15 ms·
Urban highways destroy wealth
- gerbilly 11y agoOriginal in French here: http://kchozeurbaine.blogspot.ca/2014/02/les-autoroutes-urbaines-en-valent-elles.html http://kchozeurbaine.blogspot.ca/2014/02/les-autoroutes-urba...
- nashashmi 11y agoTL;DR version: - Urban highways cost more money than urban transit - They divide cities logistically. - Introduce pollution - Are very unsightly to neighborhoods - Steal traffic from roads in commercial zones and undermine regional commercial activity. - Put emphasis on car-first neighborhoods and businesses (which give little ROI). - Encourage urban sprawl and community inefficiency. My take: These points are understood and expected from urban highways, but then again urban highways were meant to solve a different problem. The points are simply what the solution costs.
- chad_oliver 11y agoWhat problem were they meant to solve? (That's a serious question. I'm interesting in hearing how other people view the purpose of an urban highway.)
- jff 11y agoThe problem of getting from one side of town to the other very quickly, without clogging up the "walkable neighborhoods" in the middle, with their narrow streets and wide sidewalks. The people going through get on the highway, out of the way of the people actually living in the town.
- stuaxo 11y agoIn the UK we have built bypasses for most towns and most of the traffic goes around them instead of through.
- arethuza 11y agoThat's generally true with Glasgow being a notable counter example - fortunately the equivalent designs for Edinburgh were never implemented: http://www.gcat.org.uk/blog/?tag=edinburgh-motorways http://www.gcat.org.uk/blog/?tag=edinburgh-motorways
- marcosdumay 11y agoIn Brazil, every city bypass we build becomes the new city center in about a decade. The city just moves there.
- jff 11y agoAnd we all saw how well that worked out for Arthur Dent! I'm a fan of ring roads, Rochester for instance had a small inner loop and a much wider outer loop of freeways (with freeway segments and decent arterials connecting the inner to the outer, it looked kind of like a wagon wheel) that meant you could get almost anywhere pretty quickly.
- jacobolus 11y agoRochester has an extremely sad downtown area, because it’s tightly encircled by highways killing any connection to the surrounding areas, and it was turned into an office park filled with parking lots. Only a few blocks (where there are students) have any kind of vibrancy. For anyone who doesn’t have a car, it’s the perfect dystopian nightmare. A great illustration of what the article under discussion in this thread was talking about. It was much more of a real city up through about 1950. This comparison shot is striking: http://iqc.ou.edu/2015/01/21/60yrsnortheast/ http://iqc.ou.edu/2015/01/21/60yrsnortheast/ At least they’re trying now though, http://www.cityofrochester.gov/InnerLoopEast/ http://www.cityofrochester.gov/InnerLoopEast/
- hydrogen18 11y agoDoesn't the UK have zoning laws that prevent the city from gravitating towards the bypass?
- kevinnk 11y agoI'm not an expert but I'd imagine the biggest advantages are: Faster travel within the city itself. Easier to move in and out of the city. Reducing rush hour traffic on local streets.
- astrodust 11y agoThat's the theory, but due to induced demand the opposite tends to happen. Travel in the city gets slower because there's more traffic, it becomes harder to move into and out of the city due to increases in commuter activity, and rush-hour traffic on local streets gets worse as more people try and funnel into these highways.
- pmiller2 11y agoI would think it's primarily moving people from point A to point B (or, possibly from point C to point D via some stretch in between A and B). [Begin Rant] This brings up the biggest problem I have with Bay Area public trasnportation. I live 11 miles from work, but it's impossible to get there via any reasonable public transportation-based route in less than 1 hour. On flat land, I can bike at least 50% faster than that, in normal clothes, without breaking a sweat. The BART portion of my trip takes around 25 minutes. Once I get off BART, my choices are basically to take Muni or walk. Walking gets me there reliably in around 25-30 minutes. Muni theoretically gets me there in around 15 minutes, but that's in an ideal world where there are no delays on the line and I don't have to wait to transfer. I'd rather end the day $2.25 richer and get the little bit of exercise than save a whole 15 minutes. And, of course, the same goes for the trip home. People who live in, say, the Outer Sunset and commute to SOMA or the Financial District have even worse options. Your Muni trip involves taking 2 or 3 buses, and there's no other reasonable way to make the commute than drive (and we know how miserable and expensive driving in SF is). [End Rant]
- awjr 11y agoBART + fold-up bicycle?
