9 ms·
Why NSA Surveillance Scares Me
- fweespeech 11y agoWhile I don't agree with the way he is pricing in government failure...because it can be argued and its ultimately weakening to the argument. The fact J Edgar Hoover controlled the FBI for more than half of its existence. He is also 1/12th of the people who have held the position. I'd say that is a strong enough argument in and of itself. You just need one guy at the top of the surveillance pile pulling the same tricks and 1 in 12 odds is pretty high. [ Yes, I'm aware this isn't technically accurate but its close enough for rhetoric purposes. ]
- rm_-rf_slash 11y agoI think the author's two points were that by mixing an unscrupulous individual with a lot of power and access to immense amounts of information you have the recipe for totalitarian control, and those ingredients are much closer than we would like to think.
- leroy_masochist 11y agoThe problem with this analysis is that the problem set the NSA exists to address is not limited to terrorism. Most of the work they do is spying on foreign governments in order to inform U.S. policy. Building a cost/benefit analysis of the loss of privacy effected by NSA operations on the number of lives lost to terrorism does not provide an accurate measure of the value delivered by the national-level SIGINT enterprise. With regard to the author's general point: we should indeed be very concerned with the potential for widespread surveillance to abet the violation of civil liberties or even a totalitarian takeover.
- coldpie 11y ago> Most of the work they do is spying on foreign governments in order to inform U.S. policy. Really? I'm not disputing this, but I'd love to see some evidence backing it up. What I remember from the Snowden disclosures is the vast majority of the leaked information actually did relate to violent threats to national security. Am I remembering wrong, or did I miss something?
- nickff 11y agoThe NSA was founded in the early 1950s to be the primary signals intelligence (SigInt) branch of the US Government, largely to gather information which would be of strategic importance in the Cold War. You might look at the NSA as a SigInt counterpart to the National Reconnaissance Office (NRO), which runs most of the spy satellites and other strategic imagery. The Wikipedia article on the NSA is quite good.[1] [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/National_Security_Agency https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/National_Security_Agency
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- strictnein 11y agoThey're also charged with ComSec. If your main source of info on the NSA are the Snowden leaks, you're not getting the full picture. If you're really interested in the subject of the NSA's history, and what it does, James Bamford's work is pretty interesting. Very dry books, tinged with his politics (more so Body of Secrets [1] than the Puzzle Palace [0]), but interesting none-the-less. [0] The Puzzle Palace http://www.amazon.com/Puzzle-Palace-National-Intelligence-Or.. http://www.amazon.com/Puzzle-Palace-National-Intelligence-Or.... [1] Body of Secrets http://www.amazon.com/Body-Secrets-Ultra-Secret-National-Sec.. http://www.amazon.com/Body-Secrets-Ultra-Secret-National-Sec.... Body of Secrets is an easier read, because it's written more around historical events. The Puzzle Palace got a little too in the weeds for my liking. One of its primary sources were a ton of unclassified internal memos, newsletters, etc, and he goes into things like who ran grounds security at the NSA's Fort Meade location.
- marcosdumay 11y agoIt does not really matter how important it is inside the NSA. Universal surveillance is useless for spying foreign governments, targeted surveillance is the tool for that. Thus, it should not enter the cost/benefit analysis anyway. (By the way, it also at best useless for fighting terrorists too...)
- btilly 11y agoI made the argument that I did because the public justification for the NSA is terrorism. But I could have made a different argument focused only on the merits of spying. Yes, it is obviously helpful to steal secrets. Yes, this gives us an edge in negotiations, allows us to steal technologies, and so on. However people get pissed off at us when they discover that we have done so. See Angela Merkel's cellphone. Some of our attempts to assist spying leave us open to harm. See backdoors deliberately left in software that black-hats later discover. Lack of trust has a cost. I've seen estimates that US companies have lost tens of billions of dollars in contracts because other countries don't trust us with their data. And when everyone knows that we spy, everyone else is likely to spy back just to level the playing field. But spying is asymmetric; small players can do it effectively with very little in the way of resources, and big players have more to lose. When I put together everything I know, I believe that our aggressive spying programs are a net economic loss for us. We could be better off by spying in a much more targeted way, but with very large penalties for anyone who we caught spying on us. Obviously I have biases and incomplete information. But I'm not convinced that spying is a good justification for the NSA, even if we were honest with ourselves about it.
