7 ms·
Inside Pinterest and its ad sales operation
- franze 11y agoWow, sounds to me that Pinterest is on the right track. F#ck the CPM sales "community", focus on the product.
- TheLogothete 11y agoYeah, fuck the people who pay you.
- Ronsenshi 11y agoSo many assumptions in one short sentence. Why do you think CPM-people pay him? He might as well work in a company that does not rely on marketing/advertising industry. Those do exist. Even if he was paid by CPM-people - so what? A lot of people work for money, not because they like their employers or share same views.
- lmartel 11y agoThe "you" he's referring to is Pinterest, not the commenter.
- Ronsenshi 11y agoDon't quite see the issue. If Pinterest cares about what kind of advertising to show. If they are interested in a quality curated advertising that fits the content of the website instead of mindless ads where you only care about CPM - I'd say great for them and for their users. > The "you" he's referring to is Pinterest, not the commenter. It is a commenter that said: "F#ck the CPM sales "community", focus on the product.". Don't see where is he trying to portray the words as if they were coming from Pinterest.
- TheLogothete 11y agoBuyable pins reported to be an (embarrassing) flop, according to an article on qz.
- achow 11y ago(In 2014) Pinterest reportedly brought in $25 million in revenue,..forecasts of $2.8 billion in revenue and 329 million users by 2018… the figures suggest the company is at the cusp of hockey-stick-like growth. http://qz.com/581191/why-2016-is-poised-to-be-the-year-that-it-all-comes-together-for-pinterest/ http://qz.com/581191/why-2016-is-poised-to-be-the-year-that-...
- eva1984 11y agoI think those buyable-button-like initiatives are inherently flawed from ground up. Clicking ads, comparing to viewing them, is rare enough, with a lot of are done by mistakes, so what makes those people think their users could make a decision of purchase, which often takes several rounds of researching, comparing ,hesitating to make the final stride, by randomly scrolling through something might bot even be relevant, is totally beyond me. Even if the user happens to like the item in the ads, the actual action would come after several hours, do they expect user to come back to app, find the ad, then click the buy button?
- keithpeter 11y agoQuote from OP "Most notably, Kendall also led the move to narrow Pinterest's ad focus on just two categories, retailers and consumer-packaged-goods brands, as The Wall Street Journal first reported in December." Smallish purchases (music, books, household items, some aspects of holiday spending): I tend to go with the first thing I find that looks right. I could imagine using a 'buy' button next to an entry in a discovery system such as Pinterest, although I'm not in their majority demographic. Larger purchases (stage piano, new laptop &c): yes, I research and have a bias towards places where I can try stuff out (I'm old). This organisation seems to want to specialise.
- ddingus 11y ago
- frik 11y agoPinterests recommender system algo (picture suggestions) is flawed/broken. It shows you always the same pictures, of the same k-mean group. And their nag screen to login/signup is as annoying as on Quora. Btw: Has Quora completed their pivot already, they joined YC like a year ago? http://venturebeat.com/2014/05/09/meet-the-oldest-y-combinator-startup-ever-quora/ http://venturebeat.com/2014/05/09/meet-the-oldest-y-combinat... Glad to see pg doesn't like the nag screen either: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5217449 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5217449 (full context: https://www.quora.com/Why-did-Quora-join-the-2014-Y-Combinator-batch https://www.quora.com/Why-did-Quora-join-the-2014-Y-Combinat... )
- tajen 11y agoPinterest's nagging panel is in my uBlock Origin rules... What a nice era we live in, where we can ban knee-jerk behavours.
- jsprogrammer 11y agoIt's an even better era than that: you don't even have to click on a link to Pinterest.
- rajacombinator 11y agoSounds like some VCs really desperate to dump the IPO on the market before everything implodes (hence pushing this submarine article), some butthurt sales monkeys who didn't get their commissions, and oh hey there's Pinterest doing what they've always done, being really careful about building a great product.
- awakeasleep 11y agoFellas, that goose must be FILLED with golden eggs!
- joelrunyon 11y agoSo wait, the hyped investor valuations aren't going to match what the IPO valuation will be based on revenues. News at 11.
- RyanZAG 11y ago> So if you're a marketer with a budget, where do you allocate it? Put it on Google or Facebook, where there are tons and tons of users where you can target very well? Or on Pinterest, which is a much smaller audience, female, lower-income, where you can't target well? It's just not as efficient." This part is really interesting considering how other tech companies put a huge amount of effort into acquiring that exact female crowd from their mostly male mid-to-upper crowd.
- raverbashing 11y ago"considering how other tech companies put a huge amount of effort into acquiring that exact female crowd" Exactly this. Pinterest caters to a niche. You can advertise to your target directly and probably spending less money Much better than FB or Google "targeting"
- TheLogothete 11y agoROAS numbers do not agree with you.
