3 ms·
Ask HN: Microsoft lied about upgradability of our computer, how mad should we be?
My father's Microsoft Windows 8 computer had the Windows 10 upgrade prompt as expected but when followed it said it wasn't possible to upgrade because his Nvidia graphics (GeForce 7025/ NVIDIA nForce 630a) was "unable to run Windows 10" and that Nvidia was responsible for not making it "compatible".
Note they didn't say it was just "not supported" but that it was _unable_ to run and was incompatible.
An example image of the error is shown here, http://ivanrf.com/en/nvidia-compatibility-issue-with-windows-10/ (nvidia-compatibility-windows-10-01-en.jpg).
Note Microsoft in their misleading error message give a handy link allowing you to purchase a new computer from them ... how, er, convenient.
The only thing is that the computer is completely able to run Windows 10. Running the upgrade using a Microsoft tool that was easily downloaded the computer ran, even without driver upgrade (albeit with reduced graphics) and after a simple graphics driver update (with an Nvidia.com downloaded installer) was fully working.
Clearly Microsoft lied in saying that the upgrade was impossible, their tool did it perfectly.
What should the response to this sort of fraud be? I wonder how many users like my father assumed they had to get a new computer to get Windows 10?
- smt88 11y ago> What should the response to this sort of fraud be? I really wouldn't assume it was fraud. Margins aren't that amazing on hardware, and it's very possible that Microsoft has more of an interest in having your father on Win 10 than selling him a new laptop. In fact, Microsoft's hardware business is supposedly just to make sure that flagship Windows machines exist, not to make Microsoft the premier vendor or have the largest market share. This false negative was probably A) a bug, B) a design flaw in the installer that told you whether the PC could run Win 10, or C) Microsoft covering their asses. In the past, Microsoft caught tons of flak for driver issues when people upgraded to Windows Vista. They've probably learned their lesson on that one.
- DKnoll 11y agoSuck it up. Nobody lied to you, you are still entitled to the Win10 upgrade if you want it, but Nvidia has not made a Win10 driver available for your GPU.
- Someone1234 11y agoYour dad's computer didn't ship with Windows 8. His graphics card is from 2007, and Windows 8 shipped in 2012 (Windows 7 in 2009). Windows Vista, which was originally on your dad's computer, isn't supported by the Windows 10 free upgrade promotion, and by extension a lot of hardware from that period also isn't supported. So you want to know why your dad's computer isn't compatible? It is too darn old. > What should the response to this sort of fraud be? You should be compensated every penny that the Windows 10 upgrade cost you: Zero dollars and zero cents. But snark aside for a second: Microsoft is trying to offer the best user experience. They would prefer NOT to upgrade a user who will wind up with a poorly supported system (e.g. an 8 year old graphics card not supported by the manufacturer on Windows 10). According to Nvidia's website, they do not offer a Windows 10 driver for that specific chipset. Windows 7 seems to be the latest driver. So while I'm sure Windows 10 can fall back to a Windows 7 64 bit driver (just as I suspect Windows 8 did also) there is no assurance of how well this graphics driver will work with Windows 8/8.1/10 specific features. It might work but Nvidia or Microsoft aren't making assurances. I agree with them, it is "incompatible." It works, but who knows what edge cases may appear. Ultimately your tone for a completely free promotion and calling it "fraud" is utterly pathetic.
- pbhjpbhj 11y agoIt's practically entirely compatible. The card may have been released in 2007 but the system was purchased new in 2012. Win 8 cost £100+ for the license. >a poorly supported system // They didn't say that though; they said "unable to run". Yet clearly MS know that's not the case (now if not at release). Unsupported and "unable to run" are entirely different. I'd have no problem if MS said "may not work" or "unsupported by Microsoft". >You should be compensated every penny that the Windows 10 upgrade cost you: Zero dollars and zero cents. // The cost is time - as an ordinary user the nag telling my father to upgrade was treated as an essential. Then on that nag screen Microsoft informed him that his computer couldn't run the upgrade and kindly offered to sell him a new computer. If he hadn't asked me the cost would then be disposal of a perfectly good computer (who wants a 2nd hand computer that "can't run windows") and the price of replacement from the MS offerings. I imagine quite a lot of people would have trusted that there computer was "unable to run" Windows, MS would know after all, and so followed the sales links in the nag screen. What do you call false statements made to increase sales if not fraud?