- javajosh 11y ago>other countries don't trust us with their data. To riff on this, the reason is a cultural issue regarding the value of self-restraint. Self-restraint is no longer valued. In fact, self-restraint is considered a critical weakness. To not take any action you can get away with, that advances your interests, is weak. It's lack of value is written in stories of police brutality, it's written in the manner in which popular elections are conducted, it's written in the policies of our executive agencies, and it's written in the way business is conducted. Confronted with clear evidence of wrong-doing, leaders are no longer expected to apologize and resign; we expect them to deny, to resist, to fight to the bitter end, no matter what. They wait out the public, they wait out the courts, and they win. The question that I am having a hard time answering is simply: how did it get this way? Bush had a profound impact on this culture; there was a man who knew the anti-value of self-restraint! The anti-value of self-reflection, of taking responsibility for mistakes. Wall Street learned the anti-value of self-restraint, because they gambled, lost big, and got bailed out anyway. Police are taught the anti-value of self-restraint, because there is risk to the officer when using too little force, but virtually no risk to the officer when using too much. Power delegitimizes itself when it shows a systematic lack of self-restraint.
- jrcii 11y agoI agree with the dangers of an executive branch that has access to nearly unlimited information on everyone, especially when you consider the surveillance of Congress, governors, or Supreme Court justices. The math doesn't sit quite as well with me. As someone recently mentioned, the projected threat of terrorism cannot be effectively measured by deaths to-date because those numbers can suddenly grow exponentially in the event of an attack. The probability of extra surveillance is baseless, etc. The points are valid, the statistical argument is weak and unnecessary.
- Houshalter 11y agoI disagree. There is a lot of evidence that terrorist groups are incredibly ineffective. Not just recent attacks in the US, but statistics world wide and through all of history. Gwern wrote a detailed essay on how incompetent terrorist groups are: http://www.gwern.net/Terrorism%20is%20not%20Effective http://www.gwern.net/Terrorism%20is%20not%20Effective >9/11, the crowning incident of terrorism in those centuries, was equaled by just 29 days of car accidents in the US - and 9/11 was only accidentally that successful! 9/11 is also a sterling example of the availability bias: besides it, how many attacks could the best informed Western citizen name? Perhaps a score, on a good day, if they have a good memory; inasmuch as the MIPT database records >19,000 just 1968-2004, it’s clear that terrifyingly exceptional terrorist attacks are just that. Remarkably, it seems that it is unusual for terrorist attacks to injure even a single person; the MIPT database puts the number of such attacks at 35% of all attacks. Certainly the post-9/11 record would seem to indicate it was a fluke... >Many terrorist organizations keep very detailed financial records (consider the troves of data seized from Al-Qaeda-in-Iraq, from Bin Laden’s safehouse, or Al Qaeda’s insistence on receipts), with little trust of underlings, suggesting far less ideological devotion than commonly believed & serious principal-agent problems. Stories about terrorist incompetence are legion and the topic is now played for laughs (eg. the 2010 movie Four Lions), prompting columnists to tell us to ignore all the incompetence and continue to be afraid. Also see his essay Terrorism is not about Terror: http://www.gwern.net/Terrorism%20is%20not%20about%20Terror http://www.gwern.net/Terrorism%20is%20not%20about%20Terror
- GordonS 11y ago
- shmerl 11y agoTo summarize: Give me six lines written by the most honest man in the world, and I will find enough in them to hang him. — Cardinal Richelieu
- gaius 11y agoThe modern equivalent would be 140 characters.
- sliverstorm 11y agoIf that's your position, then does it matter if they surveil you? There is doubtless already far more than six lines of your script publicly available to any who might desire it, at any time. Logging your activity, then, does not increase your risk. My point is they already have all they need, publicly available any time they desire it. You write it for them and publish it for them! It's fanciful to imagine privacy protects you, IMO.
- shmerl 11y agoThe point of the quote is that those who claim that you don't need privacy if you have "nothing to hide" are wrong, because the power always can abuse information it gets, as long as it wants to target someone. > My point is they already have all they need, publicly available any time they desire it Which doesn't mean you need to be lax and give them even more, or even accept such situation as normal. Don't feed the machine. To put it differently, the argument that "privacy is dead, so ignore the issue" is invalid and actually only facilitates the problem.
- TeMPOraL 11y agoThe point of the quote that many miss though is that Cardinal Richelieu wasn't a clairvoyant, and by "six lines written" he didn't literally mean Twitter. It's true that, as you say, "the power always can abuse information it gets, as long as it wants to target someone". If it wants to get you, it will abuse any information available. If you protect your Facebook from them, they'll break your e-mail. If you encrypt your mail traffic, they'll tap your phone. Or pull out census and employment data. Or simply ask around. I agree that you may be marginally safer if you're not "feeding the machine". But let's not delude ourselves - if the government turns evil, we're fucked either way, and no amount of Internet privacy will help much. There's too much data out there, and even more in the physical, material world.
