9 ms·
You have an unsubstantiated argument with presuming that taxing billionaires or millionaires at 80% would be good for society. Let's set aside arguments of in
by chrisco255 11y ago
You have an unsubstantiated argument with presuming that taxing billionaires or millionaires at 80% would be good for society.
Let's set aside arguments of individuality vs. socialism and whether government should operate for the hugely debatable, ephemeral term, "the greater good". I think that invites a separate essay on its own.
From a purely utilitarian perspective, the rich often leverage their capital to achieve things that would be impossible or difficult to do without access to the capital they created.
Case in point, is Elon Musk. If he didn't take home most of the money he earned from his involvement in Paypal, the odds of Space X, Tesla, and Solar City ever happening are decreased dramatically. When in the hands of an extraordinarily talented individual like Musk, capital can work to create long-lasting ripple effects that benefit society as a whole.
If you had taxed Musk at 80%, and he was left with a paltry $30 million or so, it's likely that one or more of the above companies never happen. The opportunity cost is that less jobs get created, unique and innovative technology never gets formed, and the ripple effects (such as spurring Chevrolet and others to make electric vehicles) never happen.
While not always the case, it is often the case that private capital investments do improve society in meaningful ways.
The economy is a very fungible thing and the idea that it is approaching "zero sum" is an unfounded one in the extreme.
- cobaltblue 11y agoI was thinking of Musk too. A person with $1bn in the bank is very rich. So is a person with $200m in the bank. But the first person still has a lot more freedom of action. When you rob people of their freedom of action, you get bad economies.
- jacquesm 11y agoMusk is the exception though, he explicitly did not take his money 'home', he invested it (all of it!) back into new projects. Most people that somehow made a lot of money would not do this.
- lintiness 11y agoname one. billionaires don't sit on their capital.
- _dark_matter_ 11y agoThe entire Walton family. (That's six).
- lintiness 11y agothey own walmart equity, you know, one of the largest employers on the planet. they have foundations, you know, that help the less fortunate: http://www.waltonfamilyfoundation.org/ http://www.waltonfamilyfoundation.org/ you guys have a lot of neat ideas for other people's money.
- jacquesm 11y agoYou asked for names, you got names. Nobody said anything about how they should spend their money.
- wfo 11y agoActually they are the biggest welfare recipient on the planet. They pay workers so little and abuse them so that they must rely on government help, provided by the taxes they avoid paying. They are a parasite.
- chrisco255 11y agoThey pay their workers $10 an hour plus health benefits. For the low-skilled labor that most Wal-Mart employees fulfill, that's a pretty good deal.
- phyrne 11y agoIsnt walmart pretty famous for paying low spectrum wages ?Foundations are based on avoiding a future tax contribution of your income,unless the inheritance tax is zero i.e unlike Joe public who dosnt have one so your definately spending a very decent amount of other peoples money
- chrisco255 11y agoMusk is not an exception. History is absolutely filled with entrepreneurs in the same vein. Disney, Rockefeller, Ford, Jobs, Branson, just to name a few. And those may be some of the more standout examples, but there are hundreds of thousands of entrepreneurs who have made similar reinvestments or expansions to some smaller effect. The carpenter who invests his post-tax capital in buying better tools or increasing his skill is producing a net-positive effect for society by improving the quality of carpentry available to people in his area. Our economy is in large part, the net effect of the sum of all those micro-improvements.
- jacquesm 11y agoI don't think you get to compare those living the high life with Elon Musk. He gives me the impression that he'd rather re-invest every last cent he has into new projects than that he'd ever splurge 10's of millions on himself. Branson and Jobs for instance own (and owned) huge boats that they had built especially for them and spend(t) lavish amount of money on themselves, their houses and so on. Instead of building a boat for himself Elon Musk decided to back Tesla. The Rockefellers and Ford are of a different era, hard to compare their wealth and what they did with it back when they made it with todays world. Disney doesn't even belong in that list (for me).
