8 ms·
I really like the concept of the EFF, and really like most of their work, but when I was reading their blog I quickly started to feel like they go off half-cock
by epistasis 11y ago
I really like the concept of the EFF, and really like most of their work, but when I was reading their blog I quickly started to feel like they go off half-cocked too often. When I first saw summaries of their report my guess was just that there in turning BingeOn on/off on a single account, or that there were temporary configuration problems on T-Mobile's side.
Some people like the idea of supporting an out-there extreme to keep the Overton window shifted to an appropriate place. I can see the logic in it, but I value truth first.
T-mobile's CEO's schtick is to act like this, and I don't really appreciate that much either, but I do appreciate T-mobile's small movements to make the cell phone market more fluid by getting rid of contracts, and I also still like BingeOn. It gives me more control over my data than Netflix or Amazon or whomever gives me.
- toomuchtodo 11y agoI'm torn. I support the EFF with donations, and I'm a 14 year customer of T-Mobile, but I have no problem with what T-Mobile is doing. The EFF has done some great work, but T-Mobile has done far more in bringing sanity back to the US mobile market.
- zanny 11y agoWhen a company does something good does not mean to ignore when they do something bad. And BingeOn is fundamentally bad, because its everything Comcast wanted when they were trying to slow-lane half the Internet, except nobody is in opposition to it because they see as a "benefit" rather than traffic shaping bullshit it actually is. They could have just given everyone unlimited data with deprioritization on their network over fixed data users, but they didn't - they make some heavy consumers of data "free" while leaving others against the tide of data caps, and thus harm the free Internet.
- toomuchtodo 11y ago> When a company does something good does not mean to ignore when they do something bad. Agree. > And BingeOn is fundamentally bad, because its everything Comcast And here's your problem. It's not fundamentally bad. T-mobile is not Comcast. T-Mobile has a limited amount of spectrum on each tower, and a limited amount of backhaul to each tower. It can in no way be compared to Comcast, who can pipe Gb/s into your home, and who isn't limited by the laws of physics for delivering bits. They can always drag more fiber. There is only so much RF bandwidth in existence. I have a choice in my mobile provider, I do not in my local internet. If the EFF wants my support back, start lobbying your ass off to get tax breaks and funding for municipal fiber and stop wasting your time on T-Mobile.
- hueving 11y ago>It can in no way be compared to Comcast, who can pipe Gb/s into your home, and who isn't limited by the laws of physics for delivering bits. They can always drag more fiber. There is only so much RF bandwidth in existence. That argument falls flat because you can just say T-mobile can always put up more towers and lower the transmission power. The density of cell phone towers is directly related to how many radios they try to provide service for with one tower.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- remarkEon 11y agoPutting up new radio towers isn't that easy, though. You face significant NIIMBYism wherever you want to put them.
- Dylan16807 11y agoAt most Comcast would have to add some backhaul fiber. That costs nothing compared to the last mile. Adding more phone towers is even worse than a cable company's last mile, because the returns diminish as the frequencies clog.
- dogma1138 11y agoPutting up more towers won't solve the problem RF goes everywhere the cellular spectrum is limited and with WIFI creeping into GSM bands (and vice versa) it's even more saturated now. Put more towers and your signal to noise ratio goes down the toilet. As for transmission power well this is regulated T-Mobile can't just crank up the power. Not to mention if they start spreading out towers like mushrooms the "health and safety" nuts will pop up after them claiming that towers give you cancer and they should be removed. Comcast and any other ISP can pretty much increase it's bandwidth indefinitely it's only real limitation is how much room it has under the ground and hint that's allot. And considering that people go crazy when cell providers try to spread Wifi around and push people using data (and even voice some times) to non cellular wireless internet this is pretty much a mess the consumers have made for themselves. If you live in a metropolitan area you should petition your mobile provider to expand it's Wifi network and even partner with a residential wifi sharing providers to give you more coverage. Cellular bandwidth is becoming more and more expensive and until h265 becomes a streaming standard don't expect to be streaming 1080p on your mobile devices in a dense area. I live in London and I use maybe 500MB of 4G a month and that's because everywhere in my home, tube stations, work, and commercial areas there is a hotspot which is either provided by my carrier or my carrier has partnership with and I am getting very good download speeds all the way (I've cached the entire map of London on Google maps which was about 900mb yesterday in about 4min while waiting for the tube without any hickups).
