3 ms·
But KSP does give a false impression. It is very much a "spheres in a vacuum" approach to orbital physics. It doesn't model many/most of the realworld forces.
by sandworm101 11y ago
But KSP does give a false impression. It is very much a "spheres in a vacuum" approach to orbital physics. It doesn't model many/most of the realworld forces.
When dealing with the truly minuscule forces such as would be created by lasers aimed at asteroids, one much accommodate all other similarly-sized forces before taking action. Rocks in space are subject to a force/pressure from the sun, a pressure comparable to that from a earthbound laser. Before trying to deflect, one would have to understand how the sun will be altering the course. That calculation is not easy and requires details (albedo/rotation) that are hard to come by for tiny rocks. You don't want to be countering the force from the sun only to push the rock into an intercept it would otherwise have missed.
Vaporization also need not mean destroying the rock. So long as the vaporized material achieves escape velocity (not hard on an asteroid) vaporizing the surface of an object creates a force, a thrust, which is greater than the pressure directly from the laser.
- marcosdumay 11y ago> Rocks in space are subject to a force/pressure from the sun, a pressure comparable to that from a earthbound laser. Hum, is it? When near the Sun, yes, of course, but when away from it, we can probably throw way more energy on it than the Sun. Yes, it does require details that we currently can't measure. The good new is that the laser doubles as an excellent instrument for measuring those details.
- sandworm101 11y agoThat very much depends on the laser. Most of the approaches I've seen discussed involve multiple 'attacks' on a rock spread out over a considerable period of time. You only fire when the rock is far enough above the horizon (say 25-30% of the time if you have 1 ground laser). And then you want to hit it when it is at some sort of apsis, preferably when it is far away with a relatively slow velocity. The sun has a 24/7 line of sight and is always firing.
- chr1 11y agoPressure from either sun light or laser is very small, and can be ignored for time intervals smaller than centuries. The method proposed in the article is only about thrust created by vaporization
- sandworm101 11y agoThe sun vaporizes. That's where comets get tails.
- Already__Taken 11y agoDoes it? I thought that was heated gasses boiling off.
- marcosdumay 11y agoBoiling off == vaporized (ok pedantically, boiling off -> vaporized, but not the other way around). The Sun only does that on icy rocks, and when they are near. Lasers can (in theory) do that on icy rocks that are much further away.
- sandworm101 11y agoIn space it often isn't so much boiling (liquid+heat=gas) as sublimation (solid+energy=gas). Sublimation can, weirdly, occur well below the freezing/boiling point. That one lone cosmic ray can heat a single molecule of water enough to cast it into space as a gas ... all in an environment where the average temp is well below freezing points. Temperatures in vacuum are strange.