5 ms·
H.264 Licencing and Free Software
- shrikant 17y agoWhile it might work for dead-tree media, I don't see any benefit of 4 little columns vs. 1 wide-ish block for a blog. Especially when blockquoting a fairly sizable amount of text. The Readability bookmarklet works well on this.
- thristian 17y agoI agree that it makes the page less readable, but I can forgive Roc that little indulgence; he implemented support for CSS columns in Gecko; it's only fair that he gets to show it off. Asa Dotzler's blog (http://weblogs.mozillazine.org/asa/ http://weblogs.mozillazine.org/asa/) has the headings twist by five degrees or so when you mouse over them; he's not even a Gecko developer, so he's got no excuse.
- shrikant 17y agoIt's 3 degrees, ha! ;) .title a:hover { -moz-transform: rotate(-3deg); -moz-transform-origin: top middle;" color:#2A0000; } Annoying, yes. Readable, yes.
- statictype 17y agoIn terms of open standards, is there any reason to switch from Flash to HTML5 video if that video is going to be in H.264? I understand that there are possibly technical reasons for Chrome\Safari choosing H.264 as the default codec instead of Theora but it strikes me as somewhat disingenuous for people to harp on about the need to move away from a proprietary technology like Flash, if the alternative is an open standard built on top of a proprietary codec.
- tumult 17y agoH.264 is not proprietary. It's a standard, created through the coordination and cooperation of a large number of groups. Unlike much software that is 'protected' under patents, the development of MPEGn, H.264, etc. was a significant investment in both time and money by those participating. That does not make it any more justified, but it is something to keep in mind -- the project is not a joke or a patent troll. Anyone can view the standard and implement it. To distribute, you are to acquire a license from the MPEG LA. The terms are not onerous or the fee excessive. Google and Apple both pay the license fee for each download of Safari or Chrome. The patent holders have so far not prosecuted projects like x264, which distributes its implementations without a license. Do I think software patents should be abolished? Yes. Do I think Mozilla is holding back the open web by not supporting H.264? Yes.
- ZeroGravitas 17y agoIf the MPEG-LA's fees are neither onerous or excessive then why was there widespread industry revolt when they were introduced? Didn't that one company have a very public falling out with them about it? What was their name again? Oh yes, Apple: "Apple Computer has rejected proposed licensing terms for the emerging MPEG-4 video standard, leaving the future of its QuickTime multimedia technology in limbo. At a company-sponsored conference on Tuesday, Apple previewed the latest versions of its QuickTime digital media player and new QuickTime broadcast technology, both built on MPEG-4. But the company said those products will remain grounded indefinitely as it seeks to change MPEG-4 licensing terms unveiled last month by a key licensing clearinghouse. The terms, set by MPEG LA on 31 January, have prompted a wave of criticism in streaming circles for including a per-minute streaming charge that adds up to 2 cents an hour for video clips delivered in the MPEG-4 format." from Apple's MPEG-4 snub may halt QuickTime http://news.zdnet.co.uk/internet/0,1000000097,2104282,00.htm http://news.zdnet.co.uk/internet/0,1000000097,2104282,00.htm If Apple can fight against stupid licence terms why can't Mozilla?
- tumult 17y agoThis is for a broadcast license, from an article in 2002, for an older technology (straight MPEG-4, not the newer superset H.264 which is now widely embraced.) I don't know whether or not this proposed broadcast license fee was ever even enacted, though QuickTime does support plain MPEG-4, so I imagine not.
- robin_reala 17y agoSafari hasn’t chosen it as the default, it’s chosen it as the solitary option. If they’d integrated Theora then every single browser that supports the <video> tag would also support Theora and the argument would be moot.
- GHFigs 17y agoSafari hasn’t chosen it as the default, it’s chosen it as the solitary option. Not true. They've chosen to implement it in a codec-agnostic way. It simply requires installing XiphQT, which itself only involves moving a file into a folder. This is unlike (say) Mozilla, to which <video> support of h.264 cannot be added by any means. You could argue that Apple have made it the solitary option on their mobile devices, but that's because it depends on the availability of hardware decoder support, which doesn't exist for Theora. and the argument would be moot. No, the argument would shift over to trying to get content creators to use Theora, even though 70% or so of the browsing audience doesn't support it or <video>. Web video would still be dominated by h.264 in Flash, the only format that would work everywhere.
- zacharypinter 17y agoI'm guessing that "simply requires installing XiphQT, which itself only involves moving a file into a folder" doesn't apply to the iPhone or iPad?
- GHFigs 17y agoHence my second paragraph.
- tumult 17y agoMy understanding is that Apple and Google cannot use Theora because they are targets for patent trolls, and would be sued by a multitude of companies claiming to hold patents that cover Theora. correction: It's just Apple/Safari that does not support Theora, not Google/Chrome, which does.
- 17y ago
- xenonite 17y agoone reason for moving away from flash: iPad, iPhone and some other mobile devices cannot run Flash content.
- felixge 17y agoSo if you provide a service for just encoding video to H.264 (using ffmpeg)), without streaming the videos to end users, you are already deep into patent trouble?
- jermy 17y agoYes, producing encoded content would indeed require you to have a licence. But, if you're running such a service, at least licences are cheap (even if the pricing model is still set around the concept of hardware devices).