- kaybe 11y agoOr/And, if safe storage exists at both ends, bicycle with electric support, which should increase the no-sweat speed even further.
- pmiller2 11y agoElectric and fold-up are both decent options. I rate them both above taking Muni and below just walking for myself. It still irks me that I can't just hop off a train at Embarcadero and onto a local BART train to somewhere closer to work. Once again, as in so many other situations, the last mile is the killer. :(
- AngrySkillzz 11y ago
- jesstaa 11y agoUrban highways solve a political problem. When you have voters that spend a hour or so a day stuck in traffic it's really easy to sell them the idea that a highway will reduce traffic congestion without them having to change anything about their daily routine (ie. take public transport, bicycle, walk) Since the highway will only reduce traffic congestion for a short time it's something you can sell to the voters again at the next election.
- tremon 11y agoWhen you have voters that spend a hour or so a day stuck in traffic it's really easy to sell them the idea that a highway will reduce traffic congestion without them having to change anything about their daily routine That's disingenuous. I commute by car exactly because public transport takes longer to most of my clients, even when including structural and incidental traffic jams. It's happened exactly three times in the last five years that my car commute took longer than public transport would have taken. And on one of those occasions (excessive snowfall), most trains were canceled too.
- lagadu 11y agoThat only speaks to the inadequacy of the public transportation network where you live though, which is exacerbated by the construction of urban highways instead of a better mass transit network.
- tremon 11y agoIt's probably more that my situation doesn't match the topic under discussion. I live in an urban area, whereas many clients are in the rural areas surrounding it. Servicing those areas with mass transit would be prohibitively expensive: there is no mass traffic to service.
- lmm 11y agoGood mass transit that got cars off congested roads would speed your kind of journey just as much as building urban motorways, and be more effective overall.
- HillRat 11y agoAt least in major Southern cities, the problem was often "the blacks." Highway locations were often chosen to cut off less-desirable neighborhoods from city centers and more upscale residential neighborhoods. (I-30 in Dallas and the proposed I-485 in Atlanta, and arguably Robert Moses' Cross Bronx Expressway all come to mind.) Today, the need for highways hasn't gone away, but more enlightened urban planning and urban gentrification means that cities are finding ways to either relocate or ameliorate the effects of those roads -- though the expense is significant.
- jacobolus 11y agoThey were meant to get people from far out of the city into the city, fast, in a way that would only be accessible to professional-class whites, so that they could keep downtown jobs while moving their families to the suburbs and stop spending their property tax money on poor brown people.
- superuser2 11y agoHe's not exaggerating: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/White_flight#Roads https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/White_flight#Roads Urban highways in the US are a facet of the American Dream vision of the suburbs as "a safe place to raise your kids," which is basically a euphemism for "far away from the scary minorities who live in cities."
- dinkumthinkum 11y agoWell, out of curiosity, do you think suburbs are actually safer than inner cities?
- gr3yh47 11y agocrime data would seem to indicate so
- splitrocket 11y agoHowever, mortality data would disagree. Generally speaking, in cities you are more likely to be the victim of homicide and crime. In suburban and rural environments you are substantially more likely to be killed/injured in general. http://science.time.com/2013/07/23/in-town-versus-country-it-turns-out-that-cities-are-the-safest-places-to-live/ http://science.time.com/2013/07/23/in-town-versus-country-it...
- rhino369 11y agoThat only accounts for city vs rural. It never says where suburbs fall on that scale. If they are going based on US government definitions, suburbs are mostly considered urban (1000 people/sq mile or more).
- SFjulie1 11y agoShortening the time it takes to go from north to south. All island are plagued with the "points of entries and congestions". Montréal is 30x40km island. With limited bridges. So by making a large artery that almost lead people from bridge to bridge (N/S) you may think you can create a traffic that will not interfere with the inter urban traffic... (laminarizing) thus getting rid of intra congestion. (Since it is in a trench and has bridges on top). But it also creates opportunities (like with real estates part) that have adverse consequences. And vortex around the entry points. It also create ruptures in the city that artificially recreates partitions. Thus recreating "islands" in the island. Maybe not for cars, I admit. It also generates more pressure on the outside bridge thus congestion at the edge of the city that are way more expensive to solve. Which make montréal famous for its traffic jam when commuters leave/come. Regarding the inside near décarie : not all inhabitants have cars some are not rich enough. And it is destroying local area business (thus jobs for the guy already plagued). Thus parts maybe gradually abandoned (unused infra decay faster) in the blocks near Decarie, and ... well, it does not attract neither business, nor wealthy inhabitants. So it is like a decaying scorch in the city, infra that still require maintaining with less income ... slowly draining money by fiscal pressure (no perequation between districts) ... making people leave ... (vicious circle) I am really puzzled by the way engineers model flux in the city. I would really like to understand the bug in their brain. Probably education + "a one best way and no need to measure"
- JackFr 11y agoWith regard to the island problem, in Manhattan any bridge or tunnel which leads from a highway and primarily dumps you onto a local streets has a toll on the way in. This is expressly a throttling measure, as it's considered better to have a traffic jam on the highway going in rather than gridlock -- literal gridlock -- on the local streets.
