7 ms·
The fact that nobody benefits much is very much worth pointing out. Furthermore absolutely no viable public purpose can be served today by backdating new rules
by btilly 11y ago
The fact that nobody benefits much is very much worth pointing out. Furthermore absolutely no viable public purpose can be served today by backdating new rules to past works. We didn't create any new works from the 1950s by passing laws in the 1970s. Those works were already created on incentives that authors already received. It is just a giveaway to the tiny minority of said authors whose work achieved success.
Of course the main driver of this is Disney, which is trying to keep Mickey Mouse under copyright. (Never mind the fact that trademark is a better fit for how they use it...)
Also I'd like to highlight the 1987 part of the argument.
The early computer era saw a lot of games written for platforms like Apple ][ by companies that went out of business and the copyright ownership went to places unknown (though they theoretically exist). You can't make and pass around legal copies of them from the floppies that they originally came from. Some of the games (Ultima, PacMan, etc) would likely see copyright renewed. But a lot of them would not. And that would be great for people like me that want to revisit our childhoods.
In fact historically there were stories that only became popular BECAUSE they fell out of copyright. The most famous example is https://www.globalipmatters.com/2015/12/17/when-a-quirk-of-copyright-law-creates-a-christmas-classic-its-a-wonderful-life-and-the-public-domain https://www.globalipmatters.com/2015/12/17/when-a-quirk-of-c... but it isn't alone. Just think what new cultural gems we might create if artists of today could safely refer back to works from a generation or two ago.
- thaumasiotes 11y ago> The fact that nobody benefits much is very much worth pointing out. > Of course the main driver of this is Disney, which is trying to keep Mickey Mouse under copyright. I read an analysis that didn't think much of this view. It said we should look at ever-extending copyright protections as a form of economic protectionism against the past, forcing the public to buy potentially-inferior modern IP rather than fall back on older IP. You suggest this yourself, with > historically there were stories that only became popular BECAUSE they fell out of copyright and I think it's worth thinking about. In particular, I'm pretty sure "the fact that nobody benefits much" isn't actually a fact.
- bograt 11y agoThe problem with this analysis is that, if such a course of "ever-extending copyright protections" were pursued, it would run the 'well of creativity' dry. The 'creative commons' is a recognition that cultural works are not created ex nihilo but by building on the works of previous generations; as creators benefit, so must they contribute.
- zanny 11y ago> so must they contribute. A tremendous swath of people have been born or published works since 1928 and have since died, whose works remain under the perpetual Disney copyright. So no, we have had generations die now that never contributed back to the commons because Disney said so.
- thaumasiotes 11y agoThe well of creativity is unlikely to run dry. In particular, we can observe that a huge chunk of literature effectively can't be consumed today because no one alive speaks the language it was written in (also, because no copies survive!). That's a much more effective ban on using the work than copyright is, and it's permanent. But it hasn't led to storytelling just gradually dying out because we forgot all the stories.
- btilly 11y agoThere are analyses that say many contradictory things. I haven't read that analysis and don't know whether I would think much of it. But let's suppose that if I did then I would be convinced that the economic effects of copyright extension are better understood as that type of protectionism. That doesn't change the fact that I still have evidence that Disney is explicitly involved both directly and indirectly in lobbying for copyright extension. And they start lobbying for it like clockwork as soon as Steamboat Willie starts threatening to slide into public domain. Therefore no matter what the economic arguments, I believe that the people actually changing the rules are changing it to keep Mickey Mouse under copyright. That said, I think little of the position taken in that analysis. It claims that the public is forced to buy potentially-inferior modern IP. To the contrary, I believe that the public is free to not buy IP at all, but instead to find other ways to entertain themselves. In fact I believe that if modern authors and artists could freely draw on iconic past IP, they could create compelling new works drawing on the old ones which would increase consumption of IP. Thereby making the public happier AND content creators richer. Therefore I believe that the net effect of copyright extension is to increase the rent that current content owners can get from past content at the cost of both the public and current content creators. (And yes, this holds true even though there are content creators employed by content owners.) --- As to "nobody benefits much", I remember one of the briefs that I saw for Eldred v. Ashcroft that demonstrated that over 99% of the possible present value of a work is captured by the author under the terms of the 1976 law. That is, if we take the possibility of public domain away and assign perpetual copyright to authors, we will not add more than about 1% to the compensation authors can expect. Turning that figure around, today's content creators would be better off with the 1976 laws if they in aggregate could increase consumed commercial content by more than 1% from having full access to past content to work from. (Exactly like Walt Disney did with works like Sleeping Beauty.) I believe that this is quite possible. A number of economic experiments have found that increasing availability of free content increases consumption and ultimately increases revenue to artists. See, for example, http://www.baen.com/library/prime_palaver1.asp http://www.baen.com/library/prime_palaver1.asp for one of them.