- AndrewKemendo 11y agohe'd rather re-invest every last cent he has into new projects than that he'd ever splurge 10's of millions on himself Take A Tour Of Elon Musk's $17 Million Bel Air Mansion[1] [1] http://www.businessinsider.com/photo-tour-of-elon-musks-house-2014-11?op=1 http://www.businessinsider.com/photo-tour-of-elon-musks-hous...
- jrockway 11y agoTo be fair, $17 million is 0.14% of his net worth. I don't own my apartment, but if I did, it would be approximately 100% of my net worth.
- cmiles74 11y agoI think this argument is presuming that when someone is looking at an income of $1 billion per year, they will simply accept that fate and write a check to the US government. This sounds astoundingly unlikely, in my opinion. This person who's making $1 billion will simply put their money someplace else, they will figure out a way so that they need not claim it as income. They may push some of this money back into their company, perhaps raising the wages of some (or all) of their employees. They may form a new company to shelter this income and this new company may do something fabulously exciting and, thus, generate another shockingly large sum for this individual. Both of these sound okay to me.
- pc86 11y ago> They may push some of this money back into their company, perhaps raising the wages of some (or all) of their employees. This is a good point that I've never seen brought up before. How much of increasing inequality (whatever your definition of that) can be attributed to stagnating wages at the bottom 4 quintiles, because the tax climate isn't sufficiently incentivizing reinvestment? On the whole my first instinct is to oppose new or increased taxes if only on philosophical grounds, but this may be cause for a second look.
- squozzer 11y agoThis seems like a good spot to go meta - what exactly does someone who has achieved a level of financial success owe the rest of us? The Christian church has a well-known - at least among churchgoers - figure, which is 10% or a tithe. Ask someone who favors government and they will probably say something like "as much as we need." Ask someone who does not and they will probably say something like "as little as possible." It's a long shot but it might help if we had some consensus of what constitutes an equitable "contribution."
- TeMPOraL 11y agoThat's why Effective Altruism movement settled on the 10% of income as a default "good enough" contribution. As Scott Alexander explained in [0], "It’s ten percent because that is the standard decreed by Giving What We Can and the effective altruist community. Why should we believe their standard? I think we should believe it because if we reject it in favor of “No, you are a bad person unless you give all of it,” then everyone will just sit around feeling very guilty and doing nothing. But if we very clearly say “You have discharged your moral duty if you give ten percent or more,” then many people will give ten percent or more. The most important thing is having a Schelling point, and ten percent is nice, round, divinely ordained, and – crucially – the Schelling point upon which we have already settled. It is an active Schelling point." It's still better to get a suboptimal outcome than to not get any outcome at all. [0] - http://slatestarcodex.com/2014/12/19/nobody-is-perfect-everything-is-commensurable/ http://slatestarcodex.com/2014/12/19/nobody-is-perfect-every...
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- mattgibson 11y agoI think the 80% thing you're discussing is a bit like the 'duplo economy' that PG mentions in his essay. Very large broad-brush taxation, with little specificity. It would be trivial to make the taxation regime more high-resolution so that people who reinvest their cash into other ventures are taxed at a far lower rate, whereas those who wish to retire early and do nothing else are taxed a lot more. Better to start from the society you want to see and work backwards from there to design a taxation system, rather that say yes or no to one or two one-size-fits-all options, I think.
- pc86 11y agoIf you reinvest money in a company, it's no longer your income, your AGI decreases, and your marginal and absolute tax rates both decrease. The current system is exactly as you describe.