- CrLf 17y agoOk, can someone explain this to me: if H.264 licensing is an issue, why not offload the whole thing to the platform's video codec APIs? If the OS vendor already pays license fees for the decoders, than that should cover it. If the vendor doesn't, well, then that's a problem.
- xenonite 17y agowhy not? if you distribute h.264 videos on a large scale (>100k viewers), you need to pay licensing fees. if you want to bundle a h.264 decoder with your software, you need to pay, too. Only if you use the OS' native decoder, you don't need to pay. But Firefox is multiplatform. WinXP, Linux do not support h.264 out of the box.
- CrLf 17y ago"if you distribute h.264 videos on a large scale (>100k viewers), you need to pay licensing fees." Clearly, the likes of Youtube and Vimeo don't care about this. They do seem to care about using a codec that is standard, widely supported and with good and varied implementations (both encoding and decoding, with or without hardware acceleration). Theora has neither of these characteristics. "Only if you use the OS' native decoder, you don't need to pay. But Firefox is multiplatform. WinXP, Linux do not support h.264 out of the box." Well, WinXP and Linux do not support Flash out of the box, but that doesn't seem to pose any problems.
- didroe 17y agoBecause for Mozilla it's not a case of side-stepping the law. It's a case of their moral intentions. They want the web to be usable for people who want to run free software, or at least for it to be possible to write a browser stack based on open code.
- deleted 17y ago[deleted]
- jonknee 17y agoGreat, my vendor (Apple) is on the list. Just use their decoding functionality please--it works beautifully.
- xenonite 17y agoyes, but sadly websites cannot get around using a flash plugin or ogg theora on other platforms for streaming movies.
- DrJokepu 17y agoWell, given that Microsoft is on the list as well, 98% of all desktops are covered. The remaining 2% are welcome to purchase licensed third party codecs. I don't want to sound offensive but just because some tiny portion of people would prefer a free/open solution, the large majority of the people (who actually use a commrecial OS and and don't really care about the whole thing just want YouTube working on their desktop) shouldn't be "punished".
- robin_reala 17y agoMicrosoft weren’t on that list when XP came out, so it’s hardly 2% of users.
- vetinari 17y agoActually, it is new thing in Windows 7, so Vista also does not have H.264 decoder. What about turning it around? 100% has access to open decoder, and if 2% wants to use licensed codec, they can. Remember, Theora was suggested as baseline codec, not as only codec.
- megamark16 17y agoSo my question is, what video codec should we be using? Is there a codec of sufficient quality that is completely open and free?
- robin_reala 17y agoTheora. Whether it’s of ‘sufficient’ quality is debatable, but for normal YouTube style videos it’s fine. For higher definition videos there’s Dirac, but that’s not really field tested yet.
- ZeroGravitas 17y agoThey could probably get a good chunk of improvement out of Theora if they broke the spec, fixed a couple of things that either seemed sensible at the time or were just plain stupid and took advantage of what we've learned about codecs and assumptions about processors speeds and capabilities in the meantime. They haven't done so yet because there's still room for improvements to be wrung out of the current spec and the longer they wait to do a non-backwards compatible spec break the better they'll be able to make it. If Google releases one of the VP codecs then it's probably not going to be that much better than what xiph could have done if they weren't trying to keep compatability since they're based on the same core technology.
- robin_reala 17y agoYes, the Thusnelda improvements do seem to be paying dividends.
- KirinDave 17y ago"Normal YouTube style videos" are a historical target. The quality of video the end user is able to produce is progressing at a startling rate. Go to and see what even amateurs are doing, it's not just "My face in a small window with a bookcase in the background" anymore. In general, I've been disappointed with theora output for very high def stuff. What's more, the video standard affects more than just what software component you load. Vendors like Apple have devices which must support video playback in hardware. Without a very good solution there, theora is basically a non-starter. And people who complain that Apple should support Theora because it is free need to consider that, moving forward, mobile playback is extremely important.
- briansmith 17y agoIs a h.264 license more expensive than the extra bandwidth that would be necessary for Theora?
- aw3c2 17y agoSince there is an infinite number of licensees, yes, definitely yes.
- briansmith 17y agoHow can there be an infinite number of licensees, when the number of people & corporations is finite, and licensing is only needed for a finite amount of time (until the patents expire)?
- jon_dahl 17y agoFor businesses, this is a good question. H.264 licensing can be relatively inexpensive (free for moderate use, cheaper than MP3 or AAC for high-volume use). So most businesses are probably better off using H.264 than Theora. Firefox is another story; they aren't charging, and according to the article, would be responsible for the licensing costs for every one of their (hundreds of millions of?) users.
- deleted 17y ago[deleted]
- ajross 17y agoUsing h.264 is a win for bandwidth only if you know what you're doing. Most encoders out there (see the x264 site for details) are run with poorly tuned settings and generally do a poor job. And yet ... no one care, they do it anyway. The idea that marginal 20% or so bandwidth costs are expensive is mostly a red herring. Frankly if Safari and IE were to suddenly support Theora (or Firefox and IE to suddently support h.264), this argument would be over. No one cares about the technical details. Any codec that works pervasively will win.