claim? I've never heard that before.
- Retric 11y agoThey are very different numbers. A small number of new drugs get on the market every year vs. every drug that ever entered the market. One way of comparing these numbers is to look at changes in life expectancy. But that changes very slowly suggesting minimal change per year from one years new drugs. Actual deaths from prescription drugs are also hard to measure, but generally assumed at well over 20,000 per year. http://www.voxeu.org/article/genuine-innovation-new-drugs-save-lives http://www.voxeu.org/article/genuine-innovation-new-drugs-sa... Call it ~6-12 months lost vs. ~1-2 months gained. Though the clear upside is those gains should stack year over year. Just not when you compare introducing drugs a few months early as they would have made it to the market anyway. PS: The clear conflict of interest is the fairly short lifespan of drug patents.
- notahacker 11y agoIf there's any evidence that the 20k deaths per annum from prescription drugs come mostly from the development of new drugs, you haven't presented it. What you have presented is evidence that net of deaths from drugs, each year's new drugs offer an extra 2 months of life expectancy to those living in developed countries. By inference, a new regime which uniformly imposed a six month delay to drug development would cost a net 1 month of life expectancy per person. Across a population the size of the US, that's over 300 million months of human life expectancy, or an order of magnitude more whole human lives than your figure for all prescription drug deaths...
- Retric 11y agoIf you approve a bad new drug it's not just killing people for just one year. Opiates for example have been in use and killing people for a long time. Arguably, every drug death is a cost from approving some drug at some point in the past. It's true approving nothing would cost more lives, but that does not mean defaulting to accepting everything is a good idea either. After-all, Opiates are not known as a life saving drug, even if they prevent a lot of pain. Thus, the 20k+ or ~1% of all deaths are part of the accepted costs for our current system. Don't forget there are plenty of drugs that are not associated with any deaths.