- SFjulie1 11y agoWell, it makes sense. Why don't all city/stated paid engineers paid with public money don't work like and open knowledge community? A medieval based city (Europe) is often with bridges on a river. US squared big cities are often on rivers. And probably the same everywhere. Flux congestion due to bi partition of graphs is such a common pattern out there. The rivers are here because they were normal way of communications transport. But if it is not a river, it can be highways, mountains... I may be an idiot but google does not show papers, or stackoverflow, or public conference when I search for "how to solve traffic congestion in city with a bridge". Every single city fight the problem on their own. Why isn't this problem on the public place? My answer is engineers don't have the right culture. They believe in canonical ways of doing and do not accept to be scrutinized or share. Engineers nowadays are for me like a medieval corporation stuck to defend their own privileges at the expand of the community. Maybe it is time to question the education system that build experts. Science is the belief in the ignorance of the experts.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- marcosdumay 11y agoI don't know what they were created for, but today they solve the problem of making a city grow integrated, instead of like a lot of small (probably poorer) cities near each other. And they are the best tool for that job. The problem is that they alone are not enough, but any other option alone won't be nearly as good.
- Zach_the_Lizard 11y agoThere was a political problem. The interstates were spending truly ungodly sums of money in rural area; the whole system cost something like $400 billion - $500 billion in inflation adjusted dollars. If you were a city, your residents--who tended to be wealthier than rural areas--were footing the bill and getting nothing in return except maybe somewhat lower shipping costs. So what's a politician to do? Easy: extend the highways to cities. In the 1950s the thought was that cars were going to lead us to a glorious future, free from congestion on public transit, so urban leaders gladly paved over their downtowns. There were (and still are) huge subsidies for suburban areas, and other fears were that without these highways cities would be irrelevant as everyone moved to the suburbs and jobs eventually moved with them. In the wake of the planning failures of the 50s and 60s with regards to highways cities moved huge amounts of planning powers to hyperlocal areas and requiring environmental reviews, stopping all the highway nonsense. Unfortunately, it created a new villain in the form of the newly empowered NIMBY.
- ihsw 11y agoHow do you reconcile urban sprawl with the sorry state of urban transit? Wealthier residents categorically avoid urban transit in many major municipalities because they are generally unsightly (dirty, littered with ads) at worst and generally unreliable (complete and total lack of consistency in travel times and distances from homes) at best.
- rayiner 11y agoWealthier residents generally avoid urban transit simply because they do not live in urban areas. Post white-flight, cities are generally quite a bit poorer than their surrounding suburbs. Cities that were built before that phenomenon (e.g. NYC), have good transit that even wealthier residents use.
- SFjulie1 11y agoTL; DR $ person transported/km for highways >> subway For all the cons you quoted. Living in montréal, biking all year. The problem is much more the diffusion of the flux (aggravated by graph partition and an asymmetry of rules making turning left strongly discouraged). They don't seem to have any engineers studying hydrodynamics, percolation, diffusion or geometry or physics in their offices. They reason in terms of big arteries and making car go consistently fast there (50) and construction costs and rely on magic for congestion and diffusion. Riding a bike feels like you are gonna die every morning. Especially in winter. They weirdly enough make expensive dangerous bike paths to solve the problem that are more likely to cause accidents than none. And they evaluate that a fall from a bike make cyclists safe with a 50 cm security distance (I am quite taller and when I fall, it is much more 1m20 margin). Let's say that even if some jerks found it funny to scare cyclists and sometimes bump them, on the 99.99% distribution they are nice people but a tad forgetting to watch there mirrors when opening their 50 cm doors in my 80 cm "safe" space on the streets. Had some bruises, fears, strong words and went to the hospital get my wife after some accidents. Still alive, though. Still alive. Pretty proud of us and faster/cheaper than most transportations (car and subways included).