- golergka 11y ago> Surveillance sliding into dictatorship is one of the most common ways that democracies fall. What? Give me one example where surveillance was the _reason_ and main tool for ascending dictator.
- distracted_boy 11y agoIn Nazi Germany the Stasi was quite effective in monitoring people, suppressing the people and keeping them in constant fear. Maybe not the main tool for Hitler to reach his position as Fürer but it was certainly one of the main tools to keep him in power.
- hiram112 11y agoThe Stasi was East Germany's post WWII security apparatus. You're confusing it with the Gestapo. I understand and agree with what you were probably trying to say ;)
- golergka 11y agoI hope you don't get offended if I say that when you attribute Stasi to Nazis, you don't show a depth of historical knowledge required to blindly trust you on your analysis on these issues. Yes, every regime is trying to get information about who's trying to destroy it. But (1) it's not a tool to get to power as much as a tool to hold to power, and (2) it's not inherently evil: if you have some regime that you actually like and don't want to see violently overthrown, you would support such measures, implemented in a reasonable way (!), too.
- hiram112 11y agoI don't think most arguments against surveillance are necessarily implying that it is the reason that dictators rise, but instead it is one of many tools used to allow it to happen. Furthermore, the fact that billions of people are voluntarily using social media, all stored on private company's cloud servers, along with ML, massive computing increases gives those who'd use surveillance for power grabs exponentially more power than the Stasi, KGB, Hoover's FBI, etc. could have ever dreamed of.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- stcredzero 11y agoWe have satellites that can read the text on your iPhone screen Do you have a citation for this?
- nickff 11y agoThere is no need for a citation, because it is obviously wrong. If you calculate the angular resolution required to read 16 point font from low Earth orbit, you will find that you need a satellite with a primary mirror much larger than has ever been launched. In addition to the (currently) unavailable high-resolution imagery which would be required, atmospheric distortion would render any text illedgible, and it seems very unlikely the individual characters would be resolvable. Many of the techniques used to reduce/compensate for atmospheric distortion in telescopic imaging are not possible in Earth observation.
- TeMPOraL 11y agoThat said, it's only little off. They may not be able to read the text on your phone, but they can see that you have a phone in your hand. Also, things will get worse since satellites are not really the future. Solar-powered high-altitude planes that can keep themselves aloft for years are potentially much cheaper to launch and operate, and much more flexible, so I'm guessing this is where things will be heading in the next few years. They may be easier to detect and shoot down, true, but they seem perfect for domestic surveillance ops.
- scrollaway 11y agoOT but this reminds me of the Mythbusters episode on the U2 plane. Well worth watching if you haven't, and it also nicely displays how amazingly powerful these are for surveillance. Found a youtube video: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=iTXnJF5MnHQ https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=iTXnJF5MnHQ
- bedros 11y agosurveillance is a power grab, whoever controls the people's private lives, controls the people.
- tptacek 11y agoOn the off chance that it might clarify the thread a bit: Is there a single non-throwaway commenter that disagrees with 'btilly on this? Not, like, disagrees about whether it's the most important NSA concern, but disagrees that the gravity of this concern is outweighed by the importance of the work that NSA is doing. To be sure: there are tons of people who disagree with him around the US. But I'm surprised if many of them comment here.
- iolothebard 11y agoThe NSA fear killed a project I was working on. I got it to the point of working (proof of concept) because the nonsense they are trying against the Megaupload founder (I'm not on his side either, but I felt we need a safe harbor software suite). I had my brilliant russian buddy (grew up studying in the ussr) poking holes in my logic from a discussion level. Then I started thinking, what if this pissed off someone spying on us. They could hack my machine (windows) and throw some CP or something on there that would ruin my life (I have no fear of anything I've got on my computers as a result of my own downloading). So I killed the project. Just like the article posts, with the fear of Hoover. I have the same fear of the government. Funny thing is I'm a pretty liberal person for the most part. Our government operating like it does, from local police being above the law all the way up to the 3 letter agencies and congress themselves. Is really disheartening.
- Balgair 11y agoThe issue is that we do not have the full data set. We only see those cases where the NSA fails and select cases of success. Most successes, if there are any, are hidden to maintain secrecy in operations. I'm not saying there are any successes. What successes we do see are ones that are 'scrubbed' of intelligence or were made with intel that is now known to be useless and only then years after the fact. Again, if there are any successes to begin with. To make an educated conclusion, we need the facts, something we cannot have. Things could be worse or better, we do not know.
