2 ms·
"If SF weren't such a liberal city, it would have far fewer homeless." Sorry, but that's an argument that you have to prove, with actual facts. You can't simp
by timr 17y ago
"If SF weren't such a liberal city, it would have far fewer homeless."
Sorry, but that's an argument that you have to prove, with actual facts. You can't simply assert your worldview to be true.
Could the homelessness problem in SF be caused by excessive social services? Sure, I suppose it could. But it could also easily be caused by the incredibly moderate weather (which makes it possible to live on the streets year-round, without fear of freezing to death -- many cities with moderate climates have similar problems). Or, for that matter, the homelessness problem could be due to the absolutely insane cost of living, and a lack of social services.
I don't know the cause of the problem, but I'd still wager that it's a bit more complicated than a simple-minded theory involving the politics of the city government. I also question the premise of any theory that assumes that the homeless and mentally ill (neither of whom are highly mobile populations) are packing up and heading west explicitly to take advantage of the "liberal" social services in San Francisco.
- neilc 17y agoWell, one data point: "38% of homeless survey respondents reported that they first became homeless outside of San Francisco or were relative newcomers, having lived in the City for three months or less." And that's actually a significant decrease from the 2007 survey. http://www.sfgov.org/site/uploadedfiles/lhcb/homeless_count/SF2009HomelessCountFINALReport.pdf http://www.sfgov.org/site/uploadedfiles/lhcb/homeless_count/...
- ardit33 17y agoSan Diego has much better weather than SF, yet there are no homeless there. People there are more centrist/republican leaning. So Weather is not the reason bums come to SF. But the lunatic support the city gives to the homeless. Last time they counted, 2/3 of the homeless were not from California at all. SF, is like a homeless mecca. http://www.sfweekly.com/2009-12-16/news/the-worst-run-big-city-in-the-u-s/ http://www.sfweekly.com/2009-12-16/news/the-worst-run-big-ci...
- lg 17y agoi wondered about that. i suspect that SD actively tries to get rid of them. the cops there seemed pretty aggressive.
- dmv 17y agoYou replied to a comment about backing assertions up with facts, with "yet there are no homeless there". I do not live in San Diego, and "there" implies that neither do you. So let's look at facts before making points through assertion? The top 5 hits for "homeless san diego" yields the following organizations: http://www.sdrescue.org/ http://www.sdrescue.org/ http://sdhomeless.org/ http://sdhomeless.org/ http://www.alphaproject.org/ http://www.alphaproject.org/ http://www.rtfhsd.org/ http://www.rtfhsd.org/ And the latter two provide immediately accessible numbers. Alpha Project "is a nonprofit human services organization that serves over 2,000 men, women, and children each day." The Regional Taskforce for Homelessness in San Diego published a 2009 overview (PDF, http://www.rtfhsd.org/pdf/PITC09.pdf http://www.rtfhsd.org/pdf/PITC09.pdf) indicating at least 7892 counted within the San Diego area, at least 4338 in San Diego City. Those are facts, and they took one minute to acquire. If your point was that there were less per capita, I cannot argue with that as I do not have comps.
- timr 17y agoWell said. Also, the article he linked had absolutely nothing to do with homelessness. Even if we assume San Francisco to be a horribly governed place, it doesn't automatically mean that the social services lead to homelessness.
- drm237 17y ago"better" is relative. Sure the winters would be nice for living outdoors, but the summers would likely kill you.