- raverbashing 11y agoDo you have a quote for that? (Also might be an issue of not tailoring campaigns to Pinterest) It seems to be getting behind Instagram, that's for sure http://www.adweek.com/news/advertising-branding/new-social-stratosphere-who-using-facebook-twitter-pinterest-tumblr-and-instagram-2015-and-beyond-1622 http://www.adweek.com/news/advertising-branding/new-social-s...
- TheLogothete 11y agoThe very same article we are commenting under, for one. And it's not an issue of not tailoring campagins. In fact, you are forced to make Pinterest-specific campaigns. It's an issue of inferior ad units, targeting and operations in comparison with FB and the same plus inferior monetization model in comparison with GOOG. I don't know why you linked to that adweek article. It's about demogprahics and usage, not adspend efficiency.
- flashman 11y agoI got 'page not found' and had to go here instead: http://www.businessinsider.com.au/pinterest-worth-11-billion-valuation-revenue-grow-5x-2015-2016-1 http://www.businessinsider.com.au/pinterest-worth-11-billion...
- hayksaakian 11y agospeaking as someone who's actually purchased pinterest ads: the review process is much more careful than facebook or google. they only really want content that would make sense organically on pinterest. facebook and google are pretty loose about the "salesy-ness" of ads, but pinterest is pretty strict in comparison. obviously with all these restrictions, agencies don't like it because they have to cater their message to pinterest instead copy and pasting the same noise on every platform. pinterest probably won't kill google proper, but I could easily see pinterest killing google images. When is the last time a company seriously decided to take on image search at google scale? Google doesn't even show ads in it's image search. another reason agencies probably don't like pinterest is the high fixed-floor bids of 10 cents. you could have lower effective cpcs, but your ads actually have to be engaging, and they have to get repins and shares. bottom line: Pinterest simply demands more effort from advertisers, and they're pretty picky. Consequently, users don't mind their ads as much. The best case scenario for pinterest's investors (in my mind) is an acquisition by facebook as part of a strategy to take on the web search market.
- pjc50 11y agoeasily see pinterest killing google images Not with their annoying interstitial it won't. And pinterest isn't great for finding images of things that aren't "products".
- chestnut-tree 11y agoNot with their annoying interstitial it won't This is my main gripe with Pinterest: the hostile and intrusive block on viewing the site unless you register first. This wasn't always the case. I'm guessing the permanent prompt to register turns many users away (I'm sure they're tracking this this to see how it's faring). And pinterest isn't great for finding images of things that aren't "products". Pinterest is a great resource for finding visual design inspiration, not just products. You'll find plenty of design examples no matter how broad or narrow your search: typography, graphic design, illustration, web design, mobile app design, book covers, comic book design, calligraphy, geometric patterns, packaging design, paper sculpture, origami - the list is endless. In fact, the site deliberately overwhelms you with related pins and pages that scroll forever to keep you browsing as long as possible. If you are a designer or developer creating a web site or a mobile app, then you are missing out on lots of visual inspiration if you don't use Pinterest.
- paulpauper 11y agoBusinessinsider is a notorious click-bait aggregator, spinning minutia into hype. Reminds be of the Uber California court report they hyped last year, which predictably didn't really anywhere http://www.nytimes.com/2015/06/18/business/uber-contests-california-labor-ruling-that-says-drivers-should-be-employees.html?_r=0 http://www.nytimes.com/2015/06/18/business/uber-contests-cal... That was seven months ago and Uber didn't die as many predicted it would Some people so badly want for this to be 2000 all over again they they have to make things up. They have to turn molehills into mountains.
- eggie 11y ago> Some people so badly want for this to be 2000 all over again they they have to make things up. Why do you think this is the case?
- ytNumbers 11y agoIt's just human nature. Misery loves company. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Schadenfreude https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Schadenfreude
- zazpowered 11y agoI skimmed through the article and it was pretty neutral. They didn't really try to paint Pinterest in a bad light.
- paulpauper 11y agoThe visual scrapbook platform should be printing money. Its predominantly female audience browses Pinterest's various boards for inspiration about their next fashion purchases, vacation destination, or on how to decorate a house — and they also act as free brand representatives by "pinning" their favorite products, making them visible to others. It may come as a surprise to some, but making money is not important. That's why so many people lost their shirts shorting the 'unprofitable' Amazon.com Rather, it's the the demonstrated ability to make money, which is more important. Should the time come to turn on the advertising money printing press, Pinterest and Snapchat, like Facebook, should have no difficulty making money. There's already a huge line of advertisers ready to plow hundreds of millions of dollars into Pinterest ads. Investors are patient, knowing that Pinterest will start printing money when the time is right. But right now, Pinterest is still building the userbase and perfecting their ad platform. Like Facebook, Pinterest's profit margins will be extremely high, and it would not surprise me if this company is worth $50 billion soon. But right now, Pinterest, like many web successful web 2.0 companies, is more interested in taking its time to build positive user and advertiser experience, than milking every user for every last dime.