- lvs 11y agoThis is a fatally utilitarian response. You want to be able to calculate whether an equilibrium lies between good and bad outcomes of a process. That is a somewhat defeatist analysis to make because it implicitly denies the gaping moral and ethical risks of the system.
- blennon 11y agoI agree with the author wholeheartedly, except for the mathematical analysis at the end. I believe one of the existential threats to our country is becoming a dictatorship. I'm always shocked when I share this point of view with people around me and their reaction is basically, "that's so unlikely it's not worth worrying about". There are many examples of this throughout history, e.g. the Roman Republic, the Weimar Republic, those that the author cites, etc. We should not be so arrogant to think that we are somehow exceptional and immune to this. My personal belief is that there are certain constants in the dynamics of human nature, and one of them is seek power. Broad, unchecked domestic surveillance is a dangerous tool to give to a potential dictator. We should not set up a framework where a power-seeking individual can circumvent our democracy through coercion.
- Zigurd 11y agoThere are some who make a compelling case that representation of the people has been nerfed already, and we're in a dictatorship of the deep state. If that's true it is inevitable that "security" will be defined in terms of the continuity of control of the deep state.
- slg 11y agoCan we really use the Roman empire as a predictor for the Unites States? I like to think some things have changed with the world in the last millennia and a half. Maybe I am missing something obvious, but I can't think of any recent examples of a mature democracy that succumbed to a dictatorship without being manipulated by a stronger foreign power. Do you have any examples?
- Create 11y agohttp://www.bbc.co.uk/worldservice/specials/1020_ageofempire/index.shtml http://www.bbc.co.uk/worldservice/specials/1020_ageofempire/... We begin therefore where they are determined not to end, with the question whether any form of democratic self-government, anywhere, is consistent with the kind of massive, pervasive, surveillance into which the Unites States government has led not only us but the world. This should not actually be a complicated inquiry. https://archive.org/details/EbenMoglen-WhyFreedomOfThoughtRequiresFreeMediaAndWhyFreeMedia https://archive.org/details/EbenMoglen-WhyFreedomOfThoughtRe... Surveillance is not an end toward totalitarianism, it is totalitarianism itself.
- cryoshon 11y agoAs the author notes, we've tread this ground before when J. Edgar Hoover essentially ran the country via intimidation/blackmail for decades. It always shocks me that Hoover's reign is mentioned so lightly. Democracy wasn't functioning during those decades because one unelected individual had hugely outsized power. NSA surveillance is a backdoor to democracy because it enables blackmailing of politicians or inconvenient people. The CIA does this all the time abroad using information the NSA gathered.
- Houshalter 11y agoThis is the best argument I've read on the subject. Before I really didn't worry about the NSA. I mean I didn't think they were doing much good, since I think terrorism isn't a significant threat. But I'm not that cynical or conspiracy-theory-ish to worry that they would abuse their power significantly. This is the first time someone's tried to show that's a real threat with examples from US history.
- btilly 11y agoThanks. Reaching people like this was exactly my hope. It is easy to preach to the choir. It is much harder to produce an argument that can reach people who don't alread agree with you.
- TeMPOraL 11y agoA HNer, whose identity shall remain undisclosed, posted an insightful extension of the statistic games that later got deleted, probably because of the downvotes. I believe this is an important thing to consider, so let me take the karma hit and restate the problem. The poster pointed out that if we're taking a 3000 years view, it's worth considering the great filter hypothesis[0]. If one is to believe it's ahead of us (as an explanation for why we haven't seen any signs of aliens yet, and mind you, this is not a joke), then it stands to reason we'll likely fuck ourselves over with some future technology. Given that, mass surveillance may be a way to avoid this fate. Also, the poster pointed out that "the debate is silly. This level of surveillance is inevitable." -- The comment I was about to post in response: Actually, I do agree, for two reasons. 1/ SIGINT is basically inevitable, barring total collapse of technological civilization. We're only starting to be good at data gathering and processing, and there is no reason to suspect we won't be getting much better very quickly. Look - 100 years ago we could barely record a person's voice. Today, we use sound to acquire pictures. We use light to acquire sound. Between cheap microphones being good enough to pin-point the position of a firearm discharge in a big city and your mobile phone about to be equipped with a 3D geometry sensor and a fucking radar on a chip, with NASA being able to map ocean floor using gravity sensors, that by the way happen to be Cold War-era technology, does anyone really believe we can stop mass surveillance? It's a side effect of useful high-tech tools. You basically can't have one without the other. 2/ Progress of technology also keeps increasing the amount of power a single person can wield. Throughout almost all history, the biggest damage an ordinary individual could do to other people is to set something on fire. Burn down a building, maybe. 100 years ago, an ordinary citizen could at best drive someone over, or blow something up. In the last few decades, bombs had become easy, and people were worried about terrorists with crude nukes. Today, a teenage hacker could do anything from blowing up a gas station to shutting down power in a large area. Tomorrow, your high-school friend may be playing with potentially dangerous viruses in their basement. This is not a joke. We're entering an era where playing with self-replicating machines is getting very easy very quickly. Today it's not just big biotech companies doing that - your local hackerspace is most likely doing baby steps with reprogramming bacteria too. Now tell me, honestly, how are we going to defend against that? And keep in mind - it's not the angry that are the problem. It's the crazy ones. Surveillance will probably have to be a part of the answer, but I fear it will be far from enough. [0] - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Great_Filter https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Great_Filter
- staunch 11y agoEither you stand by your principles when they're tested, or you don't have principles.