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- VLM 11y agoAlso both subways and highways have identical maintenance and operation costs of zero, which is kinda weird.
- lnanek2 11y agoHaving some trouble swallowing this paragraph: " The richest metropolitan areas in the US are San José, San Francisco, Seattle, Boston, Washington, Houston, New York, Portland, Hartford and Salt Lake City. Areas with relatively few urban highways are overrepresented in that list, with Houston being the one big exception. " When I need to get anywhere in New York, most of the time I am better off grabbing the west side highway or the FDR rather than going through the grid and hitting traffic lights and gridlock constantly. So that's two highways, one on either side of a 2.3 mile wide (at most) island and then 95 crosses it at the top. San Francisco similarly has elevated 280 and 80, and 101 mostly on the ground with some lights slowing it. At least SF is much bigger than Manahattan for similar amount of highways to help his point. I get the feeling he just isn't from the US and doesn't know anything about our cities, though, so that paragraph is just way off.
- GFK_of_xmaspast 11y agoWhen I think of major US cities that are under-served with urban highways, the one that immediately comes to mind is Baltimore (granted, I-95 goes thru, and I-83 (81?) dead-ends near downtown, but otherwise good luck). For the ones he's mentioned DC's got big sections that aren't well served by highways, but there is still the beltway, the BW parkway/I295, I395, the southeast freeway. I don't know Hartford that well, but it's got two major interstates going thru. I wonder what "relatively few" means, and what some examples of cities with "relatively many" highways would be.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- jdminhbg 11y ago> When I think of major US cities that are under-served with urban highways, the one that immediately comes to mind is Baltimore (granted, I-95 goes thru, and I-83 (81?) dead-ends near downtown, but otherwise good luck). I-83 ends downtown. There's also 695 (the beltway), 395 (from 95 to the stadiums/downtown), 895 (Harbor tunnel), and 195 (BWI airport connector). It's never felt underserved highway-wise to me, but I've never actually lived there, just visited a lot.
- shrewduser 11y agoso what, i'm not supposed to have any good way to cut across the city and get to the airport? also in the world of automated cars we're about to enter i would think the amount of people you can transport via freeway would far outstrip rail, not to mention that there are obvious consumer preferences. I love rail, but i feel like we're about to see rail become far less pervasive with automated cars / busses etc coming online. it will just be that much more convenient to get to where you're going.
- lagadu 11y agoMetro. It's also the fastest, cheapest and most convenient way to get to the airport in the cities I've lived in. Not affected by traffic either.
- masklinn 11y ago> so what, i'm not supposed to have any good way to cut across the city and get to the airport? If you come from inside the city, the city could (and should) have the transportation necessary. If you come from outside the city, the article is only about intra-urban highways, not about circular roads to go around the city if you just need to go through to the other side. > also in the world of automated cars we're about to enter i would think the amount of people you can transport via freeway would far outstrip rail That makes very little sense. > I love rail, but i feel like we're about to see rail become far less pervasive with automated cars / busses etc coming online. it will just be that much more convenient to get to where you're going. I'd expect the opposite. With full car automation you remove the necessity for car ownership and parking, this means you can easily get automated transport to a hub, then use public transport from there. That's especially the case for intra-urban transport, even in cities with good intra-urban public transport there is very limited capacity and convenience to leave your car on the outskirt and jump on light rail or metro if you come from the suburbs or from a neighbouring city. Automated cars fix this, you just leave the car and it goes do something else, the other way around you can notify the system that you'll need a car when your traincar reaches whichever station, and it can wait you there.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- csomar 11y agoIs it me or the author is simply making assumptions based on his "intelligent point of view". Here is my version: Urban highways create unparalleled amounts of wealth. By enabling people, businessman, police, firefighters to get from point A to point B faster; they boost the economy. They also reduce pollution, since you are not stuck in traffic. But hey, I have no data to back this up.
