4 ms·
Suppose the following idea was put to vote: Confiscate the wealth of the top 1% of Americans and redistribute it by dividing it up equally among the remaining
by grandalf 17y ago
Suppose the following idea was put to vote: Confiscate the wealth of the top 1% of Americans and redistribute it by dividing it up equally among the remaining 99%.
Each of the 99% would get a check for about $500,000.00
Would it be in the best interest of the 99% to vote "yes" on such a proposal?
Only if you look at the short term outcome. After a while, the economy would be seriously harmed, not just because others would not seek wealth if it could be confiscated like that, and also because in capitalism wealth flows to those who add value by helping others get what they want.
The healthcare reform debate is similar. While in the short term health care reform will help people who can't afford expensive care, it will slow innovation (propelled by the profit motive) and will encourage people to engage in expensive (in terms of healthcare costs) lifestyle choices.
- yungchin 17y agoI really wouldn't know if you're right or wrong about healthcare reform, but in the context of the BBC article, I wonder: do you think many voters made their decisions based on the sort of arguments that you put forward here? I'm inclined to believe that indeed they went with a gut feeling that had very little to do with economic analyses. I should note though, that while the article's theory seems very plausible to me, the supporting evidence is merely anecdotal. There must be more meaty research on voter behaviour out there, I hope...
- rue 17y ago> Only if you look at the short term outcome. After a while, the economy would be seriously harmed, not just because others would not seek wealth if it could be confiscated like that, ... This line of reasoning only makes sense if your premise is that wealth can be created from nothing and does not correspond to actual resources available/needed.
- jnovek 17y ago"After a while, the economy would be seriously harmed" I would imagine that the economy would be immediately harmed as the meaning of value is contextual -- how much is a banana worth if everyone suddenly has the same amount of money? In the long term, I think things would stabilize as a new economy emerged.
- Zak 17y agoIn the long term, society would stabilize if you killed half the population. Stabilization does not imply a lack of harm.
- joe_the_user 17y agoI submit that you are correct about Zimbabwe-style confiscation policies being disastrous for an economy. Aside from the other points ....the economy would be further harmed by a massive inflation fueled by all that excess cash chasing the same number of consumer goods. But at the same time it's true that the degree of distinction between rich and poor at the moment is still highly detrimental to American society as contrasted to either contemporary Scandinavia or American in 1955. Indeed, it's extremes like present American wealth disproportionalities that can make Zimbabwean confiscation seem more appealing to the majority regardless of one might rationally argue with them (one can look at Latin America for a lot of example here). Just as much, I'd mention that there have umpteen versions of health care reform in the debate and they cannot all be mechanically compared to simplistic confiscation. Further consider that neither the US public education system nor the US highway system have not been economic disasters for the US and the British NHS provide health far more cheaply than the US health care non-system provides. That said, I would admit that the particular compromise bill that has come out of Congress is pretty much a statist disaster in the making (though hopefully now in the unmaking). Also, it's worth noting that America's current private-public system is more or less the worst of both worlds. The majority of private companies aren't innovators but parasites on government funding while the government doesn't have the mandate to directly distribute any goods. Either pure free enterprise or state health care could be an improvement IF either could start from a clean slate - but naturally that won't happen regardless.
- ErrantX 17y agoWhile in the short term health care reform will help people who can't afford expensive care, it will slow innovation (propelled by the profit motive) and will encourage people to engage in expensive (in terms of healthcare costs) lifestyle choices. Im not sure, though, that is the reasoning driving this populist opposition. This healthcare reform business has seemed a bit of a mess for me, living in the UK. To us the new proposals seemed like common sense and "I thought everyone did it that way". The mass opposition was unexpected (at least for me anyway).
- fadmmatt 17y agoJust curious where you got the number $500,000 I've heard ballpark estimates that the total wealth of the U.S., the sum of all assets (bridges, buildings, companies, cars) minus debts is roughly $80-$90 trillion. Wikipedia seems to think it's nearer to $60 trillion. Assuming $90 trillion and 300mil people, if we divided up the wealth of everyone (not just the top 1%) and redstributed, we'd only get to $300,000 per person. If the top 1% hold a third of all wealth, you've got at most $100,000 per person.
- Zak 17y agoI imagine he made it up. The number itself doesn't matter; you probably believe it is in your interest to have an extra $100,000.