- michaelcampbell 11y ago> When a company does something good does not mean to ignore when they do something bad. And likewise the other way around. The enemy of the good is the perfect.
- nqzero 11y agoBingeOn does exactly what the ads for it say it does, and is entirely optional. letting customers choose the quality is good for customers, and t-mobile isn't beholden to anyone else the EFF has lost it's way
- shkkmo 11y agoBingeOn also imposes a 1.5Mbps throttle non-streaming video files and on streaming video files where lower bitrates are not available. http://motherboard.vice.com/read/t-mobiles-binge-on-indiscriminately-throttles-all-video-content http://motherboard.vice.com/read/t-mobiles-binge-on-indiscri...
- toomuchtodo 11y agoI cannot shrug hard enough. Big deal!
- shkkmo 11y agoT-mobile automatically opts their customers into a plan that throttles bandwidth for specific usage, then claims they are not throttling anything and publicly bashes the EFF for exposing them. You don't see any problem with that? I'm glad we have consumer advocates such as the EFF that pay attention to this. I appreciate all of the other things that T-mobile has done to move the US Carrier industry forward, but they got this one wrong. There isn't anything wrong with trying to innovate, but T-mobile should have not opted customers in by default, especially without being upfront about the throttling.
- jshevek 11y agoHow has EFF lost its way? They simply reported the facts. Without EFF, the important facts which Legere has been trying to gloss over would not have reached me.
- moistgorilla 11y agoFacts aren't good when they disagree with my worldview.
- moistgorilla 11y agoI keep hearing this but the one time I went to the tmobile store for the supposedly cheaper offering, the price was exactly the same as what I get from ATT with less coverage.
- nivla 11y ago>when I was reading their blog I quickly started to feel like they go off half-cocked too often. While I am a fan of EFF and the work they do, I too have started to notice this recently. The title of articles have become borderline click-bait and sometimes conveniently omits vital information that may help better understand the issue. The most recent one is "Stupid Patent of the Month: Microsoft’s Design Patent on a Slider" [1] [2] which surprisingly is a lawsuit on a whole lot more than just sliders. However on this issue I am kind of split. I agree with both EFF and T-mobile. As for T-mobile, BingeOn is optional and can be disabled anytime with just a click, so it does little to nothing to hurt customers and cannot effectively be called throttling. As for EFF, they have the right to be worried that this may set a precedent for bigger control over your data in the future. [1] https://www.eff.org/deeplinks/2015/12/stupid-patent-month-microsofts-design-patent-slider https://www.eff.org/deeplinks/2015/12/stupid-patent-month-mi... [2] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10802413 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10802413
- tracker1 11y agoThe fact that it's optional (enabled by default) does not change the fact that it is, indeed, throttling. There's also the fact that this throttling (regardless of what they'd like to call it) was actually happening for video services not included. This is precisely the opposite of content neutrality, in that they're making general internet traffic intentionally worse.
- epistasis 11y agoCall it throttling, call it whatever you want. It makes my general internet better. The service is optional from all sides: both the consumer and the content provider. It gives me, as a user of the general internet, more control over what I do with the internet. Not less. It may be better if there was RFC for devices to register their bandwidth preferences that Netflix and other video services implemented, but there's not. Perhaps BingeOn is a route towards that.
- iraphael 11y ago
- specialist 11y ago...they go off half-cocked too often. Playing defense is hard. You're reactionary. You have to cover every base. You have to take every utterance of your opponent seriously. It's easy to get duped. Etc. I won't do it any more. I've spent a lot of time fact checking, refuting, explaining. It's a sucker's game (you can't win). "A lie can travel halfway round the world while the truth is putting on its shoes." -- Mark Twain (maybe) "If you're explaining, you're losing." -- Lee Atwater I encourage all activists (organizations) to have an affirmative agenda. Tell me what you're for, not what you're against. Policy groups like EFF need to learn how to seize the initiative. There is value in deep diving into policy issues. That's what think tanks are for.