6 ms·
UIKit for the Mac
- kennydude 11y agoHopefully this will take off! Could use something like this as using OSX's frameworks is so painful (creating list views with items of various heights is overly complicated)
- a-priori 11y agoIf you want something that works now, there is Chameleon, the project this is based on: http://chameleonproject.org/ http://chameleonproject.org/ Unfortunately, it seems the project's maintainers have mostly lost interest in the project (last push to Github in May 2014), but there's a few forks that have kept on. I maintained this one for a few years for our own uses: https://github.com/toushay/Chameleon https://github.com/toushay/Chameleon Unfortunately, the company behind that fork, Toushay, went out of business last year so there won't be any further work done on that fork. There may be others out there that are still maintained.
- LeoNatan25 11y agoOr, instead of debugging and maintaining over-ambitious lowest common denominator projects, which will limit you any way you look at them, just re-write the UI portion of your software with proper Mac design in mind, in AppKit.
- a-priori 11y agoUsing something like Chameleon can get you up and running in a very short time. Literally, it took one afternoon for me to get our app running on Chameleon. True story. I actually did it without management approval on the day they said "we should have an OS X app" and demoed it to them at the end of the day. It wasn't perfect, and took another week or two to iron out a few bugs in Chameleon we ran into. That was the start of our fork, actually. But it worked, and it would have taken two to three months to get to that point from scratch. I should know, because I did from-scratch ports to other platforms and that's how long it took each time. You can mix and match Chameleon (UIKit) and AppKit in the same application, so you can incrementally replace Chameleon with a "proper" solution. If you find that's important to you.
- sjmulder 11y agoI'm still hoping for API convergence between the Mac and iOS, opening the road to universal Mac/iOS apps. People keep bringing up how iOS is designed for touch and the Mac for mouse and keyboard, and how screen sizes are different and all that, but those differences can all be accounted for. Microsoft have shown it possible. Why? Extend the Mac software ecosystem and allow for multi-paradigm devices, like the iPad Pro should have been.
- zw 11y agoI think it's gotta come from the other direction, ultimately. They're working hard to push AppKit forward and bring it into the future, but I think UIKit will figure out the hard problems (menuing, keyboard navigation, pointer input) before that. I think pointing at Microsoft as having the solution to this problem is disingenuous. Modern Windows has had so many false starts, and I still feel their multi-modal devices are inherently compromised — jack of all trades, master of none.
- LeoNatan25 11y agoPossible? Maybe. Desirable? No, not all. Don't get me wrong, AppKit is very much in need of a modernization, and it definitely is not as actively improved upon as UIKit is, but the two have very little in common from a design UI/UX standpoint. What has Microsoft shown with their multi-paradigm direction? That lowest common denominator is bad. And same would be for a possible "UXKit".
- Aleman360 11y agoWhy would you want different UI framework for each screen size/input device type? Seems silly to have one set of API's for small touch devices and a completely different one for large mouse-driven devices. Shuts the door to large touch devices and small mouse-driven devices. iPad Pro is already awkward. At that size, a mouse would be nice, along with lots of other desktop UX paradigms. > What has Microsoft shown with their multi-paradigm direction? Seems to be working. Windows Shell, modern Office, Edge, and Xbox dashboard are all using the same UI framework.
- Aleman360 11y agoSeems risky to go for this when it's very likely something Apple is working on.
- LeoNatan25 11y agoIs it really? UXKit has not moved at all. It has remained relatively static in the Photos app. It's a serviceable patch-work that Apple has done for their specific purpose, but I don't think it's actively being pushed forward for a possible AppKit replacement.
- mdw 11y ago> UXKit has not moved at all. This is speculation, unless you have inside information, UXKit could well be under active development - we don't know.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- seivan 11y agoUnless Apple are activly working on UXKit a better bet would be an implementation of UIKit with SpriteKit, with sane 'defaults' for Mac OS. I've missed something like CollectionView on Mac OS with same API as UIKit. By sane default I mean something like: Tab Bar on IOS, Slidable Side Menu on iPad and regular side-panelMac OS. UXKit has some issues, e.g you can't swipe back with the touchpad. So I take it has some work left before being a complete replacement of AppKit.
- ttflee 11y agoTwitter tried once upon a time: https://github.com/twitter/twui https://github.com/twitter/twui
- liviu 11y agoI thought that the Chameleon project is dead. I studied the source code a few years ago.