- lmm 11y ago> Case in point, is Elon Musk. If he didn't take home most of the money he earned from his involvement in Paypal, the odds of Space X, Tesla, and Solar City ever happening are decreased dramatically. When in the hands of an extraordinarily talented individual like Musk, capital can work to create long-lasting ripple effects that benefit society as a whole. What you're claiming here is that Musk can allocate capital better than a government, right? That leaving the money in his hands was better than taxing it and spending it on government projects? (note that all three of SpaceX, Tesla and Solar City received substantial amounts of funding from the US government (directly or indirectly) and would likely not be viable without it, even leaving aside all the USG-funded basic research that was necessary to make them possible in the first place). Even if that's true for Musk specifically (which I doubt), is it true on average? How efficient is the average billionaire at using their money for social good? You gloss over a lot with "While not always the case" - how does the average return to society on a private capital investment compare with a public capital investment?
- graeme 11y agoOn what basis are you claiming that the government could have equalled SpaceX's achievements? SpaceX has made several firsts that no company or government ever has before. Receiving money from the government doesn't mean the government could have done the same thing.
- mikeash 11y agoLanding their first stage was huge, but what other firsts have they had? All the others seem to be of the form "first private X" which excludes government only by definition.
- TeMPOraL 11y agoIndeed. They had a lot of "new and put into practice" things - a new engine design, a new way to manufacture rockets, a new way to manufacture engines (were any other operational engines 3D printed before?). They improved on quite a lot of things. But "firsts"? Not many indeed.
- kamaal 11y ago>>If you had taxed Musk at 80% He would have thought about futility of giving one's whole life to building something and then watch 80% of it taken away by someone else. A few options remain for such people. Tax havens, countries with better respect for individual merit and contribution or plainly make money till a point and quit. All the three are equally damaging to any society for a long time. Eg: See USSR, North Korea, Venezuela, Cuba etc. You don't achieve anything by making the rich poor. Apart from the sadistic pleasure to soothe your flames of jealousy towards their wealth. The end result is you scare almost any genuine contributor to the economy, and they learn they are better off in some other place.
- gjm11 11y ago> You don't achieve anything by making the rich poor. Who is proposing to make the rich poor? The most anyone here seems to be proposing is to make the rich less rich but still rich.
- kamaal 11y ago>>anyone here seems to be proposing is to make the rich less rich but still rich. This is backwards. Not sure why this should even be done. And why does this have to end at an individual? Why should some countries be so economically powerful and others not? Will it be ok if wealth from developed nations were transferred to poor nations, every year? You make poor people rich, you make the sick and malnourished healthy, you make the illiterate literate. You don't make the rich less rich, or the healthy less healthy or the literate less read. Progress happens in the forward direction, not by pulling people down to make your failure look good. There is a irrational fear here somehow equating wealth and evil. Not sure why people even think that way.
- gjm11 11y ago> This is backwards. Only because I copied your phrasing. I dare say there are people around who want to tax rich people just because they don't like wealth, but that's not what's being proposed by the OP and it's not what most people advocating higher taxation are calling for. E.g., from the OP: "So by taxing the wealthy and spending it on services, we can better ensure that the level playing field you allude to continues to exist." (In case it isn't clear from that quotation, the "level playing field" isn't about equalizing wealth or income, it's about providing public services to everyone.) > equating wealth and evil Who's doing that? Here's the OP again: "No one believes that there should not be rich people." "No one wants to take the money you have away." You may think the OP is insincere, but he is very plainly not equating wealth and evil. I don't see anyone here equating wealth and evil, implicitly or explicitly. I'm afraid I think you're just imagining it. Here are arguments I see actually being made by people in this discussion advocating more tax. I have italicized the only one of these arguments that is on the same continent as the ballpark of "equating wealth and evil", and it's still a fair way away. Governments can allocate capital more effectively than most billionaires. Taxation may incentivize wealthy people to invest more. Taxes are low right now compared with what they have historically been, so raising them might be a good idea. Inequality itself causes social problems. No single person can really be so much more productive than others as to justify billions in wealth; so if someone is that wealthy, they got that way on account of others' work, so they don't deserve it. Economists are saying we need to reduce inequality to avoid disaster. > Will it be ok if wealth from developed nations were transferred to poor nations, every year? Yes, that would probably be a good thing. Is it supposed to be obviously not? Most developed nations do in fact transfer some of their wealth to poor nations every year. So do citizens of those developed nations. We call the first of those "aid" and the second "charity" and while it's possible to argue about how effective they are it's certainly not obvious that they're a bad idea.
