4 ms·
Except, it's not brilliant, and we've been doing it for years. This post is a hollow re-tread of the "lower my taxes and I'll trickle it down" argument, which
by timr 17y ago
Except, it's not brilliant, and we've been doing it for years. This post is a hollow re-tread of the "lower my taxes and I'll trickle it down" argument, which has been the primary platform of the Republican party (and wealthy people) since I've been alive. Our tax rates are dramatically lower than they were even 20 years ago, and I have to say...it doesn't seem to be working that well.
Two observations that came immediately to mind while reading this post:
1) Accountants and lawyers are people with jobs. Fire them and replace them with non-accountant, non-lawyer jobs, and all you've done is shuffle the jobs around.
Yes, you can argue that every dollar spent on non-administrative expenses can be invested into productivity, but that leads me to my second observation:
2) Small businesses just don't spend that much on administrative overhead.
I've worked at far more small businesses (<20 employees) than large ones, and all of them -- every single one -- has out-sourced the accounting expenses to such a degree that I doubt there's a single full-time equivalent lost in the shuffle. Legal expenses can be more variable, but typically not because of government overhead.
When I hear this argument coming from extremely rich people, my natural instinct is to assume that they're using the populist vision of the "struggling small business owner" to promote policies that would benefit their personal bottom line. Quite honestly, this looks like more of the same. Mark Cuban has a lot more to gain from cuts in the corporate tax rate than does your average small business owner -- yet he'll never employ enough people to make up the difference.
- cwan 17y agoIt's not just administrative overhead, it's friction in getting things done. There is such a thing as objective value creation. The complexity of the tax code in the US has been increasing with ever larger loopholes to satisfy lobbyists and curry favor with various special interests. This isn't even about taxes - it's about simplifying something that shouldn't even be complex. Further, the irony is the people who lobby for the complexity are often the "extremely rich people". I don't know whether to laugh or cry at your argument that moving jobs from tax accounting/legal which attempt to manage friction in transactions to professions that create goods and services people actually want to pay for is just "shuffling the jobs around". As an extension of your argument, shouldn't the government employ everyone by fiat and simply abolish unemployment? This is especially made particularly absurd that the US Treasury Secretary couldn't even figure out how to pay his own taxes but now runs the IRS. There is something very very wrong with this picture.
- timr 17y ago"It's not just administrative overhead, it's friction in getting things done. There is such a thing as objective value creation." Yeah, which is why I said you could make that argument, and why I mentioned my second point -- small businesses just don't spend that much on this kind of thing. It's a red herring. "I don't know whether to laugh or cry at your argument that moving jobs from tax accounting/legal which attempt to manage friction in transactions to professions that create goods and services people actually want to pay for is just 'shuffling the jobs around'." You shouldn't laugh or cry, because it's just a statement of fact. I said that people who have jobs as accountants and lawyers are, by definition, people with jobs. So if you eliminate one accountant's job, and replace it with some other kind of job, you haven't increased the number of jobs. At best, you've made some small move toward "increasing productivity", which will then perhaps have a non-linear increase in other jobs, but that's an extremely tenuous argument for most small businesses. "As an extension of your argument, shouldn't the government employ everyone by fiat and simply abolish unemployment?" No. That would be stupid. It has nothing to do with my argument. " This is especially made particularly absurd that the US Treasury Secretary couldn't even figure out how to pay his own taxes but now runs the IRS. There is something very very wrong with this picture." Straw Man. I'm not arguing that the complexity of the tax code is a good thing; I'm arguing that reducing the complexity of the tax code is very different than "lowering the corporate tax rate". I'm also arguing that rich people like Mark Cuban have a disproportionate interest in doing the latter, in the guise of doing the former.
- cwan 17y agoSmall businesses do spend increasing amounts on tax accounting and legal. There's a very real and tangible cost to complexity in both regulations and taxation. "No. That would be stupid. It has nothing to do with my argument." You're right it would be a stupid argument except according to you, a job is a job. Not sure how it's even a tenuous argument to point out that reducing friction increases jobs as it not only frees up people who have to navigate the complexity - ie the tax accountants and lawyers to doing something more productive but it also reduces the costs of compliance for companies themselves. The US tax code is now over 16500 pages with non-compliance a criminal offense. I find it remarkable that you don't think there's an increasing cost to this compliance. Ask just about any internal accountant or anyone in a position of leadership and they'd tell you differently especially over the last 15 years.
- dantheman 17y agoReshuffling jobs from nonproductive to productive is a huge increase. Ask yourself, would you rather have less accountants and lawyers and have more people who actually produce something that makes your life better -- whether it be new software, improved medical care, better food, etc.
- timr 17y agoIt depends on context. When you think "small business", don't think "startup". Instead, think "neighborhood shop" -- these kinds of small businesses represent the vast majority of hiring, and they hire help in response to customer demand. So even if they could save the equivalent of one full-time employee on accounting and legal (an exaggeration, but let's go with it), they'd only re-invest that savings into other employees if it made sense to do so in light of current demand. The general problem I have with the assertion that lowering taxes will create jobs, is that it assumes that taxes are the limiting step. In my experience, that's not the case for small businesses. The much bigger problem is ensuring that customers are always walking in the door.
- dantheman 17y agoYes, but they'd have more money to spend. They'd be getting value for their money, whether it is expressed through corporate spending or through their personal spending. As it is right now their is giant drain on the us economy where people have to spend tons of money preparing taxes when a much simpler system could easily be used.