- onewaystreet 11y ago> Investors are patient, knowing that Pinterest will start printing money when the time is right. Someone isn't patient, otherwise this article wouldn't have been written.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- asdfologist 11y agoNot necessarily. It's trendy these days to bash unicorns.
- samfisher83 11y agoThere is time value of money. Opportunity costs, for example if a VC could invest in company x that is growing at rate y instead of pinterest. Also VC raise rounds for a fixed number of years so they need to cash out.
- nl 11y agoDisclaimer: I'm pretty bullish in Pinterest. I wish I could put money into it, even at the $11B valuation. and it's not all good Well.. now I've read the article I'd agree. But there was nothing in that article that I found particularly concerning - indeed, the fact they are focused on product at the expense of monetisation makes me even more bullish. The thing that does concern me wasn't mentioned though. Their growth seems to have leveled off, albeit after very fast initial growth[1][2]. [1] https://www.google.com.au/trends/explore#q=pinterest%2C%20snapchat%2C%20ebay&date=1%2F2011%2061m&cmpt=q&tz=Etc%2FGMT-10%3A30 https://www.google.com.au/trends/explore#q=pinterest%2C%20sn... [2] https://www.google.com.au/trends/explore#q=pinterest%2C%20snapchat%2C%20ebay&date=1%2F2011%2061m&cmpt=q&tz=Etc%2FGMT-10%3A30 https://www.google.com.au/trends/explore#q=pinterest%2C%20sn...
- DanBC 11y ago> The visual scrapbook platform should be printing money. Its predominantly female audience browses Pinterest's various boards for inspiration about their next fashion purchases, vacation destination, or on how to decorate a house — and they also act as free brand representatives by "pinning" their favorite products, making them visible to others. Pinterest tried skimlinking, but the some of the userbase hated that, claiming it was hurting their business. When I used Pinterest I would not have cared if they had used skimlinks for anything I posted, but it doesn't seem to be an option I can turn on. And I want Pinterest to protect me from people posting their own affiliate links. A bunch of people post low quality content and stuff it full of affiliate links. Pinterest is worse with those people on the platform. One thing it could do is skimlink everything, and charge for people who want to use their own affiliate links. Most services provided to businesses are charged for, and allowing someone to run an affiliate marketing business on Pinterest is a service that Pinterest should charge for. > You have a lot of lower-income, middle-America people on Pinterest than you do on other sites, and it's very female-centric. So if you're a marketer with a budget, where do you allocate it? Put it on Google or Facebook, where there are tons and tons of users where you can target very well? Or on Pinterest, which is a much smaller audience, female, lower-income, where you can't target well? It's just not as efficient." Wait what? I see people pinning stuff for weddings (average cost of US wedding is $26k) or home redecoration (average cost of US kitchen remodeling is over $15k) so these may be lower income people, but they have something that they're saving up for and are prepared to spend considerable amounts of money on. Carefully placed ads could be amazing for that market. The real problems with Pinterest are the awful awful awful mobile experience which is very hostile to the user. Almost embarrassing. I don't post any links to Pinterest anywhere because of that hateful experience.
- inthewoods 11y ago"The real problems with Pinterest are the awful awful awful mobile experience which is very hostile to the user. Almost embarrassing. I don't post any links to Pinterest anywhere because of that hateful experience." What's awful about it?
- leppr 11y ago
- chris_wot 11y agoThis article appears to have been pulled. Anyone else getting a page not found error?
- chris_wot 11y agoAh. Well that's rather stupid, they have detected I'm from Australia, so they redirect me to an Australian 404 error page. But then they suggest I look on the U.S. site. and get me to click on: http://www.businessinsider.com/pinterest-worth-11-billion-valuation-revenue-grow-5x-2015?r=US&IR=T/?IR=T http://www.businessinsider.com/pinterest-worth-11-billion-va... Dang or someone, could you update the link to this URL?
- JabavuAdams 11y agoI use Pinterest mostly for concept art. I don't think I'd use it at all if it became overrun by in-your-face ads. Of course, I'm just one user.
- inthewoods 11y agoI'm bullish on Pinterest for two reasons: 1. Limited number of advertising options that reach a broad audience - especially women. There just isn't a lot of inventory out of there that isn't cats and dogs. You've got Google and Facebook (Tier 1), Buzzfeed/Twitter/Yahoo/Bing (Tier 2/3) and then individual media properties (Business Insider et al) - the tiering here is fairly arbitrary. My point is that if you are a larger purchaser of advertising, there aren't that many top properties to go to - so Pinterest, with it's very good audience, is particularly interesting. 2. User information from Pinterest is very different from other venues. Google can show purchase intent based on search criteria - excellent for immediate purchases. Facebook can show ads based on demographics, location and behavior. Pinterest can show what users are interested in buying in the future, or what their wants are - a very unique dataset and one that is very interesting to a lot of advertisers.