5 ms·
When Uber is forced to recognize its employees as employees, it's game over for their business model. That is the elephant in the corner of the room.
by gaius 11y ago
When Uber is forced to recognize its employees as employees, it's game over for their business model. That is the elephant in the corner of the room.
- jacquesm 11y agoThe weird thing about the whole Uber affair is that as long as the drivers can't set their own prices that's a very strong piece of evidence that they are not independent operators, whereas that very same fact about Uber setting the prices is the biggest bulwark against a race to the bottom, which is very much to the advantage of the drivers. Sooner or later Uber will have to let this go to enhance their position that drivers are independent and then suddenly Uber won't be nearly as interesting to work with/for and the quality will plunge.
- kelseydh 11y agoUber's biggest risk will come from competitors or co-ops eating into their 20%-25% profit margins. There are a lot of regions that like the concept of ride sharing, but don't like how an American silicon valley company is capturing wealth locally and sending it to Silicon Valley. That's why I'm convinced we will soon see efforts to make co-op versions of Uber that copy its technology, but return 95%-99% of the money in each transaction back to the driver.
- rahimnathwani 11y ago"There are a lot of regions that like the concept of ride sharing, but don't like how an American silicon valley company is capturing wealth locally and sending it to Silicon Valley." I live in China, and enjoy cheap rides with Uber. I'm pretty sure the money is flowing the other way, and investors are subsidising local drivers and riders.
- hiharryhere 11y ago"I live in China, and enjoy cheap rides with Uber. I'm pretty sure the money is flowing the other way, and investors are subsidising local drivers and riders." For now. When the local market is won then the taps reverse and the money will flow the other way.
- sandworm101 11y agoAgainst the race to the bottom? Uber sets the pace. Their rates are a low as possible to maintain a driver base. There is a degree of debt in Uber atm because of this. Many drivers are not accommodating the true operating costs of their vehicles. They are using vehicles they had at hand, not one they purchased for the business. When those cars start to need replacement, Uber suddenly isn't paying enough. There is a reason many jurisdictions place limits on cab age. City driving for money simply destroys vehicles.
- hectormalot 11y agoOn the other hand, I took a lot of ubers last year (in Amsterdam). We don't have uber X, but Black and Lux. Pricing of black is on average 10-20% below normal taxi's. All driver's I've asked have said that they prefer uber for mainly 3 reasons: 1. Control over when they drive 2. Higher utilisation (which in extension should be a big driver for Uberpool) 3. Friendlier/less troublesome passengers Some actually bought (nice) new cars (Mercedes/BMW) and explained me a bit more about the economics of buying a new car and how it made sense for them while driving for Uber. Many I spoke to share the car with another driver to get more rides done per day. As such, I wouldn't assume that most drivers don't account for the total cost of ownership. To me it seems that many do.
- sandworm101 11y agoThose are very different drivers than those I've had experience with in the US. All I've seen are family/personal cars pressed into service when times got tight.
- DrJokepu 11y agoI mean, I don't know how this works legally, but don't most franchises set their pricing centrally?
- ChuckMcM 11y agoI suspect you are right. It will make for an interesting year. But rather than being toast, it may be that the livery business is changed from a local monopoly, to a more market driven one. And then it will be interesting to see whether or not companies can deliver better service than the Taxis have over the last few years. I worry sometimes that rather than empowering drivers and enabling better service, it just changes who gets all the money. Sort of the same old, same old, just different names. And if that is the outcome, even with Uber being "successful" then I don't think it really will have dented the universe at all.
- simonebrunozzi 11y agoIt's a race. In a few years (5? 8?), driverless cars might become a reality. Will they be able to survive until then? They just need to wait, lobby the hell out of it, and keep raising money at higher and higher valuation. As much as I don't like Uber, so far their strategy has paid out.
- collyw 11y agoI am curious why everyone believes that self driving cars are coming so soon. They have been talked about for decades. Aircraft have been close to self piloting for years as well (as far as my understanding goes), but you never hear anyone claim that pilots will be gone any time soon.
- toomuchtodo 11y agoBecause a car can pull over and stop if something goes wrong. Google is covering tens of thousands of miles in autonomous mode every month [1], and Tesla is refining their algorithms and mapping data with every mile Tesla Model S owners drive (whether they've paid for Autopilot or not, the vehicle just needs to have the hardware). Hockey stick and all that jazz. [1] https://www.google.com/selfdrivingcar/reports/ https://www.google.com/selfdrivingcar/reports/
- ghaff 11y ago
- pjmorris 11y agoI don't understand this point of view. Isn't the better, more convenient service enough to warrant enough revenue to pay what a company with employees would pay? I don't see why the business model, additionally, has to cut employee costs, beyond maximizing profit. But there should still be enough profit on the revenue side.
- nopzor 11y agoIt isn't a matter of "enough" profit. Uber wants to get so big, and make prices so low, that they decimate current competitors and discourage future ones. It's a winner-take-all model; a land grab. The drivers are just along for the ride. Low(er) pricing not only supports faster growth, but it gets enabled by the scale and efficiency of its network. That becomes a moat for Uber. Raising pricing can come later, and with autonomous cars in the future. Getting the global network huge is only the precursor.
- pjmorris 11y agoGetting big is a goal, not a business model. Standard Oil took decades to achieve monopoly, Uber's goal may be to optimize the speed-to-monopoly, but that's a separate issue from business model.
- hamilton 11y agoThis, right here, must be why they're betting big on self-driving vehicles.
- icebraining 11y agoEven after Taxi companies are forced to do the same? Chicago taxicab companies are “misclassifying” their drivers as independent contractors and should consider them employees eligible for overtime and the state’s $8.25-an-hour minimum wage, a federal class-action lawsuit claimed Wednesday. http://chicago.suntimes.com/politics/7/71/167962/class-action-lawsuit-seeks-back-pay-for-cabdrivers http://chicago.suntimes.com/politics/7/71/167962/class-actio...
- SilasX 11y agoI don't think that's true. All it would mean is that Uber would lower cash payout rates and provide some employee benefits, in effect forcing drivers to take some of their complemsation as employee benefits. (The bit about "not having to pay employer tax share for contractors" is a red herring; the sum of the employee and employer tax shares is the same, and economic incidence is -- per a well known result -- unaffected by who the tax authority assesses the taxes on.) It would be a little less profitable (because of the parties' supply/demand curves, and hence why they oppose it) but it doesn't break the core business model.
- nopzor 11y agoI assume that people who say "not having to pay employer tax share for contractors" they mean things like unemployment insurance, and other employer-components of "payroll tax"? Is that still a red herring? Also, it seems the paperwork and entities involved would get messy. The "employees" still own the car and need to expense/depreciate it, right?
- SilasX 11y ago>I assume that people who say "not having to pay employer tax share for contractors" they mean things like unemployment insurance, and other employer-components of "payroll tax"? Is that still a red herring? It doesn't have the same dynamic as the payroll tax, but it's misleading because the other point applies: the more benefits you buy for workers, the less (direct) cash you have to offer to entice them to do the work. Like with health insurance, a mandate for it would just mean Uber would lower time/mileage rates. In effect, this is the same as forcing drivers to use their cash earnings to buy unemployment insurance, which may be a worse use of the money. >Also, it seems the paperwork and entities involved would get messy. The "employees" still own the car and need to expense/depreciate it, right? Huh? They're already doing that as contractors. And Uber is now at the scale where (relatively) fixed paperwork costs aren't that big a deal.