- vonklaus 11y agoI have began to change, or at least think more deeply about survelience and the role of gov't. I still am pretty much the same mind of the author, and blanket survelience is intrusive, ineffective and anti-anerican; both literally and in sentiment. However, and I still not sure what role I trust the gov't to play here, the need for defense is pretty strong. Let's take this red test for example: While $100k is a lot of money to me, we will assume many people could have access to this amount. There were > 1 million people in times square on NYE. The strike cabanilities of an inclined individual are higher now than ever. This is the negative sode effect of the otherwise positive shift in individual autonomy and lowering of power distance between entrenched heirarchies and individuals. A flock of drones can be purchased and controlled remotely and outfitted with bombs or guns and used to conduct an attack previously reserved for the u.s militaries indiscriminate bombing raids on other countries. Analytical tooling and conputation can be purchased cheaply. Trend analytics, macroshift evaluation and near real time satelite imagery can be had for little money. Biohacking is quite new but even after the overhype of the synthesis of (i think it was) smallpox from discrete labs, this is still semi-possible. So, I don't think it is up to the government to fix this, especially with blanket survelience, but we do need to come up with a reasonable way to mitigate threats. 5 people and 100k could basically outfit a safehouse, a drone fleet, real time intelligience and a small bio labratory giving those who would not use that amazing luxury for good, the ability to create a high impact negative change event.
- walid 11y agoYou set a scenario for a potential disaster but what has surveillance done to protect those in times square on new year. This question has no answer and the answer if it exists is NOT something a democracy has access to. So if surveillance is an answer to a potential terror plot then what needs to be known is whether it can actually be effective. Terror plots are not the norm of human life. They are feared more because we humans are designed by nature to be afraid first when we see a lion, run away and think later. If we stood there contemplating the possibility of of having a deep conversation with that lion that lion would have managed to have a meal deep in its stomach. Thought is very low on mother nature's agenda. Even other great apes don't comment here! Basically we are more afraid of the danger because we are primed to be so. I guess what I'm trying to say is that while fear is a danger is a logical thing it shouldn't be the only thing to consider when deciding on surveillance. Currently it is the only reason presented to the public and it is not good enough on its own.
- differentView 11y agoI hope I am wrong, but I can't imagine a modern day Hoover, with better surveillance, to not have already placed blackmailed politicians in all key political positions and is effectively ruling the United States.
- dmix 11y ago> Even then, organized crime was prioritized below his private anti-Civil Rights Movement vendetta. Even though this put his policies at odds with several Presidents. Not many people realize the FBI started as a domestic intelligence agency first and only became primarily a federal law enforcement arm later on. This would make suppressing foreign-backed or (what they deem) dangerous political dissent their priority early on.
- kra34 11y agoGovernments and more specifically democracies evolve over time. They benefit from all the ones that have come before them and failed. It could be that the inevitable conclusion of any democratic society is a last ditch power grab made by the unlucky person standing in office when if all falls apart. It's happened quite a few times before, and I don't see any reason why this time around would be different. I for one welcome our new overlord Trump and look forward to the new government that forms in his wake.
- Outdoorsman 11y agoI think it's important to differentiate between countries of our present era and countries that "fell" in past eras, when evaluating or speculating on the potential for longevity... The technologies of today, especially the ease and rapidity with which information can be exchanged by private citizens, seems to me at least, a hindrance to an "overthrow" of our government...a freely functioning "Fourth Estate", journalism--the press, also acts as a safeguard... At the point where either of those are verifiably co-opted I'd become very concerned... Surveillance, per se, doesn't worry me so much...tens of thousands of covert operations are in play every day around the globe...those in play to guard against terrorism on U.S. soil are likely just the tip of a vast iceberg...