3 ms·
> The card may have been released in 2007 but the system was purchased new in 2012. You purchased a 5 year old Vista machine in 2012? If it was actually from
by Someone1234 11y ago
> The card may have been released in 2007 but the system was purchased new in 2012.
You purchased a 5 year old Vista machine in 2012?
If it was actually from 2012 you wouldn't have needed to spend "£100+" for Windows 8, it would have shipped with it. Not to mention that in 2012 Windows 8 upgrade only cost £14.99[0] for the upgrade edition (the promotion ended January 31st 2013).
> Yet clearly MS know that's not the case (now if not at release).
They don't "clearly [.] know that." They don't go through and test every piece of hardware one by one. They often just depend on what the manufacturer of that hardware (namely Nvidia) tells them. In this case Nvidia offered drivers for XP, Vista, and Windows 7 (32 and 64). They did not offer drivers for 8/8.1 or 10.
So Microsoft looks up the device, the device doesn't have a compatible driver, so they decide not to upgrade. Last thing Microsoft need is a bunch of threads about how "Microsoft broke my computer during upgrade!!!" The Windows 7 driver mostly works, and that is great, but Microsoft has no way of knowing that without testing every piece of potential hardware one by one.
> What do you call false statements made to increase sales if not fraud?
Microsoft made none.
This is one of those "damned if they do, and damned if they don't" situations. If they do what you want and are more liberal with upgrades (e.g. upgrade anything with a working Windows 7 driver) then there is a real chance they could effectively upgrade people's computer to a version of the OS which the hardware doesn't support, however if they don't upgrade those computers then people moan about "fraud" and "lies."
[0] http://www.techradar.com/us/news/computing/microsoft-confirms-windows-8-upgrade-offer-uk-pricing-1084035 http://www.techradar.com/us/news/computing/microsoft-confirm...
- pbhjpbhj 11y ago>You purchased a 5 year old Vista machine in 2012?// New motherboards with the geforce7025/nforce630a chipset are currently on sale even now. Not that it's pertinent to whether MS made false statements but my elderly father purchased the machine and it seems paid for the OS as a line item, it was not an upgrade but a non-OEM install at the full price advertised by MS. None of that is pertinent really. >> [pbhjpbhj] What do you call false statements made to increase sales if not fraud? > [Someone1234] Microsoft made none The upgrade now nag screen said the machine was "unable to run" Windows 10. That is categorically false. The presence of the 'but never mind you can buy a new computer from us with this link' on the nag screen suggests a motive which I'm inclined to agree with. If they don't know whether a particular hardware arrangement works or not then they shouldn't state twice that it doesn't, they should say "your hardware may not work" or "your hardware is unsupported" or "we don't consider your hardware to work well enough" or something else that is actually true. The motive isn't a fact but the lie is.
- Someone1234 11y ago> New motherboards with the geforce7025/nforce630a chipset are currently on sale even now. So is a mint condition boxed Apple II+ from 1977 (for $1,400). Why doesn't Windows 10 run on that? You can still buy a new motherboard with a 7025 but they're still from five years ago. They're just old inventory sitting in a warehouse somewhere. > The upgrade now nag screen said the machine was "unable to run" Windows 10. That is categorically false. It is more true than false. It has a graphics card in it that has no compatible Windows 10 drivers available. The fact it runs at all is surprising, and considering these are completely automated messages it is completely understandable why Microsoft would relay that message. MOST users with a machine like your father's would be better off not upgrading to Windows 10, because compatibility cannot be assured. It could break their computer. > If they don't know whether a particular hardware arrangement works or not then they shouldn't state twice that it doesn't, they should say "your hardware may not work" or "your hardware is unsupported" or "we don't consider your hardware to work well enough" or something else that is actually true. I will grant that it could be worded more carefully. The upgrade agent shouldn't allow people to proceed, however, the wording could be constructed differently. Overall I don't have a whole lot of sympathy. This is a free upgrade. Nobody is forcing you to take it, and nobody owes you anything because it wasn't compatible.