- vannevar 11y agoFrom a purely utilitarian perspective, the rich often leverage their capital to achieve things that would be impossible or difficult to do without access to the capital they created. They also often waste their capital on complete failures. Whether the rate of wasted spending among the rich is greater or lesser than the rate of waste in government is open to debate. But "from a utilitarian perspective," you can't ignore the fact that there is also massive waste and fraud in the private sector.
- zepto 11y agoAny argument for a policy that hasn't been tried under current conditions is 'unsubstantiated', so that isn't s valid attack. But.. I think the idea that a government would allocate the money better than Elon Musk, is indeed suspect. The point here is that Elon Musk is an unusual person. A more useful question might be - how can we optimize the number of people like Elon Musk who get to execute? Moving capital to the government probably isn't going to help with that, but concentrating money in the hands of 'investors' is probably not optimal either. In many ways they are just a lesser version of government - a bit less bureaucratic, and a bit more open, but nevertheless not the people who create new wealth. They may have created wealth themselves in the past which is a better qualification than being a politician, but unlike Musk, who is executing himself, for the most part investors are not. It seems to me that the real constraint is not on who gets to pick winners (govt vs investors), but enabling more people to take a shot. From that point of view PG's piece is doubly weird, since YC was started from this very premise. Does the current kind of increasing inequality reduce the pool of people who get to take a shot or increase it? If it reduces if then we need to change something.
- wfo 11y agoIf we leave the money with private wealthy capitalists, they might do something good for society on accident as a side effect of their ego-aggrandizing or wealth-concentration efforts. If we tax it, we can actually do something good for society on purpose with it. We can give the business/tax subsidies that are required for all of Musk's ventures to succeed. We can educate Musk's workers. We can maintain and create and enhance the infrastructure required for Musk to continue to make his obscene profits, which we continue to tax and reinvest in the country. Or we can just keep hoping that the rich and powerful class of billionaires have weird hobbies that tech people happen to think are cool.
- TeMPOraL 11y agoYeah. That's why I think Elon Musk is absolutely the least representative rich entrepreneur on the planet. He's one of the few 'rich and powerful billionaires' whose hobby happens to be fixing the world. It's a rare thing; your average billionaire is nothing like that. In fact, many laws that exist today were created to protect us from rich people whose hobbies did not include making things better for everyone.
- TeMPOraL 11y agoAn important warning: you can't draw generalized conclusion about rich entrepreneurs by looking at Elon Musk, because he is totally unlike a typical rich entrepreneur. He plays by a completely different book than almost everyone else. He is not in the game to make money, he is in it to fix a few big problems for the whole mankind. His companies are only the vehicles to achieve this goal. SpaceX wasn't created because he was looking for a way to make money and found that satellite launches are a market ripe for disruption. It was created because he wants humans to go to Mars, and (after failed attempts to buy ICBMs from Russia) starting a very innovative rocket company was the best way for him to make it happen. I agree that what Elon did would not be possible if he was taxed at 80%. But he is an extreme case. He is an outlier in the outliers group. Most rich entrepreneurs, frankly, don't give a shit. The few that do have often tied hands (there's only so much you can do if your company has shareholders deciding about stuff). But most don't give a shit. Can you imagine, say, CEO of Oracle investing all his wealth to literally force an electric car into market viability because he believes that we need to do something about sustainable energy right fucking now? I can't. So maybe that 80% tax would stop an occasional Elon Musk from saving the world. But if it also makes everyone much better off, then maybe it's worth it. Especially if it could relax the current economic pressures, so that we wouldn't need crazy millionaires going against the market to fix something on this planet.