- lsc 17y agothe thing about lowering taxes is that other than through increased consumer spending, it does not free up more money for me (the business owner) to hire people. I pay people out of pre-tax money; I'm going to have the same amount of pre-tax money no matter if the tax rate on the money I pay myself is 20% or 70% Complexity, on the other hand, is paid for out of pre-tax money. If you go from me spending 10% of my pre tax money on accounting overhead to 20% of my pre-tax money on accounting overhead, that money comes out of my budget for employees and equipment. I mean, that money still goes to jobs, but those are /defensive/ jobs- I pay for an accountant, not because it gives me an advantage over the competition, because it does not. If anything, it slows me down. However, if I don't pay for the accountant, then I am at risk of being destroyed by the IRS. That is money I don't get to spend on beating my competition. Just looking, it appears that my accounting overhead is a noticeable fraction of my personnel costs. my personnel costs are dwarfed by equipment and power costs. So yeah, it isn't that bad. But still, if you ask me how the government could help my company, the first thing I would ask for, before tax cuts or subsidies or anything is for a reduction of the complexity of tax, employment, and other laws I need to deal with.
- fortes 17y ago> 2) Small businesses just don't spend that much on administrative overhead. I may not be a typical case, but this is false for my business. I am the founder and sole employee, although I have used contractors for jobs before. My first year, I spent at least 2-3 hours / week on average learning and dealing with the accounting and legal needs for having a corporation. There are a lot of agencies and each have their own rules. Just keeping up with all the tax law changes is a fair amount of work, nevermind the risk that you've misunderstood / forgot something. Obviously, it wasn't my full-time job, but it took a big enough chunk of my time (and therefore potential income) to be a real hassle. The next year, I outsourced much of it and ended up paying around $2,000 (not including the actual taxes and license fees). I realize that isn't much, but for a one-person entity that's a non-trivial amount of money. (yes, cost of doing business, blah, blah, blah ...)
- lionhearted 17y ago> This post is a hollow re-tread of the "lower my taxes and I'll trickle it down" argument, which has been the primary platform of the Republican party (and wealthy people) since I've been alive. Our tax rates are dramatically lower than they were even 20 years ago, and I have to say...it doesn't seem to be working that well. You don't think life has gotten much better for poor people over the last 20 years in the United States? I mean in absolute terms.
- lsc 17y agoSpeaking as a small business owner, (3 people) I'd prefer a higher tax with less complexity over a lower tax rate with more complexity. Yeah, I have an accountant who handles all that stuff for me. (Now, I should have a lawyer, but right now I honestly dont even know enough to know /when/ I should ask the lawyer, so I mostly rely on the fact that it's not worth suing a company with my revenue.) The problem is that when I have a new business idea, there are a myriad ways that intersects with tax law. I run all new business ideas past my accountant right now, because I'm wholly unqualified to understand that intersection. To give you an example, for most larger customers, it would make a lot of sense (well, they would pay less) if they bought hardware and I hosted it for them; the thing is, I can obtain high-ram hardware much cheaper than my customers can, and obviously, if it's exactly the same as all the other hardware I have I will be better equipped to manage it, as I have spare parts and experience with any problems the gear may have. So, the obvious idea is for me to sell the hardware to my customers, then charge them for manging said hardware. But apparently there are some complexities with sales tax (right now, I buy all my server parts retail... apparently there is some accounting complexity in then making sure that I keep track of drive with serial number X and how much I paid for it, then it went in server Y I sold for Z dollars.) Right now, I don't need to screw with sales tax; I just keep track of all the server parts I buy. Just doing that accounting easily doubles the work required to assemble a server. (server assembly isn't exactly /rocket science/ keep your ground strap on and you'll be fine.) So, I continue to rent servers rather than selling them, providing less value than I would have to the larger customers.
- timr 17y agoSales taxes are administered by the states. They have nothing to do with federal tax policy.
- pragmatic 17y agoYou've worked for a small business, but have you ever owned and/or ran one? The time I have to spend on government forms (taxes, business registration, etc) takes away time from other activities (SEO, new blog posts, software development). Yes, I can outsource this, but I still have to deal with it. And it adds no value for my customers. Accountants and Lawyers don't get software built, they don't get blog posts published. They handle my interaction with the government. At my current company (day job) we're spend a lot of time working out some stimulus package details. It's a bunch of overhead, we have to track our time on it, and for a reimbursement of 80 cents on the dollar. So, if you think that lawyers and accountants somehow get things to customers, yes, you have a valid argument. I haven't found that to be the case.
- pragmatic 17y agoLower taxes != less complex taxes. They've only gotten more complex. And this is too the benefit of large companies who can hide tax loopholes in the code. It also benefits the large accounting/tax companies. They will have a great business as long as we have a complex tax code. "IRS Commissioner Douglas Shulman does not file his own taxes in part because he believes the tax code is complex." http://thehill.com/blogs/blog-briefing-room/news/75119-irs-commissioner-doesnt-file-his-own-taxes http://thehill.com/blogs/blog-briefing-room/news/75119-irs-c...
- ellyagg 17y agoActually, it worked exceedingly well. I mean, breathtakingly well. Basically, the economy expanded incredibly, aside from a brief and mild recession at the end of elder Bush's tenure, from the time Reagan enacted his tax cuts, to midway through younger Bush's presidency. Reagan experienced an unparalleled peacetime expansion and then Clinton broke his record. We are in a recession now, but it's pretty hard to link a causal chain including tax cuts to it. In fact, we know exactly what caused our current situation, and no one thinks it was "the tax rate was too low".