- dx211 11y ago> The fact that nobody benefits much is very much worth pointing out. Warner Brothers, Disney, etc. benefit from this, as do their employees, in quite concrete terms.
- pc2g4d 11y agoI thought they were emphasizing the fact that, under the previous scheme, authors had to do something to renew copyright, which meant that unexploited works automatically lapsed into the public domain. Under the current law, even works whose authors do not care remain under copyright. Previously, the default state was public domain. Now, the default state is copyright. This means that for a huge majority of works, their remaining under copyright benefits neither the uninterested rightsholder, nor the public who are now prohibited from reusing the work.
- meric 11y agoIf we made these laws protect Disney exclusively and leave everyone else out of it, and we would be better off.
- 13of40 11y agoI'm going to play Devil's Advocate and say that the Winnie the Pooh copyright is better off in the hands of a large corporation that can use it to create wealth. Besides that, it's not like the Queen of England owns it and keeps it hidden away where only VIPs can see it (I'm looking at you, Vermeer's The Music Lesson). They use it to create media that the majority of people on this forum have happily consumed. What do we get if it goes into the public domain? The ability to download old books for free that you'd otherwise have to pay...oh...fifty cents for at the local St. Vincent De Paul? Slash fiction? (Again, Devil's Advocate, so no down votes.)
- umanwizard 11y agoThe wealth creation is completely artificial. I'm not sure how having to pay a tax to Disney for a Winnie lunchbox "creates wealth" more than getting the identical thing for cheaper. Basically your post is a more subtle version of the broken window fallacy.
- deciplex 11y ago> Never mind the fact that trademark is a better fit for how they use it... I'm not sure about this. I think trademark would prevent you from publishing a work and calling it "Mickey Mouse" or something similar, but it wouldn't stop you from producing work which incorporated Mickey Mouse somehow, and calling it something else e.g. "I Hate Corporate Mice" or something.
- nitrogen 11y agoMickey's shape is trademarked, so you'd have to go to great lengths to make sure that your Mickey doesn't convey any of the meanings protected by trademark.
- monochromatic 11y ago> Furthermore absolutely no viable public purpose can be served today by backdating new rules to past works. We didn't create any new works from the 1950s by passing laws in the 1970s. This is a really good point. I don't know why I've never thought about that before.
- danieltillett 11y agoI suspect this is because the popular media is a limited number of conglomerates who generate enormous profits from retrospective copyright extensions. Funny that stories that don't benefit these conglomerates aren't published.
- danieltillett 11y agoIt is not Mickey Mouse that Disney is protecting (he is protected by trademark), it in Winnie the poo. The copyright on Winnie supports billion of dollars of revenue in licensing deals - basically millions of kids lunch boxes and backpacks.
- frobozz 11y ago> Furthermore absolutely no viable public purpose can be served today by backdating new rules to past works. I disagree. Although you are correct for rules that extend the duration of the exclusive right of the copyright holder, a rule that reduces that duration would allow greater access to these works sooner.
- treenyc 11y ago> I disagree. Care to elaborate, and give some examples? Tks
- frobozz 11y agoWhat do you mean by elaborate? I thought my statement was pretty clear. From the linked article: "Readers – from the conspiracy theorist to the grammar enthusiast, the student of racial injustice to the sociologist – would have something to celebrate." If applying the pre-1978 laws to pre-1978 works would cause this celebration, then surely applying them to post-1978 works would also cause such celebration. For further elaboration - if the contemporary rules were applied, then a work from 1977 would become public domain in 2033 and a work from 1978 would become public domain in 2048 (or 2073). If the pre-1978 rules were to be reinstated today, without backdating, then that 1978 work would still take 70 or 95 years. With backdating, it would become public domain in 2034.
- treenyc 11y agoSince you disagree with "Furthermore absolutely no viable public purpose can be served today by backdating new rules to past works." I just would like to know your bases for your disagreement, and ask for some examples. Maybe there is a misunderstanding.
- frobozz 11y agoAre you only reading the first few words of my comments, and ignoring the rest? It's right there. A new rule that reduces the term opens up old works earlier than if the contemporary rule is left in place. Let's consider something other than copyright. It is bad to retroactively prosecute people for new crimes, but (for example) should people convicted of sodomy prior to 2003 have to serve out their (up to life) sentences, or since the act is no longer illegal, should they be freed? Surely, if an act is no longer a crime, it's abhorrent to treat people who have committed that act as criminals.
- static_noise 11y ago> It is just a giveaway to the tiny minority of said authors whose work achieved success. I think you mean the copyright holders. When the authors sign it off to somebody else they are different entities.