- kchoze 11y agoI admit that data is hard to find, but that's not a reason to discount rational exploration of this issue. There's plenty of anecdotal cases for it, just see the devastation of Detroit, for example. As to your claim, throwaway as it may have been, here is why I think it to be wrong. First of all, police, firefighters and other public services rarely use highways in urban areas. The reason for that is that urban highways are few in number due to their monumental construction costs, so each highway tends to be a few miles away from the nearest parallel highway. As a result, going from A to B in the same city is often faster on arterials than on highways for trips that are 6 miles or less, because the detour to access the highway is longer than the time gain from using it. Second, highways do speed up longer distance travel, but how much of a benefit is it really? That depends on the kind of travel. As I wrote in the article, rural highways that connect regions together serve an important economic role by helping to speed up the transport of goods and people between them. However, commuting is quite a different beast, because with regards to commuting, there is a phenomenon called "Marchetti's constant", people tend to make choices of location for their residence and their workplace to maintain a commute time of roughly 30 minutes on average, because people understand distance as travel time, not as actual distance. So when you speed up travel inside a metropolitan area (from suburb to city/other suburb), what you do is that you incite people to live further and further away from their workplace and from the stores they patronize. Therefore, urban highways do not really lead to a reduction of commute times overall (some may have that benefit, but rarely is it generalized) but rather to an increase in distance driven. Which leads to more pollution (though often less concentrated), higher transport costs and a development pattern that makes transit non-viable, therefore forcing people to buy cars to access jobs and services. An example of this is that in 1972, a study of commuting time and distance revealed that the average commuting time for people commuting 20-24 miles to work was 36 minutes, just 6 minutes more than for people commuting 11-14 miles. In other words, an increase of commute distance of 100% was associated by an increase in commute time of just 20%. http://www.nber.org/chapters/c8824.pdf http://www.nber.org/chapters/c8824.pdf (table 6.7, page 19 of pdf) So higher speed was correlated with longer commute distances AND with longer commute times. Correlation is not causation, but that should give people pause when they claim to want faster roads to reduce commute times. So higher mode share for cars and greater distance traveled means more pollution, more wealth expanded just to provide transport (which consumption, like electricity, has no good in and of itself). That's a drain on the economy. Now, because I'm nice, I'll give you one thing: highways allow cities farther away to become economically integrated, resulting in much bigger metro areas. Since much of the modern economy gains from concentrating people and resources in an economically integrated area, this may be seen as a positive. However, what we've seen in Asia and Europe is that in the absence of highways, metro areas can still be just as populous, concentrating as many people and resources in one economically-integrated region... that region just happens to be much more compact, often concentrated around train stations, with highways going around inhabited areas, connecting industrial areas, serving essentially for trips to and from other regions.
- mladenkovacevic 11y agoI always had this idea for a highway conversion that makes it into a sort of a railway for individual cars. SO imagine you drive on your local streets until you get to this "highway". Then via some mechanism (something like the drive-through car wash but more heavy duty obviously), you merge onto the highway and get pulled by electric motors (perhaps even motors within your own car) along with all the other cars. You can then relax in your car, read, nap or watch videos until you are taken out at your exit ramp. No pollution, no grid-lock, no accidents. Just a smooth ride all the way to within 2-5km from your destination.
- euphemize 11y agoLiving in Montréal, I'm happy to see this article. The highways / traffic situation is horrible here, but I will point to one example in particular. Getting to the airport: there is no way to get to the airport easily. There is a dedicated bus line that might get stuck in traffic for 10$, or you pay 35$ for Uber, or 50$ for a normal cab (which also might both get stuck in traffic). You need to plan at least 2 hours from your house to get there, often 3 hours in advance for your flight. I've taken the bus dozens of time, and you can see the faces of the poor passengers, realizing they thought 1h to get 20KM away would be enough. I go back and forth to Amsterdam and the difference is embarrassing. I get to Schiphol, hop on a train (every 5 mins), it costs 5 euros and I'm at Central Station in 15 minutes. Light train? metro extension? How hard can it be?
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- mbcrower 11y agoHighways are only useful because there are so many of them that connect just about every community in the contiguous US - what economists call a "network effect". Therefore adding a new highway tends to make the other highways and roads it's connected to more useful. Likewise, public transit systems like the NYC subway are useful because there are so many of them. When the first train is built in a metro area, it's not going to be useful to very many people. As more lines are built, however, that first train line becomes useful to more people because they can transfer to another line, or a bus line. As the third and fourth lines are built, the marginal utility of that each new mile of tracks goes up as the train becomes feasible for more people. Of course there are examples of both highways and trains that probably shouldn't have been built where they were built (http://streets.mn/2014/07/07/strangulation-on-the-green-line/ http://streets.mn/2014/07/07/strangulation-on-the-green-line...). My point is that cost comparisons of building a new highway versus building a new train are skewed by the fact that most metro areas have a mature (even crumbling...but that's another point) highway system, but few is the US have a large network of public transit yet, other than buses that are often slow, late and dirty.